11 ms·
What's the advantage of the chopsticks landing over splashing the thing down in the ocean? Does an ocean landing cause significant damage that's not present wi
by simonw 2y ago
What's the advantage of the chopsticks landing over splashing the thing down in the ocean?
Does an ocean landing cause significant damage that's not present with an on-land chopsticks landing?
Presumably there are pretty big advantages considering how much it must have cost to develop the chopsticks approach.
- davidguetta 2y ago- salt water is horrific for anything - time to transport, move back into initial position.
- simonw 2y agoThat makes sense - sending out barges / recovery vehicles into the ocean can't be cheap. The environmental impact of a chopsticks landing is likely a whole lot less damaging too.
- singleshot_ 2y agoWhat do you figure is worse for chemical changes to materials, being engulfed in a big call of plasma, or being dunked in the ocean? I don’t know any chemistry but there seem to be a lot of smart people round here. What say you?
- lukeschlather 2y agoSeagoing ships are good at being in salt water but don't deal as well with being engulfed in plasma. Starship is pretty good at being engulfed in plasma but doesn't handle being engulfed in salt water very well. Making a single ship that can handle both is a very tall order, even just doing one or the other is hard.
- shiroiushi 2y agoSeagoing ships are pretty good at floating on top of salt water for a while, but they're not very good at being "dunked" in it (i.e. sunken). It is possible to raise sunken ships and rehabilitate them to regular service, and this has been before, but it generally destroys everything inside, and requires a ton of work. Salt water is one of the most corrosive substances we know of.
- iterance 2y agoOcean is worse. (For rockets.) - used to be an engineer in aerospace
- piombisallow 2y agoDesigning it for both is probably worse than either one separately
- jojobas 2y agoBeing dunked in seawater while still being red/white hot from the plasma.
- wbl 2y agoDunked in the ocean. There just isn't a ton of plasma and it's not very good at transferring heat to things it isn't being pressed up against. So heat shields and the like function very well. Seawater by contrast gets everywhere, and if it does even a little damage, keeps doing it for a long time.
- chroma 2y agoA lot of the damage happens as soon as the spacecraft enters the water, because it's extremely hot, causing more chemical reactions than you might think. Even jet engines have trouble with corrosion from ingesting small amounts of aerosolized salt water.[1] 1. https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19690007944/downloads/19690007944.pdf https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19690007944/downloads/19...
- fixprix 2y agoThis is the answer. Salt water destroys the engines.
- Aaargh20318 2y agoThere are several advantages: - Turnaround time is a major one for SpaceX. They want to stack a new Starship on top of it and launch the booster again in hours, not weeks. By catching the booster they can simply lower it back onto the launch mount, refuel and relaunch. - No need for landing legs. The legs add significant weight, especially on something as large as Super Heavy. Leaving these out means more usable payload to orbit.
- carabiner 2y agoIf the chopsticks are catching the rocket by the grid fins, doesn't that mean the grid fins (and associated structure) have to be strengthened (weight added) to support the entire weight of the vehicle? That would negate some of the weight savings of removing the legs. Does this end up being more efficient because more of the loading is in tension instead of compression?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Teever 2y agoSort of. They need to lift the rocket to put it in place on the launch structure so that is already built into the design.
- rockemsockem 2y agoThe chopsticks actually don't catch the booster by the grid fins, there are little struts that stick out from the rocket that don't stick out nearly as far. I thought the same thing before the first catch, if you go look at the catch footage you can see the booster resting those on the chopsticks.
- carabiner 2y agoSo the struts (plus supporting structure) are lighter than the legs? Why is that?
- pfannkuchen 2y agoHard to have a spaceport if your vehicle needs to land in the ocean.
- AgentK20 2y agoKeep in mind, splashing the booster down in the ocean almost always results in rapid unscheduled disassembly (explosion) of the booster. It lands upright but has no ability to stay upright on its own, so usually makes a soft water landing and then immediately tips over. The shock of the side of the booster hitting the water usually ruptures one or more pressure vessels, resulting in a nice fireball and destruction of the vehicle. Even the Falcon 9 when it lands "at sea" is actually landing on a barge that is able to keep it upright (usually) and out of the water, but any booster vehicle that SpaceX (or anyone) launches that does a soft water landing is a write-off. The only real exception to this is return capsules with astronauts in them which are explicitly designed to land in the water and deploy buoys to keep themselves afloat while they wait for the Coast Guard to come pick them, and the capsule (which is a one-time-use component) up.
- usehand 2y agotiny correction, but I believe the capsules are also re-used
- skissane 2y ago> The only real exception to this is return capsules with astronauts in them which are explicitly designed to land in the water and deploy buoys to keep themselves afloat while they wait for the Coast Guard to come pick them, and the capsule (which is a one-time-use component) up. With SpaceX Dragon (both crew and cargo variants), the capsule is designed to be reusable, so it is no longer a “one-time-use” component. The same is true of Boeing Starliner and NASA/LockheedMartin Orion. “One-time-use” was true of previous ocean-landing capsules, such as Apollo’s Command Module, with the sole exception of the Jan 1965 Gemini 2 uncrewed testflight’s capsule, which was reused for another uncrewed testflight the next year, as part of USAF’s Manned Orbital Laboratory program (which was cancelled in 1969) Of course, reuse after a spaceflight and ocean landing requires significant refurbishment. Also, both Starliner and Orion are only partially reusable, since both (like Apollo) have a service module designed to burn up on re-entry. Dragon likewise has a trunk, but Dragon’s trunk contains fewer spacecraft systems than Starliner or Orion’s service modules, making it more reusable overall.
- Gee101 2y ago
- dantheman252 2y agoI don't think they reuse the boosters that they do a splashdown with. So reuse vs trash.
- adolph 2y agoRocketlab is working in it. They have sent the first one or two to the production line for refurb. https://www.rocketlabusa.com/updates/rocket-lab-announces-reusability-plans-for-electron-rocket/ https://www.rocketlabusa.com/updates/rocket-lab-announces-re...
- modeless 2y agoThe booster is destroyed when it tips over after "landing" vertically on the water. It's like a 20 story building falling over. If you're asking why they don't land it on a floating barge like Falcon 9, there are two reasons. One is that landing back on the launchpad lets them refuel and relaunch immediately. The other is that landing legs are big and heavy and significantly reduce the payload capacity. If you're already landing on the launchpad you might as well add arms to catch it. The mass of the arms is free because they're on the tower instead of the rocket, and the rocket only needs tiny nubs to catch on the arms instead of giant legs. Also the arms double as a crane to lift and stack the rocket on the launchpad.
- jojobas 2y ago>immediately So far this hasn't been shown even on much simpler Falcons. The barge gives quite some energy advantage for not having to boost back. Ideally they'd build a capesize kinda barge with chopsticks to catch it in the ocean, then perhaps service what they have to while it's steaming back.
- literalAardvark 2y agoHasn't been shown because they're not meant to be immediately reusable. Spaceship and/or super heavy are (I don't remember the details).
- jojobas 2y agoI'll believe it when I see it.
- avmich 2y agoIt would be good because there are many people who, roughly, refuse to believe their own eyes and keep moving goalposts, misrepresenting what they said or meant earlier, inventing additional conditions, changing their mind etc. If you would honestly believe that Starship can fly frequently when you see it flying frequently, you're already ahead of some.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- db48x 2y agoWhy do people ask the same questions every time? Can’t you search?
- diebeforei485 2y agoAbility to re-launch the same day.
- kfrzcode 2y agoEfficiency. If you don't have to recover the booster, load it up and transfer it back to the recovery & restoration bay, you save time and money. Not to mention if you can land the booster directly on the tower, clean it, fuel it up, and send it right back... imagine 4 Starships launching per day!