6 ms·
Valve developers discuss why Half Life 2: Episode 3 was abandoned
- fullshark 2y agoSo they had no idea where to go next and were tired. That's reasonable. Seems to be what happens to most long running pop culture entertainment products, but creators usually have mortgages to pay and can't alternatively devote their energies to building out something more lucrative like Steam.
- rightbyte 2y agoL4D was a real hit though. I don't think they let anyone or them self (the artistic spirit, not Valve) down.
- the_af 2y agoL4D was a genuinely good, groundbreaking game for its time. I didn't think it was possible to have so much fun with a multi-player FPS (CounterStrike and its ilk did nothing for me). I'm sure there are more impressive MP games nowadays, but back then it felt revolutionary.
- rightbyte 2y agoYe it was revolutionary. Both as multiplayer coop and as a zombie game.
- davidczech 2y agoI think Half Life: Alyx really is their "Half Life 3" - there's no game I've played that comes close to anything like it. It's fairly clear in hindsight they opted for a prequel to disassociate with the baggage HL3 carries, in all aspects.
- Wowfunhappy 2y agoI don't think it's reasonable. When you release part of an episodic story, you are making an implicit promise to your audience that you will finish the story! Even more so if you end on a cliffhanger. This applies just as much to George R. R. Martin, btw.
- Mistletoe 2y agoI think a lot of video game companies get into this trap. I can't speak for others but for me, I don’t care about technical innovation, just give me more Skyrim, Witcher, Fallout, Half Life, Baldur’s Gate, Elden Ring story. It’s not rocket science. Put all the money you wanted to give to tech guys that want to revamp the engine every year into hiring amazing writers and art direction people.
- bartread 2y agoI don't know: then you just end up with the videogame equivalent of the MCU which, at my most charitable, I would describe as uneven reaching mid at best. However, if we look at the median of how I feel about MCU, I'm just bored to tears with it. It's utter bilge. You just end up with this meaningless churning out of endless content for content's sake that goes nowhere and signifies nothing. Destiny 2 is actually a great example of this in the world of videogames.
- DrillShopper 2y ago> then you just end up with the videogame equivalent of the MCU We've been there for a long time - just off the top of my head: Call of Duty, Halo, Assassin's Creed, World of Warcraft (doubly so now with Classic), Fortnite Some people really just want to go back to the old and comfortable.
- usrusr 2y agoTrue. But is that market really that big? Once you've fallen behind a few releases you just don't care for the latest, and the not-latest lack any of that novelty appeal that video games tend to rely on quite a bit.
- righthand 2y agoThey also built up the myth both internally and externally that nothing they developed for the game was good enough, when people were already satisfied with the current mechanics. They wore themselves out saying it could be anything and accepting nothing. A monster of their own creation that is easily killed with a little humility. It is their desire to be unreasonable that led them there. Not reasonable at all IMO.
- schmidtleonard 2y agoYeah, the ice gun and blob baddie would have blown my mind even if they were 5 years late or whatever. I'd still love to play with them.
- aithrowawaycomm 2y agoIt seems like the real problem was burnout among the rank-and-file, not Gabe Newell's perfectionism. The staff seems to have had more fun with a goofy new IP like Left 4 Dead, versus a serious plot like HL2 where any perceived narrative misstep would be severely criticized. If they shoved the episode through and lost a lot of staff, then that would be a Phyrric victory. Contrary to some opinions here, Valve did not owe a single thing to HL fans, and they had no obligation to finish the story.
- righthand 2y agoThey don’t have that obligation to finish the story, but Half-Life 2 Episode 2 immediately retcons the ending of Half-Life 2 to give you more play in the world. Half-Life: Alyx, the entire game is a retcon of the ending of Episode 2. So to sit and claim there was nothing narratively interesting to work with and not a good direction to go in, is ridiculous because they always had a an escape hatch with the retcon. A company that has failed with sales of Portal 2 but has plenty of operating capital to continue on, Half-Life 2 Episode 3/Half-Life 3 at the very least was a promise they made and walked back. Yes they did owe something to the fans over the last 20 years. They were the ones who set out to outdo the previous episode and let the idea blossom into never good enough, not the fans.
- xk_id 2y ago
- mrandish 2y ago> So they had no idea where to go next and were tired. In my experience, a creative team realizing this and choosing to move on is both important and all-too rare. The only alternative I've seen is to find new project leadership who gets what made the original work, has a vision for extending it in new directions and the energy+talent to execute it. Obviously, finding that with high confidence is hard to do.
- hnthrowaway0328 2y agoWhat a tragedy. I hope the community projects go better.
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoAlso, the rent-seeking middleman business for PC games is easier and more profitable.
- righthand 2y agoHold on, just need to validate this comment by phoning home. In the mean time enjoy DOOM for $1 this holiday season.
- adamrezich 2y agoYeah Steam is terrible—I wish I still had to purchase my PC games from the other rent-seeking middleman at the Gamestop in the half-defunct mall in town, instead of clicking a few buttons and having a video game appear on my computer, ready to play. Though now that you mention it, it's weird, I never remember there being any indie PC games in my local Gamestop... strange...
- jcranmer 2y agoFrom the timeline, the decision to not pursue Episode 3 anymore was made well before Steam was a money printer, since this was back in 2008, and I don't think digital distribution became the dominant distribution medium until like 2010 or 2011 (note that Steam Greenlight only came into existence in 2012).
- Jtsummers 2y agoSteam made $1 billion in revenue in 2010. It may not have been the dominant distribution medium, but it was definitely a moneymaker by the end of the '00s.
- jcranmer 2y agoVia sourcing from Wikipedia, https://web.archive.org/web/20110213025041/http://www.forbes.com/forbes/2011/0228/technology-gabe-newell-videogames-valve-online-mayhem.html https://web.archive.org/web/20110213025041/http://www.forbes... notes that digital downloads surpassed physical media in 2010, and ancillary comments also indicate that it's on a pretty steep growth path at that time (Valve was rocking 200% growth rates at that time). Also, FWIW, Valve was regularly making ~one game a year, and only stopped that with the release of Dota 2 in 2013.
- citizenpaul 2y agoI don't understand why they are so cagey about releasing any of the work that was done even just as media content. At this point its been so long they cannot ruin the market and there is zero chance of it seeing production as is. They already print money with Steam, not like they would lose revenue.
- worble 2y agoI've said this before and it might be a minority opinion, but frankly I really couldn't care less if Valve made another half life game. There are tons of companies churning out fantastic games from both the AAA and indie space, that there's really no lack of games to choose from. Meanwhile, between their contributions to linux, proton, the steam deck, the index (just waiting on a new revision... any day now valve...) they are doing work that no-one else wants to, or can afford to, achieve. I'm glad they're focusing their efforts on these niche places with their infinite money printer, rather than being just another video games company.
- jsheard 2y agoThe cynical take is that they've given up on singleplayer games as a whole because their multiplayer titles are far more lucrative. In the 13.5 years since Portal 2 they've only released one full SP title, HL:Alyx, and that was arguably motivated by their VR initiatives need for a flagship showcase more than the desire to make a new SP game. It just had to be an SP game because VR was too niche to sustain an MP population. Everything else they've made in that time has been live-service forever-games which have relatively minimal development costs but generate hundreds of millions of dollars in profits, largely through predatory gambling mechanics. Putting a fresh coat of paint on Counter Strike made them upwards of a billion dollars in the first few months alone, and it'll keep printing money for much longer than Half Life 3 ever could: https://esports.gg/news/counter-strike-2/valve-cs2-money-2023/ https://esports.gg/news/counter-strike-2/valve-cs2-money-202... The sad thing is that being a private company they don't need to pursue Scrooge McDuck billions at any cost like a publicly held company would, they have the freedom to make whatever they want, but apparently what they want to do above all else now is to peddle lootboxes.
- schmidtleonard 2y agoThat or the flat organizational structure is dysfunctional and leads to constant restarts / vision changes. I don't know if they are too capitalist or too communist. Or both.
- wahnfrieden 2y agoThey may have a flat org structure but their payments are not similarly "flat" across the org. The economic structure is still pure capitalist.
- diggan 2y ago> I don't know if they are too capitalist or too communist. Or both. Or neither, Valve seems to do just fine as-is. Maybe they should just continue doing exactly what they're doing so far.
- SahAssar 2y ago
- luxuryballs 2y agoI would think they learned from L4D3 that they should stick to their normal pattern of stopping at 2.
- aranelsurion 2y agoHuh? But there was no L4D3? (am I having a whoosh moment here)
- luxuryballs 2y agoOh dude you’re right, for some reason I thought this was a sequel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Back_4_Blood https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Back_4_Blood
- underseacables 2y agoMaybe it's nostalgia but I would absolutely pay for a new Half Life. I would like to see the story completed.
- giobox 2y agoAnother point to remember in all this, is that in the early to mid 2000s game companies were obsessed with the idea of "episodic content". There were many other games in this time period ended in the same trap, that promised a number of episodes following the main release but gave up after the first couple - Alan Wake, Deus Ex HR etc. No one really even discusses the term "episodic content" in the industry anymore. I suspect the vast majority of Episode 1/2 players did so because it came bundled in Valve's famous Orange Box release, not because they bought the expansions separately. A quick google turns up this article discussing the same thing: > https://www.howtogeek.com/whatever-happened-to-episodic-games/#:~:text=Episodic%20games%20promised%20frequent%20releases,it%20hard%20to%20sustain%20financially https://www.howtogeek.com/whatever-happened-to-episodic-game....
- mdorazio 2y agoEhhh, only sort of. “Episodic Content” mostly turned into “DLC” and “Seasons” rather than disappearing entirely.
- astrange 2y agoAFAIK this is a way to keep your production pipeline busy by releasing parts of the game more often. If you do one large project, then your developers are tools down months or years before the game ships - so you need something for them to do next. If it's nothing, you may have to lay them off.
- unsnap_biceps 2y agoAt the time, each episode brought out amazing new gameplay mechanics and we were all buying them as soon as we saved up enough money. I don't think the episode format changed anything other then making it okay to send out a shorter game then a full flagship.
- giobox 2y ago> we were all buying them as soon as we saved up enough money Except most of us didn't. Valve actually gave some decent numbers in 2008. In just one year, Orange Box had sold over twice as many copies as Episode 1 did on its own. The pre-orange box sales suggest ~20% of Half Life 2 players bought the expansion stand alone. Fast forward to today, vastly more people will have played Orange Box, especially as it was the only way to play Episode 1/2 on the PS3 and Xbox 360. The lesson here was full games (Orange Box) typically sell better than episodes, which was the lesson almost everyone learned about "Episodic Content" in the 2000s. I note some folks argue we just got DLC - but we had DLC in the PS3/360 era too. "Episodic Content" was distinct from this as a business strategy, even if it strongly overlaps. Microsoft were constantly pushing the idea back then especially for the 360, there are a ton of talks/interviews still online from around 2005/6 from guys like Peter Moore on it. > https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2008/12/valve-divulges-life-time-retail-sales/#:~:text=Half%2DLife%20(Valve)%20%2F,Valve)%20%2F%202000%20%2D%204.2%20Million https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2008/12/valve-divulges-life-t...
- levocardia 2y agoI don't know why comments here are so negative. I respect the fact that they realized they were not on their A game and were not going to be able to deliver a great, innovative game to the fans. Having been disappointed many times in the last decade or so with many half-finished disasters of a sequel (and not just in gaming!) I'm incredibly happy Valve did not cynically crank out a garbage Episode 3 to cash in, when they easily could have. Of course, my #1 preference would be to have a mind-blowing, innovative, and narratively satisfying Episode 3, but my #2 preference is to not have a garbage sequel tacked on that would make me resent even HL2 and E1/E2
- bigstrat2003 2y agoIt doesn't seem like it should be that difficult to understand. Everyone shares your #1 preference (obviously), but for many people their #2 preference would've been to get any ending at all even if it wasn't perfect. I didn't play the Half-Life series but I tend to agree with those people. A story not having an ending taints the entire affair such that I would rather have never started it at all. A mediocre, or even bad, ending is far better than nothing.
- simoncion 2y ago> It doesn't seem like it should be that difficult to understand. You've explained it, and I expect OP already knew what you explained. It's still pretty incomprehensible. It's very, very strange that folks would rather have a shitty, low-quality, godawful ending to a high-quality multi installment story, rather than having the storywriters just walk away from a proven-to-be-high-quality, multi-installment project they know they can't make a good final installment for.
- bigstrat2003 2y agoI don't think "I disagree with these values" is the same as something being incomprehensible. I personally think it's bizarre that people want to have nothing versus having something flawed. It is imo a great example of letting the perfect be the enemy of the good. To me, that is tantamount to saying "I would rather that this series be retroactively ruined than have a flawed ending". But even with all that, I understand your position. I disagree with your values (strongly!), but that doesn't mean I can't comprehend them.
- tetrisgm 2y agoAs a former game developer, I can completely empathize. Some teams want to push the medium forward. Look at Doom, Mario 64. Half Life 2 is one of those titles. The problem is that the Episode 2 ending did tease the story going somewhere. It's not like the game was a mindless shooter consisting only of groundbreaking mechanics. It spent three games building these characters. People were invested in the story, and they were let down. However. People remember Half Life 2 for its physics. For the way it pushed graphics. For how it did environment based storytelling. For its AI entities you could control. For the amazing architecture. Very little of what made HL2 is the story. I think they made the right decision not to ship something they couldn't be proud of. That takes a lot of bravery, in my opinion. I wish they had been more open about it. In the recent years, I was impressed with how Nintendo came out publicly and said they were somewhat stuck and unhappy with Metroid Prime 4's development, apologized, and decided to start over. Metroid fans know about waiting for great games. It'll be worth it.
- wbl 2y agoFather Gregori? Barney's "about that beer I owe ya"? Even the architecture and scenery I'd count as story. The AI squad I never really took that much advantage of, but the antlions were cool.
- tetrisgm 2y agoYep that’s what I meant by storytelling through environment. The antlions were AI squad too :)
- _carbyau_ 2y agoSo they burnt out on it. That's fair. Then the managerial "owner" of the franchise should step back and let someone else run with it. It's a company, with $$$$$, not a single team. They could honestly do it right now - but by now it'd have to be a good story. Story is key. Hire someone to get a good story going and then motivate from that. There's a billion things you can do in that universe. I was hoping they were going to reinvigorate HL3 when they got the Portal people on. I don't need more and different engine mechanics, I just want a good story. Give me a level where I'm dual wielding gravity gun and portal gun while floating in a space suit and directing bouncy goop where I need it. Play with scale, let me push a planet through a portal or by opening a big portal on each of two planets let their gravity mean they smash together oh so slowly. Hell, make that the background motivation that means I have to get my shit done fast. But tell a good story please.