5 ms·
Seems like the logical endpoint of a lot of this is people getting paid directly for their attention. Want to call me? I've set a price of $5/call that I answer
by xnx 2y ago
Seems like the logical endpoint of a lot of this is people getting paid directly for their attention. Want to call me? I've set a price of $5/call that I answer, and an additional $10/minute of listen time after the first 10 seconds. Want to send me an email? $1/email and $5/100 words. Anyone I have emailed is automatically on my allow-list, which I can also adjust manually.
- wzsddtc 2y agoI think you have just described LinkedIn's business model, minus the fact that you don't get the money but the filter provider does.
- xnx 2y agoYes. There are all kind or brokers selling the attention of their audiences: Google, TV Networks, podcasts, LinkedIn, etc. I'd like to see another attempt at disintermediation in the space.
- tokioyoyo 2y agoAnd maybe like a temporary hold of the money, so you get it back if I’m convinced it’s not spam. Probably would resolve 99% of spam issues in the real world and create a chain of trust. Add some temporary disabling feature as well if you’re expecting a call from a random number too, so you’re set.
- swores 2y agoSounds like a great solution to the minority of people like you and me who wouldn't mind the added steps of approving every real phone call as not spam after, having to remember how to set that you're expecting a call from a random number, etc. I can't see it being acceptable to enough people for any network to go down this road unless spam levels get way worse.
- toss1 2y agoSpam is already at the level of changing people's default behavior from answering calls that come in to (as I saw described abt younger mobile users) "would rather pick up a live hand grenade than an unknown caller" Personally, my default was to pick up and is now if recognized contact pickup, if not and I'm expecting an unknown call, scrutinize, then if pickup, only answer with a cough or two — never "hello" or "yes" due to threat of voice cloning escalate to banks. Spam is universally detested My assessment is that voice calls are on the verge of going obsolete if the telcos fail to get a handle on spam. Yet the telcos behave as if they have no clue whatsoever and DGAF.
- plagiarist 2y agoReporting spam should be the other way around, it defaults to assuming a normal interaction. Consider: if you get harassed with a call or text you don't like, you send an SMS with that phone number to some known short code. You then receive $1 from the caller. If the caller cannot be found, the last verifiable link in the chain is responsible for paying the fine. This would cause carriers to behave overnight, instead of allowing foreign call centers to spoof other people's real private numbers with your area code.
- kyleee 2y agoAt least we can dream, ehh?
- swores 2y agoThat sounds a lot better to me
- red-iron-pine 2y agocouldnt they just automate ways to handle the code? plus a lot of spam comes out of compromised phones, or compromised systems. what good is this if i have your phone, or just your SIM?
- tokioyoyo 2y agoNot approving all the time, just setting every call by default to $1. Everyone who knows you will call knowing they’ll get their money back. And you can do an easy “add everyone in your contacts to a whitelist”, boom done.
- guidoism 2y agoThat's similar to the idea I had for combating texting spam: - If your number is in my address book then texts are free for you - If this is the first time you are contacting me then you pay me $1 There are probably downsides and ways this will screw up real relationships but it will certainly increase the cost of spam.
- Nition 2y agoOne issue I can forsee: - Every contractor (plumber etc) you hire will ask you to please add them to your contact list first so that they can message you. - After a while of half their clients not doing that and lots of fees on their end, contractors stop providing a phone number at all, asking you to please install ContractorApp to communicate with them.
- thejazzman 2y agoI love every part of this. Not having things in writing is one of the most common tactics with bad contractors. And I miss their call backs because I have unknowns goto spam, so I have to remember to disable that feature...
- crummy 2y agoMaybe when you first receive a text you see: This message is from an unknown number. (Accept / Block / Charge sender $1)
- telgareith 2y agoWell, that just invokes we-had-a-baby-its-a-boy
- sailfast 2y agoThey had a baby. It’s a boy! That said - perhaps harder to change the name that shows up as quickly as you could leave a recorded name? :) Still one of the best ads ever made.
- 2y ago
- bawolff 2y agoIf you have already sorted the world between people you want to take calls from and people you don't, why wouldn't you just block the people you don't want instead of charging them money?
- dotancohen 2y agoBecause there's a middle ground of people who we have not yet categorized. I don't know every phone number my doctor might call me from.
- anonzzzies 2y agoMy doctor, bank, eh well everyone, will text or email me if they cannot reach me. I haven't answered a number I don't recognize for the past 10 years; life is excellent.
- bawolff 2y agoAnd you think your doctor would be willing to pay for the privledge of talking to you?
- xnx 2y agoMy attention is valuable. I should be able to sell it on my terms.
- vinceguidry 2y agoNo way to vet the quality of your offering makes a both-ways attention economy fundamentally unworkable in a Western society. If you were really prepared to be an 'attention worker', then you could go work at a click farm or content moderation firm or the like, one of the fastest growing markets in the developing world. Best I can offer you is an in-game bonus for watching an ad.
- bawolff 2y agoIs it though? Like it might be valuable to you, but i doubt its valuable to anyone else in a phone call situation and both parties need to find value to make a sale. Like if you are interested in the convo then you should be paying the other person as you are getting value from the convo. What's the situation where you don't care about the convo but for the right price you could care, and the other party also thinks that price is reasonable? Like maybe if someone is trying to recruit you i guess, but the situations where that is true seem very few and far between (and we already have a system for that, where traditionally someone offers to buy you a meal in exchange for listening)
- speerer 2y agoSatoshi Nakamoto's first visionfor Bitcoin was just this - pay-to-send email.
- petesergeant 2y ago90% sure this was also an idea in Bill Gates’ “The Road Ahead”
- wcoenen 2y agoI think you're thinking of Hashcash? Not invented by Satoshi, and not pay-to-send exactly. It's proof-of-work for email. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hashcash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hashcash
- speerer 2y agoI'm certain Satoshi was thinking of Hashcash! But I did mean what I said, though it wasn't until Martti Malmi released his emails with Satoshi that I knew this, and so might not be well known: https://mmalmi.github.io/satoshi/ https://mmalmi.github.io/satoshi/ > "[this next bit turned out to be very controversial. there is extreme prejudice against spam solutions, especially proof-of-work.] > It can already be used for pay-to-send e-mail. The send dialog is resizeable and you can enter as long of a message as you like. It's sent directly when it connects. The recipient doubleclicks on the transaction to see the full message. If someone famous is getting more e-mail than they can read, but would still like to have a way for fans to contact them, they could set up Bitcoin and give out the IP address on their website. "Send X bitcoins to my priority hotline at this IP and I'll read the message personally."
- janalsncm 2y agoI have considered creating this email service. I’m sure many others have as well, in some form or another. Does it already exist?
- j2kun 2y agoPay to email has been tried multiple times, and failed.
- edelbitter 2y agoOr.. just have telcos do that to each other, instead of offloading any more of their service onto their customers/victims?
- mos_basik 2y agoThat's EVE Online's approach to fighting ingame "email" spam [0]. Every player can configure an amount of ingame money that is levied from a sender's account to deliver a message to them. It's a currency sink, so it's themed as a "tax" levied by the NPCs and its value is destroyed rather than paid to the recipient of the message. I thought it used to default to 5 ISK (a pittance, something you can make back by shooting a single NPC pirate ship). I see some references to the default being ~2000 ISK at the time that it was changed to 0, where it is now. Worked pretty well, imo. Players that need to be publicly contactable (people who organize public events, for instance) can turn it off easily. People who are "space famous" can crank it up to reduce targeted spam. Even at the default setting, it's effective at keeping ingame scammers from blasting the whole player list with messages (at least, the poor ones :). Doesn't apply to people you've already exchanged messages with. I think there's also some allowlisting you can do, etc. 0. https://wiki.eveuniversity.org/EVE_Mail#CONCORD_Spam_Prevention_Act https://wiki.eveuniversity.org/EVE_Mail#CONCORD_Spam_Prevent...
- xnx 2y agoGreat real world functioning example. The idea in general seems to have been around since 1992: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hashcash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hashcash
- ryandrake 2y ago> it's themed as a "tax" levied by the NPCs and its value is destroyed rather than paid to the recipient of the message. It’s a cool idea and would work good for real world fines, too: fines that destroy the money paid instead of transfer it (to the city, the court, the police and so on). The fines would disincentivize bad behavior, while also not incentivizing the police to “go generate some crime” because it pays them.
- xnorswap 2y agoSome argue that's how taxes work already. Taxation destroys money, government spending creates money. MMT (modern monetary theory) argues that taxation isn't about "funding", it's actually about controlling inflation. MMT is somewhat controversial.
- carlosjobim 2y agoEven if it was 20c per call/e-mail, it would solve the spam problem overnight, while not interfering significantly with legitimate communication.
- zahlman 2y agoHow exactly do you propose to collect the money?
- IshKebab 2y agoWell... I still get SMS spam. I assume spammers just use other people's hacked phones.
- Scoundreller 2y agoYou can get a sim for a few bucks and spam under the rate limit. You can buy jigs that hold hundreds of SIMs connected to a handful of cellular modems connected to a c&c and drip them out.
- IshKebab 2y agoRight but it costs money to send SMSs. At least it used to. I dunno if they've given up charging for that now since nobody uses them. Tbf I haven't seen a phone contract without unlimited texts for at least a decade I guess.