6 ms·
Open-Source Software Is in Crisis
- jqpabc123 2y agoOpen source is a system of prefect logic built on the foundation of a few flawed assumptions. - Money doesn't matter - Contributors are benevolent and altruistic - Commercial interests can't/won't game the process - Support and security is someone else's responsibility - Building useful and viable software is a fun hobby - All software should and will eventually be Open Source
- Pet_Ant 2y ago> Building useful and viable software is a fun hobby It is! It's a lot like community theatre. A lot of people who maybe thought they'd be major movie star when they took drama in high school end up in reality working boring jobs but producing for the love the art and the dream stuff that is much better than it has any right to be. Will it ever be as good the professional stuff with large budgets? Rarely. But it is good and remarkable how far it's come.
- openrisk 2y agoYou'd have to ask though, if the whole premise is so flawed, how come it has been the dramatic success it has been? There is nothing like this anywhere else in society. The only thing coming close might academic publishing (science) and this hints to what propels open source: openness, sharing knowledge is insanely productive, it creates enormous leverage to build on each others effort. Clearly so far we have not found ways to fairly attribute that benefit to make the whole phenomenon easily self-financing. But its not clear it cannot be done.
- jqpabc123 2y agoThere is nothing like this anywhere else in society. I wonder why others don't work for free too? Even my 13 year old neighbor expects to get paid for mowing my lawn. But its not clear it cannot be done. It's not possible to prove that something can't be done.
- openrisk 2y ago> I wonder why others don't work for free too? You need to explain the billions of lines of open source code. > It's not possible to prove that something can't be done. This is just sophistry. Many "business models" are being tried, granted none seems to be failproof but it suggests there is a space to explore. We are talking about a process that is barely two decades old. The familiarity and safety of paid work with fiat money, contracts, private investment and all that, its all based on inventions that came about to solve similar frictions in the past.
- pjmlp 2y agoMost of it is building portfolio, or university students projects, thesis. That is how those millions came to be, outside paying jobs.
- ttoinou 2y agocoders are both artists and artisans, sometimes it’s just beautiful, sometimes it can generate money
- tartoran 2y ago> There is nothing like this anywhere else in society. Though they are rare, they exist. The Osho cult comes to mind , Rajneeshpuram Commune became a self-sustained community that attracted thousands of followers and they worked for free. This is related to ideology when it aligns with what people want and it is sustainable, people have no problem offering their work for free. And of course someone comes along and takes advantage of it all.
- Vegenoid 2y agoBut they weren't really working for free, they were working for food and housing, right?
- GauntletWizard 2y agoI'm not sure you can call a group most noted for its "Role in 1984 bioterror attack" a success.
- account42 2y agoThe big difference is that open source is no longer an isolated community - the whole world is built on open source software. I agree though that sharing and caring is not as uncommon as some people would like to pretend. Another example of it are all kinds of online communities sharing anything from memes to cat pictures to mods to instructions how to do all kinnds of things to direct help. Some of this is drifting more and more to being monetized (see most YouTube channels) but there is still a huge amount of people sharing with others without a profit motive.
- bcdtttt 2y agoIt's anarchism, my friend. Not the purge style anarchism, but the academic Kropotkin "Conquest of Bread" style of anarchism. And it's existed many times in human history, it just is fairly antagonistic with capitalism, so anarchism is a lot less popular these days. But it absolutely exists elsewhere in society!
- tuna74 2y agoI am a soccer coach for kids (my own included) in my free time. In a lot of ways it is the same as working on FOSS software. You don't get anything for it, but you get to work with other people and it is pretty fun interacting with the kids. And even if one of the kids becomes a pro you won't get any compensation for your work as well :)
- account42 2y agoIt's not a matter of finding ways to reward people that positively contribute society, it's a matter of convincing those in power to implement them - and those people largely overlap with those benefitting from the current model.
- einpoklum 2y agoYou could say that Free software is built on a different set of assumptions: - Money is not all that matters - People will write software for themselves and their friends, and will not deny it to the public out of spite/greed. Companies might, but licensing can mitigate this. - Commercial interests might game some of the process, but not its core - Support and security is my responsibilty, your responsibility, everyone's responsibility - Building useful and viable software is sometimes fun, sometimes necessary, sometimes profitable - Most software people use should and will eventually be Free - lire and gratis
- vinceguidry 2y ago> Companies can pledge to help out Ha! Best laugh of the day. You went out of your way to cater to bigcorps by avoiding free software licenses like the plague then complain that they're mistreating you by not paying you? Soon they'll start wearing suits and spout buzzwords.
- ndriscoll 2y agoMissing option: don't grant a license to use your code if you'll be upset that people will use your code. Use something like AGPL or don't grant any license at all. Granting no license means others using your code in any way is copyright infringement, which individuals don't need to care about, but makes it something no business of any significant size will touch.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- graemep 2y agoIf its FOSS you also have to convince other contributors to work your choice of license. The first example in the article is Wordpress whose developers did not get to chose the license because they forked an existing GPL project. > Granting no license means others using your code in any way is copyright infringement, which individuals don't need to care about, but makes it something no business of any significant size will touch. How do individuals get your code? How do they install it? Copyright matters to most distribution mechanisms. A good many small businesses (not just those of significant size) would be reluctant to breach copyright. I think if you want to do that use a license that allows non-commercial use or use by businesses below a certain size.
- ndriscoll 2y agoIf you build a business on a fork of someone else's project, you can't really complain. Using GPL was the cost of starting from that base. Individuals get your code from you or each other. I don't doubt that you'd have easy to use packaging if "Source available + All Rights Reserved + casual piracy" caught on as a copyleft "license"; the *arr software sort of demonstrates that already. That it only allows people who are not reluctant to break copyright laws to use your software is exactly the point. It's a proper anarchist's copyleft license.
- graemep 2y ago> If you build a business on a fork of someone else's project, you can't really complain. Using GPL was the cost of starting from that base. I agree - but that is what people like the Wordpress developers are complaining of. > Individuals get your code from you or each other. I don't doubt that you'd have easy to use packaging if "Source available + All Rights Reserved + casual piracy" caught on as a copyleft "license"; the *arr software sort of demonstrates that already. I am very cautious about installing things not from either distro repos (on my desktop) or from a known app store (not necessarily the OS developers) on mobile. How would people know that was your intent? If they get the software from each other, how could they verify it did not have malware inserted. One of the things I like about FOSS is that it can be forked. If the original developer stops working on it (especially if they stop applying security patches), or to take it in a different direction, or if the original developer changes licence for new versions (the equivalent with your idea would be to start enforcing the copyright). > That it only allows people who are not reluctant to break copyright laws to use your software is exactly the point. It's a proper anarchist's copyleft license. Its not copyleft. If people get software from each other how do you ensure that the source gets distributed? Or that people know they can get the source and from where?
- account42 2y agoThere is no crisis, only slow learners finally realizing why the (A)GPL exists.
- spacemanspiff01 2y agoSo I don't really know what I'm talking about... But isn't the EU cyber resiliency act about requiring companies to provide guarantees on their software? Open source projects alone cannot provide those, but it seems like something a secondary organization could provide ala a 'pay us a fee, and we will provide a legal guarantee' on software quality + liability insurance. The only way that those liability organizations could provide those type of guarantees is by being associated with the project/updates, and ideally use the money they get from liability fees to cover developer pay?
- Kon-Peki 2y agoThe act was modified to ensure that it wouldn't kill non-commercial open source. But if you try to monetize, you have a lot more responsibility. That is reasonable, but on the other hand, with burnout and other issues surrounding unpaid work... How sustainable is open source without any sort of monetization?
- ta_111424 2y agoStep 1. Assert there is a crisis. Step 2. Insert yourself as the solution. My goodness. Didn't we see the results of the "Code of Conduct" wars? There was a "crisis" of "toxicity" that had to be fixed. What resulted? Endless drama from meddling management types. They couldn't write a line of code to save their lives, but want to take over the projects to serve their social goals. > Whitacre suggests “three levers to pull to solve the open-source sustainability crisis and quit burning out maintainers.” These three levers revolve around commercialization, taxation, and social validation. Rofl. You want to know how to cause a real crisis in the open source world? Involve government, taxes, and "social validation" systems. Edit: Oh, by the way. Once you start receiving tax money, you become dependent on it. And then the government effectively gains control over your project. "Develop this, or we cut off your funding."
- einpoklum 2y agoI would say that "Codes of Conduct" _are_ a crisis, and exacerbated toxicity... as you put it, "endless drama". As for involving government in FOSS - many of the universities and institutions where software was written, shared and exchanged in the 1960s and 1970s were "government" or government-funded. DARPA is government, UC Berkeley is a state university, etc. So government was very much involved. Otherwise, I agree that the article does not establish a crisis.
- eclark 2y agoOpen source has a lot of issues: - The anchoring principal. Once you have set the that the software is free, humans expect it to be free forever and all related things are judged off the initial impressions' price bucket. Humans will never want to pay for it later. It's judged worthless. Open-core and closed-source addons and support models have misaligned principles. The community wants things to be easy to use and opinionated, while the OSS company wants to include as many customers as possible who need or want your help with their niche choices. - Sustainability is awful. If you start an open source project you're either going to burn yourself and the community out, or require funding to do it as a day job. So, if you want the project not to stop early, you need money to pay for developers to make software better. - Larger companies want something opinionated but rarely what's good for most of the community. So eventually when big tech/big industry is paying for developers to work on the project, there's a point where the large company will want their cake and the community is hostage. Do that enough times and the large company forks internally and the community fractures or withers out. Source: I was at Cloudera while the Big Data craze took off. Then, I did open source for large tech.
- random3 2y agoHey Elliott, long time . I think the key issue is with the assumption that anything beyond the license will happen. Any assumption that there's another (moral?) contract is wrong. If the OSS is free, then the product can't be the OSS. Any unaligned incentives can put the community in conflict which is something that was common in the Apache ecosystem. So the problem is not with OSS itself, but the sustainability assumptions around some OSS efforts.
- eclark 2y agoHey Cosmin long time! I agree the contract should be clear up front. Changing expectations later is a big problem. People want to give away the software for a while, using it as a loss leader to get attention while not being honest about their later need for money to fund the ongoing concern. I tried to write a little bit about that in my post here: https://www.batteriesincl.com/posts/fairsource https://www.batteriesincl.com/posts/fairsource I was starting Batteries Included and had been writing it in Elixir. I want to give back to the community, show how to use Phoenix/Live view, and be transparent about what users are running, etc. However, I also know that if this will work long-term, I can not give it away to everyone forever. So it's better to be honest about things as early as possible. We paid a very smart lawyer to draft the best compromise we could as early as possible. https://www.batteriesincl.com/LICENSE-1.0 https://www.batteriesincl.com/LICENSE-1.0 This means we can develop in the open here: https://github.com/batteries-included/batteries-included https://github.com/batteries-included/batteries-included while also giving it away long term and still being honest that this will require some long-term revenue stream. That revenue stream will come from the companies using it on larger installs.
- random3 2y agoThe author is missing the point. This is trademark battle, not a licensing one. OSS is not in more trouble than it ever was. Software is, but that's a different problem. The assumption that you're going to make something open source and get all the benefits of open source distribution while assuming that you're going to make money on it because you deserve it, while others don't is wrong. If you have any assumptions about how and to whom your software will make money. Put them in the license.
- DataDaemon 2y agoUnfortunately, inflation and the cost of living are killing the idea of free software. It's hard to program anything when your stomach is rumbling from hunger.
- foobarian 2y agoMaybe it can go back to the domain of students and residents of humane societies that provide a safety net. Little of value will be lost.
- jmclnx 2y agoSomeone creates a cool app, a fortune 500 company takes it, makes billions and gives nothing back. That is the issue, there are many examples. Look at OpenSSL, the timezone database issues a few years ago. The developers were pretty much close to being homeless. An issue occurred and companies paniced, did the give, no. I do not know what happened to OpenSSL, but I think some "foundation" took it over and the original developer(s) still got nothing. OpenSSH is another example, IBM gives 0 to it, but it is used in AIX and Red Hat. Of all companies, Microsoft does donates some $ to OpenSSH. With Cloud Applications, this is getting worse fast.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jltsiren 2y agoThe real issue is people selecting a license that says something while actually wanting something else. You either develop open source because someone pays for it (in which case it's an ordinary business transaction) or because you find it inherently rewarding and you have another way of paying your bills. If any of these stops being true – if the business fails, if the hobby / volunteer project stops being rewarding, or if you need more time for a normal job – you abandon the project. Maybe someone else picks it up or maybe nobody does, but it doesn't matter. The traditional permissive licenses are named after universities, and they are modeled after the reward structures of the academia. A big company taking what you created and making billions with it (without giving you anything) is exactly the outcome you hoped for. You'll have some real-world impact to show the next time your performance is evaluated. If that's not what you wanted, you need to select a more appropriate license for your project.
- lifeline82 2y ago[dead]
- einpoklum 2y agoRead the paper, and did not see evidence presented of there being a _crisis_. Certainly, commercial companies not contributing back is a _problem_, but what is it that's about to collapse? PS - Writing this from the perspective a FOSS developer and maintainer who feels under-appreciated and is not compensated for maintenance work of (in my biased opinion) somewhat-important code.
- alexjray 2y agoTypical OSS is a luxury belief. If it's not supporting a business it typically fails and is being supported by businesses as a proxy. The core issue is that maintainers have a luxury belief counter to this. OSS is a strategy/tool for companies. The only exception to that is fundamental software that creates entirely new markets that can sustain it like bitcoin. That being said there is no crisis, sustainably supported OSS will continue to thrive.
- gtsop 2y agoOpen-Source is in Crisis because Open Source is the corporate spin on Free Software in order to make money, which as many have pointed out, isn't a great fit. It cpuld work, but as an exception. On the other hand, actual Free Software as in GPL are in no crisis at all. I'll smirk everytime i see such news and it warms my heart. I know, i'm a bad person.
- bcdtttt 2y agoThis is laughable. Like, yes, free software is better and open source is a capitalist spin. But these problems still impact free software. AWS can still exploit the labor of free software engineers and profit while not giving those devs any support.
- rbanffy 2y agoIf you make your software freely available to everyone, it seems to follow you do not expect compensation for the software you offered freely to everyone. I do a little - a couple Docker images (mostly someone else's software), a couple utilities, a font, small contributions to projects for solving problems I experienced. I don't expect compensation for any of that - it's a hobby. I have a day job and I use some of that software in it, and, at least until we arrive at a post-scarcity economy, that's what will pay my bills.
- bcdtttt 2y agoI don't think that follows are all, actually. I might give something away and say, "support my patreon" or "buy me a beer" or "contribute back" or "pay for support". You might expect that any arbitrary person might not compensate you, but still expect compensation. Giving away your work doesn't mean you don't value your labor.
- rbanffy 2y agoStarting a Patreon might be a good idea.
- teeray 2y agoOpen source shouldn't be a complete free lunch for for-profit companies. It would be nice if there was some tithe that companies had to pay to open source that they used. Like, take N% of the revenue your project generated and distribute it equally among the open source projects your project depends on.
- dyauspitr 2y agoLicenses are a solution to this. You can stipulate that if your code is being used for profit by a company with more than 1000 employees, then you need to pay a certain amount into it.
- rbanffy 2y agoOr just start by offering it under the (A)GPL with the option of dual licensing.
- SpicyLemonZest 2y agoI wouldn't frame it this way in a vacuum, but the organizing philosophy of open source is precisely to be a free lunch. Meta doesn't pay me when they use my projects, but they also don't charge me when I use React. Introducing mandatory monetary compensation would produce a lot of thorny coordination problems. The free software movement makes it work with in-kind code contributions, of course, but that's a cost most commercial users are unwilling to pay.
- pevey 2y agoAnd then the software would never be widely adopted. FOSS is what it is and the dynamics around it haven't really changed. What has changed is people wanting the rapid adoption rate possible from being FOSS without actually... being FOSS. I'm sorry, I have zero sympathy. If you want your product to be a paid product, just charge for it. What's that? No one would try it? Just give a free trial. What's that? Not enough people would use it for there to be this large community of people providing help, and tutorials, and addons/extensions/plugins, etc.? The freeloaders are the people releasing their software as FOSS, using the community to get big, and then wanting to change their minds about it.
- bloopernova 2y agoSo many for-profit corporations depend utterly on non-profit open source. They'll feel the bite if open source is negatively affected in the coming years.
- Vegenoid 2y agoIt's a bit confusing to see maintainers of software with permissive licensing getting upset about companies using their software. Does this happen because they didn't really think about the license and its implications when they chose it? The potential of "our software is extremely valuable and used by massive corporations who give nothing back" was too remote to properly consider? Maybe most of the projects where this is occurring are a bit older, and new projects are thinking carefully about the license from the outset.
- evoke4908 2y agoLicenses often are not respected by business. Businesses also tend to demand free support in perpetuity without ever once contributing anything be it money or code. Viewed this way, businesses are just using open source as free labor.
- jhickok 2y agoI'm out over my skis a bit on this one, but out of curiosity (and having never experienced it), what sort of leverage does a business have demanding free support from contributors that are under no obligation to provide it? Those seem to be easy emails to ignore, personally.
- tcmart14 2y agoThat is true. Maintainers don't owe them anything, most of the licenses say this and express no-warranty or guarantees. But its more about, people feel obligated to provide support for their open sourced projects even though that technically isn't required. More of a human nature/psychology thing.
- cudgy 2y agoFurthermore, you are dealing with someone (maintainer) who is giving their time for free to further the project so corps can use it to build stuff. Who better for a corporation to make unrecompensed demands from? They already demonstrate willingness to work for free.
- danjl 2y agoWe could easily support government grants to Open Source developers and companies without needing to increase taxes. It should already be part of the NSF grant process that funds a large number of universities, who's research is also given away for public use (most of the time). Sure, you'd have to fill out lots of forms and be at the mercy of the bureaucratic grant submission system, but that process already has mechanisms for managing IP and leaving ownership with the grantee. Despite its frustrations, it is already a much healthier way of developing IP compared to the VC-supported route.
- ThinkBeat 2y agoThe problem is not with open source as a concept and as a craft. The problem is that people confuse it with making money. If you are doing open source with the expectation that you will get rich, then you are in the realm of cognitive dissonance. There is nothing inherently wrong about donig it that way, but its not in the spirit of open source. A lot of "open source startup bros" just think open source is leet cool, its trendy. But the idea that their hard work will go unpaid is an affront for them. Maybe you have a codebase and if it starts geting tractino you have a while Where the community invests time and expands what the codebase can do. Then there comes a juncture a semi open source "core" and then premium (often partially created by the community) becomes closed source and epxensive. Yet the same people are happy to use open source platforms, databases, operating sytems, etc etc ot create their new project yet they never seem to feel the need to pass the money down the chain of programmers who hve created everythig they use.
- Ferret7446 2y agoThe term "open source" itself explains the problem. It was originally called free software, which is admittedly confusing in English, but also inconvenient for corporations who wanted to exploit it. Because it's not a huge issue whether free software was libre or gratis, because practically all of it was both libre and gratis. But if you're a company, you like neither the libre nor the gratis. So it was rebranded to "open source" precisely to market it to businesses. https://producingoss.com/en/introduction.html#free-vs-open-source https://producingoss.com/en/introduction.html#free-vs-open-s...
- anacrolix 2y agoI have mountains of open source projects and over the years I have discovered mostly though accident that it is being used without attribution or any communication in numerous projects. It's also copied and stolen outright by other open source projects. There's very little recognition for successful projects either: Interviewers still want ridiculous take home tests and other nonsense despite 100s of thousands of lines of code in numerous languages. Open source is a psy op for companies and individuals that excel at marketing more than actual programming.