9 ms·
If you have the chance to try out a Waymo (you own a credit card and smart phone and find yourself in San Francisco, Los Angeles, Phoenix or Austin if you can g
by simonw 2y ago
If you have the chance to try out a Waymo (you own a credit card and smart phone and find yourself in San Francisco, Los Angeles, Phoenix or Austin if you can get through that waitlist) I thoroughly recommend it.
Right now it's the most exciting tourist attraction in San Francisco.
The first few minutes are pretty terrifying... but the ride is so smooth that you very quickly settle into it. It's absolutely worth experiencing.
- underseacables 2y agoI'd like to but how do you overcome the slight powerless feeling? Like when those guys surrounded a vehicle and made it to stop with people helplessly inside. You're kind of stuck.
- lesuorac 2y agoSame as when you're in an uber?
- Frederation 2y agoYou have control in that instance. Apples and oranges.
- fragmede 2y agoWhat control over the human Uber/Lyft driver, whom you've never met before, do you have?
- barbazoo 2y agoSelf preservation.
- Dylan16807 2y agoYou control someone else's self preservation? That doesn't make sense to me unless you're suggesting the passenger also threaten the driver. Did you answer the question they actually asked?
- Sohcahtoa82 2y agoOstensibly, the Uber/Lyft driver is also feeling threatened and will gun the throttle in an attempt to escape the situation, even if an attacker is directly in front.
- fragmede 2y agoSure, but that wasn't the question.
- kaycebasques 2y agoOr an airplane.
- rglullis 2y agoOn an airplane, the pilot has skin in the game. If he screws up, he will pay with his own life. What happens to the developers/manufacturers of a driverless car that kills a passenger or a pedestrian?
- kaycebasques 2y agoI thought we were talking about the feeling of powerlessness? Still seems like an apples-to-apples comparison in that regard. > how do you overcome the slight powerless feeling
- rglullis 2y agoI don't have any "feeling of powerlessness" when I am on a plane, or a taxi, or a bus or train or a boat, because I believe that whoever is conducting those vehicles have interests aligned with mine: to get safely and uneventfully to the end of the journey. There is no such alignment on a driverless car, plane or boat. No engineer or executive will get punished in case the car gets double parked, let alone if it runs over a pedestrian crossing the street.
- jerlam 2y agoIn the event of an emergency, the Uber driver is also a human who would take action (possibly extreme or illegal) to get out of a life-threatening situation. The self-driving car will not.
- minwcnt5 2y agoYou can open the door and get out if it's stopped. You can press the "pull over" button to have it pull over as soon as it can safely do so. You can call rider support or 911 while the doors remain locked to the outside. I agree that it's a slightly more vulnerable feeling than driving myself, but I still feel far less vulnerable than taking public transit or walking. And when you factor in risk of a crash, it's also safer than Uber or driving myself. I don't think Waymos will often be targeted by criminals for anything besides vandalism, with 20+ cameras and potential remote monitors the risk:reward ratio is much worse than other options.
- rglullis 2y ago> I still feel far less vulnerable than taking public transit or walking. This sounds incredibly dystopian. What hellhole do you live? What are the dangers you have from taking public transit?
- underseacables 2y agoWell, New York City, but that is more of an edge case. Most public transit in America is safe .... I think.
- fragmede 2y agoThe other people on public transport, not the least of which from them is second hand smoke from either fentanyl or meth, not sure which, nor do I care to learn. I still ride the bus/trolley/tram/subway, especially when the streets are busy, but late at night I'll opt for a Waymo, depending on the circumstance.
- rglullis 2y ago[flagged]
- spankalee 2y agoI guess this old gem doesn't just apply to Twitter: > Twitter is the only place where well articulated sentences get misinterpreted. > > You can say “I like pancakes” and somebody will say “So you hate waffles?” > > No bitch, that’s a whole new sentence wtf is you talkin bout
- dpe82 2y agoYou get over it very quickly. The first ride or two is a bit weird and then you just settle into enjoying it.
- mattnewton 2y agoThe real difference is that those guys felt emboldened to act that way with nobody at the wheel. They might not have trusted an uber driver to not drive into them, and there is a social element where some people apparently don’t think about how they are acting on video, they think nobody is around. I expect this to go away over time as people realize driverless =\= witnessless You can quickly call for human assistance on one of the big support buttons.
- heelix 2y agoI did my first ride when I was at a conference in SFO earlier this month. Part of it was it 'shows' you what it sees, which was a bit better on what I could track as a human with my head on a swivel. The car never went beyond residential speeds and it was very much felt like a fast car trying to be cautious. It was less terrifying then teaching my kid to drive. We very much felt like we were on a tourist ride - and the taxis that drove past us often had folks trying to get video/pictures of us passengers in a car without the driver. Watching a couple hundred of them try to get out of a parking lot was comical.
- barbazoo 2y ago> Like when those guys surrounded a vehicle and made it to stop with people helplessly inside. Is that a common thing? I wouldn't be surprised honestly. I heard of the traffic cone thing but not this.
- singleshot_ 2y agoYou get out and use reasonable force to break free of their false imprisonment, the same way you would if you were in your own car and you were falsely imprisoned. I hope very strenuously that the implication is not that you would run over people who are blocking you if you were in control of the car.
- rangestransform 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attack_on_Reginald_Denny https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attack_on_Reginald_Denny I would rather take many lives than be subjected to this sort of injury
- singleshot_ 2y agoUnfortunately the Bush Doctrine is not valid in traffic. I believe you will find significant challenges if you try to justify murder this way.
- rangestransform 2y agoThe government expecting me to resign myself and roll over in this situation is the real problem
- singleshot_ 2y agoSociety expects you to roll over. The government has the power to imprison you if you refuse.
- DiggyJohnson 2y agoI would strongly consider it, for sure. If I was stopped by obvious muggers in a dangerous place, alone, then definitely. I wouldn't aim for them, and I would certainly hope they jump out of the way. But quite literally you can expect to get hurt if you play in traffic.
- DiggyJohnson 2y agoDo you ever fly?
- doctorpangloss 2y ago> Right now it's the most exciting tourist attraction in San Francisco. I'm as excited as you about self driving cars, but the vehicles are essentially driven remotely, maybe not by live video feed but nonetheless by remote operators, in the sense that matters. It is more tourist attraction than it is end-all be-all of technology, which was very deflating to find out. All I am really saying Simon is that you are a highly educated guy: adopt a more nuanced take on this. According to the people I know who work in this space and are not trying to raise money for autonomous vehicles, and according to many journalists, there is a lot of consensus that Waymo has adopted a remote driving scheme that is working, and perhaps that is why they are operating a taxi service and others are not. It isn't clear if that growth story, as great as it is, will help them raise enough money to invent truly autonomous vehicles.
- Elinvynia 2y agoIt's like people forgot about the Amazon stores being an army of cheaply paid third world labour disguised as revolutionary technology.
- Dylan16807 2y agoThey had too high a rate of needing humans, but nevertheless it was almost entirely computers. That wasn't a disguise.
- bowmessage 2y agoSource for this claim?
- porphyra 2y agoRemote operators only help out in rare cases
- Pxtl 2y agoVehicles per-operator is the important metric, imho. If one operator can supervise a dozen vehicles at a time with only occasional manual intervention then it's still a massive labor-saving tool.
- rglullis 2y agoPlease, don't. Let's not normalize yet another corporate attempt to privatize urban mobility: https://youtube.com/watch?v=040ejWnFkj0 https://youtube.com/watch?v=040ejWnFkj0
- mise_en_place 2y agoUrban mobility means very little when your streets aren't safe. I'm paraphrasing a poor translation, but as a Central American leader recently said: >Some say that we have imprisoned thousands, but the reality is that we have freed millions. Waymo is very much like this. It inconveniences a few people, but it also saves a lot more from accidents, or even worse.
- rglullis 2y agoPushing for autonomous vehicles will lead to a local maxima which is worse, more expensive, and less universal than solutions that already exist and have been deployed in every developed country that is not increasingly car dependent.
- rangestransform 2y agoIt's a sisyphean effort to build rail in the US, and an even bigger one to drag american suburb dwellers into an urbanist future. Developing autonomous vehicles good enough for 90% of trips is probably cheaper than building rail, the total amount invested into waymo so far (11.1B) will build you about 4 miles of subway in manhattan [1] [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/28/nyregion/new-york-subway-construction-costs.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/28/nyregion/new-york-subway-...
- rglullis 2y agoYou are arguing based on sunk costs, and even if rail was not an alternative, the US could be investing in other modes of transport: light rail (trams), buses and electric bikes. Also, you are not accounting for externalities. Get the suburbanites to pay for all the extra costs they incur on the roads, power/water/waste distribution, healthcare costs incurred by air and environmental pollution from all the cement for roads and parking lots... Quickly they will change their tune and will be willing to become "city dwellers".
- bekantan 2y agoI was in SF back in May, but didn't manage to get through the waitlist :( It was so cool to see them diving around. Interestingly, when I showed the clips to some of my senior family members, they didn't seem interested at all. I think they couldn't comprehend what was going on, even after I explained. Their (several independent trials) reaction was similar to showing them some AI-generated image of something which clearly can't exist. It was so absurd that it was just filtered out with a comment "yeah, yeah - nice car".
- buzzert 2y agoEvery quantum leap in technology looks that way. It's so unbelievable/magic that people can't even comprehend it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mistrial9 2y ago> Right now it's the most exciting tourist attraction in San Francisco Right now those robocars are widely and openly hated by many people who live in San Francisco
- astrange 2y agoPeople who live in SF hate everything though.
- creer 2y agoSome of them pretty much do, and they are certainly vocal about it!
- smugma 2y agoThis is certainly true, but doesn't mean that they aren't hugely popular [1]. We (me with young children) used to call out "Driverless Car" whenever we'd see one, but it is less interesting when you may see 15 over the course of a 2.5 mile, 15 minute drive. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/SelfDrivingCars/comments/1gi8cyf/waymo_did_300k_trips_in_sf_in_august_more_than/ https://www.reddit.com/r/SelfDrivingCars/comments/1gi8cyf/wa...
- s1artibartfast 2y agoWe just shout "Whammo!" but also enjoy them.
- simonw 2y agoThat's pretty common for popular tourist attractions generally.
- kfajdsl 2y agoThey are also widely and openly loved by many people who live in San Francisco. I bet if you did polling the vast majority of people would either like them or be ambivalent.
- eric_cc 2y ago
- andrei_says_ 2y agoI will definitely try it out. Long term however I feel uneasy about actively undermining the income opportunities for so many people.
- DiggyJohnson 2y agoThat's an interesting tradeoff to make. So try it once and swear it off afterwards for ideological purposes? I already feel myself creating a bit of a conversational rage trap here though, so apologies in advance.
- harmmonica 2y agoI certainly understand the sentiment, but can you think of historical examples where technology, which oftentimes in history has undermined income opportunities for people, has not been adopted for that reason? I guess I'm really asking whether there has ever been a successful effort to stop the adoption of tech that undermines human labor/income opportunity. We're certainly in the thick of it right now. Recent high profile ones: LLMs, port automation, other types of AI for media production, I'm sure the list goes on and on. The reason I'm asking is not to advocate for technology, but rather to understand if there have been successful efforts in the past to stifle tech. If there haven't been noteworthy ones, then my gut says we ought to be focused on how to get those people to not be left behind (so so incredibly difficult) rather than preserving something solely for the sake of people making money off of it. Like I said, so easy to say, but incredibly difficult to achieve in practice. Not sure there are great examples of people not being left behind.
- jqpabc123 2y agoundermining the income opportunities for so many people. Don't worry. Once the novelty has worn off, the cost will probably be on par with Uber and Lyft with real human drivers --- if not higher. The acquisition, maintenance and supervision costs for the self driving vehicles will probably consume any difference in cost.
- ghaff 2y agoA lot of people are assuming that replacing cars driven by minimum wage/sub-minimum wage drivers with high tech robotaxis will make this sort of transportation almost too cheap to meter. Long-term there's presumably some advantage espeically as costs drop to the level where an autonomous car is just a car. I'm not sure there's ever this magical transition where a car you use a few times a day (and is specific to your needs) is ever replaced by an on-demand service to a significantly greater degree than today.