6 ms·
Edge Scripting: Build and run applications at the edge
- jsheard 2y agoThey're undercutting CF Workers - requests are $0.2/million rather than $0.3/million, and CPU time costs the same. Seems pretty good on paper. There's no free allowance like you get with Workers though.
- j45 2y agoIf cost is a factor, one could plausibly put bunny behind cloudflare’s free side. Another positive side effect would be to have paid dual redundancy then too. Backblaze is another neighbour that plays nice with bunny.
- Sytten 2y agoTheir bandwidth is still too expensive and that is what really matters for an edge worker. It is not AWS expensive, but still 0.01$/GB is not cheap.
- csomar 2y agoYou usually use them for compute and low-bandwidth related activities (like an API).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jorams 2y agoThey're close to as cheap as they come for CDN bandwidth list prices without minimums, especially for CDNs with their level of global coverage. Competitors in this space in particular are often much more expensive, like Deno Deploy's $0.50/GB. Cloudflare is effectively impossible to compare because it's all "free until you get an email from sales".
- pier25 2y agoI don't think egress really matters for this use case. How many API calls or HTML pages do you need to transfer 1GB?
- skybrian 2y agoI was wondering how this compares to Deno Deploy. From an API point of view, it looks rather limited? They seem to have some storage offerings but it’s unclear how they connect.
- apitman 2y agoBunnySDK.net.http.serve(async (request: Request): Response | Promise<Response> => { return new Response("Hello World"); }); I love that pretty much all the JS runtimes have settled on `(Request): Response`[0], but I really wish they would standardize starting the server as well. Would make writing cross-runtime services easier. [0]: https://blog.val.town/blog/the-api-we-forgot-to-name/ https://blog.val.town/blog/the-api-we-forgot-to-name/
- plopz 2y agoThats new to me, is that an attempt to standardize similar to PHP's psr-7?
- laktek 2y agoI think the closest thing we got is the Default fetch export https://docs.deno.com/runtime/fundamentals/http_server/#default-fetch-export https://docs.deno.com/runtime/fundamentals/http_server/#defa..., which Cloudflare Workers, Deno Deploy and Supabase Edge Functions support.
- throwitaway1123 2y agoNode is the only major outlier. Bun supports this convention as well: https://bun.sh/docs/api/http#export-default-syntax https://bun.sh/docs/api/http#export-default-syntax
- apitman 2y agoI had no idea this was a thing. Thanks!
- diggan 2y agoI wonder where the pattern first comes from? I think I either came across it in Express (JS) or Ring (Clojure) first but surely it was first done somewhere else.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 2y ago
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoWouldn't running on the edge of the internet mean running on the devices that I see when I look around my house? It feel like this serverless thing is rather serverful, unless I've overlooked the part where users are running a node somewhere.
- jsheard 2y agoIt's generally taken to mean "close enough to the edge that latency is negligible regardless of where your users are".
- FireInsight 2y agoI guess edge is just a buzzword, maybe it is like a metaphor; if you think of the internet as a sphere users reach to for content, something being on the edge means you don't have to reach that hard, it's right there on top. Or maybe it means close to the edge, close to end-user devices. Serverless is definitely a misnomer, but it means that you don't 'own' the server your thing is running on, there are some restrictions and you can't run anything you could on an actual VPS or hardware box. So in a way the server is abstracted away. You just use resources, but those could be anywhere, running on any node of the edge network.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoRight after CenturyLink rebranded to Lumen, but before I heard about it, I clicked a buzzword-laden link looking for people involved in "Edge Computing". I had been writing vehicle traffic controller firmware and thought "hey, I guess I'm doing edge computing--out here at the curb--maybe I should check this out." Turns out, they meant installing modems in people's houses. Edge, it would seem, is a very versatile buzzword.
- toast0 2y agoI feel like Edge is more acceptable; running at a PoP is close to the edge; running inside an ISP network is even closer; it's not really achievable, but running in ISP managed modems or cellular base stations is pretty much the limit of plausible Edge computing. Serverless really should mean the client does the work, but it seems pretty equivalent to shared hosting. Dreamhost (and the shell account you used to get with an ISP!) was serverless before it was cool?
- delanyoyoko 2y agoI guess this is the same as other offerings - Vercel Edge, Cloudflare Workers/Pages?
- ascorbic 2y agoVercel Edge is Cloudflare Workers. This is interesting because there are relatively few providers that are running a proper runtime for generic JS functions at the edge. Cloudflare, Deno Deploy, Fastly, Wasmer.
- nehal3m 2y agoScript edging: Never finish building applications
- seangrogg 2y agoAh, so my side projects in a nutshell.
- DHRicoF 2y agoIf you nut's in your side project then you aren't edging enough.
- WesolyKubeczek 2y agoMy side projects are not past the foreplay stage
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y agoI can vouch for Bunny. They are a fantastic company with fantastic prices and fantastic reliability. I have used their CDNs and all of their products for more than 4-5 years now.
- guyfromfargo 2y agoCompletely agree. We migrated our entire video library from Azure to Bunny. We went from paying over $2,500 in egress every month to about $200. It’s unreal how much Bunny has saved us.
- christophilus 2y agoSame here. Bunny CDN plus Wasabi. It’s an excellent, inexpensive duo. Bunnny now has their own Object storage, but it wasn’t mature in time for me to. Hold around it a few years back.
- pestaa 2y agoCrucially, their object storage doesn't have an S3-compatible API. I'll migrate the day they add it.
- christophilus 2y agoThat’s what it was. I couldn’t remember why we stayed off it so long. Also, iirc, they’re a bit pricier.
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y agoYes, that is the one thing where they have sort of kept saying they will have it for over three years now. That's the one place where I can dock some points for Bunny. If anybody from Bunny is reading this, what's the ETA?
- pier25 2y agoSame. We use their edge storage and cdn to distribute our js to our customers globally.
- laktek 2y agoCongrats on the launch! It's great to see more companies build serverless offerings on top of Deno. I lead Supabase Edge Functions product, a similar offering built on top of Deno runtime too. We have open-sourced our runtime (https://github.com/supabase/edge-runtime https://github.com/supabase/edge-runtime), and it's self-hostable. It supports NPM, node built-ins, pluggable storage, and web sockets. We also have a built-in API for AI inference (https://supabase.com/blog/ai-inference-now-available-in-supabase-edge-functions https://supabase.com/blog/ai-inference-now-available-in-supa...) Supabase Edge Runtime is easy to self-host (works great as a multi-threaded JS web server). We love community contributions :) Let us know if you would like to collaborate.
- devmor 2y ago> We've all been there: your app gains popularity, and suddenly, you're scrambling to add new servers. Yeah, but the headache is usually from database, cache and other shared resource servers. Scaling HTTP has been very easy for most applications for the last 15 years or so. I have to confess I really don't see the appeal of edge workers in general outside of specific applications where latency is of high concern. Such applications do exist, of course, but this kind of offering is treated so generally that I feel like I'm either immune to the marketing or I'm missing something important.
- ruthmarx 2y ago> I have to confess I really don't see the appeal of edge workers in general outside of specific applications where latency is of high concern. Such applications do exist, of course, but this kind of offering is treated so generally that I feel like I'm either immune to the marketing or I'm missing something important. I agree, it mostly seems like a fad/gimmick.
- tomByrer 2y agoOh, there are lots of things you can do 'on edge' that can be easier/faster: + A/B testing + cookie warnings just for EU but not everyone else + proxy; helpful if you want to hide where your API is from or username/pass + route redirects + take off some workload from your server + mini applets (eg signup forms are great edge use-case) ref: this is my old repo: https://github.com/lukeed/awesome-cloudflare-workers https://github.com/lukeed/awesome-cloudflare-workers
- fyzix 2y agoWhat’s the file size limit for wasm modules? Do you get charged for cpu while awaiting I/O? Do edge apps run before or after cdn caching?
- eqvinox 2y agoI'm getting old and grumpy, and my apps are edgier* than any of this: they're native offline code. * Pun intended.
- thephyber 2y agoWhat are applications that are well fitted to edge computing? I spent 2 evenings brainstorming this, but haven’t come up with anything.
- ricardobeat 2y agoIt’s all about latency. Even simple dynamically rendered websites can be much faster when you avoid multiple roundtrips to a far away DC.
- ranguna 2y agoIf your pages depend on data from APIs that are not globally distributed, having an edge runtime can be worse. Specially when dealing with non distributed databases.
- KTibow 2y agoIf you want to avoid super slow starts for an app that has some secret keys / other backend logic while staying on a free tier
- stickfigure 2y agoI recently wrote a city -> geo lookup API for typeahead. Running on edge it's wicked fast. The database just barely fits in a CF worker though.
- victorbjorklund 2y agoI used it before for a simple geolockup service for a autocomplete.
- maz1b 2y agoHaven't had the chance to look into this in depth yet, but is this a like Cloudflare pages or Vercel? Can you host static sites a la Next/Nuxt/Sveltekit/Solid etc?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sgammon 2y agoWhy design your own API so that I can't try it without rewriting my entrypoints? No thanks. Cloudflare is building an insanely good platform and I think it is one that is worth betting on into the future. I have no idea where this company came from. Maybe it's a rebrand, because they seem to have serious customer base and perhaps network footprint. PoPs are ~119 which is significantly fewer (less than half) of Cloudflare's presence, and Cloudflare has queueing, streaming, D1 (databasing), R2, and all sorts of other things. Workers' DX cannot be beaten. Just my 2c. If the creators are here, I'd love to know why you decided to design a new API. That is so upsetting.
- tomByrer 2y agoCloudflare had only 100 PoPs just a few years ago. Bunny has been around 10 years, but didn't get the cash injection from Google like Cloudflare did. If you read the article, Bunny uses Deno, CF uses a cut down version of Chromeium (each instance is like a browser tab; isolated). Thus the API difference. But I do agree, CF is building out more of a suite.
- sgammon 2y agoWorkerD isn't anywhere near a "cutdown version of Chromium," it is an incredible platform with years of engineering put into it, from some of the people behind very similar and successful products (GAE, Protocol Buffers, to name some). I assume you are referring to V8 here but that also powers Deno. WorkerD is open source: https://github.com/cloudflare/workerd https://github.com/cloudflare/workerd I personally am not a fan of Deno because of how it split the Node JS ecosystem, so that is not a benefit in my eyes. Of course, Workers can run Rust. Nothing you said here necessitates an API difference.
- Onavo 2y agoBunny has been around for much longer than CloudFlare. All those third party video streaming websites (e.g. adult content) all rely on CDNs like these. Bandwidth is very cheap. CloudFlare is able to command their prices mostly because of the security features and the fact that they are a pull based CDN. Most of the internet outside of SaaS rely on traditional CDNs like Bunny for low cost distribution.
- pier25 2y agoso they are reselling Deno Deploy?
- ascorbic 2y agoNo, it looks like this is their own.
- roydivision 2y agoI have yet to read a definition of 'edge' that makes sense to me, sysadmin/infrastructure/coder of ~30 years in the industry. Anyone?
- fragmede 2y agoIn this case, instead of putting everything in a couple giant DCs (eg us-east-1, put PoPs (point of presence) as close to end customers as possible. that way, round trip times between the pop and the customer is as small as possible, making their experience better. Edge then simply refers to those PoPs collective conceptually; edge compute is then just running code on those PoPs.
- roydivision 2y agoOk, got it. So this implies installing equipment in a number of PoPs presumably based on some study of where your core customers are? And I guess this isn't for all application logic, just cache stuff, quick and easy interaction gains, and none the less still passing heavy lifting back to the DC?
- fragmede 2y agoPresumably. As far as app logic, it depends on how much you can get the workers to do in their allotted time (which is short, iirc) so yeah, imo you still need heavier resources in a DC.
- roydivision 2y agoThanks!
- tmikaeld 2y ago"Please note that normal charges for CDN bandwidth are billed separately" Compared to cloudflare workers, which has free bandwidth, bunnys bandwidth is not that cheap at 0.01$/GB So while their example suggests stream-encoding video is possible, it would probably be cost-prohibitive.
- pier25 2y ago> Here's what's coming soon: A globally distributed database This is very exciting.