7 ms·
Sixteen U.S. states still ban community-owned broadband networks
- mrbluecoat 2y agoOnce space-based broadband Internet becomes widely available, I predict shortsighted ISPs will join the ranks of Kodak and Blockbuster.
- alwayslikethis 2y agoIs the total possible bandwidth available on these even comparable to optical fibers?
- badgersnake 2y agoPretty obviously not, theoretically you could have tens of terrabits per fibre core. The limiting factor is the electronics at either end.
- YetAnotherNick 2y agoThe bigger concern is the latency. Even if some technical progress increases the bandwidth, latency is bounded by speed of light and couldn't be as low as cable.
- larkost 2y agoThe low-earth orbit generally means that this is not as big of an issue as in older satellite technologies. Currently if you are in an area where the satellite does not need to bounce your data through one or more other satellites before hitting a ground station they are in the tens of milliseconds of latency (20-60). Comcast is generally in the 20-30 neighborhood, unless you are using their gigabit service, then it is more like 10-15 milliseconds. So it is higher, but not debilitatingly so (unless your application is very sensitive to latency). I would imagine there is a lot more jitter in Starlink, but that is more a feel than real numbers. Mainly on a terrestrial system you wind up bouncing through more substations on the way to the general Internet, whereas with Starlink you are generally bouncing straight from your dish to the satellite to the base station. So less bounces, but farther to go. The physics favors the wire, but not as much as it used to.
- 0xcde4c3db 2y agoSpaceX apparently doesn't like to give definitive numbers (perhaps there are too many configurable tradeoffs and/or dynamic adjustments to variable environmental conditions for that to make sense), but the downlink throughput of a Starlink V1 satellite is reportedly about 20 Gbps over an area of several square miles. Putting that on a single fiber wavelength is mature enough to be firmly in SOHO/homelab territory these days (e.g. QNAP and Mikrotik both have 25Gbps switches that are about $1000). It looks like commodity CWDM mux/demux boxes can cram 16 of those into a single fiber. It's safe to assume that the big guys like Comcast and CenturyLink/Lumen can get equipment capable of far more than that.
- cj 2y agoIf that happens, wouldn't it be potentially worse than the current situation? Surely your local neighborhood isn't going to deploy its own dedicated satellite constellation. If/when satelite broadband becomes widespread, it will likely be consolidated and provided by 1 provider (maybe 2?) which might end up resulting in higher costs for everyone all around.
- jtbayly 2y agoIt is very hard for me to imagine space-based internet ever being able to be competitive financially with an earth-based option outside of special circumstances.
- toast0 2y agoRunning an LEO satellite constellation is very expensive. But installing and maintaining a wire to everyone's house is also very expensive. IMHO, it's a question of capacity and acceptable service levels. Starlink monthly pricing is higher than my DSL and nearby cable as well as my local muni fiber. But it's not so much higher as to rule it out. And the install fee is a lot lower than muni fiber. It's going to take a long time to get ROI on my installation cost for the muni fiber if I compare monthly cost to Starlink. Muni fiber service level should be much better, but Starlink service would probably have been good enough.
- deepsquirrelnet 2y agoSecurity in LEO will eclipse the cost of everything else. Right now it’s free. When it becomes critical infrastructure, it has to be protected.
- toast0 2y agoSecurity in outside plant isn't free either. We're a long way away from widespread outages because someone thought they could get high with the proceeds of a stolen satellite, but there are lots of disruptions when people take down pole mounted fiber because they thought it would be worth something.
- hotpotatoe 2y agoSo? We trade a terrestrial based monopoly for a space based one?
- lxgr 2y agoWe'd also trade the fragments of resilience we have left against a single point of failure (both organizationally and infrastructurally). Space-based internet makes total sense for very remote areas or as a bridge technology, as well as a technology to compete with incumbent terrestrial monopolies, but I'd hate to see fiber and terrestrial 5G rollouts stopping entirely in favor of it.
- orwin 2y ago> We'd also trade the fragments of resilience we have left against a single point of failure It's the characteristic of the 21th century, trading resiliency and robustness for performance. As long as the world is stable, it's nice.
- llamaimperative 2y agobut this one is owned by twitter guy I like! /s
- a_vanderbilt 2y agoIt might come even sooner as mobile internet becomes faster and gets lower in latency. I used to have Cox, and the service availability was so bad it was nigh unusable. Switched to TMobile home 5g and in some cases, it's actually faster. That shouldn't be a thing but here we are. I don't play twitchy games so latency isn't really a concern for me. By the time 6g or whatever it's going to be called is well established, I think we'll see the incumbents get blockbuster'd.
- jvanderbot 2y agoThis has a "Bitcoin will solve finance" feel to it. Not to be super dismissive, but there's just as much likelihood it will help as it won't. But in your corner: It's true that right now space-based deployment of broadband will provide broadband in locations where it's not currently available - perhaps spurring competition. It's also probably true that space-based broadband will be able to compete directly with urban / dense areas where Comcast & company have an effective monopoly - also a good thing! But there's no reason to think it will put comcast/company out of business at all. Has cell-tower based intenet service at all displaced comcast? Verizon and T-Mobile canvas my neighborhood claiming to offer the best internet, but as far as I can tell, everyone still uses Xfinity, even if Centurylink is much, much better.
- sabbaticaldev 2y agoTV made radio irrelevant, the internet made TV irrelevant. Both still exists but as money-losing mass manipulation tools
- jvanderbot 2y agoBut those are new kinds. Not new providers. There's no phone company that made all other phone companies irrelevant. There's no tv channel that made all other tv channels irrelevant. And there's no radio station that .. you get it. And so it's hard for me to concolude that there's some ISP that will make all other ISPs irrelevant. Honestly most people will probably have about a 50/50 split between home wifi and phone internet. And that home wifi might have significant intrusion from space-based ISP, but not completely. (I realize spacex is also hoping to provide some phone service from satellites, but I digress)
- badgersnake 2y agoTV certainly didn't make radio irrelevant, radio is very relevant in situations where you can't look at a screen, or would prefer not to. It's also much lower bandwidth, takes up a lot less space, uses a lot less power on the receiver (even compared to say a modern mobile device) and audio only content is much cheaper to produce. I've heard it argued that podcasts make radio obsolete. That is more plausible.
- MyFirstSass 2y agoIm extremely jealous of this techno optimism perspective. In my view at no point has there been a decrease in monopolisation or increase in democratisation since the hopeful cybernetic 90's, so i just don't see this as good, more like some Tyrell or state owned corporate almost fascist dystopia where everything is owned and censored by the few, and just because it's "awesome and space based" only adds to the exclusivity. It's already leaked Musk is working for the US military, so it isn't some benevolent, utilitarian or even broad scaled project it's a project for world domination and enslavement.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dboreham 2y agoShannon says no.
- MrBuddyCasino 2y agoStarlink has insufficient capacity for metropolitan areas. I don't think this is easily solvable, given the shared medium and the bandwidth constraints.
- tzs 2y agoLet's try some back of the envelope calculation for providing broadband to the US via LEO satellites. Initially assume everyone is spread out uniformly, and that we need a broadband connection for every three people, and that 100 Mbps counts as broadband. If all connected were in use at the same time downloading at 100 Mbps we need an aggregate bandwidth of 11000 Tbps. Actual usage would be more bursty, so let's assume we can oversell by a factor of 100. That reduced the aggregate bandwidth need to 110 Tbps. Wikipedia tells me the satellite with the most bandwidth currently are those in the ViaSat-3 constellation of geosynchronous satellites, each with a bandwidth of 1 Tbps. Let's assume we can get LEO satellites with that bandwidth. We would need 110 to get the required aggregate bandwidth. However, since each satellite only spends roughly 1/8 of its time over the US we need to multiply the number of satellites by 8. That brings is to 880 satellites, but remember, we were assuming a uniformly spread out population. We need to take into account the non-uniformity of the actual population. To do that we need to know the ground area that a satellite can serve simultaneously. That depends on the height of the satellite. Google is telling me Starlink's around around 350 miles up, so let's assume that is what we use too. A naive distance to horizon calculation says that a satellite at that height would have an horizon around 2500 miles away. I'm not sure if that means it could actually broadcast to people 2500 miles away from whatever its spot is over or if there would be problems due to the shallow angle the signal would have to travel to the receiver. If each satellite can effectively broadcast to such a large circle then most of the 110 visible at a given time from the US would be visible over a wide enough area that how the population is distributed might not matter much. This is assuming that the satellites do not interfere with each other. My guess is that there would be interference and they would have to operate more like cellular networks operate, with each satellite having a limited ground area that it broadcasts into using some kind of spot beam. Feasibility now depends on the size of those spot beams and how accurately they can be aimed. If they can adjust the beams to cover large areas when they are serving a rural area and small areas when serving a dense area, and if they can aim that spot anywhere in that 2000+ mile radius circle where the satellite is visible then 880 satellites may be enough. If, on the other hand, their beams are pretty much fixed in size and direction, then we would probably need a lot more satellites. Given the area of the US, for everyplace to have coverage the 110 satellites that would be over the US on average would have to each be responsible for a circle of around 200 miles in diameter, and could handle the needs of 3 million people. If you've got more than 3 million people in a 200 mile circle you'll need more satellites over that circle. Suppose we have an area that needs several satellites. It might be possible to arrange orbits so particular places always have a lot of satellites so that you could cover that area without having to simply make your constellation bigger. I have no idea if that is possible. If not you may have to increase you constellation size so that you every place has the number of satellites that your highest density 200 mile diameter circle needs. I don't think that there is any 200 mile diameter circle in the US that would need more that 20 satellites, which would mean we'd need 17600 satellites in the constellation. Note that this is quite dependent on the circle size so could be way off from reality. Also I've not considered communications from the ground to the satellite which might also impose constraints. Conclusion: it doesn't seem obviously impossible to provide 100 Mbps broadband via satellite to everyone in the US. A more detailed analysis is needed.
- conradev 2y agoOr maybe, if we’re lucky, they’ll have to compete on quality as well as price. When Verizon laid down fiber optic cable in my (former) neighborhood, it was so much better than Xfinity’s service, and everyone I knew switched. Not to say that the type of physical cable matters as much, DOCSIS 4.0 is in the cards, but latency and bandwidth will always be better on a (good) wired connection. One quirk worth mentioning, though, is that WWAN did leap-frog WLAN with 5G and especially with ultra-wideband (which isn’t everywhere). Until I installed 6GHz Wi-Fi, the fastest wireless speeds I saw were on ultra-wideband connections to my phone.
- vel0city 2y ago> WWAN did leap-frog WLAN with 5G and especially with ultra-wideband > Until I installed 6GHz Wi-Fi So after you upgraded your WLAN it was faster than your WAN until you bothered upgrading your WLAN. That's a personal deployment decision not necessarily a matter of what was or wasn't' available at the time. >1G WiFi existed years before ultra-wideband was a thing.
- conradev 2y agoThe first phone to ship with ultra-wideband was the iPhone 11 in 2019, and the first phone to ship with 6GHz was the Galaxy S21 Ultra in 2021. The Intel AX210 was the first wireless card to ship with 6GHz at the end of 2020 and the first laptop to include it from MSI shipped in 2021. Calling WiFi 6 >1G is a pretty far stretch. I don't think I've seen a real world test that breaks that barrier in favorable conditions, even with today's routers: https://evanmccann.net/blog/2022/5/u6-pro-and-u6-mesh-review https://evanmccann.net/blog/2022/5/u6-pro-and-u6-mesh-review https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-wi-fi-router/#how-we-tested-plus-the-results https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-wi-fi-router... Whereas ultra-wideband was capable of pulling 2Gbps in 2020, something I have not even seen Wi-Fi 7 able to do. Ultra-wideband still has quite an edge: https://www.reddit.com/r/ATT/comments/gbr335/this_might_be_a_reddit_record_2gbps_on_5g_mmwave/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ATT/comments/gbr335/this_might_be_a...
- vel0city 2y ago
- gosub100 2y agoI hope so but I don't think any constellation can handle even a medium sized town without significant throttling.
- paxys 2y agoIt takes 5 minutes of back of the envelope calculations to realize that this is a pipe dream. Starlink isn't a substitute for fiber internet, it's a substitute for no internet.
- bombcar 2y agoThe missing piece is "buckets of Internet" where you pay a provider to have a connection, and they deal with whether it comes over 5G or fiber or Starlink or whatever. Nobody cares about HOW the connection is delivered, just the speed, latency, and reliability.
- pmb 2y agoNo. Satellite (except when they use lasers, but nobody is proposing space lasers) is a broadcast medium and wire is point to point. Wires will almost always be cheaper and more reliable and faster on a per-customer basis and have less interference.
- ravenstine 2y agoWe don't even need space based broadband for this. Terrestrial radio (5G and LTE) already will gradually drink the milkshake of most cable and fiber based ISPs.
- wintermutestwin 2y agoMaybe if you have an antenna on top of your house? As it is, I regularly lose internet connectivity (2 bars or LTE or 1 bar of 5g) on my phone when I step into many buildings that are within .25km of highway 80 in a large CA city.
- PittleyDunkin 2y ago? What does "space-based broadband" offer that's so attractive?
- lokar 2y agoMusk
- wintermutestwin 2y agoAFAIK, latency sensitive games like CoD and Fortnite suffer badly on Starlink. Don't you think that would have a massive impact on adoption in areas where you can get "wired" internet?
- varispeed 2y ago[flagged]
- terminalbraid 2y agoNo one says this.
- AnimalMuppet 2y ago"Corruption" isn't a binary. It exists in the West. It's bad that it exists in the West. But it exists less in the West than in some other places, and that difference matters.
- rlili 2y agoIn many countries, lobbying is considered corruption. That it is legalized in the US alone, suggests to me that it actually exists more in the West.
- 3D30497420 2y agoIt also depends a lot on the type of corruption and how it works. I recall an econ class from ages ago that compared two middle-income countries. In one, there was a strong central government, so the corruption was relatively organized and predictable. The economy was harmed by the corruption, but still functioned, grew, and helped to reduce poverty. In the other country, the central and regional governments were weak, so nearly every interaction with government officials (police, judges, customs, etc.) resulted in some kind of bribe with highly variable costs. This dramatically slowed down and reduced economic activity and increased poverty.
- krapp 2y agoI don't think that anyone, anywhere, ever says that. Not even in the West.
- hansvm 2y agoWhen trying to convince a Russian engineer a few years ago that the west has plenty of corruption, his main counterpoint was "yes, but it's not the same; you guys have a kind of corruption that's at least able to function." He made a big deal about how severe it is even in very minor roles. With recent events I imagine the difference is going to decrease a bit, but I don't think it'll be the same within 4yrs.
- plussed_reader 2y agoAnd this won't change for at least the next 4 years. Regulatory capture is a bitch.
- bluejekyll 2y agoThis debate about regulations is alway interesting. There are regulations which help protect the environment, like not being allowed to dump dangerous chemicals into your local stream or river. Then there are regulations like these which are aimed at protecting the investment companies have made into infrastructure, effectively granting them a monopoly. When people debate this, they often are thinking of the first class of protective regulations that are too onerous on companies, but I think most people like clean drinking water and rivers that no longer catch fire. Whereas the second class of protection is really harmful to the consumer, and the powers-that-be have effectively been given a monopoly, and with that the money and power to protect their place in the market through continued influence on elections and other things to maintain these rent seeking businesses. We all hate the latter, but these companies have a lot of sway over politicians.
- gosub100 2y agoAnd from the article, the telecom industry receives billions in corporate welfare. A common argument against cutting it off is that telecom is capital intensive infrastructure, and if you cut their govbux you're blocking poor people from being able to communicate, we all deserve the right to communicate. But if that's your take, how can you also hate the protectionist laws? Telecom are given a monopoly because it doesn't make sense to, say, have N sets of telephone poles or power lines from each provider.
- altacc 2y agoIn some countries there is sometimes a cable & data connection owner and then a separate service provider. Laws regulate that the cable provider must let other companies provide connections to customers over their cables. The service provider pays the cable owner for a bulk of data that its customers use. The cable owner can't charge more than it charges itself when it acts as a service provider. Not sure if that made sense! I pay company B but my fibre connection is provided by Company A. If I want to change to Company C I start a contract with C and the only thing I change is the cable modem.
- T3RMINATED 2y ago[dead]
- bob1029 2y agoI am on a small fiber ISP in one of these states. I don't think it is community owned, but the distinction doesn't seem that important from a customer experience standpoint. The scale and locality of the business is what makes it great. They can care a lot about the network quality because there isn't so much of it that they need to outsource everything. All elements of their infrastructure are not only on battery backup but also standby natural gas generators. My power and water go out before my fiber does. I've never had an outage outside of scheduled maintenance windows.
- dv_dt 2y agoThat works out great until some capital pool decides to start acquiring smaller isps to roll them up into a larger corporate behemoth. As has happened in multiple other industries from groceries, animal vets, rentals, software niches, to hospitals and these days nursing homes Then the "efficiency" becomes how much can be extracted from the business and customers
- mschuster91 2y agothat can be made very hard to outright impossible (or prohibitively expensive) to do, if the foundational documents of the company are set up correctly. Say, a non-profit, or a cooperative-ownership model... Yes, non-profits can be fucked up too (as we saw with "Open"AI recently) and cooperative-ownerships can be bought out if one is willing to spend enough money, but it at least raises the bar a significant amount.
- bob1029 2y agoPrivately held companies have the option to reject these offers. A business doesn't have to be a non-profit or community-owned in order to do something principled. One good leader/owner is all it takes.
- hobs 2y agoAnd one bad (next) owner, a hostile takeover, a change of ordinances, a license not renewed, etc - there's so many ways to use money and entrenched positions to destroy a single business operator.
- EGreg 2y agoWhat about mesh networks like Guifi in Spain, Freifunk in Germany, or Red Hook Mesh in Brooklyn?
- tivert 2y agoLinked from the OP: https://www.newamerica.org/weekly/how-did-north-dakota-become-crown-jewel-internet-midwest/ https://www.newamerica.org/weekly/how-did-north-dakota-becom... IIRC, North Dakota, despite its Republican voting record, is actually pretty socialist (including a few legitimately state-owned companies).
- adabyron 2y agoThey also have a state owned bank. ND once had a very strong "Democratic Farmer Labor party". Not to get into R vs D here, as the parties have flip flopped a lot since then & the Limbaugh movement changed the state from a very purple state (all Congress members were D in the 80s-90s). The only way you win in the state now is with a R next to your name, so the Rs are having an identity crisis. The real good call out is the coop attitude that has been very strong in ND for decades. Sadly I have seen some of those coops start to spend a lot of money on creating talk shows with extreme political personalities who have little actual knowledge on things. I would love to see the state go back to being more neighborly & community building. Either way the history of the coop attitude is a great one for building strong communities. Every community should take notice of this. For rural communities, especially in the early 90s & 00s, having internet access was equivalent to access to an elite private school.
- tivert 2y ago> They also have a state owned bank. ND once had a very strong "Democratic Farmer Labor party". Not to get into R vs D here, as the parties have flip flopped a lot since then & the Limbaugh movement changed the state from a very purple state (all Congress members were D in the 80s-90s). The only way you win in the state now is with a R next to your name, so the Rs are having an identity crisis. Minnesota had the DFL. North Dakota had the NPL. Yeah, I think the intrusion of national political culture has been pretty toxic everywhere. IIRC, Heitkamp, the last ND Democrat, lost (or at least had some trouble), because she had to hem and haw on abortion to appease her out-of-state donors and could not adapt to local circumstances. Didn't really follow that election too closely, so I don't really know what else was going on.
- josefresco 2y agoSixteen states (down from 21), detailed here: https://communitynets.org/content/state-state-preemption-stalled-moving-more-competitive-direction?mc_cid=229ee1be3f https://communitynets.org/content/state-state-preemption-sta... Despite this ban, many communities in these states have pushed forward.
- jvanderbot 2y agoAnd there's more good news. Minnesota is not on that map, but Minnesota has moved in very good directions re: ISPs. My rural neighbors have community internet, and it's _good_. High quality fiber. I have centurylink - ok not a community plan, but it competes directly with T-mobile, Xfinity (comcast), and other cell-based providers, and provides an excellent product for much cheaper. And I know for a fact that colorado has been fighting the good fight. https://communitynets.org/content/colorado-passes-new-broadband-laws-takes-aim-landlord-monopolies https://communitynets.org/content/colorado-passes-new-broadb...
- phil21 2y agoCenturylink mentioned in the same ballpark as a "community network" is hilarious to me, having grown up in Minnesota. It's literally the incumbent Bell provider - back in the day being AT&T and then USWest after the antitrust breakup. Times certainly have changed for someone to even have this thought, much less write it down!
- jvanderbot 2y agoRight - not exactly what we were referring to, but a really good product at a cheap price, nonetheless.
- waveBidder 2y agoI've been confused by that law, because I'm pretty sure Bemidji has an internet coop (which is quite good, especially for a small town like it).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- helf 2y ago[dead]
- Brian_K_White 2y agoA hundred years ago on irc someone from Russia was describing their internet connection, which was ethernet, while I had only ever heard of dial up outside of large companies. It was just people had set up their own hubs and switches in their appartment buildings and strung cables between buildings. This blew my mind. They just ran themselves ethernet and everyone got a drop from a switch in their building. It wasn't clear how it got from a neighborgood level upstream. But just the idea that they could all just decide to give themselves internet, and ethernet no less, string ethernet outside the walls of their own appartments to other appartments, and outside the building from one building to another? Unimaginable in the US. I was boggled and jealous.
- wyldfire 2y ago> Unimaginable in the US With good reason. Building codes in the US prevent disasters like the one that happened at Grenfell Towers in the UK. Run plenum-rated wires through an appropriate space for safety's sake.
- xnorswap 2y agoUK building codes (we call them building regulations) should also have prevented Grenfell. A large issue was that the companies involved were using materials which weren't up to code.
- londons_explore 2y agoSpecifically, they stuck to the letter of the law, not the spirit of the law. (made an 'equivalent' fireproof product, which legally didn't need retesting, but in fact performed far worse) Same with VW and dieselgate. (made a car which did well when tested, but badly in the real world) The pattern is that complex regulations always have loopholes, when far better would be to wipe out all the regulations and simply put in prison people who don't take sufficient care of the environment or other peoples lives. Let courts decide what is insufficient care on a case by case basis.
- 2y ago
- ensignavenger 2y agoMissouri's law was "reinterpreted" to allow broadband networks. The article even mentions KCFiber, a wholly owned fiber network (owned by the city of North Kansas City) which provides free services ($300 one time activation fee) to the entire city! Another one is Springfield, which built a fiber network which it owns but leases to ISPs (currently only one offers service, but in theory others could participate as well).
- eqvinox 2y agoCommunity-owned _broadband networks_ I'm not sure about. Community-owned _physical infrastructure_ (especially last-mile — fiber & copper going to everybody's house) … that needs to be the default. And if it's not community-owned, it needs to be regulated with open access requirements. Yes you can theoretically build a second fiber network and hook up people's houses. Yes it has happened in actual practice. But it is commercially questionable and just completely silly.
- bombcar 2y agoHaving the "last mile" be owned by the community just makes complete sense; in fact it should be a requirement of future government subsidies (perhaps with an option for the existing infrastructure, if "good enough - fiber" to be sold to the community) as it reduces overlap and waste. Around here we have had THREE separate companies drop fiber in the last year (technically not to everyone's house as they only do that last connection when you subscribe) - so my yard now has five fiber lines through it. That's a bit overkill. They could have had the municipal electric utility run fiber to everyone, and then designate a single building as a POP/exchange and let any company that wanted to run a fat pipe to that and start reselling.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoCommunities own the roads, trucking companies are commercial.
- Propelloni 2y agoIt's almost like someone read Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations!
- red-iron-pine 2y agosomething something externalities something
- Analemma_ 2y agoWhat you're talking about is called local loop unbundling - the government owns the last-mile infrastructure, then leases access on FRAND terms to ISPs. It's a perfect alignment of incentives and a huge win for customers, so naturally ISPs fiercely oppose it and look to immediately crush any move in that direction whenever they can.
- ck2 2y agoIt's weird to me anyone thinks this is going to improve? The exact opposite is very likely to happen in the next four years, a federal ban on community networks, lobby paid for by the same big telecom that was previously doing it piecemeal at the local level, they'll just buy 100 rooms at that special hotel in DC and the bill will get signed in sharpie like a 5-year-old. Sure, it will end up at the supreme court in a lawsuit but of course that's a lock too now.
- cornstalks 2y ago"Ban" is used pretty loosely here. For example, Utah allows community-owned networks but requires them to be "wholesale-only" instead of direct-to-customer. It's a limitation, sure, but I have a hard time considering that a real "ban."
- silisili 2y agoOf all the states I've lived, TN blew me away wrt internet the most, by far. Most have heard about EPB over in Chattanooga. KUB in Knoxville recently did the same thing. But those aside, it seems like every little nook and cranny has some sort of fiber, whether it's from the utility board or a private company. I lived in a city of about 20k, not near any big city. There were two different fiber companies(one utility, one private) and Spectrum offering service. Cookeville, Crossville, McMinnville, Manchester, Tullahoma, etc...cities most probably haven't even heard of, all have generally great FTTH coverage.
- bitcharmer 2y ago[flagged]
- burnt-resistor 2y agoAh, but a workaround is a regional co-op not necessarily tied to a city or county. gvec.net is one example around hill country in TX.
- o999 2y agoJust another reminder U.S. is not a real democracy
- SoftTalker 2y agoI don't think community broadband should be banned, but if we're talking about municipalities, they really don't know what they are doing. My town is installing municipal broadband, and the contractors they hired are ripping up people's lawns, punching holes in gas, water, and sewer lines, and generally making a huge mess in a way that would never be tolerated if ATT or Comcast were doing it. Only time will tell if the service will be any good, once all the collateral damage is mended.
- TechDebtDevin 2y agoAT&T uses the same contractors your municipality would have.
- SoftTalker 2y agoPerhaps, but if they were running amok like they are, there would be riots at the mayor's office and outraged citizens at the city council meetings. But because it's "municipal" it all gets a shrug and a pass.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bwanab 2y agoI really hate to make a political connection here, but it's hard not to notice that of those states exactly one didn't vote for the current President-elect.
- johnea 2y agoYour notice is valid. I would expect the situation to regress significantly as the FCC is reorged...
- jmyeet 2y agoThe legislation banning municipal broadband is a symptom. The problem is capitalism. All capitalism does is try and create enclosures and then use that monopoly to jack up prices for people who absolutely do not have to see the negative externalities of those endeavours. It is the most parasitic form of intermediation. National ISPs are terrible. They shouldn't exist. The best Internet in the US by a mile (and it's not even close) is municipal broadband (eg [1]). [1]: https://epb.com/fi-speed-internet/?#choose-your-plan https://epb.com/fi-speed-internet/?#choose-your-plan
- b3ing 2y agothe states https://communitynets.org/sites/default/files/2024-10/Preemption%20map%202024.png https://communitynets.org/sites/default/files/2024-10/Preemp...
- guest__user 2y agoAll those well informed state legislators really have it out for community broadband, I wonder what could have influenced them.
- red-iron-pine 2y agotl;dr: Alabama, Florida, Louisiana, Michigan, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, N Carolina, Pennsylvania, S Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia, and Wisconsin. FL, LA, and NE are called out as having the worst prohibitions