6 ms·
The socioeconomic system is broken, not the people. Population boom only happened because women weren't empowered, contraceptives weren't wildly available. For
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
The socioeconomic system is broken, not the people. Population boom only happened because women weren't empowered, contraceptives weren't wildly available. For the human, this is great, if it is their choice (we should want to support agency and autonomy imho). For the systems? Bad for them. Build better systems. If your economic system requires a total fertility rate floor above what a combination of desired and realized fertility is, you're gonna have a bad time.
People will argue about the cost of caring for the elderly, sovereign debt that will need to be paid back, and so on. Well, perhaps consider the obligations you're originating and foisting on a future that may not pay for them.
Comments I've written with robust citations for this thesis:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41799048 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41799048
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41661724 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41661724
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41225389 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41225389
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41035224 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41035224
- everybodyknows 2y ago> 83% of young korean women think of south korea as “hell” The page shows 78% of young men with same opinion. But -- what other countries do they think would be better?
- mekster 2y agoI just find it hard that these times, it's more like heaven from human history point of view. At least in there, there's no active war (there is a threat but bullets aren't flying around or you have problem acquiring food and water), and cities are moderately safe, you can buy stuff with a few clicks, many entertainments to choose from, convenient phones etc etc. And you get to take advantage of those without earning a fortune. It's so absurd to think this is some sort of hell. They don't know actual hell like past and some present people are experiencing. Why don't those people appreciate the situation they're in?
- satvikpendem 2y agoHedonic adaptation. Humans can quickly become accustomed to circumstances, rich or poor, and then they can start criticizing it. This is in fact one of the prime drivers for innovation in the world, because those that thought everything was already good enough wouldn't be the ones innovating.
- rwyinuse 2y agoThe working culture in South Korea absolutely seems like hell compared to most of human history. People had much more free time in agricultural societies, and they mostly spent it outdoors, instead of slaving it in the offices doing meaningless work to make shareholders richer.
- carlmr 2y agoExactly. And hedonic adaptation makes all that entertainment with phones, TVs etc meaningless. Lack of free time is hell. Especially if you spend all your days in the same drab office building. Office work is fine in and of itself, but humans are meant to move, to be outside for a good portion of the day. Work-life balance is more important than the latest gadgets.
- mekster 2y agoPeople starving, born with disabilities/incurable diseases, people at the front line of a war, especially if critically wounded, people caught as a prisoner being tortured, people living their lives as a slave with physical violence and any other serious situations I couldn't imagine, seem like worse than someone at least with physically safe condition and possibly a way to escape if one wants to.
- unscaled 2y agoThe term "Hell Joseon" was widely popularized (Joseon is the old name of Korea, and incidentally still the name used for North Korea in Korean, Chinese and Japanese). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hell_Joseon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hell_Joseon "Escaping Hell Joseon" is apparently a thing: https://asiatimes.com/2019/12/75-of-young-want-to-escape-south-korean-hell/ https://asiatimes.com/2019/12/75-of-young-want-to-escape-sou... I think only a small percentage of respondents have brought their aspiration into practice, but they obviously think other countries are better than Korea. I'd love to see a poll asking them which countries they would prefer. I don't think they are entirely wrong. Economic hardship and uncertain future for young people are prevalent in all developed economies, but South Korea also suffers from terrible work-life balance and strict work culture (probably significantly worse than Japan on both counts). And recent admissions scandals[1][2] have made Koreans even more skeptical about the fairness of the system. I'm not sure if Ivy League universities are any better, but the Korean scandals were really in-your-face. [1] https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/disgraced-ex-south-korea-minister-gets-two-years-jail-over-graft-scandal-2023-02-03/ https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/disgraced-ex-sout... [2] https://graphics.straitstimes.com/STI/STIMEDIA/Interactives/2017/03/south-korea-scandal/chung-yoo-ra.html https://graphics.straitstimes.com/STI/STIMEDIA/Interactives/...
- shiroiushi 2y ago>The page shows 78% of young men with same opinion. But -- what other countries do they think would be better? The women: most western European nations probably. The men: South Korea 30+ years ago
- faangguyindia 2y agoIt doesn't matter what they think, Hell and Heaven are relative not absolute Humans do not operate in absolute metrics, it's always relative.
- yoyohello13 2y agoThere is always this uncomfortable undercurrent of misogyny in all these fertility discussions along the lines of "how do we coerce women to have more children?" or "it's a woman's duty to breed." I'd like to hope we are more enlightened than that, but the sentiment is worryingly pervasive. The doomsayers are probably right, we are in for hard economic times as birth rates decline. But maybe that is a good thing, and we can finally come up with a system that doesn't depend on exponential population growth.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- irrational 2y agoNot just misogyny, but racism as well. The overall human population is still on the rise, but that’s primarily happening in Africa.
- soperj 2y agoi think it's only happening in Africa. Every other continent is experiencing a decline
- red016 2y agoMore likely birth control will filter out anti-natalists in the long term.
- lotsofpulp 2y ago“Anti natalism” is not a genetic trait that gets inherited. Any woman can look at what another woman goes through during pregnancy/childbirth/infant rearing and think they might want to avoid that. Or avoid doing it multiple times.
- RGamma 2y agoOTOH there are some with a great desire to procreate even though it might mean (temporary) hardship or doesn't fit with their socioeconomic status. I know several of those. The ones who shall inherit the earth.
- b112 2y agoNo. Pollution, likely microplastics are preventing and interfering with reproductive behaviour. Understand, we are complex beings. The desire to reproduce is not conscious. It is innate and compulsive. And if you interfere with that hormonally derived urge, this is the result. It's not about money. That's on the conscious side. People had scads of kids during depressions and recessions, even when the pill was available, having kids was more important than not. And if you looka around the world, the amount of children has nothing to do with the country, or culture. Women oppressed or not, it doesn't matter. And what culture is more unique than Japan compared to the West? It's not culture, for the entire planet has a collapse in birthrates. We're going extinct.
- yoyohello13 2y ago> We're going extinct. I think that is hyperbole, but I agree with your general take. Maybe we are just at the top of the human population sigmoid curve and this is a normal collective correction. We've hit the carrying capacity of the post-industrialized world. Food isn't the limiter as much as an unconscious 'perceived opportunity for growth'.
- analognoise 2y agoIt’s amazing that rather than recognize that the rich have too much and we too little, we’d rather organize around them hoarding so much wealth that the population declines. Like we could not imagine a fairer distribution that would incentivize more people to have children in a positive fashion. I think we might even go the other direction - circumscribe the rights of women directly to increase the birth rate, Handmaids Tale style.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- shiroiushi 2y ago>I think we might even go the other direction - circumscribe the rights of women directly to increase the birth rate, Handmaids Tale style. Given recent events, I think the Republic of Gilead will be a real thing in the USA before too long.