5 ms·
Why shouldn't you give money to homeless people?
- sabbaticaldev 2y agoif that’s your argument on this, you can help by buying from people selling things in the street, they often are the homeless people that are trying to get out of this situation.
- recursivedoubts 2y ago> And I still have no idea what I’ll tell my own children when the time comes. of all sad words of tongue and pen the saddest are these: dad was right again
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- NathanielBaking 2y agoIt is better to give to homeless shelters and food banks.
- xvedejas 2y agoI think the author agrees but is dismayed that these organizations don't "solve" homelessness. I'll offer the suggestion that it might be _even better_ to donate that money towards somehow providing housing.
- schnitzelstoat 2y agoWhere I live in Europe there is plenty of shelter available for homeless people. But they often don't want to go there because of their substance abuse issues as there's typically a zero-tolerance policy for drugs and alcohol.
- xvedejas 2y agoI don't mean temporary shelter. But I agree there is a subset of the homeless population that have more problems than just homelessness. It may be impossible to solve their homelessness without solving other problems first.
- master-lincoln 2y agoIt's even better to vote for politicians who want to change society so that nobody has to live on the street.
- n4r9 2y agoBest of all is to infect multiple people with compassion and empathy. The rest would follow!
- PittleyDunkin 2y agoSure, I have no doubt they'll materialize any day now.
- cogman10 2y agoThose policies, if they include means testing, need rational means testing. For example, it can't be all or nothing. You shouldn't be kicked out/lose all support by getting a job or a raise. Assistance can be reduced, but it should be something like pulling back $.5 for every dollar earned over since level. Whatever limit should also be index to inflation. An example of how to do everything wrong is what we did with SSI and Medicare for people with disabilities. Means test set in the 70s, no inflation adjustment, and all or nothing.
- pydry 2y agoThis is functionally equivalent to voting to reduce the value of investor property portfolios. Building enough housing for everybody = building new supply = reducing the value of existing homes. Since American political parties are utterly financially reliant upon donations from investors with property portfolios, you're rarely if ever able to vote against their interests as a group. If the US were democratic like Finland rather than being an oligarchy then it might be possible, but at the moment, 60-70% of US voters craving single payer healthcare isn't enough to make that happen and that would only hit a specific group of investors. A finland style "housing for everybody program" is a political pipe dream given the damage it would do to donor portfolios.
- occz 2y ago
- UncleMeat 2y agoI'd believe that people were serious about this if every time they said "well, they'll just spend it on booze" then also went home and donated an equivalent amount to such programs.
- unregistereddev 2y agoThe currently in-vogue answer is "give them houses", but your answer is more attainable. When someone asks me for money I take it as a reminder to donate to organizations that help the homeless and near-homeless. The best homeless shelters have programs targeted at helping people graduate into apartments. They have social workers and counselors that try to help people overcome addictions. They partner with charities that collect donated home goods and turn them into a "free store" so that when someone graduates into an apartment they are able to furnish it. This is how the shelters in my area operate, but many shelters do not have the resources to offer this many resources. The best food banks do not question your level of need, but offer food and hygiene supplies to anyone who asks. If someone owns a car and home but has run across hard times, these no-questions-asked resources help them make do without losing their car or their home. Giving to homeless shelters and food banks helps us to have better homeless shelters and food banks. Shelters that have more resources are able to offer more to those in need, including helping people graduate to stable living conditions.
- PittleyDunkin 2y ago> but your answer is more attainable. It's also just institutionalizing homelessness rather than trying to address the cause of the problem: refusing to give (or subsidize sufficiently) people who need houses. > The best homeless shelters have programs targeted at helping people graduate into apartments. The capacity and cost of this is a tiny, tiny, tiny fraction of the problem with homelessness we face today. It's nice, it's good that there are some resources available, but it's not going to lessen the overall problem of homelessness.
- consteval 2y agoI don't believe that is the root cause of homelessness. Rather, the root cause is actually lower-level and is a fundamental flaw of capitalism. For all of time, there will always be a subset of people unable to work. Homeless people aren't just homeless, they're jobless, many permanently so. Due to mental illness, disabilities, drugs, etc. Ultimately giving these people houses does not solve the problem, because they will still be very unsuccessful in a capitalist system. You need a job to survive. What happens if you don't have work? We don't have a solution for this. Typically, we do bandaids. Retirement funds for those who can't work, medicare, social security. That helps a bit for those people who did work but no longer can. SOME homeless people can be "trained" to be ideal capitalistic laborers. Most can't, and never will be, because of physical limitations of their person. We don't know what to do with them. Previously, we just institutionalized them. Disqualified them from society. That was awful, so now we let them participate. But they fail, and always will fail. Ultimately, there is no way around it regardless of the solution you choose. There will always be a subset of people that cannot work and will never work.
- mariusmg 2y ago>It is better to give to homeless shelters and food banks. Watch this stand-up comedy bit which deals with this topic https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qm6kl17HH9s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qm6kl17HH9s
- pydry 2y agoMany homeless shelters are worse than sleeping rough because the security situation is so dire. At worst you can be locked in (yes, some lock you in for the night) with violent and rapey men but an averagely bad night might still mean having your phone stolen. Too add further stress to overwhelming anxiety, many people who work in homeless shelters are also, unfortunately, narcissistic bullies on a power trip. Nobody gives a fuck about the security situation of homeless people though and their reluctance to use shelters is usually chalked up to them being drug addicts unwilling to deal with the no drug mandates.
- Thorrez 2y agoIf I give to a charity, I get a tax deduction. If I give directly to a homeless person, I don't. Let's say my marginal tax rate is 50%. That means I could give $10 to a homeless person, or $20 to a homeless shelter, both costing me the same amount. If someone has highly appreciated stock that is going to be sold, can donate it (e.g. through a DAF), and has the highest possible marginal tax rate in California, that person has the choice to donate $10 to a homeless person or ~$80 to a homeless shelter, both costing the same amount.
- willcipriano 2y agoDon't give them food either. If you live in a western country, or even most developing nations (India in particular has a great culture around this) food is available to the homeless. When you give them food they have to eat it on the cold wet ground often with filthy hands, not at a table with a knife and fork like they had gone to the shelter or soup kitchen. They don't get to feel human. They don't get to experience dignity. The soup kitchens are strategically located, often in areas where begging won't net you much. This is intentional, its set up to drive the homeless into the arms of the social workers and help them stay sober so that they might have a moment of clarity whilst talking to them. If you want to help volunteer, make the toast or wash dishes so the social workers can spend more time trying to reach their clients. You aren't trained to help so don't try. Its a more complex problem than you are equipped to do anything about. Trust the people who dedicated their lives to this work.
- danparsonson 2y agoOr you could, you know, ask them what they need.
- johnisgood 2y agoWhen I was younger, I once gave a homeless man some of my pocket money, and I was pleased to see him buy a hamburger with it. > When you give them food they have to eat it on the cold wet ground often with filthy hands Seriously? There is a wide range of packaged food available, ensuring that your hands never have to come into contact with the food, and they give you napkins and plastic utensils, too, if you want. You simply hand it over to them in the packaging.
- willcipriano 2y agoI have volunteered for a decade, religious and non-religous organizations in the NYC and Philadelphia area. I have helped serve tens of thousands of meals. When the temperature drops I get called in for the code blue response. Every single expert I have spoken to, people who have actually saved thousands of individuals from the cycle of mental health issues, addiction and homelessness shares this view. In fact, I used to think like you prior to meeting them. I have learned that I was wrong. Your act allowed him to continue begging, this allowed him to obtain more of his drug of choice and only prolonged his battle with addiction. It did not help him, if he didn't get help like I previously described he is likely dead. You meaned well, you aren't a bad person, I just ask you to understand what the experts in the field have to say and perhaps consider that they know more than you.
- ninetyninenine 2y agoYour dad is partly right. The main reason though is that we don’t care. Most people don’t care. That’s the dark truth of it all. Don’t worry about your kids or yourself. As usual most people won’t think so deeply about the matter and they will come up with some excuse to lie to themselves. A few people will actually care enough to help. But these people are a tiny minority. Among the people that don’t care most will be lying to themselves. Out of these people a small portion will be able to face their own intrinsic evil and literally say it like it is: I just don’t give a shit. I’m one of those people. Anyone else like me?
- jareklupinski 2y ago> That’s the dark truth of it all. dont pull us into despair
- ninetyninenine 2y ago[flagged]
- johnisgood 2y agoWow.
- ninetyninenine 2y agoI think you’d be surprised how many people are like me but don’t admit it. I’m just be honest here. Maybe I’m a bit more evil then normal with the reply but I think my original comment is quite commonplace.
- johnisgood 2y agoI know, I do realize that. I worked in healthcare before. Regardless, I am not judging, live and let live. I still believe your comment was unwarranted, unnecessary, and inappropriate.
- 2y ago
- lupusreal 2y agoIt depends on the individual. Any generalized answer will have cases that don't seem to fit. Personally, if a guy looks like he's in rough shape and asks me for a drink, I might oblige him. Not because I think it's helping him in the long run, but because it could help him feel better now.
- simulo 2y ago> Not because I think it's helping him in the long run, but because it could help him feel better now. Very much this: The long run is vague, and the only sure thing is that we will be dead. But this is a small thing one can do now.
- troupe 2y agoI've tried to help some homeless people get into a place where they are provided with housing, jobs, etc. to try to get them back on their feet. They often didn't last very long because they knew that on the street, people would give them money that they could spend on drugs and alcohol. So the difficulty with giving them money for alcohol is that it might make it harder for them to stick with a place that is actually able to help them in the long run. (And I don't mean to be critical of your position, just pointing out that it might not be neutral in the long term.)
- giraffe_lady 2y agoMore likely the housing had requirements like strict abstinence without providing any of the support they would need to actually quit. When people aren't using the services there's always a reason. You might not find that reason valid ("well then they should just quit" etc) but it's there. An addict on the street isn't having a better time than you would be doing the same thing. You have to consider why they experience that as a better option for themselves than the one you're presenting.
- troupe 2y ago> When people aren't using the services there's always a reason. That is what I was saying. There is the perceived return on investment of using the services designed to help get one out of homelessness, and it is being weighed against the perceived return of going back to the street. If you can bring in several hundred dollars a day on the streets that you can spend on alcohol, the effort of being in a place that is trying to help you change your situation might be hard to justify. But a big piece of the equation is how easy it is to just get cash from well-meaning people on the street. I'm not disagreeing with you about needing help with addictions, but there are two sides to the equation.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- esperent 2y agoHere's my answer to the "but they'll spend it on drugs" point: Well, the life of a person whose addiction (always stemming from spirals or depression, abuse, physical or mental illness) has driven them to homelessness is horrible. Why shouldn't I give them the means to a brief escape from the pain? Yes, of course, escape from addiction and rehabilitation is the goal. But denying them temporary relief of the only kind they, in their addiction, are currently capable of, is just more cruelty. And nothing will drive them deeper into it than being ignored by everyone who walks past. Of course, if you have time and means, volunteer, donate to a homeless shelter or charity. But if you, like most people, are not going to do that, and you just get the occasional pang of conscience when walking by, then by all means, give!
- jlkuester7 2y agoYes! I have never struggled with drug addition, but I have had personal experiences that showed me how sometimes in life "getting through today" takes a higher priority then "fixing the underlying problems". Looking back at my life, several unexpected highlights came from the kindness of random strangers who helped me out when I did not deserve it. Giving a homeless person $5 will not fix any of their underlying issues, but it might be the thing that gets them through the day.
- gosub100 2y ago> Why shouldn't I give them the means to a brief escape from the pain? Because they'll leave their Hep-C infected needle on the sidewalk when they're done with it?
- consteval 2y agoThe argument is this will be done regardless of if you give them money.
- fluoridation 2y agoTherefore don't give them money. Both courses of action lead to effects contrary to your interests, but in one of them you get to keep the money.
- adamlett 2y agoI sometimes give to panhandlers, but it’s mostly for my own benefit. I don’t believe my actions do anything to solve a problem, but I also don’t want to desensitize myself to the misery of others so much that I can easily ignore them. As far as I know, there is ample evidence that homelessness can be solved if there is sufficient political will to implement a structural solution.
- johnisgood 2y agoRestaurants MUST throw away food because it would look bad to have homeless people around the area, public image and all. I am against this wasting of food. This does not apply to restaurants only FWIW.
- jacknews 2y agoAre there not charities that go around collecting leftover restaurant food that's still edible?
- johnisgood 2y agoI am not sure, definitely unheard of in my country. If you know of a country that does this (or maybe a state in the US, or just a city somewhere) I would like to know for the sake of restoring some faith in humanity.
- Thorrez 2y agoHere's a charity that does it in the US: https://www.foodrunners.org/ https://www.foodrunners.org/
- gharper 2y agoMy local county lists a few options for local businesses looking to donate excess food: https://kingcounty.gov/en/legacy/depts/dnrp/solid-waste/programs/waste-prevention/toolkit/food-rescue https://kingcounty.gov/en/legacy/depts/dnrp/solid-waste/prog...
- 2y ago
- snarfy 2y agoI honestly don't care if they spend it on drugs and think addiction is another ill of society like any other. Fear of giving money to an addict is an excuse we give ourselves. I always give them money, but I only do it once for the same person, so that the next person has an opportunity.
- 23B1 2y agoFor less than the price of a candy bar you can feel better about yourself for the rest of the day. Small acts acts of kindness are rational even if the guy does go buy a bottle of gin.
- acheron 2y agoI would feel shitty about myself that I got taken in by a scam.
- PittleyDunkin 2y ago> I would feel shitty about myself that I got taken in by a scam. Sorry, what are you referring to?
- fluoridation 2y agoFor example, someone telling you a completely fabricated pity story to get you give them money could be said to be scamming people.
- 23B1 2y agoscarcity mindset
- mtalantikite 2y agoI give money to people on the street all the time, but it's rarely about the money. It's about stopping, asking how they're doing, showing them that someone cares even for just a minute or two, and then, lastly, giving them money that might be good for a slice of pizza or coffee. There was a guy on my corner here in Brooklyn who I'd do this with a lot over the years. One night I was coming back from Manhattan and he clearly had just taken something -- he was in a totally joyful, high state. We say what's up, he's laughing, and then is like "can I have a hug?!?". And so we hug, he starts yelling "thank you!", and I ask him if he needed any money, to which he said "no money! just hugs!". He's clearly been through an amount of trauma I can't even begin to imagine. If throwing a few dollars his way while chatting for a moment makes him feel like people see him as a human, then I'm going to keep doing it.
- strict9 2y agoEvery situation is different. I live in a city that had a huge influx of migrants. And with them, children. It feels different when those asking for money or trying to sell goods have children with them. Rather than someone who looks like they've struggled with addiction and homelessness for decades. Everyone should do what they feel is the right decision at that time. One blanket answer for every context and every person out there isn't the answer. Some people like to help everyone, others only in certain situations, and yet others never give help at all. And that's OK.
- lo_zamoyski 2y agoI think charity has been abstracted into a kind of grandiose and removed act, even a matter of institution. But charity, from the Latin caritas, is an act of perfect love for the other in which we act for the good of the other, not as a means for our own enrichment (though we are enriched spiritually by it), not for the sake of domination and control, but for the good of the other. This can mean helping an elderly person at a store carry groceries to her car, or spending extra time to tutor a child, or buying a homeless person a meal and talking to them (if possible; they might not want to). It is also manifested in our relationships with loved ones: our spouses, out children, our parents, our friends, etc, such as when we show patience with an aging parent who is losing their hearing or memory, or a spouse with a temper, or a child struggling at school. Charity is kind of habit, a virtue, a gift of self that increasingly becomes part of who you are the more you engage in it. In a way, charity allows you to more fully become who you are. I would claim that if people practiced more genuine charity, they would become less miserable.
- gnu8 2y agoWhat does it matter if they spend the money on drugs? Their lives suck. I can hardly blame them for wanting drugs and if it makes them more comfortable for a short period of time, that is probably the best I can do for them. I’m powerless to change their situation. Even if I had the resources to house and employ such a person, I have no way to cure their mental and emotional issues that prevent them from being a stable person.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoI always come back to the this passage from john chysostom's on wealth and poverty: > The almsgiver is a harbor for those in necessity: a harbor receives all who have encountered shipwreck, and frees them from danger; whether they are bad or good or whatever they are who are in danger, it escorts them into its own shelter. So you likewise, when you see on earth the man who has encountered the shipwreck of poverty, do not judge him, do not seek an account of his life, but free him from his misfortune. Why do you make trouble for yourself? God has excused you from all officiousness and meddlesomeness. How much most of us would complain, if God had bidden us first to examine each person's life exactly, to interfere with his behavior and his deeds, and only then to give alms? But as it is we are freed from all this kind of annoyance. Then why do we bring excessive cares on ourselves? A judge is one thing, an almsgiver is another. Charity is so called because we give it even to the unworthy.
- almostgotcaught 2y ago> sounds like a lot of mental masturbation to simply justify your selfishness and unwillingness to occasionaly do a kind thing for someone less fortunate than you. At least you feel a sense of superiority – short lived though it is. accurate
- kome 2y agowhen therapy talk is used to justify being an asshole, it's really amazing—like, "i also can’t endorse subjecting yourself to the mental load." therapy language repurposed to justify self-centeredness, dressing up selfish behavior as a form of "self-care" or boundary setting really feels like a hallmark of our era. it would be much easier to say, "i am a bad person, and i don't care," and own it. that would help develop a less hypocritical vision of ethics and the functioning of society. confronting the banality of our own evil would humanize the evil in others. probably even better than offering food, which is the most patronizing and offensive move (just offer money, always, please—and if they use it for drugs or alcohol, good for them). If people ask money, give money please. don't be an ass.
- fluoridation 2y agoWhat's so offensive and patronizing about offering food? Are you also opposed to charities that give out food and clothes? And food is hardly the most offensive thing you could give. You could toss a bunch of change on the ground, or give them soiled money.
- terminalbraid 2y agoI usually give when I see people. I've volunteered helping and met people in a variety of circumstances. The only thing I've learned that's common to all of them is they don't want to be in that situation. I'm not going to judge someone on what they do with it. I have a fundamental belief that people are going to do the best they can with what they have. I'm going to put it all in the same level of self-determinism as the people who give me my income and what say they have on what I can do with it (none). If anything, by giving them that with no strings attached at least I gave them a little bit of dignity. If you're not convinced, I encourage you to talk to them and make up your own mind.
- wrp 2y agoThere is a homeless shelter in my town that we support. When a transient asks me for money, I direct them to where they can get food, clothing, shelter, and a job. They never seem interested. I suppose they already knew about it but didn't go. A few times some have appeared to be legitimately victims of unusual bad luck and I offered to buy them a meal, but each time they only wanted cash.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoWhen I was homeless I knew where to get food. I had a place to sleep safer than the shelter. No one was going to give me a job. What I needed was money to buy a coffee and sit and charge my phone and get out of the weather for a few hours. To buy aspirin and clean socks, cash to wash my clothes and sleeping bag. Toothpaste, shoelaces. Just a dozen little things that cost a few dollars I didn't have.
- bell-cot 2y agoYES, to the article in general - though many of the government systems which interact with these people are profoundly dysfunctional. At least around here - Michigan, USA. For those who are intermittently homeless, due to mental health issues, and served by the public mental health systems - there seems to be no priority given to "find things that work for this client, then STICK TO THAT". Example - I've lost track of how many times a friend's niece has gone completely off the rails - because her latest gov't "psychiatrist" decided to switch her meds yet again, and she didn't like the new/different/worse side-effects. There's also the issue of organized homeless encampments. NIMBY's and most of the government seem virulently opposed to those - even if well out of sight on low-value public land, and more orderly and safe than many traditional (but bottom-end poor) neighborhoods and housing complexes. Why? Does a "better" homeless encampment fail to provide enough boogeymen and government interactions and head-bashing opportunities for the politician and bureaucrats and cops?
- DrOctagon 2y agoI don’t know why people tie themselves in knots over this. If you have money and you want to give it to a homeless person then do it.
- lo_zamoyski 2y agoThat's the crux of the problem, isn't it: should you want to?
- 23B1 2y agoNo, that's the crux of the problem as framed by purported rationalists including EA. The real existential question, once you jerk off into the cosmological mirror for long enough, will still be "do you want to?"
- fluoridation 2y ago"Should you want to?" What does that even mean? Wanting is a thought. There is no thought you should have. Have the thoughts you have and act on them. Period.
- PittleyDunkin 2y agoI always give money if I have any on me, and I always try to have cash on me for this very reason. I do not want to live in a society where being inured to such a state of being is normal. And until we can figure out a way to convince other americans that everyone deserves a home, that we pay for if necessary, that's the best an individual can do. Besides, kindness begets kindness. I have been on the receiving end of selfless help from uncountable people; to not do the same with the money I have would be cruel.
- troupe 2y ago> until we can figure out a way to convince other americans that everyone deserves a home I helped get a homeless person into a place that provided him with an apartment, food, and work that he could do, with a path to helping him become independent. He quickly left because on the street he had a better system for getting money that he could spend on drugs. It sounded like there was a large percentage of people the charity tried to help that ended up taking that path. There were some who were able to get back on their feet. The charity basically felt it was worth giving everyone a chance in order to reach the ones that were actually trying to get out of homelessness. However, as far as providing free housing is concerned, that is what this place did. Unfortunately (at least for this person), the well-meaning people who were always willing to give him money on the street meant what the charity was offering wasn't of interest to him.
- foogazi 2y ago> Unfortunately (at least for this person), the well-meaning people who were always willing to give him money on the street meant what the charity was offering wasn't of interest to him. Why couldn’t they get the housing AND the money too ?
- troupe 2y agoWell, they were giving them jobs where they could earn money as well as providing for most all the things that a homeless person is going to need. But the return on investment from people just giving handouts is hard to compete with.
- fluoridation 2y agoThe real reason you should not give money to panhandlers is because it incentivizes panhandling. You should give money if you want to see more panhandlers.
- PittleyDunkin 2y agoWhat's wrong with panhandling? The social dysfunction that gives rise to panhandling won't disappear if the panhandlers do.
- fluoridation 2y ago>What's wrong with panhandling? My statement does not necessitate there being anything wrong with panhandlers, but at a base level it's annoying to be interrupted from what you're doing to be asked for money. >The social dysfunction that gives rise to panhandling won't disappear if the panhandlers do. There's not a single reason why people panhandle, but if enough people give money it turns panhandling into a viable profession.
- PittleyDunkin 2y agoIt seems like it'd be easier to remove the cause of panhandling rather than resent the individual panhandler.
- fluoridation 2y agoOne of those causes is that people give money, hence my original statement.
- dazc 2y agoAs someone who's experienced homelessness, I am where I am now through the kindness of strangers and doubt I would have made it otherwise. Another homeless person went out of his way to get me a sleeping bag, someone else would stop and chat, offering ideas for how I may be able to get more help. Another offered me a place to stay until I got back on my feet, 12 years later he's still my best friend. I never asked for money and was never offered it. I'd witness people who did ask with no second thought and, undeniably, they were doing so to fuel a drink or drug addiction (many of these people were also not technically homeless). If you can really help a homeless person then go ahead and do it, that help is unlikely to materialize via a simple transfer of cash though.
- JohnFen 2y ago> If you can really help a homeless person then go ahead and do it, that help is unlikely to materialize via a simple transfer of cash though Entirely this. Giving some amount of money is easy and might make you feel good, but it's not actually that helpful. Really helping takes effort and genuine caring. As to whether or not you "should" give money, I think that's the wrong question. I don't think there's anything wrong with doing that, but I also don't think it's very effective.
- dfxm12 2y agoI think we can look at this in two ways, how to support the current homeless and how to prevent future homelessness. Having worked in a soup kitchen, I've observed the current homeless are in their positions for many different reasons. Some had a long string of bad luck, some had one huge bout of bad luck (in terms of an unexpected bill, layoff, heath issue, etc.), some are homeless because of addiction/mental problems, some have addiction/mental problems because of homelessness, etc. So, all these different categories have to be addressed in different ways. There's no one size fits all solution, and pocket change is certainly insufficient in all categories. It's a tough sell politically to spend resources on this, and while religious and charity efforts can certainly "momentarily defer discomfort", they simply can't address all the underlaying issues all of these folks are having. In terms of preventing future homelessness, that would require policy changes, like cheaper housing, a stronger welfare system, easier access to health care and more modern drug addiction treatments. Addressing these will be helpful for everyone, so hopefully it is easier to at least throw some political weight behind it for the future.
- quantrox 2y agoBeing homeless is a state of mind and your money won't help anyone. Unless you found rare occurrence of homeless man who don't want to be homeless but some serious incident in life which did that to them. In the past I was homeless for a month. I was young at that time (18 years old). After a very depressive period of 2 weeks I started to act so I won't be homeless any longer. Today I have 3 kids and a good job. It went well for me. But usually, you will find people who are homeless and they like it. Or they don't want to change anything in their life to make a difference. For example, here where I live there are shelters for homeless people so they can find a place to sleep, take shower and wash their clothes. Also, they can get new clothes. But most of them don't want to go there as it is forbidden to be under influence of drugs and alcohol. Also, here is easy to find a job. Even if one has no special skills, there will be always something to do on the constructions. After one month of work and sleeping in the facility which I mentioned you can easily rent something and live normally. But being homeless, you don't need to work. That's it.
- sriram_malhar 2y agoThe author has jumped through many hoops to render himself into exhausting inaction. He isn't doing anything about a problem that bothers him, which includes the meta act of feeling bothered about his smug feeling of having thought about this problem in such detail. It is really not complicated. It is not difficult to be generous at all levels to the extent you can. Give to the panhandler, give to a shelter, give to and volunteer at a soup kitchen, volunteer your time to public policy meetings. So many options that need neither your guilt nor gloat.
- b0dhimind 2y agoShort answer that is missing: we pay taxes for welfare.
- FigurativeVoid 2y agoDuring a class discussion, one of my fellow students said the classic, “but they will use the money to buy drugs.” And the teacher responded, “So what?” I think I agree. Drugs are bad, but withdrawal is also bad. Alcohol withdrawal can be fatal.
- nonameiguess 2y agoDallas has put up signs around the city saying "Say No to Street Charity," as in, don't give cash to panhandlers. I'm reasonably sure this campaign isn't managed by cold-hearted bigots who simply think everyone out there is a worthless drug addict that doesn't need help. Some sort of study has been conducted indicating cash from strangers contributes to problems more than it helps and there are better solutions that the city itself, along with whatever charitable organizations are addressing this, are doing their best to provide. I was like this woman when I was a teenager as well. I not only did what she did, but I went well beyond that. When I got my first car, I drove into LA's skid row at night and handed out whatever cash I had to whoever I could find, at least once a week. Much later in life, nearer to now, I actually lived in a major city downtown district. Frankly, the experience left me feeling hopeless in the face of a problem the scale of which no single person could ever hope to have a meaningful impact on. I started walking for several hours a day as part of my spinal rehab 8 years ago and I'd be stopped every 50 feet at times by people asking for money. This wasn't even just homeless beggars. It was often fundraisers for political campaigns and charities. This left me not only with the impression that I could spend the entire day handing out cash and all that would happen is, as much money as I make, I'd end up broke giving out thousands a day, and still not make any dent, but more practically speaking, I'd get no actual walking done. Being stopped three times a block by all the people demanding just a minute of my time adds up to a lot of minutes, leaving nothing for anything else. It's a similar problem to retention marketing. Every single business you have ever done business with or even looked into doing business with puts you on a permanent list to send you updates of every promotion they ever run. To them, it's perfectly rational. Some evidence suggests the rate at which this turns leads into sales exceeds the cost of sending the messages. Collectively, however, if you even bothered to read all the e-mail and SMS and answer the phone calls, you'd have no time left to do anything else. You wouldn't even be able to eat or sleep. To me, the only rational response left is to turn off and ignore all of this. I don't have the capacity to do individual triage. If I tried to evaluate which beggars need money the most or which spammers trying to buy my house might make a worthy offer, that would take even more time than simply listening to or reading all the spam. Even if I wanted to do it, it's not logistically possible. This is probably not "optimal" altruism or anything, but fair or not, I've just retreated back into the circle of family and friends I already know. Plenty of them are hurting for money at times and I have never once hesitated to give it to them. I'm well aware there is no moral universe in which they are more deserving of charity than some distant kid in an impoverished, war-torn nation, but there are tens of millions of such kids and I can't get to know them the way I know my own family. I already pay taxes, and as far as I'm aware, though governments do a far from perfect job of this, their basic purpose is to address these kinds of large-scale coordination and knowledge problems that individuals can't possibly hope to address on their own.
- Molitor5901 2y agoI once prescribed to the notion that it was wrong to give money to the homeless because it will just be used to feed some addiction. A friend challenged me on that by saying "who care?" Choose to give money or not to give money, who cares what they spend it on, or what they need to get through the day? I think he was saying base the decision based on your own values and morals, but don't assume so you can make judgements about what they do with that money.
- fluoridation 2y agoThe correct answer to your friend was "I care". There's no inherently wrong way to decide whether to give money or not. If your friend doesn't base his decision on what they'll use the money on, that's fine, and if you do base it on that, that's also fine.
- hackeraccount 2y agoMy Dad has always said the we should give money to people on the street. That we shouldn't worry about what they'll do with the money - that's their lookout; our worry should be about giving. Now, that said, my Dad has also arranged his life so that he's rarely in a position where people are asking him for money. If he's out driving and see's someone he can pull over and ask them or he can keep driving. I on the other hand am constantly accosted by people. I never have cash so that I can truthfully tell people I don't have money to give them. I avoid eye contact and have been embarrassed when a person asked me for directions and appeared to actually want directions to a place. The thing I really suspect is that giving money really is about you not the person you're giving it to. That when I have had cash and handed it over it was because I actually interacted with the person acting and I just couldn't imagine myself as a person who would rudely tell another person asking for help "no" and then walk away.
- scoofy 2y agoI want to take this essay seriously. One major weakness of consequentialist ethics is that ethical actions require a non-trivial amount predictive power from agents: Should we spoil our pants to save a drowning child? Sure. Should we wire a significant amount of money to a Nigerian prince who has informed us that he is setting up an organization to save drowning children? Probably not. Would we save baby Hitler? How could we ever accurately predict that a child will become Hitler? The interplay between prediction accuracy here is tough when it comes to giving money to homeless folks. It's entirely possible that giving money can do harm, but in other cases it could also benefit. This indeterminacy is a huge problem for consequentialists (I am one), and creating a reasonable discount rate for lack of knowledge about outcomes generated is a very important part of creating a consequentialist ethical theory. Dealing with general rules for difficult-to-predict decisions is the realm of deontology, not consequentialism.
- 082349872349872 2y agoYou shouldn't live someplace that, to first order, has homeless people. The unhoused are not a fact of nature; they exist only because of a deliberate choice as to the nature of the social safety net.
- 082349872349872 2y agoExample: Japan has 0.2 homeless per 10k population; the US, 20. That's 2 decimal orders of magnitude difference.
- satisfice 2y ago“Homeless” people (including people sleeping rough but not for the fun of it, and panhandlers) are part of a moral economy. The OP is considering their own moral position. This isn’t just about money, or “help.” It’s about self-respect and respect for others. It’s even about patriotism. There is no right answer— I can’t see the truth and don’t know the consequences of my actions. So, my policy is: I usually ignore them, and once in a while I offer the help they request. The first time I visited Paris I saw a man begging on a street-corner. He had a dog. I gave money to help the dog. I soon found that nearly every street corner had another guy— with another dog! I wondered if this was a scheme by the men or if the dogs started it. It was harder to not give money to dogs, but I had to steel myself or I would go broke and be forced to get my own dog.
- DidYaWipe 2y agoWhy is this post "flagged?"
- ei23 2y agoSince most problems are rooted in mindset, I created gift cards—like those metal cards with tools cut into them. I really like them; they’re quite handy. Each card has two sides with text: 1. “I want a better life! What do I want?” 2. “I have a better life! What do I have?” When you give away the card, you might say, "I have a lot of respect for what you’re doing. I want to give you this card because I believe in you. Look here: do you want a better life? You deserve it, but always have to know what you want. Now, on the other side, consider this: maybe today was a good day, maybe you’re happy with this card. So every day, ask yourself what you already have. Don’t compare yourself to others; just be grateful for what you have, even if it feels like it’s not much. And remember, this card is more than just a gift—it’s a meaningful tool.”