6 ms·
> It sounds like it's a resourcing issue, not a change in philosophy. Yes. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41920127 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
> It sounds like it's a resourcing issue, not a change in philosophy.
Yes.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41920127 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41920127 ("HN: The Forest Service Is Losing 2,400 Jobs–Including Most of Its Trail Workers")
Relevant comment by S201: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41922195 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41922195
"The overall Forest Service budget has indeed been increasing, but it's nearly all going to wildfire fighting. I recently wrote about the state of forest road funding and went in depth on this here: https://ephemeral.cx/2024/09/losing-access-to-the-cascades https://ephemeral.cx/2024/09/losing-access-to-the-cascades
> Overall, in 1995 16% of the Forest Service budget was dedicated to wildfires. By 2015 it was 52% and by 2025 it’s projected to be upwards of 67%. Without large amounts of additional funding it is virtually guaranteed that the Forest Service’s budget will continue to be siphoned away by firefighting needs."
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoCan the Forest Service make this up with use fees? Like, could California pay the Forest Service to take care of its land surrounded by California?
- pkaye 2y agoThey can use the lumber fees from the forests to pay for the cost.
- m0llusk 2y agoThat is much more complicated than it appears. Cutting and transporting trees is not easy or free, and there is already a huge glut of wood caused by the die off from phytophthera. Might still be worth looking into.
- Teever 2y agoI'm not from the region so I'm wonder if this glut of wood translating into low prices for end consumers?
- eigen 2y agolumber future prices are up over the last few months. currently 593, was 493 in July. https://www.nasdaq.com/market-activity/commodities/lbr https://www.nasdaq.com/market-activity/commodities/lbr
- xp84 2y agoHave you seen that happening? Did prices for wood even go down post-COVID back to their previous level?
- Teever 2y agoThat's why I'm asking. I live in Canada where we produce a tremendous amount of lumber but it's processed in the US and the prices spiked during COVID and while they've gone down haven't returned to anything resembling the baseline.
- sdenton4 2y agoBaseline before COVID, or baseline factoring in the (global) post COVID inflation spike?
- ssl-3 2y agoIt looks like it is more or less back to a rough pre-COVID baseline, if inflation is factored in: https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/lumber https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/lumber (But I'm certainly not seeing the glut of cheap lumber that others may appear to be alluding to here...)
- mapt 2y ago"Low prices for end consumers" seems to be around the current $3-$4 per 2x4x8 stud in retail terms, but standing lumber was never worth much even at the peak of the lumber shortage a couple years ago, it was all sawmill-limited.
- m0llusk 2y agoMost consumers want straight boards for building. Most wood, particularly from die offs, is curvy branches that may be useful when ground up for wood based products like pellets, MDF, or paper.
- hwestbrook 2y agoThis would be true if the federal allowed more than a nominal amount of logging. Most trees and logs come from private land. See page 8: https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/R45688 https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/R45688
- wbl 2y agoNot without Congress doing something to enable it.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Not without Congress doing something to enable it Why? We played with the farfetched hypothetical of California unilaterally acting on federal land. But if the Forest Service says “come on in” and they do, I’m struggling to see who would face any real consequences given the Congress’s power of the purse isn’t being touched.
- wbl 2y agoOP is talking about CA paying money to the park service. Different than them handing over a license to burn.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> OP is talking about CA paying money to the park service Sure. I don’t see how the Congress stops that if the USFS (not Parks) and Sacramento strike a deal.
- scythe 2y agoIt could possibly be managed by the state by placing a tax on fire insurance which would basically be a workaround to Proposition 13. That would probably be about as popular as a Chinese "weather" balloon but it does have a certain poetry of having the people who use the forest — by living in it — pay to manage it.
- bragr 2y agoThe fire insurance that is unaffordable or just straight not available anymore to those same people?
- scythe 2y agoMost California landowners are hardly poor. We're talking about a state with more than double the GDP per capita of Japan. And the property taxes are in some cases among the cheapest in the world. We're talking about just over a million homes in fire zones, while the total budget for the Forest Service is about $10 billion per annum. That's $10k per year per house to fund the financial equivalent of the entire Forest Service — for roughly a third the rent I pay on a studio apartment in Bergen County. I'll try to find a small enough violin for these landowners. Yes, there are some people who are asset-rich and liquidity poor, but we are not talking about West Virginia. Effective fire prevention will also make fire insurance cheaper and reducing development in fire-prone areas will reduce the cost of forest management.
- WalterBright 2y agoCalifornia has already taxed everything that can be taxed, and raised taxes to the point that further tax increases are likely to result in a decline in tax revenue.
- seadan83 2y agoWere the camp fire or the town of paradise burning down counter examples to your points? IIRC those were not terribly wealthy towns. Could you clarify? Second, how do you know it is just one million homes? I'm interested to learn more there
- akira2501 2y agoI think the issue is that it's federal land. They would just have to authorize California to do it on their behalf.
- solardev 2y agoHere in Oregon (and elsewhere), we have multi-agency partnerships between governments, different federal agencies, local tribes, homeowners, etc.: https://www.conservationgateway.org/ConservationPractices/FireLandscapes/FireLearningNetwork/Documents/FactSheet_PERFACT.pdf https://www.conservationgateway.org/ConservationPractices/Fi... https://firenetworks.org/ https://firenetworks.org/ I'm not sure how it works in California, but wildfires don't really care about our jurisdictional boundaries...
- jwlake 2y agoIf they stopped funding that completely it would halt the problem. Fire is part of nature.
- akira2501 2y agoSo is death. Interestingly we've responded by trying to minimize it where rational. Part of preventing fire is preventing death. Fires also shut down roads which can be a major problem where alternative routes don't exist. A wholesale "do not prescribed burn" is not sensible. Determining which areas are high and low value and then concentrating what resources you have on the highest value areas is.
- jwlake 2y agoNo my point is stop overfunding firefighting. Over fund forest management.
- imoverclocked 2y agoUnfortunately, it's not a binary tradeoff.
- irjustin 2y agoAt the risk of being an idiot, is the problem firefighting? Is the problem that we're continuing a losing battle? That, even when we had proper forest management, the costs were still shifting towards firefighting? Warming making everything drier on average? In the end though the only one we're truly hurting is ourselves and our desired life style when it burns out of control.
- jwlake 2y agoFirefighting makes the next fire worse. You need to have a theory that doesn't involve more expensive fire fighting every time someone builds a new house. This is general means defending towns and letting the mountainside burn.
- tacocataco 2y agoThey're still going broke despite using prison labor to fight the fires? https://www.cnn.com/2019/10/31/us/prison-inmates-fight-california-fires-trnd/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/10/31/us/prison-inmates-fight-calif...
- shkkmo 2y agoThe state of California and its consevation core is not the USFS.
- Ajedi32 2y agoDon't "prescribed burns" fall under the category of firefighting? That's the whole reason you do controlled burns in the first place, right? To prevent a larger fire later?
- leeter 2y agoSadly no, and (IANAL) the law here is clear AFAIK. Money cannot be spent outside of what it was allocated. Firefighting I'm given to understand explicitly excludes prevention. This might be one of the most short sighted budget allocations I've ever seen. As a dollar spent on prevention easily covers 10 on fighting.