7 ms·
Iconic gun-makers gave sensitive customer information to political operatives
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- jimbob45 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- some_random 2y agoIs there any other civil rights fight going on now that's more vicious than the fight over firearms rights? Maybe abortion rights, although I don't know of Planned Parenthood doing anything like this.
- falcolas 2y agoState attorney generals are suing hospitals in other states to obtain information on both transgender and pregnant folk's visits, with the intent to use that information to prosecute those people in the AG's state. I'm not sure if that counts by your measure, but it involves the government directly.
- Dah00n 2y agoSounds like a quote straight out of The Handmaids Tale! Reminds me of how Stasi operated. It also reminds me of the Signs Of Fascism list, actually.
- rsynnott 2y agoThat's kind of baffling; like, I'd have to assume that _very_ few people, even people who were generally opposed to abortion, would be okay with _that_. I live in a country (Ireland) which only recently generally legalised abortion; before that people would normally have gone to the UK. If there had been any suggestion of the government prosecuting people who did that, never mind trying to force UK hospitals to divulge records, well... people wouldn't have put up with that. The situation as it was only continued so long because it was easy to ignore; ~no-one was ever actually prosecuted under the law, and the UK was enough of a safety valve that the human cost of the law was largely masked. Like, doing things like this seems like a very good way to stoke national outrage and be forced to legalise it.
- lupusreal 2y agoAt least many people opposed to abortion ostensibly think that it's murder. Given that framing, trying to collect evidence from hospitals seems reasonable. (At least they say they they consider it murder. The way they act concerning it makes me think that relatively few really believe it.)
- falcolas 2y ago> The way they act concerning it makes me think that relatively few really believe it.) Enough people in power believe it: At least one woman (Marshae Jones) was put in jail for getting shot while pregnant, while the shooter was let free. The woman was accused of not doing more to protect the "unborn baby". At least one woman (Brittney Poolaw) has been sentenced for having a miscarriage, and others have been arrested and charges brought against them.
- AlexandrB 2y agoI looked up Brittney Poolaw. > Pregnancy advocates and others on social media are expressing outrage after a 21-year-old Oklahoma woman was convicted of first-degree manslaughter earlier this month for having a miscarriage, which the prosecutor blamed on her alleged use of methamphetamine.[1] I would argue she should be prosecuted (assuming the drug use can be proved) even if abortion in that state were legal right up until birth. This isn't a miscarriage due to natural causes or some kind of accident but due to drug use. Is the argument that the mother has absolutely no responsibility for the well-being of the fetus? [1] https://archive.is/QHV3F#selection-1145.0-1145.260 https://archive.is/QHV3F#selection-1145.0-1145.260 Edit: It seems like the case hinges on the claim that the meth caused the miscarriage. > Prosecutors argued that the miscarriage Poolaw suffered was from her use of methamphetamine. An autopsy of the fetus showed it had tested positive for methamphetamine, the Associated Press reported, but there was no evidence her use of the substance is what caused the miscarriage. The autopsy showed the miscarriage could have been caused by a congenital abnormality and placental abruption, when the placenta detaches from the womb, the AP said.
- 2y ago
- AlexandrB 2y agoProsecute transgender people for what? AFAIK there are no laws against being transgender in any state.
- lazide 2y agoso far
- Tobani 2y agoNo but gender-reaffirming care could be. So some sort of hormonal treatment or even talk therapy.
- falcolas 2y agoIs, unfortunately. And the biggest consumer of hormonal treatments as children (in the 99% range)? Cisgendered girls and boys who have no desire to transition. And though you didn't mention it, let's do a quick aside on gender affirming surgery: Boys with gynocomastia get mastectomies while girls get breast enlargements to improve their perception of their bodies.
- falcolas 2y agoThere are restrictions and bans on gender affirming care. Most often for minors, but also for adults. It's telling that most of these that are aimed at adults call out exceptions for Viagra. There are laws prohibiting drag shows which have been written so vaguely that they can be applied to trans people as well, especially those who do any kind of performance. Next up are laws forcing trans individuals to use the bathroom assigned to them at birth. I'm very curious how they expect women to react to bearded, burly men entering their bathrooms, and how they expect men to react to women presenting individuals (actually I'm quite sure of how they'll react: they'll be SA'ed if not killed). And then there's the bans on playing sports for Trans individuals - all 40 or so of them. So no, they're not explicitly outlawed, yet. Just everything about them living their life is. Much like it was never illegal to be gay, they just outlawed sodomy.
- rsynnott 2y ago
- nfriedly 2y agoThe reason the headline doesn't say which iconic gun-makers is apparently because it was a whole bunch of them: > At least 10 gun industry businesses, including Glock, Smith & Wesson, Remington, Marlin and Mossberg, handed over names, addresses and other private data to the gun industry’s chief lobbying group, the National Shooting Sports Foundation.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- doctorpangloss 2y ago[flagged]
- burnte 2y agoIt's an intentional tactic. You accuse someone else of what you are doing so when the complaints and accusation come out that you're doing it, people already have decided either it doesn't matter/just finger pointing, or "well, looks like everyone is doing it." It's an inoculation against future accusations.
- atoav 2y agoDo you think banks should publish your account balance? I think there would be nothing wrong with it.
- doctorpangloss 2y agoAre promises that are not kept, but related to politics, more important than other promises like whether or not your Etsy product is hand made?
- burnte 2y agoI'm not defending the policy, I think it's abhorrent. No company should be allowed to share identifiable data without the customer's consent.
- more_corn 2y agoCool, I hear you. It’s possible and even common for someone who commits an offense to accuse his opponents of the same offense. Now respond to the real report that gun manufacturers sold your information (I’m assuming you own a gun and registered the warranty) for lobbying purposes. You pissed off at that at all? It does seem like a violation of your privacy. Maybe we should push our representatives to pass a law prohibiting that sort of shit. We do still live in a democracy for the time being.
- 2y ago
- tiahura 2y ago[flagged]
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoIt's an actual requirement to give your personal information to gun stores when buying a gun so they can do a background check. They are prohibited by law from using that info for purposes like marketing, but they still have to collect and store it, and I'm sure all of them don't have great privacy policies. Even morons in the 1990s understood that.
- wl 2y agoThis isn't about the data gathered on Form 4473s for the purposes of running background checks. This is about people filling out the warranty cards that came with the guns.
- plorg 2y agoI've always kind of assumed the primary purpose of these is building customer lists. Were they at any point actually important in seeking warranty reimbursement or repair? I suspect that at almost 40 I reached adulthood about the time that the internet shifted the way a lot of old customer service systems worked.
- ang_cire 2y agoThey are only for collecting user data. Firearm manus tend to either cover everything aside from user modifications/damage, no questions asked, or cover nothing.
- zer8k 2y ago4473s are a different, far worse, form of privacy invasion. Ostensibly used for background checks, kept forever in order for the ATF to do fishing expeditions.
- _blk 2y ago“The hypocrisy of warning about a governmental registry and at the same time establishing a private registry for political purposes is stunning,” So does he suggest that databases on advertisement/customer preferences, voters, ... be run by the govt? All debatable but I'll argue the constitution never gave the govt the right to know who owns guns since the ratification of the 2nd amendment, the purpose of which is exactly to defend against unconstitutional govt acts. So per se, that means if it's legal to be tracked, it has to be done in private registries.
- _ea1k 2y agoWhile I don't like manufacturers doing this, the comparison to government gun registries is indeed strange. The manufacturers didn't compel buyers to provide this information with the thread of prison time, and perhaps more importantly, they didn't compel buyers to inform the manufacturer of every subsequent transfer.
- michaelt 2y agoAre there reasons to oppose a government database of guns that don't also apply to a private sector database of guns? For example, if a future government decided to round up all the guns and needed a database to find them, the fact the database is in a different building ain't going to stop them.
- dmurray 2y agoSure. The government database presumably covers "all the guns". The private one includes some subset of guns, for example, all those whose owners want to subscribe to a certain gun manufacturer's newsletter, or all guns whose owners opted into a warranty program despite knowing it would get their names in a database. The fact that this particular database included data collected under false pretenses shouldn't preclude anyone from making a mailing list of gun owners.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 2y agoOne could reasonably argue intentions matter, and the only possible intention for a government database is explicitly prohibited. If one were worried about such things, then a private database existing is of course problematic in that a ready-made one is there any time the government decides to stop prohibiting itself from doing such a thing... But this is more bone-headed than sinister.
- goodluckchuck 2y agoWhat’s wrong with this? If I shop at Joe’s Grocery, then it’s no secret that I’m allowed to tell my county commissioner about the fact that Joe sold me a banana. Are they saying that Joe can’t tell the county commission that I bought a banana? This is all just stuff we learn. It’s basic freedom of speech. Sure, if I paid Joe $2 to keep it secret because my wife thinks I’m allergic… that’s different.
- kyleblarson 2y agoIt is unlikely that the government is going to send armed men to take away your bananas.
- sophacles 2y agoWhy? They send armed men to take away my cats and my flowers. Whats to stop fruit from being next?
- rbanffy 2y ago> They send armed men to take away my cats and my flowers. Can you please elaborate on that?
- sophacles 2y agoTry to keep a pet tiger. Try to grow a boquet of cannibis indica. You may just find armed men at your door.
- rbanffy 2y agoAs for tigers, I am not sure - there are some safety standards you'd need to comply to so that your neighbors don't become meals for Fluffy. As for cannabis, all you need to do is move to one of the more enlightened states that allow cultivation. Given time, I believe all states will recognize the benefits it brings.
- 2y ago
- brodouevencode 2y agoThe reason gun owners do not like government registries is because they may be used for targeting those owners for compulsory buy-back or confiscation programs. While the deceit of the manufacturers is indeed abhorrent, owners are not afraid of manufacturers showing up at their door. It is two different things, and both are bad (but one is way worse).
- mrguyorama 2y agoExcept companies like Palintir show that there's nothing to stop law enforcement from buying exactly those same lists.
- WaxProlix 2y agoBut the manufacturers re-shared that information with the government, isn't that the point of the article?
- rootusrootus 2y agoThat's just conspiracy theory. The government has no appetite for such a thing, not even a tiny bit. The best we could hope for is an extremely well funded voluntary buy-back program. Offer a thousand bucks each no questions asked (and no silly loopholes like turning in empty rocker launcher tubes, and exclusions for newly created weapons) and we could take a huge number of guns off the streets. Would cost a fair amount of money, sure, but at the scale of the federal government as a non-recurring cost it is entirely feasible. Economically, I mean, not politically.
- AlexandrB 2y agoIt's weird how this article is ostensibly about the violation of gun-owners' privacy, but can't help but wander into the 2nd amendment discussion with sentences like: > Last month at a high school in Georgia, a 14-year-old used an assault rifle to kill two students and two teachers and wound seven more people. The assault rifle in question is an "AR-15 style rifle". I.e. not an assault rifle. > Semi-automatic-only rifles like the Colt AR-15 are not assault rifles; they do not have select-fire capabilities.[1] In conclusion, I don't know who this article is for. Gun owners and pro 2nd amendment readers will probably be put off by technical errors like this and the thinly veiled contempt for gun ownership. Many non-gun owners and anti-2nd amendment readers will probably think: "good, fuck em". [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assault_rifle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assault_rifle
- kevin_thibedeau 2y agoDepending on the state, scary features like a carry handle or a bayonet mount upgrade a semi-auto to banned status. Bayonet on a bolt action? No problem.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- matthewdgreen 2y agoThe article is reporting on a privacy violation. If the fact that it also expresses opinions you dislike makes you want to disregard those facts -- then you're making bad decisions and you should do better. Personally I think it's valuable to have this information out there. Both for the folks whose privacy was violated, and for people who are concerned about how closely the gun industry works to coordinate its customer database with lobbying groups. (PS I own a gun and don't like anything about this news, from either of those perspectives.)
- generalizations 2y ago> you're making bad decisions and you should do better. This part was unnecessary btw.
- 2y ago
- rsynnott 2y ago[flagged]