6 ms·
AMD Q3'2024 Financials
- nextworddev 2y agoStock down 10% post earnings on lackluster guidance
- uncharted9 2y agoDesktop Gaming segment is the ignored child
- bluescrn 2y agoIs there any future for the gaming/enthusiast PC segment? Feels like it's dying. Becoming an ever-smaller niche. High-end gaming PCs became vastly more expensive over the last few years, between general post-Covid inflation and the chip shortage allowing high-end graphics card prices to be pushed well into 4-figure territory. Other than those very expensive GPUs, performance improvements elsewhere have come slowly. And on top, Microsoft is doing their best to push people away from Windows. And the VR bubble has deflated. AAA game development is a seriously struggling industry with little tolerance for risk/innovation, fewer releases, and many high-profile failures. And most of the really popular games can be played well on a 10-year-old PC or a console.
- izacus 2y ago> Is there any future for the gaming/enthusiast PC segment? Feels like it's dying. Becoming an ever-smaller niche. This meme of "dying PC gaming" is being repeated since like 1998 while the actual sales numbers show consistent growth of that market over last years.
- vineyardlabs 2y agoI don't think it's dying I just think things are shifting. More realistically, I think we're watching console gaming die right now (other than Nintendo). Neither Sony nor MS are doing strict console exclusivity anymore, with MS going as far as to put out their own IPs on Sony consoles. MS claims there's going to be a next Xbox, but I honestly wouldn't be surprised if it's basically a computer with some custom version of windows with a console-tailored UI. So in some ways, PC gaming is healthier than it's ever been as it is gaining a growing market share as the console market share shrinks. I think what's happening in the PC space is that we've reached a kind of Moore's law for graphical fidelity where we're deep in the diminishing returns part of the curve. Look at Read Dead Redemption 2 for example. It's 6 years old and still goes toe to toe with games coming out now. By contrast compare Crysis (2007) to anything that came out in 2001. Halo, for example. It's a night and day difference. So yeah the highest end hardware (specifically GPUs) has gotten crazy expensive but it's also gotten crazy overkill. A lot of new games are playable on low to mid settings on older and/or more budget hardware, and low settings still look fantastic on many games. Add to that there's a general distrust right now of AAA studios to actually make a decent product, really great stuff coming out of AA/indie studios, and a lot of people playing only one or two live service games like CoD or Fortnight instead of playing lots of different AAA games and there's less dollars to get thrown at every new 100 million dollar budget game that comes out. I think we're close to the point where the AAA publishers wake up and realize that it's not tenable for every game that comes out to have 100+ hours worth of content and cost 100+ million dollars, and the industry will be better for it.
- jajko 2y ago> basically a computer with some custom version of windows with a console-tailored UI I presume you mean PC, but still this is situation for past 2 decades. PS used to run on Unix, I guess they still do, on very much a PC hardware, just not the exactly same chips you can buy on PC. Xbox even more so, its ridiculously expensive to come up with your own cpu & gpu, all use amd/intel and amd/nvidia and definitely not the top of the ranges. OS should be skinned Windows with maybe some non-core parts cut off (but I presume telemetry remains). The only one building non-PC consoles is Nintendo, which uses which uses very much cell phone hardware (but more custom IIRC).
- vineyardlabs 2y agoI'm not talking about hardware. I mean perhaps the next Xbox will literally be a windows PC with a console-focused interface and the Xbox binaries and PC binaries of games will literally be the same. In the same way that a Steam Deck is actually just a PC.
- kouteiheika 2y ago> By contrast compare Crysis (2007) to anything that came out in 2001. Halo, for example. It's a night and day difference. So yeah the highest end hardware (specifically GPUs) has gotten crazy expensive but it's also gotten crazy overkill. A lot of new games are playable on low to mid settings on older and/or more budget hardware, and low settings still look fantastic on many games. You can actually play the original Crysis maxed out at 60 FPS on modern integrated GPUs. Crazy.
- yread 2y agoDont forget integrated GPUs actually working quite well for 80% of gamers
- KeplerBoy 2y agoAs it should. There's no money to be made by selling FP32 chips at 200$ a pop.
- jauntywundrkind 2y agoWho knows what it means but I don't feel super hopeful that RDNA (Ryzen/consumer) & CDNA (Compute/data-center) are being merged to UDNA after RDNA4. https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/cpus/amd-announces-unified-udna-gpu-architecture-bringing-rdna-and-cdna-together-to-take-on-nvidias-cuda-ecosystem https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/cpus/amd-announce... The consumer gpu's were unobtainium during COVID. You can't make money if you don't even have cards to sell. Then rx7000 series offered a pretty minimal upgrade. I'm very hopeful I might finally upgrade my rx580. An affordable chip that did pretty great. RDNA4 sounds similar, after their expensive multi-chip flagship got cancelled a long while back. It just feels absurd that AMD is slacking so hard here. Nvidia got where they are by selling consumer cards that ran CUDA well. AMD seems to think their high margin data-center GPUs don't need any consumer market to succeed and maybe they are right but it's such a gamble to have ROCm with so few consumer offerings available for it, so have such a decaying consumer side.
- betaby 2y agoAMD P/E ratio is ~185 Nvidia P/E ratio is ~65 Yet I constantly hear how Nvidia is overvalued.
- vardump 2y agoI do think AMD has way more headroom to grow. So maybe that high P/E could have some justification.
- _huayra_ 2y agoThe high P/E means that "room to grow" is already priced into the stock though.
- ssijak 2y agoThat AMD P/E ratio is artificially high because of some accounting adjustments after a merger with some other company.
- metabagel 2y agoXilinx, I guess, although I don't know how the accounting works on that.
- JonChesterfield 2y agoYeah, that was Xilinx. Bought with stock. I remember thinking the rise from $30 to $140 or so was way too fast so using the gain to acquire Xilinx looked great. It turned a huge gain on paper into a new division of the company with a track record of steadily printing money. It was totally lost on me that it would come at the price of literally years of people looking at P/E and declaring it too expensive. Company just put up ~7B in a quarter at 50% gross margin. Market cap is 240B. So about 9x a year's revenue, for a fabless semiconductor company. Looks crazy cheap to me, '132' P/E ratio and all.
- RicoElectrico 2y agoOps margin for AMD is in 3-ish %, for Nvidia 63%. I wonder if that changes anything.
- rtenserl 2y agoThe Nasdaq crash in 2000 started with semiconductors like ASML underperforming and dropping 20%. We are in a very bad situation due to global wars, excess COVID money (a lot of which went to rich people who pumped up the stock market) and an energy crisis induced by sanctions and the Nordstream terrorism act. No company in Germany will buy expensive CPUs, they barely survive. Global revenue matters ...
- cedilla 2y agoNordstream was already out of use when it was sabotaged, and the death of the German economy is greatly overstated. Things are not fine, but companies still can afford to buy Nvidia cards.
- metabagel 2y agoThe war in Ukraine is a regional war. The damaging of the Nordstream pipeline wasn't terrorism. It was an act of sabotage. Nobody was terrorized. I don't see any current energy crisis. https://www.macrotrends.net/2480/brent-crude-oil-prices-10-year-daily-chart https://www.macrotrends.net/2480/brent-crude-oil-prices-10-y... Germany has narrowly avoided recession, at least for now. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/oct/30/german-economy-growth-gdp-recession-fears-end https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/oct/30/german-economy... > Economists said the inflation shock that followed Russia’s invasion of Ukraine – sparking a dramatic increase in energy and food prices that undermined business and consumer confidence across the eurozone – was beginning to ease. Inflation is moderating. https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/inflation-cpi https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/inflation-cpi https://tradingeconomics.com/euro-area/inflation-cpi https://tradingeconomics.com/euro-area/inflation-cpi
- belval 2y agoMy unpopular opinion (well to people heavily invested in AMD anyway) is that their valuation is bordering on the delusional based on a conjecture that they will somehow completely kill off Intel in the datacenter and eat some of Nvidia's lunch for GPU-based workloads. They are seriously hurting Intel in the datacenter space, but Intel is not dead yet and their accelerator have so far seen very small adoption. They are fabless meaning that their margins are capped, x86 mobile CPUs are under attack from ARM and all hyperscalers are working on their own accelerator with some degree of success. They won't move to AMD GPUs. They are a good company putting out great hardware, but at the current price I just don't get it.
- qzw 2y agoI think it’s because AMD has been the “if only…” company for decades. It used to be in relation to Intel’s x86 dominance, and now it’s relative to Nvidia. The x86 fairy tale did eventually come true, which made a lot of money for investors who held on long enough or got in early in the Ryzen era. So now a lot of people are hoping the same will happen in GPUs, and that accounts for the valuation/speculation. And it does make a certain amount of sense. When you have basically a market duopoly but instead of two nearly equal sized competitors you have a 90/10 split, then there’s always a chance the smaller firm will somehow gain significant market share at some point. Waiting for that pop and selling high is a gamble a lot of investors are willing to make.
- JonChesterfield 2y agoOne could rephrase your thesis slightly. Conjecture that Intel will continue killing themselves and that some of the companies spending billions on AI that doesn't care what hardware it's running on will continue to choose the much cheaper hardware. Fabless means the capex is tiny. The hyperscalars have been trying to follow Google's TPU approach for a decade now. Whole load of silicon startups came to life, set fire to a lot of VC money, died off in the same time period. I believe AMD is the most likely winner of the silicon age. Progress is slower than one would like but everything is heading in the right direction.
- hakfoo 2y agoI think the case for AMD over nVidia is that it's somewhat less bubble-driven. A lot of the crypto boom is over. If the AI boom fizzles, and nVidia goes back to selling GPUs for gamers, an admittedly niche market, that's going to be a hell of a haircut. If AMD has to retreat to that, well, they've lost far less, and they have a successful CPU product line to lean on.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]