8 ms·
Family medicine is in decline
- A_D_E_P_T 2y ago[flagged]
- Pxtl 2y ago[flagged]
- mfer 2y agoWhat policies have been put in place that would cause the problems they are experiencing? If there is a politics issues, the policies can be talked about.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoPolicies like the ones in the article, the removal of complexity billing codes, drastically reducing GP earnings. But AFAICT mostly it's their lack of constructive new models. Alberta has been fiddling at the margins with changes like dividing up the province into districts. OTOH BC introduced a wildly successful new physician pay model almost 2 years ago. I indirectly know several doctors who moved from Saskatchewan & Ontario to BC partly because of that. P.S. I should emphasize that the new BC physician pay model not only attracts new doctors but it also encourages rostering, encouraging doctors to become the single point of generalist GP that is becoming scarce in Alberta according to the article.
- michaelrpeskin 2y agoMy take on it is that ACA set up the insurance companies as essentially a cost-plus system. I forget the actual name for it in the ACA, but the general idea is that insurance needs to spend at least 80% of the premiums on health care. Sounds good at first pass, but there's also no limit to costs in the ACA. So the way an insurance company makes more money is to pay more for service. And the providers are happy to comply. Costs go up, insurance explicitly doesn't fight costs, so that premiums go up and they keep 20% of a bigger pie now. I've essentially stepped out of the system. I get the cheapest, biggest deductible policy through my employer to cover a big emergency. But for my personal care, I do Direct Primary Care where I pay my doc $175/mo for my family of 4 and any time I need him, he's there "for free" no office visit fees, etc. If I'm sick, I can always get same-day telehealth or next day in-office visits. For routine care, I may have to book out a week or so. He's never rushed because his incentive is consult me to keep me healthy so that I _don't_ need to see him. His incentives are not to keep me coming back for more visits. During my last routine yearly visit, we had a hour long conversation about all the little nagging things that were happening has I get older, and we made a good plan on what to do. I love this model and I could see it scaling like this: Rather than forcing (individual mandate) ACA-specified insurance purchases, you are "forced" to put that cost into a HSA-like account (government supplemented for if you can't afford it), and then use the HSA to buy the insurance and/or DPC memberships you want and work for you. That would put downward pressure on price since you're making the decisions not the insurance/government. And you adds competition on service since you choose your providers.
- lurking15 2y ago[flagged]
- deepthaw 2y agoI see the same issues here in the states. I think no matter what the economic model, we need to take a long hard look at the overhead and complexity of healthcare. And by and large, I suspect the insurance companies will be found to be at the root of it. I can't believe I of all people am calling for less regulation, but the amount of bullshit it seems like doctors have to go through to provide basic service seems counterproductive.
- lurking15 2y agoI think people will hit a breaking point and it will be undeniable that heavy regulation and subsidization is the root of dysfunction and deterioration of most important aspects of life. It's hard not to see the parallel between healthcare and education where the parasitic overhead has been completely unchecked and enabled by federal subsidies. There's a similar deal with food, housing and other areas. It's absurd the amount of money that has been spent by the federal government in these areas with so little to show, the average person feels not only a lack of progress but decline.
- ses1984 2y agoMuch of the regulation you’re saying is to blame was written in blood. Want to know what food and housing was like before regulation? Read the jungle. Do you think we have deteriorated since then? Maybe the prosperity you think has deteriorated was not due to lack of regulation, but due to black swan events like… i dunno conquering and industrializing the entire North American continent, all peer nations blowing each other to bits in two world wars, etc?
- lurking15 2y ago> Want to know what food and housing was like before regulation? Read the jungle. Not convincing since you're reducing the entire time period to The Jungle which was sensationalized fiction, effectively political propaganda. But to your broader point, things improved directly from capitalism and markets. My reading recommendation? Deirdre McCloskey "Why Liberalism Works" on the absurd increase in living standards brought about through innovation enabled by capitalism, we're talking some 3,000% in average income over the course of time you're referring to.
- plus 2y agoI've been experiencing this exact issue in the US. Lately a medical issue of mine has been getting worse, and the earliest I can see a new PCP is in May 2025. I managed to get a referral to a specialist by visiting urgent care, but they referred me to a different specialist, and I won't be able to see the latter until late January 2025. Meanwhile my medical issue is continuing to get worse, and I have no one I can talk to about it. I'm looking into alternative options but things are looking bleak. I'm probably going to have to go out-of-network and drive 2 hours to find a doctor that has wait times on the order of weeks (as opposed to the in-network providers, that have wait times on the order of months).
- Spooky23 2y agoI had this issue due the consolidation of medical networks. Luckily I have a BlueCross PPO. So I’ll get fast access to a specialist in NYC in Boston then transfer the records back to the local dude if needed. My wife had an issue with a complication, and I found a doctor who was a contributor to a major study on it and we got treated by him. Epic makes managing this trivial. It’s the best of both worlds, but only if you have the privilege of legacy insurance and PTO.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> I won't be able to see the latter until late January 2025 Where are you? This is unusual. In America, the "average wait time for a [cardiologist, dermatologist, og/gyn, orthopedic surgery or family medicine] appointment for the 15 large metro markets surveyed in 2022 is 26.0 days" [1]. In Canada, the "median national wait time 1 was 78 days," with wait ime "defined as the period between a patient’s referral by a family physician to a specialist and the visit with said specialist" [2]. Broadly speaking, American medical wait times are quite good, particularly for specialists [3]. But PCPs/capita vary greatly from state to state [4]. [1] https://www.wsha.org/wp-content/uploads/mha2022waittimesurveyfinal.pdf https://www.wsha.org/wp-content/uploads/mha2022waittimesurve... [2] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7292524/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7292524/ [3] https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/health-care-wait-times-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/health-ca... [4] https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/rankings-and-ratings/states-ranked-by-total-primary-care-physicians-in-2024.html https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/rankings-and-ratings/s...
- nsxwolf 2y ago10 years ago I could see my doctor when I was sick. Like, the same day. Now if it can't be done at the Target or CVS, it's the emergency room. I didn't even get an annual checkup last year because my doctor had to cancel, and the earliest I can be seen again is this summer. I'm now at the age where this is probably starting to matter. And I pay like... $30,000 a year minimum for this?
- bongodongobob 2y agoI know insurance can be pricey, but $2500/month? Who's your provider? Do you have a family of 6 or something?
- elif 2y agoPremium + deductible + prescriptions + out of network care I believe 30k is possible for a healthy single American.
- elif 2y agoI didn't think so back when I was in a startup insurance program where it literally covered stuff. But i've been on a "normal" health plan through my wife's job for the last 5 years. The American health system is experienced totally differently by different classes of people.
- antisthenes 2y agoJust because it's possible, doesn't mean it's typical, or even common.
- elif 2y agoI mean my wife and I pay $700/mo premium, we both hit our $2500 deductible this year already, my physical therapy is out of network and costs me $800/mo That's $23k already before prescriptions and we are in our 30s with no major health issues.
- bodiekane 2y agoI'm intrigued by this line from the article: > Before the pandemic, she says, she might have done two disability tax credit forms; last year, she did twenty Did Covid cause massive disability? Did legislation change to make claiming a disability easier or more lucrative? Are people claiming disability in response to inability to get jobs that meet their expectations? It's not the point of the article, but a 10x increase in requests for "disability tax credit forms" seems like a very significant sign of something deeply concerning. I wonder how many people seeking disability are more accurately described as disenfranchised. If people are looking at bleak prospects of low-paid jobs with limited possibilities for advancement, alongside soaring housing and other costs, how many people with previously manageable impairments are throwing in the towel and using a disability designation to escape the rat race.
- analyte123 2y agoEven for the first person described in the story, her search for a doctor is not primarily described a search for medical care, but a search for someone who can create a paper trail to ensure her child's eligibility for benefits.
- apothegm 2y agoYes, Covid did cause massive disability. The colloquial term for it is Long Covid. I know at least three people suffering from it —- along a spectrum from slight to severe impairment of daily functioning.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Covid did cause massive disability. The colloquial term for it is Long Covid I know a previously-healthy guy who got an early variant that went for his pancreas. He now has Type 1 diabetes, a condition one is normally born with and for which there is no cure, just chronic, expensive and time-consuming treatment.
- malfist 2y agoHow old is he? Type 1 can show up in your 20s-30s, it's not always the case that you're born with it
- elif 2y agoIt's so frustrating. We signed up for a pediatric practice in Atlanta that has 8 doctors. We saw a great doctor on our first visit, then our next visit we didn't even get to see a doctor, just a nurse practitioner... Kinda annoying I don't want parenting advice from a nurse... So on our way out when scheduling we asked if we could see the same Dr next time. "Oh sorry she only works Tuesdays" "Okay weird but this is 2 months out though so that should be fine" "Actually Tuesday would put you over a week away from when the appointment was requested I can schedule you with ..." 3 visits later and we still haven't seen a doctor once. Not even a 30 second pop in the room to say hi. We've gotten like 20 immunizations from nurses and can't ask doctors about any of it.. Like cool cool all for these peopl advancing their careers without med school but like ... Usually you want your doctor's to have gone through medical school
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> our next visit we didn't even get to see a doctor, just a nurse practitioner... Kinda annoying I don't want parenting advice from a nurse Is your kid sick? If not, you don't need a doctor.
- elif 2y agoFor a baby you have regularly scheduled appointments through the first year to make sure developmental milestones and for the correct immunization schedule. The amount of bad and actually hazardous parenting advice I've gotten from nurses and PA's is staggering. When we were discharged from the hospital, the pediatric nurse actually told us it was safe to feed him in the car seat on the drive home.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> a baby you have regularly scheduled appointments through the first year to make sure developmental milestones and for the correct immunization schedule Sure. None of this requires a doctor, though. > pediatric nurse actually told us it was safe to feed him in the car seat on the drive home This is bad advice. But I'm failing to find studies that quantify the risk. You're correct that they shouldn't have said this. But I'm not convinced no doctor would advise similarly. If everyone wants their kid to be seen by a doctor, we either need to lower the standards of doctor or normalise perfectly-well kids being seen by NPs. (That or a higher billing code if a patient demands a doctor for routine care.)
- mg 2y agoI wonder what percentage of medical issues we could tackle by better analyzing and categorizing the existing medical studies that are out there. And then attaching a user interface to the data that guides the user through a step-by-step self-diagnose process.
- bluGill 2y agoThere is too much "medical students syndrome" - you learn about some symptoms and they decide you have the issue because the symptoms match even though they don't match in the right way. There are also a lot of rare things that need expensive procedures that shouldn't be done on a whim. Many medical tests increase your odds of cancer for instance - if you really need that test done to figure out your issue it is worth it, but those tests shouldn't just be done - it is often better to treat the most common causes without verifying that is really the root cause and then only if those treatments fail do the tests to see what you really have.
- marcinzm 2y agoThis is my understanding of the US situation. It used to be that doctors were running their own small medical offices a lot. Unfortunately, due to insurance overhead it's no longer profitable for individual doctors to do that, especially without existing patients, so the remaining offices are mostly from doctors near retirement age. So as doctors retire and new doctors don't want to start their own practices those practices have been getting bought out by large medical networks or private equity. Some offices are also going out of network with insurance companies. It doesn't help that PE is willing to pay a ton more than any new doctor could for the practice. I'd recommend picking medical plans with out referral requirements and with good out-of-network coverage.
- Mistletoe 2y agoMy brother was a Family Medicine doctor and he got burned out and retired early and is now a potter lol. His ex gf was a doctor and did the same. I suspect this sort of thing is behind a lot of the issues this article is explaining. After Covid, a large portion of the world that could retire did so and never came back. Those that are left and stuck in that world working or trying to use it, are not happy about it.
- CharlieDigital 2y agoI wrote a more detailed post elsewhere in this thread, but I also think this is the case and you can see an analogue with consolidation of clinical trial sites by private equity. https://www.fiercebiotech.com/cro/private-equity-invests-trial-sites-cro-consolidation-continues-pitchbook https://www.fiercebiotech.com/cro/private-equity-invests-tri... > Private equity dollars are flowing toward clinical trial sites as industry conditions demand larger site networks, PitchBook's analysis of first quarter 2024 deal activity shows. > > For CROs, scooping up trial sites is one aspect of a greater movement toward vertical and horizontal consolidation, a long-standing trend that is still playing out in the space, the PitchBook report confirmed. CROs continue to combine with contract development and manufacturing organizations to establish end-to-end drug development capabilities under a single roof, making them more competitive in the outsourcing market.
- eob 2y agoI think Taiwan is worth adding to the list of healthcare systems that folks study. I believe it may be similar to the Swiss system. Everyone has national health insurance, but you also get to choose where to go, and some doctors also offer non-insured services that you can pay for out of pocket. The result is universal coverage combined with a competitive market that drives prices down and encourages innovation. I know this is just anecdata, but having held an insurance card there for a while, our family was always able to see our family doctor the same day we called. And the one or two times a specialist or emergency room was needed, there was minimal hassle. I'm sure there are problems with it, too -- I just don't know what they are. As a customer/patient, it seemed to work far better than the American system I'm used to.
- cameronh90 2y agoMost of Europe has a similar model to what you've described: some form of mandatory state-backed insurance combined with a mix of private and public healthcare providers. In many countries, however, the biggest hospitals in Europe are owned by the government. Unfortunately the healthcare systems are in the process of collapsing across the UK and the majority of the continent too. My pet theory is I don't think it's actually anything to do with the overall funding model. I think it's to do with our inability to adapt to an increasingly elderly population. People's kids here are scattered around the country, often many hours of travel away, living in small apartments, and can't easily look after their elderly relatives in a way that's much more common in East Asia. As a consequence, we are offload that responsibility onto the healthcare system, which treats them as patients with medical issues, when often they are just old people with broadly normal age-related disease. Our systems were never designed to be capable of handling millions of elderly people, and it's not an efficient way of providing the required care, so it's falling apart.
- aliasxneo 2y agoThis is an interesting theory. I just came back from Thailand where I needed to make an ER visit for a grand total of $89 USD, including the price of three prescriptions. I was touring with one of the natives who made a comment around the lines of, "We don't abandon our elderly parents here like you Westerners do." This was in a conversation around their multi-generation households. It's not necessarily a correlation, but your comment reminded me of the conversation.
- FredPret 2y agoA lot of the problems in medical care have nothing to do with the system (Canada vs US) and everything to do with doctor supply. It’s simply not a great career choice anymore. You start work very late in life, and make only OK money. Some specialists make a lot but they start even later. Some GPs make a lot but they run patient mills. For most GPs, it’s an extreme slog without extreme reward. The same career issue goes triple for nurses. Young nurses are quitting in droves.
- preommr 2y agoIt's a broken system. Years of training, very selective, highly expensive... only for a lot of it to be telling people common sense things like eat less and excercise more.
- mrguyorama 2y agoNever mind that half your patients will swear to your face that your entire decade of training was part of a global conspiracy by Bill Gates to put microchips in your arm or other bullshit. And half of your nurses will agree with them!
- Pxtl 2y agoI know it would be political suicide, but I do believe that we could still have a very good medical system if the level of education we demand of doctors was reserved for surgeons and leadership and the front-line work of GP-style treatment was 100% left to people who were qualified by a normal nurse-style process of undergrad + apprenticeship + test.
- triceratops 2y agoThat's kind of how it works outside of North America. Students go into medical school right out of high school, and medical school is about 6 years - maybe including residency. They graduate with a degree that allows them to practice general and family medicine. If they want to become specialists, they keep studying and more residency. North America seems to be alone in requiring a 4 year degree before letting a student anywhere near a medical school.
- rs999gti 2y agoWhy are you using PCPs? The urgent care route seems more efficient, scales, and takes advantage of electronic medical records. I personally have not had a PCP singular doctor or doctor group in years. I use an urgent care franchise as my PCP. I have a chronic ailment that requires daily medicine and the medical staff at the urgent care has been more than capable of providing care, writing scripts, and providing referrals to specialists.
- CuriouslyC 2y agoUrgent care is often a 1-4 hour wait and insurance tends to have a higher copay. If you have a patient profile at a large health care provider's facility, you can often get appointments same or next day if you're willing to be flexible about the specific provider that sees you, with the normal (~15 minute) wait and lower copay.
- squidgedcricket 2y ago> Why are you using PCPs? For primary care. I believe that's where the name Primary Care Provider comes from. The difference from urgent care is long term. Having the same PCP for long periods of time provides an opportunity for deep insight and developing a personal relationship.
- marssaxman 2y agoThe idea of an ongoing relationship with a single doctor has always felt to me like a relic of that mythic past when people would spend 40 years working for a single employer before retiring with a pension. In my life, as a generally healthy person working in the software industry, I have switched health insurance plans almost as many times as I've needed medical attention. What's the point of going through the trouble to establish a relationship with a PCP when you will see them at most twice, likely only once, before you have to start over after taking your next job? Urgent care is much easier.
- lurking_swe 2y agoit sounds like you've never been around old people or an aging parent. When they get old, and start having serious health issues, it’s very important to have a PCP who can play “coach”. They coordinate care with various specialists, and old people typically see many specialists. You expect an 80 year old to go to urgent care and spent 30 minutes chatting with a random urgent care doctor to get them up to speed on their medical history? lol. Due to aging population, this PCP shortage is a big problem. Urgent care is fine for a younger person with a simple medical history, or for simple issues.
- Aaronstotle 2y agoI want an AI doctor so at least there is some information I can get between the months delay it takes to get an appointment.
- jmbwell 2y agoI’ve heard what the article describes about specializing being the way to go. In the US, insurance is also a huge pain in the ass; doctors have to fight to get paid as often as we have to fight to have things covered. There’s also the overhead of insurance for their practice, the costs of running a clinic or being part of a clinic group, maintaining compliance with everything, paying Epic’s extortionate fees, etc. The last two doctors I’ve had have gone to “concierge” services to help mitigate this. They stabilize their income with annual membership fees that sidestep the insurance company horseshit. They constrain their roster a bit. They can see people more quickly. But you have to be a member. It’s sad for me, but I get it from their perspective. “Retail” healthcare in the US is by all accounts a nightmare.
- the_real_cher 2y agoAn interesting thing I'm seeing happening in primary care is that doctors are being replaced by doctor adjacent professions like Nurse Practitioner, Physician Assistant, etc. A doctor spends a decade working 60 to 80 hour weeks studying medicine whereas an NP is a Master degree, I think which can be obtained online. There doesn't appear to be clear results yet in studies on the outcomes of NP's vs MD's (see reference). Another argument is that maybe all that medical school training is overkill in Primary Care and this is perfect setting for NP's or PA's. And also maybe most doctors are not ambitious and forget most of the training they're not using on a daily basis anyway. I think it would be pretty funny if after more studies NP's showed no different outcomes than MD's. Interesting write up on NP outcomes. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18766097/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18766097/
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tomjen3 2y ago>If family doctors’ compensation is going to be the lowest of all physicians’, they at least want to rein in their hours and responsibilities. And they want to be able to take a vacation. The article is relevant, but it is a case of "you get what you pay for".
- Empact 2y agoAnyone looking for a solution to physician quality or availability can find it through direct primary care / concierge care. Personally I pay $60/month to have unlimited access to my physician in Austin. The physician, in turn, rather than having 40% overhead, has no overhead from billing or insurance. They have simple monthly cashflow that they can allocate to cover rent and wages for their practice. This means that the physician can choose how many patients they have relative to their expenses, and decide how much time they have available on average for each patient. The result is great for the patient, great for the provider, and the sort of thing that will help increase availability of doctors, and their satisfaction with their work. You can find more on this from https://www.dpcare.org https://www.dpcare.org. Here's a map of direct primary care practices: https://mapper.dpcfrontier.com https://mapper.dpcfrontier.com.
- fwip 2y agoWhy is this submission flagged?
- _heimdall 2y agoI was wondering the same
- monkburger 2y agoI am a PCP who runs utilization reviews for our provider group. I review every ED utilization for every patient attributed to a PCP in our network. My job is to try to reduce inappropriate ED utilization. I have no idea what reduces utilization. There's major shortage of primary care doctors. Most med students don’t want to go into primary care. Plus, hiring new doctors is not as easy as it sounds… even if there were an excess of doctors looking for jobs, you have to have clinic space and staff in order to run a practice. Specialists are in the same boat, post-COVID. Having to ref some pts to neurology with a 6+ month wait.
- dematz 2y agoOn replacing doctors with RNs or NPs I think the comment I replied to was removed with mine, so I'll put it here instead. The point is elevating midlevels really is worse care, whereas cutting out years of schooling for doctors would be fine. Again the fact that there's a conflict of interest doesn't falsify these examples - https://old.reddit.com/r/Residency/comments/1geiamv/icu_np_thinks_she_can_read_cxr_better_than/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Residency/comments/1geiamv/icu_np_t... Previous comment: If you said "Where applicable, level up folks with the desire and aptitude from IT support->senior engineer. This specific pain point is a talent pipeline health and structure challenge. SWE feelings around this are going to be something to consider, to note when preparing for the opposition" people would go wait, maybe the occasional fresh bootcamp grad or ITsupport technician has the potential to do strong work or manage a team, but in general their education has not prepared them. Of course if you ask a doctor "could the RN or NP run this floor" there's a conflict of interest when they tell you "no", but they're also correct. Having a nurse is probably better than no medical care at all, so a tiered system where poor people get nurses without realizing they're worse than doctors would have that advantage, but the right overhaul imo would be reducing the years of schooling required to become a real doctor (undergrad, med school, residency, maybe fellowship, finally attending). If doctors skipped undergrad and cut out some med school or fellowship requirements, they'd start working earlier and could afford to choose specialties that pay less. As well as expanding residency slots and moving insurance compensation to family medicine and pediatrics. edit - here's a good example, https://old.reddit.com/r/medicine/comments/1f6m5i9/its_scary https://old.reddit.com/r/medicine/comments/1f6m5i9/its_scary... the good news is they'd agree with you that midlevels do have a role, the problem with scope creep is defining what that role is, and the assumption that the training is 80% or even 50% there
- washadjeffmad 2y agoSatirist Chris Morris on the state of general practice in the UK: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vECEz1E0HWg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vECEz1E0HWg