3 ms·
I like this as a possible honey trap. Any company/industry that signs up to fight this is pretty much a self own admission they behave this way. Not one person
by dylan604 2y ago
I like this as a possible honey trap. Any company/industry that signs up to fight this is pretty much a self own admission they behave this way.
Not one person fighting this is a surprise
- echoangle 2y agoWhat is there to expose? Basically every company would probably like that, if a company doesn’t sign up, it’s not because they are too moral but because they think the public perception of them will take a hit.
- dylan604 2y agoWho knows what evidence will finally get someone to get off the fence, so the more evidence of whatever type and especially own goals like this are welcome
- marcosdumay 2y agoIf a company doesn't do that, or does but wants to stop, it will be in favor of the regulation and against that suit. That is for whatever reason they have for not wanting to do it. Except, maybe for not doing it for publicity reasons and exploiting that fact with a large campaign.
- xp84 2y ago> Basically every company would probably like that No, only the ones who suck. I don't mean this in a jokey way. If I'm UpstartISP, Inc. and I believe that my product is actually better than Comcast offers, I want people to be able to cancel services without being jerked around, waiting on hold, and hassled, so that they can sign up with me. It's only companies that know they suck, and that their whole business is full of scams and deception, that want this. Yes, that's entire major industries, such as the "home security" lobbying group and cablecos mentioned in the article. As well as gym memberships.
- ryandrake 2y ago> No, only the ones who suck. I don't mean this in a jokey way. If I'm UpstartISP, Inc. and I believe that my product is actually better than Comcast offers, I want people to be able to cancel services without being jerked around, waiting on hold, and hassled, so that they can sign up with me. Sooner or later, some SeniorLeader inside UpstartISP, whose bonus is driven by profit or loss, will do the math and note that making it harder to cancel will cause quarterly profits to increase by 0.N%, and then the company will surely make the change. The tendency for all companies to profit-maximize guarantees it.
- xp84 2y agoI think I basically agree with you on that part. I'd propose an axiom: "All companies tend over time toward increasing levels of cynical rent-seeking behavior in place of innovation or competition." Which is why they should be restricted from engaging in any easily-definable instances of that behavior (ideally by actual legislation instead of this silly executive branch stuff). Banning the mature, craven companies from building moats of anticompetitive, anti-consumer behavior is a way to help the next generation of new entrants to either kill them or to force them to compete, either of which is a win for consumers and better startups trying to dethrone them.
- JoshTriplett 2y ago> Sooner or later, some SeniorLeader inside UpstartISP, whose bonus is driven by profit or loss, will do the math and note that making it harder to cancel will cause quarterly profits to increase by 0.N%, Companies need people empowered to say "that will probably increase short-term profits, and damage our reputation in the long term, so no, we're not doing it; we're in this for the long haul".
- sitkack 2y agoI am more likely to sign up for something I can cancel. Also, if I can trial it and it doesn't work, I can leave. If it sucks and I can't leave I am going to be horribly pissed. A really good example is https://www.verizon.com/plans/free-trial/ https://www.verizon.com/plans/free-trial/ I was testing between verizon and mint for my physical location. For whatever reason, VZ was underperforming, so when the trial expired, I left a happy temporary customer. I have since recommended it to others, knowing that they aren't going to get locked in. Being able to cancel actually make more happy customers, not less. It is only the enshitified mba run companies that trap customers that exhibit the parasitic practice of trapping customers into long contracts, confusing bills and impossible to cancel w/o burning your payment account number. I actually would sign up for the local gym that just went under in my neighborhood, but I knew I would never be able to cancel, so I skipped it.
- Terr_ 2y agoI fear you overestimate the degree to which the market actually punishes companies that do Bad Things.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoConsidering most homes only have access to 1 wired broadband ISP, I don’t see how the market could punish them.