12 ms·
'Visual clutter' alters information flow in the brain
- Seattle3503 2y agoSending this to my partner next time I ask them to clean up.
- lupire 2y agoThis is a minor technical detail of a well known obvious fact. Research, but news.
- botanical76 2y agoI wonder if this is relevant to tech workers. Does a second monitor - if not used as a productivity boost, but rather a neutral convenience - hinder your capability to focus on tasks? Should we turn it off to properly focus? I have suspected this might be the case for a while, but I'm not aware that it is obvious.
- lioeters 2y agoI don't know about other people, but I seem to be able to focus more with visual and auditory noise. Something to do with "stochastic resonance"? A quick search yields: > Beneficial effects of noise on higher cognition have recently attracted attention. Hypothesizing an involvement of the mesolimbic dopamine system and its functional interactions with cortical areas, the current study aimed to demonstrate a facilitation of dopamine-dependent attentional and mnemonic functions by externally applying white noise in five behavioral experiments. > ..These results suggest that white noise has no general effect on cognitive functions. Differential effects of white noise in cognitive and perceptual tasks https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4630540/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4630540/ > Perceptual decision-making relies on the gradual accumulation of noisy sensory evidence. It is often assumed that such decisions are degraded by adding noise to a stimulus, or to the neural systems involved in the decision making process itself. But it has been suggested that adding an optimal amount of noise can, under appropriate conditions, enhance the quality of subthreshold signals in nonlinear systems, a phenomenon known as stochastic resonance. Stochastic resonance enhances the rate of evidence accumulation during combined brain stimulation and perceptual decision-making https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6066257/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6066257/
- ehnto 2y agoI went from two screens back to one with a tiling window manager. What I was finding, was each tab/window/screen swap was a chance to lose focus. In practice I do lose focus a lot if I'm switching between screens. I don't have the same issue with tiles, and I can also setup workspaces to act a bit like focus rooms. I do a lot of little things to retain focus, another one is removing the mouse from my workflow as much as possible as it feels kind of like taking your hands off the wheel to fiddle with the car stereo. You switch mode, and that can disrupt focus.
- hinkley 2y agoI have a friend with 4 monitors. I've set at his desk and the feeling is very similar to a tanning bed. I don't know that he actually needs those monitors, he seems to end up watching e-sports during his work day, though it hasn't affected his career as far as I know. But then he's well above average so even coasting he's doing more than most. I really have trouble justifying more than two, unless I'm working on a project with DevOps responsibilities. There are several windows you need and 'losing' one is more problematic for some people than others. You need to write code. You need to test the code you just wrote. You need source material for writing new code (docs, bug dbs, stack overflow), and you need windows for any background tasks you're responsible for. Since source material and testing tend not to overlap, one monitor for both usually works out pretty well. A third monitor, oriented it portrait mode, can usually accommodate enough windows to monitor logs or grafana dashboards. Giving over a spare monitor to it improves the gestalt and increases the odds that you will look at it on an interval that your boss approves of. With a wider (taller when rotated) monitor you can fit 2 dashboards with a little room left over to see the rate of new logs - when things are scrolling too fast or too slow that can indicate a problem with the system before it shows on the graphs. With a big enough primary monitor, I could do with just 2 (and would have to - my 2nd monitor already hangs off the end of my desk). But at 32" I don't feel I have the space to lose it. Also the 2nd monitor has my only video camera.
- ehnto 2y agoOh I totally should have mentioned, I went from two 24"@ 1080p each to a single 34" at QHD as they call it. So a significant real-estate increase was required to manage one monitor. I don't use it like two monitors in one. Usually my code editor is two thirds of the screen wide, application I am testing is one third,then terminal windows are across the whole bottom of the screen at about a quarter of the bottom of the screen. So you are right you do tend to need those things in easy view, and I have achieved that but slightly differently to a multi-monitor setup.
- mega_dean 2y agoI've noticed that I get very distracted by motion in my peripheral vision, but not by static images. So I can use a second monitor for things like documentation, but not something like Slack that shows new messages, animated gifs/emojis, etc. I've also configured my text editor to be very "static": when I type, the only things that can happen are the cursor moves, or text is inserted. I have to manually trigger things like the autocompletion popup, LSP checks, or highlighting the symbol under the cursor.
- botanical76 2y agoThis reminds me of some of the early linting tools that emerged around the time ES5 / node.js was blowing up. I found the defaults to be insanely distracting, giving me warnings about unused variables etc as I was still typing the code (of course it's unused, I just defined it!) GitHub Copilot is similar, defaulting to provide suggestions to finish your LOC whenever you stop typing. While the AI tools can be very useful, the benefit is lost if I can't focus on what I'm writing.
- alpaca128 2y agoThat's one of the reasons I use Vim. It does absolutely nothing without an input and has nothing unnecessary on the screen. Unfortunately pretty much all modern editors and IDEs aim for the exact opposite, the last time I tried VS Code it even had a button floating above the code for some git related stuff. So far I haven't seen a piece of software that tries to do everything under the sun while also being enjoyable to use.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- OgsyedIE 2y agoI figure the OP link and adversarial images (in ML) are special cases of a more general class of tomography problems.
- 65 2y agoIt's also interesting how your brain processes information in the corner of your eye. It seems to only process the most basic information - not even color. If I take a red Coke can and place it in the corner of my eye, I can't even tell what color it is. I can tell there's an object there but the color does not come through until I place it slightly more in my direct line on sight.
- CoastalCoder 2y agoI was about to post a link about the fact that our retinas themselves can't sense colors in our peripheral vision. But apparently that's been debunked! https://www.aop.org.uk/ot/science-and-vision/research/2015/11/11/research-debunks-misconceptions-around-peripheral-colour-vision https://www.aop.org.uk/ot/science-and-vision/research/2015/1...
- jangxx 2y agoBack in high school a teacher told us this "fact" as well and I remember being very surprised because it did not match my experience at all. Many times have I tested this theory since, e.g. when waiting at a pedestrian traffic light, looking off to the side so that the light is on the very edge of my peripheral vision, seeing if I can perceive it turn green and always being able to. Of course this is not proof that there are no people who can't do this, but I definitely know that I can see color at the edge of my peripheral vision and I've come to assume that this just varies from person to person.
- 65 2y agoMaybe it's my red/green color blindness that's playing a role.
- m3kw9 2y agoThat opposite of what Einstein said
- hbarka 2y agoIsn’t this really just signal-to-noise ratio? The information flow can be any input, be it visual, auditory, tactile, etc. “Clutter” is not a neutral word and leads the reader.
- ben_w 2y ago"Visual clutter" is an existing term that's been in use for a while now: https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=%22visual+clutter%22&year_start=1800&year_end=2022&corpus=en&smoothing=3 https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=%22visual+clut...
- cushpush 2y agoAren't you suggesting that we use the ear term for the eye term instead of the eye term for the ear term? ;)
- Nevermark 2y agoSignal-to-noise is often used as a modality independent term. Someone might reference signal-to-noise issues with modern news sources, body language, or a data set of any particular origin.
- rootusrootus 2y agoThat seems intuitive. E.g. It is pretty common for people to turn down the radio in their car when they are looking carefully for an address.
- gwern 2y agoFulltext: https://gwern.net/doc/psychology/vision/2024-xu.pdf https://gwern.net/doc/psychology/vision/2024-xu.pdf
- wodenokoto 2y agoI've noticed that you sometimes host scientific articles discussed on HN, but I don't see you on the author list. Are you mirroring a prepublishing archive, or did you ask authors for special permission or are you just ... sharing it?
- Rugu16 2y agoGood article! “Therefore, the detailed visual information you’re getting is from the car in front of you, but the information of interest is outside of your focus.” This must be one of the reasons you get fatigue and exhaustion during traffic rush hour due to so much visual information.
- cushpush 2y agoI noticed intense fatigue wandering Tokyo with my friend who wore magnifying lenses and he could not understand why I was tired. I said it's all the visual stimulation, the signs, the lights, the billboards. I think he was at an advantage with the eyewear, in retrospect.
- nox101 2y agoisn't this the counter example? japanese ads, magazines, documents, websites, are often super visually cluttered. seems counter to the paper to me if this clutter has negatie affects why has japanese design settled on it?
- Rugu16 2y agoIts same for TimeSquare still people pay big dollars. Both things can be right, it has negative effect however it is still engaging and effective. It gets the eyeballs
- famahar 2y agoThis may just be one small point, but I recall reading that visual clutter signifies a good bargain while lots of white space gives the impression of luxary. Most consumers want a good deal.
- igornadj 2y agoI found the opposite personally. Something about the neatness and tidiness let my mind relax and see everything similar to a calm flowing stream. Tokyo is one of the most peaceful cities I've been to, even in the busy areas, and by far the biggest and most populated.
- cushpush 2y agoTangential: staring at a computer screen while having a phone call is distracting. Recommend looking at not-a-screen while talking on-the-phone :)
- cj 2y agoI have a (IMO bad) habit of looking away from my computer screen (at visual nothingness) when having concentrated discussions over video calls. For whatever reason it’s just easier to talk when staring out the window at a tree than staring at a face on a screen. I call it a bad habit because it results in accidentally ignoring body language of the person on the other end 100% with phone calls. I typically just slowly pace around around my house when on a phone call without video.
- 6510 2y agoStrange, for me it is obvious how it works. It goes for locations and activities too but mostly if I look at something it locks and unlocks memories but the thing I'm looking at also becomes part of the active memory. You have a bunch of stuff hashed against the tree or against a dead gaze or you don't want the person to be part of the thought process. I forgot the code for the warehouse at a previous job. Typing the wrong one locks the place down. I somewhat panicked but went there anyway, got distracted by something and typed the code without even thinking about it. I also remembered it after walking inside. Took some coffee and it was gone again. I thought, I've been typing that code for years but had never realized I only remember it when looking at the door.
- cj 2y agoAs I reflect and re-read my comment, I think for me it’s simply I’m overloaded. Looking at a face while talking vs. a tree just increases the mental energy necessary for the call. When you’re chronically exhausted, you start cutting out the little things that seemingly don’t matter (like someone’s body language or facial expression during a call) Definitely a tangent here. Love the warehouse example though. Similarly, I can’t for the life of me recite my iphone, Apple Watch, or home security alarm PIN codes. It’s just pure muscle memory at this point. When I try to recall the PIN codes in my head, my mind immediately tries to recall the numbers by visualizing my phone (or alarm keypad) and attempting to remember the movement of my fingers in order to deduce what the numbers are.
- sorokod 2y agoSome figma boards end up looking like someone vomited a pile of confetti. A prime example of visual clutter for me.
- syngrog66 2y agoI've learned its best to have everyone's camera off in a VOIP call. For many reasons, one cuz if I see faces on screen live it distracts my brain internals enough it impairs my effective IQ in the moment, and adds a kind of biological lag. I don't need any fancy academic studies to "prove" it, because I've lived through directly hundreds of A-vs-B cases over many years. You lose some things without live faces/cameras, but also gain a lot. Blog post of mine on it: https://synystron.substack.com/p/video-calls-good-and-bad https://synystron.substack.com/p/video-calls-good-and-bad
- pxc 2y ago> we can’t read out of the corner of our eyes, no matter how hard we try This is not quite true. Reading via peripheral vision is a skill, but most people never have the right kind of motivation (and perhaps not the right kind of visual stimulus) to learn it. I know this because I have personally known someone who read exclusively via her peripheral vision. There's an inherited retinal disease that runs in my family. It's a form of 'cone-rod dystrophy'. Cone-rod dystrophies are diseases where the cones and the rods in the eye eventually stop responding to light. The order of the terms in the naming reflects the typical order of the dystrophy: first the cones (responsible for central vision) go, then the rods (responsible for peripheral vision) go, too. As the cones and rods go bad, this results in loss of visual acuity in central and peripheral vision respectively. (It often causes lots of other, less generic problems, too, such as: blind spots, warping/twisting distortions in the visual field, sometimes flickering artifacts, progressive colorblindness, extreme light sensitivity, and an effective reduction of contrast.) Between individual cases, there's a lot of variation in how the disease presents. There's no fixed timeline or ordering for the progression (even though the disease's genetic cause has been identified as just a single gene!). Anyhow, in my late aunt's case, her central vision was useless long before her peripheral vision could give out. So she learned, somehow, to do things like read her smartphone using only her peripheral vision. We chatted about it once or twice. Onlookers often could not comprehend that she was looking at her phone, since her eyes weren't pointed towards it. She once laughed to me about how someone had asked her 'Why are you sniffing your phone?', while she held it up to her face to read a text message. My impression is that learning to rely on your peripheral vision in this way is extremely counter-intuitive and difficult to do. (This may have something to do with the mechanisms discussed in TFA.) I wonder if it can even be done at all without first obscuring one's central vision (which I guess you could do artificially with contacts). But evidently it can be done.
- GuB-42 2y agoIt makes me think of a common trick in stargazing that is to look at stars with peripheral vision. Fixating them will make them disappear. That's because the fovea, the "high resolution" part of the eye we use when focusing on some point is entirely made of cone cells, which give you color vision, but are less sensitive, as opposed to rod cells, that make up most of the peripheral vision. In other words, peripheral vision is better in low light situations.
- thugwa11 2y ago[flagged]
- mrkeen 2y agoInteresting! I dragged this icon onto my desktop to read later. Oh no!
- GuB-42 2y agoWhat counts as a "visual stimulus" is unclear to me. Does it mean a static object, as opposed to a blank surface or something that moves, and if it is something that moves, does it move predictably (ex: a rotating fan) or not (ex: a notification). It is kind of obvious that stimuli like notifications are disruptive, but less so in the other cases.
- furyofantares 2y agoI always looked at my feet while walking as a kid. People sometimes thought I was depressed, but I was just always thinking, and reducing visual noise in service of that.
- igornadj 2y agoI wonder if it's the same as looking up and to the left when thinking?
- hinkley 2y agoWhen I started walking for exercise I pulled in a lot of the scenery. As I started trying to walk faster, and over the same old ground, my vision pulled in as I was concentrating on proprioception. On a leisurely jaunt you don't really have to think about what your legs are doing. When you're hauling ass it begins to matter if your left foot is landing a little different from your right, and how big that heave in the sidewalk is ten feet in front of you.
- mattgreenrocks 2y agoBeen yelled at one too many times for being bad at finding things when trying to find something amidst clutter. I try my best, and it’s like…I just can’t see it without a lot of effort and more time than you’d think.
- krunck 2y agoTake Amazon's web site for instance....
- suyash 2y agoNo wonder why Steve Jobs was so obsessed about focus, he loved not only a clean interface but also wore same type of clothes and lives a minimal lifestyle.
- jakupovic 2y agoNot sure if this counts, but whenever I'm starting a new project or need to figure out something involved I always start by cleaning up the shop and all surfaces. I was wondering why I did that?
- brikym 2y agoThis article is a good excuse to get rid of outdoor advertising for safety reasons. I was watching some tours of some very nice metro stations in China and Moscow. I didn't quite understand what was so nice about them until one comment pointed it out: no advertising blasting bright colors into your retinas. Advertising in public spaces needs to be banned. It's visual pollution and it's using publicly funded assets to make tangible profits while the losses are externalised easily because they're not well understood. If profit is all you care about then it's easy to justify turning your house into a brothel.
- leohonexus 2y agoI'd say the daily "visual clutter" of living in Chinese cities is on par or more than other cities, like Tokyo. In Shenzhen for example, it's not uncommon to see police wearing flashing sirens on their shoulders as part of their uniform. Motorcyclists share the same road as pedestrians, and with so many delivery app drivers you're always on the lookout to avoid being hit. On SZ and Beijing metro trains, video ads are projected inside tunnels, matching the speed of the carriage - example: https://youtu.be/sp7KDNKpVhY https://youtu.be/sp7KDNKpVhY Personally I've seen much more advertising on Chinese shopping apps like Taobao, compared to say Amazon. Cluttercore advertising seems to be a deeply rooted culture there.
- throwaway19972 2y ago> In Shenzhen for example, it's not uncommon to see police wearing flashing sirens on their shoulders as part of their uniform. Motorcyclists share the same road as pedestrians, and with so many delivery app drivers you're always on the lookout to avoid being hit. I don't think this is quite as distracting as semantic-laden graphics like ads. They quite literally pollute the mind as well as the view.
- hinkley 2y agoWhen I was in Tokyo in ‘97 they were already testing these subway displays. The ones I saw just showed fancy test patterns not ads, and were smaller.
- 2y ago
- aspenmayer 2y agoEven more compelling reasons to block ads online and in public.
- Daub 2y agoIs this research not stating the obvious? As a painter I would differentiate background from foreground by decreasing its saturation, lightness and hue local contrast, softening edges, decreasing neighboring regional contrast and Lessing its average color values in relation to the foreground. Painters have been doing this for hundreds of years.
- DidYaWipe 2y agoAnother indictment of "transparent" UI (as if we even needed one).
- arjun-dev 2y agoAny research on the effect of visual clutter in UI design/screens?
- renegade-otter 2y agoAnecdotally, I noticed that I am much happier and more focused after I clean and declutter my apartment. Clean, flat surfaces, nothing for your brain to process. Even if it's your own apartment or a house, your brain will constantly have a "thread" firing on all cylinders that tries to parse what you are seeing, non-stop. If it's things all around you, small details, objects - it will sap your mental energy and you won't even know why.
- markdeloura 2y agoI feel this as well, and increasingly as I get older. It drives me to simplify my office over and over, or at least add storage elements that can hide clutter. Our dystopian future visions for AR always include an extreme visual chaos of ads — maybe the killer app future for AR is actually to remove extraneous visual noise, much like noise-cancelling headphones.
- KarlKode 2y agoMy girlfriend (who has quite severe ADHD) is exactly like you. Before she can get any work done in our office everything needs to be put away/organized/in it's place or she'll get detracted all the time.
- harimau777 2y agoThis is why I hate the idea that discussions over coding style are "bike shedding". At least for me they have a very real impact on my productivity and likelihood if introducing bugs.
- evanjrowley 2y agoI've always felt like I have more mental clarity whenever I'm out in the fog, the heavier the better - maybe this is why.