5 ms·

C-Motive's electrostatic motors use printed circuit boards instead of magnets

123 points by Jeff_Brown 2y ago

karlkloss 2y ago
A lot of blabla, no technical data. Suspicious.
- syllablehq 2y ago
  I see quite a lot of technical data. Check their whole site including the documents page and youtube videos. (Also, I know them, they're very legit.) https://www.c-motive.com/about/documents/ https://www.c-motive.com/about/documents/
milesvp 2y ago
I’ve been doing pcb design around sensor coils for capacitive sensing. My engineering team has been playing with similar ideas around printing coils for other electro magnetic purposes. Motors are an obvious usecase. Good to see others doing similar stuff with printed circuit boards. It takes a way a lot of complexity and pcb processes have some pretty good precision these days.
- snek_case 2y ago
  I'm fairly ignorant about motor design, but my immediate thought was "isn't this going to exert pulling forces on the PCB traces?". Seems like that would limit how much torque your motor can exert? Which I guess isn't necessarily a problem for many applications.
  - skykooler 2y ago
    The forces are pretty much shear forces in the plane of the PCB, which traces can handle reasonably well. Also, the amount of force per trace is very small - the motor only has significant torque because there are many traces per PCB multiplied by many PCBs.
- magicalhippo 2y ago
  I recall watching Carl Brugeja on YouTube some years ago making tiny motors using PCB for the coils, like this[1] for example. Like you say idea is hardly groundbreaking, but there's a lot of details to optimize as with any non-trivial engineering project. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oa6sP-joAr8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oa6sP-joAr8
amelius 2y ago
Not a big fan of the dielectric fluid these motors have to be filled with.
- giantg2 2y ago
  Why?
  - tonyarkles 2y ago
    Not the person you asked but there’s a few reasons off the top of my head: - weight - leaks: liquids are always a hassle in things that move. The liquid wants to escape and will do so at the first opportunity. - serviceability: if there is a leak and a significant loss of fluid, this doesn’t sound like something I can just go pick up at the hardware store like motor oil or hydraulic oil. I’m curious what it is… they simultaneously call it a commodity fluid but also proprietary.
    - giantg2 2y ago
      "- weight" They don't post any specs, but it's supposed to be smaller than traditional motors. If it only needs a small amount to fill small gaps between disks, it might still be lighter than traditional motors. This is especially true if the PCBs are significantly lighter than windings and magnets. "- leaks: liquids are always a hassle in things that move. The liquid wants to escape and will do so at the first opportunity." Sure, but this seems like a small concern when we consider that any mobile electric motors require batteries and most of those contain sealed liquid. Even things like bearings in cars are sealed these days. "- serviceability: if there is a leak and a significant loss of fluid, this doesn’t sound like something I can just go pick up at the hardware store like motor oil or hydraulic oil. I’m curious what it is… they simultaneously call it a commodity fluid but also proprietary." Sure, if you have an oil leak in your ICE car today, you can't just go get oil, you first have to fix the leak. Don't forget that many transmissions for cars today get filled with "lifetime" fluid and are sealed. This, like the other concerns, is not likely to occur frequently and is consistent with existing paradigms. I'd be more concerned with what it is rather than it simply being there. Like is it flammable, acidic, caustic, or hazardous in some other way?
lbourdages 2y ago
Fishman has been doing these with guitar pickups for several years now. It's supposed to allow for greater consistency and also make it possible to do some stuff that couldn't be done with an actual coil of wire.
- Animats 2y ago
  Electrostatic microphones have been a thing for a long time, so that's not unexpected. But it's not a power application.
- moffkalast 2y ago
  What kind of stuff? Isn't just everything possible with FOC on BLDC motors?
  - WorkerBee28474 2y ago
    I think they use it to change the number of coils that are active in the pickup. I think this is outside of/as well as supporting existing features like coil tapping humbuckers.
    - metalman 2y ago
      Tone, is in the hands
    - ben7799 2y ago
      The Fishman pickups are stacked PCBs where each PCB has it's own coil/loop. They are then connected in a way where the polarity reverses from coil to coil so they get hum cancelling even if there is only one "virtual coil". They've got something else going on inside the circuitry that lets them manipulate the characteristics of the resulting coil as well to get all the different sounds different traditional pickups get. I don't have a guitar with the Fishman pickups but have tried them and saw a demo from the Fishman team and talked with the product manager, etc.. I live pretty close to their HQ and they came to a school where I was taking lessons years ago. Very cool stuff, but the thing is there are other much simpler solutions that don't require a battery or computer in the guitar once people can get out of the mindset of "it must be exactly as Gibson or Fender did it in the 50s." Even Leo Fender had come up with a lot of stuff that was a lot better by the time he died that Fender to this day doesn't use but does get used in say G&L guitars. The whole nonsense of guitarists thinking "it must be just like Fender and Gibson did it in the 50s" limits the market for both the stuff Leo Fender came up with later and stuff like Fishman's novel pickups.
raphman 2y ago
Nice. I like the short paragraph on "Why hasn’t anyone done this before?" at the bottom of the page. tl;dr: concept very old; C-Motive combined incremental improvements
giantg2 2y ago
I wish they had some examples of what RPM, torque, weight, and size specs were for a few possible applications. They seem to emphasize low RPM, but is that 200 RPM or 2000RPM? With other electric motors being capable of 10k-20k RPM, the "low" RPM mention is very vague. If it's capable of up to about 3000 RPM, and it doesn't weigh too much it could be interesting as an ultralight aircraft power plant.
- marcosdumay 2y ago
  It's an electrostatic motor, so expect peak performance at close to 0 RPM. It probably won't work well at 1k RPM, but whether "too high frequency" for it is closer to 10 RPM or 100 RPM isn't clear. There's a video with some waves in unlabeled axis. I didn't watch it. Anyway, it's almost certainly not aimed at aircraft propulsion or power generation. You may want something like it for robotics, but last time a paper from them circulated around here, they seemed to be focusing on instrument actuators and chip fabrication.
  - mppm 2y ago
    Their applications pages mentions wind turbines and automotive applications and promises increased efficiency vs conventional motors. That would require maintaining 90%+ efficiency at well over 1k RPM. But no specs anywhere, so hard to tell whether this is real.
    - giantg2 2y ago
      I don't think it was really for automotive applications. It said something like "low speed vehicles". Made me think of something like golf carts or maybe ATVs. Of course without a gearbox, the biggest factor would be what wheel diameters are used since that would be the main ratio with revs per mile.
    - marcosdumay 2y ago
      TBH, I didn't think about low rotational speed wind turbines. Yeah, it may be a big thing for those. "Electric drivetrains" can mean anything from an excavator moving at 5km/h with 3m large wheels in a frequency of less then 0.2Hz up to extreme race RC vehicles, at 100km/h with 5cm wheels at ~100Hz. A car wheels go barely over 1k RPM, but I don't really expect them to do anything useful for those.
Animats 2y ago
The C-Motive guys have PR all over the web. Electrolytic capacitors can have far more capacitance than air capacitors. That's the basic concept here. Here's their patent.[1] Just scroll through the drawings and you'll see how it works. Here's the key concept: "Numerous aspects of the present disclosure cooperate to increase the breakdown field strength 8406, and / or adjust (e.g. , flatten) the field strength trajectory such as : the permittivity of the dielectric fluid; a selection of fluid constituents to maintain a permittivity profile related to operating temperatures; protection of the dielectric fluid from impurities, presence of water, and / or presence of gases ; providing a surface smoothness of the electrodes 8402, 8404 (or portions thereof), related surfaces, and/ or a housing inner surface ; rinsing / removal of particles and / or impurities (e.g., from manufacturing residue, etc.); provision of a surface treatment on at least a portion of an electrode, and / or on a surface adjacent to the electrode, including varying surface treatments for different electrodes; provision of a coating on at least a portion of an electrode and / or on a surface adjacent to the electrode, including varying the coating for different electrodes; provision of a surface treatment and / or coating on a component at least selectively contacting the dielectric fluid (e.g., a housing inner surface, a packed bed, a side chamber, flow path, and / or eddy region ); protection of composition integrity of the dielectric fluid (e.g., managing materials of bearings, seals , plates , etc. to avoid material breakdown and / or introduction of degradation constituents that negatively affect the performance of the dielectric fluid ); introduction of a field disrupting additive into the dielectric fluid ( e.g., a coated metal oxide, a nano-particle, and /or a conductive particle having a conductor that isolate the conductive particle from physical contact with the dielectric fluid ); introduction of an ion scavenging additive into the dielectric fluid ( e.g., BHT, antioxidants, etc. ); management of gap distance (e.g., using bearings, magnetic separation, a separation assembly, etc.); and / or selected field weakening at certain operating conditions. The utilization of various field management aspects of the present disclosure allows for an increased average field strength in the gap, while maintaining a peak field strength below a breakdown threshold 8406, thereby increasing capacitive energy storage and consequent performance of the ESM 1002." This thing is sort of like a high voltage electrolytic capacitor with moving parts. They go to a lot of trouble to deal with most of the problems that happen inside capacitors, plus the special problems from moving parts. They had to go all the way to a pumped fluid system with filters, to keep the dielectric fluid cool and clean. Many electric car motors have liquid cooling, so it's no worse than that. It does mean this is probably a technology for larger motors, because the motor requires some accessory systems. It's not clear that this is a win over magnetic motors, but it's reasonable engineering. [1] https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/cf/eb/f0/6d48f075d23da6/US20210281193A1.pdf https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/cf/eb/f0/6d48f07...
01100011 2y ago
I've long wondered if there's a possible application for something like this using 3d printing and electrets. Basically you can freeze an electric field inside of an insulator if you apply it as the material solidifies. I think you should be able to embed electrets inside of 3d prints simply by generating a strong electric field at the print head or slightly behind it. You can also vary the field and embed a 3d electret that can act as, say, a sensor or a hidden ID in the print.
- Geee 2y ago
  Sounds interesting! Maybe you should try to make this.
- calmbonsai 2y ago
  Huh? No you can't due to leakage inductance. Are you simply making a joke about permanent magnets?
  - 01100011 2y ago
    How does leakage inductance relate to electrets?
    - calmbonsai 2y ago
      In the exact same manner that leakage capacitance limits the field strength of permanent magnets--only more so by orders of magnitude. This is, fundamentally, why electrostatic motors have not seen "power" applications. It's far easier to manufacture a high-tolerance lattice in metals than non-metals. https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/1038668 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/1038668
mNovak 2y ago
Some more technical content (literature review, but includes the university work this spun out of) if the sales page isn't doing it for you: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=9194000 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=919...
trebligdivad 2y ago
Previous discussion 2 months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41309292 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41309292
scotty79 2y ago
I found somebody doing single phase electric motor on YouTube: https://youtu.be/s3yO7jYaD98?si=xecjNpuDaMA0IP1Q https://youtu.be/s3yO7jYaD98?si=xecjNpuDaMA0IP1Q
peter_d_sherman 2y ago
From the page: https://www.c-motive.com/applications/ https://www.c-motive.com/applications/ >"C-Motive has designed a sub-5 kW (7 hp) industrial motor platform designed for direct drive applications where high efficiency and high torque lead to substantial operational savings; a 1.5 kW (2 hp) C-Motive machine could save up to $1,400 a year in energy costs in a typical industrial application." [...] "A C-Motive electrostatic generator, however, can be connected directly to the hub of the wind turbine and driven directly without an efficiency-robbing gearbox. This can add 20% or more to the annual energy output of the wind turbine..." That seems like very promising future technology! Wishing the C-Motive team a lot of luck with their electrostatic generators and electrostatic motors!
- foofoo55 2y ago
  $1400 a year in electricity at a high rate of $0.15/kWhr for all 8,760 hours in a year is about 1 kW in power savings. Reality check: A typical 3-phase 2hp industrial motor [1] is over 85% efficient and typical 10:1 reduction gearbox [2] is 94% efficient, which results in about 3kW power usage and 20% power lost to heat, or approx 0.6 kW. If their motor is 100% efficient, used in a 100%-duty-cycle application, in an area with high electrical costs, and with similar reliability to the standard AC motor, this gives $800 or so in savings per year. In a more typical application with a 50% operating duty cycle and $0.10/kWhr, and guessing at 96% efficiency for their motor, we're down to maybe $200 per year in savings. Larger (>=5hp) motors can be 91% or higher efficiency bringing savings down even more. I can't imagine how C-Motive will equal the reliability, so any extra maintenance could quickly wipe out the savings. I would guess that a variable-frequency drive (VFD) on the above AC motor, used to control speed and improve the power factor, would have the same efficiency as their motor controller. So I only looked at the AC motor + gearbox versus the C-motive motor + fluid pump. [1] - https://www.baldor.com/catalog/CEM3558T-5#tab=%22performance%22 https://www.baldor.com/catalog/CEM3558T-5#tab=%22performance... [2] - https://www.bostongear.com/ecatalog?page=product&cid=worm_gear_speed_reducers_700_series&id=721A-10-G https://www.bostongear.com/ecatalog?page=product&cid=worm_ge...
jacknews 2y ago
This seems ideal for e-bikes?

123 points by Jeff_Brown 2y ago

karlkloss 2y ago

A lot of blabla, no technical data. Suspicious.

syllablehq 2y ago
I see quite a lot of technical data. Check their whole site including the documents page and youtube videos. (Also, I know them, they're very legit.) https://www.c-motive.com/about/documents/ https://www.c-motive.com/about/documents/

milesvp 2y ago

I’ve been doing pcb design around sensor coils for capacitive sensing. My engineering team has been playing with similar ideas around printing coils for other electro magnetic purposes. Motors are an obvious usecase. Good to see others doing similar stuff with printed circuit boards. It takes a way a lot of complexity and pcb processes have some pretty good precision these days.

snek_case 2y ago
I'm fairly ignorant about motor design, but my immediate thought was "isn't this going to exert pulling forces on the PCB traces?". Seems like that would limit how much torque your motor can exert? Which I guess isn't necessarily a problem for many applications.
- skykooler 2y ago
  The forces are pretty much shear forces in the plane of the PCB, which traces can handle reasonably well. Also, the amount of force per trace is very small - the motor only has significant torque because there are many traces per PCB multiplied by many PCBs.
magicalhippo 2y ago
I recall watching Carl Brugeja on YouTube some years ago making tiny motors using PCB for the coils, like this[1] for example. Like you say idea is hardly groundbreaking, but there's a lot of details to optimize as with any non-trivial engineering project. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oa6sP-joAr8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oa6sP-joAr8

amelius 2y ago

Not a big fan of the dielectric fluid these motors have to be filled with.

giantg2 2y ago
Why?
- tonyarkles 2y ago
  Not the person you asked but there’s a few reasons off the top of my head: - weight - leaks: liquids are always a hassle in things that move. The liquid wants to escape and will do so at the first opportunity. - serviceability: if there is a leak and a significant loss of fluid, this doesn’t sound like something I can just go pick up at the hardware store like motor oil or hydraulic oil. I’m curious what it is… they simultaneously call it a commodity fluid but also proprietary.
  - giantg2 2y ago
    "- weight" They don't post any specs, but it's supposed to be smaller than traditional motors. If it only needs a small amount to fill small gaps between disks, it might still be lighter than traditional motors. This is especially true if the PCBs are significantly lighter than windings and magnets. "- leaks: liquids are always a hassle in things that move. The liquid wants to escape and will do so at the first opportunity." Sure, but this seems like a small concern when we consider that any mobile electric motors require batteries and most of those contain sealed liquid. Even things like bearings in cars are sealed these days. "- serviceability: if there is a leak and a significant loss of fluid, this doesn’t sound like something I can just go pick up at the hardware store like motor oil or hydraulic oil. I’m curious what it is… they simultaneously call it a commodity fluid but also proprietary." Sure, if you have an oil leak in your ICE car today, you can't just go get oil, you first have to fix the leak. Don't forget that many transmissions for cars today get filled with "lifetime" fluid and are sealed. This, like the other concerns, is not likely to occur frequently and is consistent with existing paradigms. I'd be more concerned with what it is rather than it simply being there. Like is it flammable, acidic, caustic, or hazardous in some other way?

lbourdages 2y ago

Fishman has been doing these with guitar pickups for several years now. It's supposed to allow for greater consistency and also make it possible to do some stuff that couldn't be done with an actual coil of wire.

Animats 2y ago
Electrostatic microphones have been a thing for a long time, so that's not unexpected. But it's not a power application.
moffkalast 2y ago
What kind of stuff? Isn't just everything possible with FOC on BLDC motors?
- WorkerBee28474 2y ago
  I think they use it to change the number of coils that are active in the pickup. I think this is outside of/as well as supporting existing features like coil tapping humbuckers.
  - metalman 2y ago
    Tone, is in the hands
  - ben7799 2y ago
    The Fishman pickups are stacked PCBs where each PCB has it's own coil/loop. They are then connected in a way where the polarity reverses from coil to coil so they get hum cancelling even if there is only one "virtual coil". They've got something else going on inside the circuitry that lets them manipulate the characteristics of the resulting coil as well to get all the different sounds different traditional pickups get. I don't have a guitar with the Fishman pickups but have tried them and saw a demo from the Fishman team and talked with the product manager, etc.. I live pretty close to their HQ and they came to a school where I was taking lessons years ago. Very cool stuff, but the thing is there are other much simpler solutions that don't require a battery or computer in the guitar once people can get out of the mindset of "it must be exactly as Gibson or Fender did it in the 50s." Even Leo Fender had come up with a lot of stuff that was a lot better by the time he died that Fender to this day doesn't use but does get used in say G&L guitars. The whole nonsense of guitarists thinking "it must be just like Fender and Gibson did it in the 50s" limits the market for both the stuff Leo Fender came up with later and stuff like Fishman's novel pickups.

raphman 2y ago

Nice. I like the short paragraph on "Why hasn’t anyone done this before?" at the bottom of the page. tl;dr: concept very old; C-Motive combined incremental improvements

giantg2 2y ago

I wish they had some examples of what RPM, torque, weight, and size specs were for a few possible applications. They seem to emphasize low RPM, but is that 200 RPM or 2000RPM? With other electric motors being capable of 10k-20k RPM, the "low" RPM mention is very vague. If it's capable of up to about 3000 RPM, and it doesn't weigh too much it could be interesting as an ultralight aircraft power plant.

marcosdumay 2y ago
It's an electrostatic motor, so expect peak performance at close to 0 RPM. It probably won't work well at 1k RPM, but whether "too high frequency" for it is closer to 10 RPM or 100 RPM isn't clear. There's a video with some waves in unlabeled axis. I didn't watch it. Anyway, it's almost certainly not aimed at aircraft propulsion or power generation. You may want something like it for robotics, but last time a paper from them circulated around here, they seemed to be focusing on instrument actuators and chip fabrication.
- mppm 2y ago
  Their applications pages mentions wind turbines and automotive applications and promises increased efficiency vs conventional motors. That would require maintaining 90%+ efficiency at well over 1k RPM. But no specs anywhere, so hard to tell whether this is real.
  - giantg2 2y ago
    I don't think it was really for automotive applications. It said something like "low speed vehicles". Made me think of something like golf carts or maybe ATVs. Of course without a gearbox, the biggest factor would be what wheel diameters are used since that would be the main ratio with revs per mile.
  - marcosdumay 2y ago
    TBH, I didn't think about low rotational speed wind turbines. Yeah, it may be a big thing for those. "Electric drivetrains" can mean anything from an excavator moving at 5km/h with 3m large wheels in a frequency of less then 0.2Hz up to extreme race RC vehicles, at 100km/h with 5cm wheels at ~100Hz. A car wheels go barely over 1k RPM, but I don't really expect them to do anything useful for those.

Animats 2y ago

The C-Motive guys have PR all over the web. Electrolytic capacitors can have far more capacitance than air capacitors. That's the basic concept here. Here's their patent.[1] Just scroll through the drawings and you'll see how it works. Here's the key concept: "Numerous aspects of the present disclosure cooperate to increase the breakdown field strength 8406, and / or adjust (e.g. , flatten) the field strength trajectory such as : the permittivity of the dielectric fluid; a selection of fluid constituents to maintain a permittivity profile related to operating temperatures; protection of the dielectric fluid from impurities, presence of water, and / or presence of gases ; providing a surface smoothness of the electrodes 8402, 8404 (or portions thereof), related surfaces, and/ or a housing inner surface ; rinsing / removal of particles and / or impurities (e.g., from manufacturing residue, etc.); provision of a surface treatment on at least a portion of an electrode, and / or on a surface adjacent to the electrode, including varying surface treatments for different electrodes; provision of a coating on at least a portion of an electrode and / or on a surface adjacent to the electrode, including varying the coating for different electrodes; provision of a surface treatment and / or coating on a component at least selectively contacting the dielectric fluid (e.g., a housing inner surface, a packed bed, a side chamber, flow path, and / or eddy region ); protection of composition integrity of the dielectric fluid (e.g., managing materials of bearings, seals , plates , etc. to avoid material breakdown and / or introduction of degradation constituents that negatively affect the performance of the dielectric fluid ); introduction of a field disrupting additive into the dielectric fluid ( e.g., a coated metal oxide, a nano-particle, and /or a conductive particle having a conductor that isolate the conductive particle from physical contact with the dielectric fluid ); introduction of an ion scavenging additive into the dielectric fluid ( e.g., BHT, antioxidants, etc. ); management of gap distance (e.g., using bearings, magnetic separation, a separation assembly, etc.); and / or selected field weakening at certain operating conditions. The utilization of various field management aspects of the present disclosure allows for an increased average field strength in the gap, while maintaining a peak field strength below a breakdown threshold 8406, thereby increasing capacitive energy storage and consequent performance of the ESM 1002." This thing is sort of like a high voltage electrolytic capacitor with moving parts. They go to a lot of trouble to deal with most of the problems that happen inside capacitors, plus the special problems from moving parts. They had to go all the way to a pumped fluid system with filters, to keep the dielectric fluid cool and clean. Many electric car motors have liquid cooling, so it's no worse than that. It does mean this is probably a technology for larger motors, because the motor requires some accessory systems. It's not clear that this is a win over magnetic motors, but it's reasonable engineering. [1] https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/cf/eb/f0/6d48f075d23da6/US20210281193A1.pdf https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/cf/eb/f0/6d48f07...

01100011 2y ago

I've long wondered if there's a possible application for something like this using 3d printing and electrets. Basically you can freeze an electric field inside of an insulator if you apply it as the material solidifies. I think you should be able to embed electrets inside of 3d prints simply by generating a strong electric field at the print head or slightly behind it. You can also vary the field and embed a 3d electret that can act as, say, a sensor or a hidden ID in the print.

Geee 2y ago
Sounds interesting! Maybe you should try to make this.
calmbonsai 2y ago
Huh? No you can't due to leakage inductance. Are you simply making a joke about permanent magnets?
- 01100011 2y ago
  How does leakage inductance relate to electrets?
  - calmbonsai 2y ago
    In the exact same manner that leakage capacitance limits the field strength of permanent magnets--only more so by orders of magnitude. This is, fundamentally, why electrostatic motors have not seen "power" applications. It's far easier to manufacture a high-tolerance lattice in metals than non-metals. https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/1038668 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/1038668

mNovak 2y ago

Some more technical content (literature review, but includes the university work this spun out of) if the sales page isn't doing it for you: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=9194000 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=919...

trebligdivad 2y ago

Previous discussion 2 months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41309292 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41309292

scotty79 2y ago

I found somebody doing single phase electric motor on YouTube: https://youtu.be/s3yO7jYaD98?si=xecjNpuDaMA0IP1Q https://youtu.be/s3yO7jYaD98?si=xecjNpuDaMA0IP1Q

peter_d_sherman 2y ago

From the page: https://www.c-motive.com/applications/ https://www.c-motive.com/applications/ >"C-Motive has designed a sub-5 kW (7 hp) industrial motor platform designed for direct drive applications where high efficiency and high torque lead to substantial operational savings; a 1.5 kW (2 hp) C-Motive machine could save up to $1,400 a year in energy costs in a typical industrial application." [...] "A C-Motive electrostatic generator, however, can be connected directly to the hub of the wind turbine and driven directly without an efficiency-robbing gearbox. This can add 20% or more to the annual energy output of the wind turbine..." That seems like very promising future technology! Wishing the C-Motive team a lot of luck with their electrostatic generators and electrostatic motors!

foofoo55 2y ago
$1400 a year in electricity at a high rate of $0.15/kWhr for all 8,760 hours in a year is about 1 kW in power savings. Reality check: A typical 3-phase 2hp industrial motor [1] is over 85% efficient and typical 10:1 reduction gearbox [2] is 94% efficient, which results in about 3kW power usage and 20% power lost to heat, or approx 0.6 kW. If their motor is 100% efficient, used in a 100%-duty-cycle application, in an area with high electrical costs, and with similar reliability to the standard AC motor, this gives $800 or so in savings per year. In a more typical application with a 50% operating duty cycle and $0.10/kWhr, and guessing at 96% efficiency for their motor, we're down to maybe $200 per year in savings. Larger (>=5hp) motors can be 91% or higher efficiency bringing savings down even more. I can't imagine how C-Motive will equal the reliability, so any extra maintenance could quickly wipe out the savings. I would guess that a variable-frequency drive (VFD) on the above AC motor, used to control speed and improve the power factor, would have the same efficiency as their motor controller. So I only looked at the AC motor + gearbox versus the C-motive motor + fluid pump. [1] - https://www.baldor.com/catalog/CEM3558T-5#tab=%22performance%22 https://www.baldor.com/catalog/CEM3558T-5#tab=%22performance... [2] - https://www.bostongear.com/ecatalog?page=product&cid=worm_gear_speed_reducers_700_series&id=721A-10-G https://www.bostongear.com/ecatalog?page=product&cid=worm_ge...

jacknews 2y ago

This seems ideal for e-bikes?