10 ms·
Phenomenal consciousness is alien to us: SETI and the Fermi paradox
- isoprophlex 2y ago> Illusionism is an eliminativist position about qualia stating that phenomenal consciousness is nothing more than an introspective illusion. The attention schema theory (AST) relates this philosophical stance to a large body of experimental data and states that phenomenal consciousness arises from an internal model of attention control. A sufficiently advanced jargon is indistinguishable from magic.
- jollofricepeas 2y agoIndeed. I thought to say the same but you’ve phrased the problem with most in academia very nicely.
- Jevon23 2y agoEvery field has jargon and specialized terminology. Do you expect to be able to read any random physics or math paper outside your area of expertise and understand every word?
- stouset 2y agoThis has nothing to do with academia. Just grab a comment about anything tech-related in your own personal comment history and send it to a friend with zero tech background. They will be equally confused. Jargon exists to simplify communication between people with specialized knowledge in a field. People without that specialized knowledge aren’t going to be able to follow as easily. News at 11.
- karmakurtisaani 2y agoApparently there's an inverse correlation between the amount of jargon in a paper and the prestige of the university of the writer. Ie, people in worse universities tend to write more complicated language. This paper seems to be in line with that finding.
- jancsika 2y agoHave you ever actually written a research paper? Some things are impossible to flesh out without jargon. E.g., a musicologist once wrote a paper disproving a previous paper that claimed to show similarities between the proportions of sections in a musical piece and the proportions of architectural sections of a basilica. How the hell are you going to discuss those measurements and proportions without using the jargon from both Renaissance music and architecture? Furthermore, what does the necessity of that jargon have to do with the "prestige" of the university of either scholar? Edit: take down the temperature by changing the word "fuck" to "hell" :)
- shermantanktop 2y agoExcessive use of opaque jargon is typical of wannabes trying to climb a ladder of authority and credibility. But jargon is also a useful tool for competent people within a discipline. Very hard to tell the difference between the two from outside. I read the comment as linking non-prestigious universities with the first case. I personally do not have the same faith in prestigious institutions that OP has.
- karmakurtisaani 2y ago> Have you ever actually written a research paper? Some things are impossible to flesh out without jargon. I have, yes. I have gotten some compliments from reviewers for clarity as well, if that's worth anything. As pointed out already by others, some jargon is necessary, and using difficult language can be seen as a way to prop up credibility. As a personal anecdote, I've known someone (from an unknown institute) who deliberately didn't want to make his results sound as simple and accessible as they could have been. However, most top people whose papers I've read are written with clarity and unnecessary jargon.
- saaaaaam 2y agoOne person’s jargon is another person’s vernacular.
- HeuristicsCG 2y agoThese are all very basic concepts from philosophy of mind, you are complaining about using words such as "linked list" when talking about CS topics. Translated the quote says: "Illusionism is a position in which there is nothing happening in the brain except the physical process as known via modern day physics, or a future physics very similar to modern day physics, that position (illusionism) is the position that other things the mind is claimed to be able to do such as vivid experiences of colours or pain (qualia)are in fact nothing more than an illusion that happens then the brain queries its own systems. The attention schema theory (AST) relates this philosophical stance to a large body of experimental data and states that consciousness of experiences (qualia again, collars, pain, sound etc) arises from a model the brain generates of control what it gives attention to.
- isoprophlex 2y ago> complaining I was in awe, enjoying it, actually. But if you take the sour interpretation, sure, I can see how you'd construe my remark as such. No sourness intended though.
- Jevon23 2y agoThere are some specialized terms here that you're unlikely to encounter outside of an academic philosophy paper, but there's nothing complex about the meanings of any of the individual terms. Once you know what the words mean, it all makes sense. >eliminativist Eliminativist claims in philosophy are claims that deny the existence of some class of entities. You can be eliminativist about all sorts of things - numbers, objective morals, countries, tables and chairs, etc. >qualia First-person conscious experiences. Pain is a qualia. The way the color blue looks, as opposed to say the color red or green, is a qualia. The sensation of hot or cold is a qualia. When someone stubs their toe and says "ow", you can infer that they're in pain based on their behavior and your knowledge of how pain works, but you can't actually feel or directly observe their pain. That's the "first-person" part. >phenomenal consciousness A synonym for "qualia", because some philosophers started to feel like the word "qualia" had too much historical baggage, so they needed to come up with a new term. >introspective illusion Exactly what it says on the tin. An illusion (meaning, an impression that something is real, when it is in fact not) generated by introspection. So, putting it all together: >illusionism Illusionism about consciousness is the thesis that phenomenal consciousness is not real. So, to give a specific example, an illusionist would be committed to the thesis that pain is not real. As a corollary, no one has ever felt pain before, because there is no such thing as pain. People have been under the illusion that they feel pain, but they actually don't.
- piker 2y ago> First-person conscious experiences. Pain is a qualia. The way the color blue looks, as opposed to say the color red or green, is a qualia. The sensation of hot or cold is a qualia. When someone stubs their toe and says "ow", you can infer that they're in pain based on their behavior and your knowledge of how pain works, but you can't actually feel or directly observe their pain. That's the "first-person" part. So cool! I’ve always felt there was something really interesting about the idea that someone might internalize the color blue as I see the color red. I know we can define the colors mathematically, but I never knew the term for that subjective interpretive difference—qualia.
- Jevon23 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- munch117 2y agoI'm not a philosophy major, so the jargon is tough, but I can kind of read it. It's not nonsense. What helps me make sense of it is that I recognise the first sentence to be similar to my own position on consciousness: Consciousness is those parts of the workings of the brain that are available to introspection. I dislike the use of the word "illusion", though. Just because consciousness doesn't have a separate material presence, doesn't mean it's not real. The article seems to boil down to this: If you take this view on consciousness, then other kinds of intelligences, such as a post-biological AI, will also be conscious, because why not. So whatever ETI is out there is also conscious. And then, weirdly, the author decides that this post-biological AI is going to have some other kind of ethics, because reasons, and that means something for SETI and the Fermi paradox. That part doesn't seem very convincing. I wonder what it means to "surpass someone in moral philosophy". I'm not sure it means anything. Maybe it ties back to the word "illusion". If you believe that consciousness is an illusion, then it follows that someone could be capable of looking past the illusion and seeing only the reality behind it, and that would have consequences for their moral posture. Since I don't believe the word "illusion" is used properly, I don't buy this conclusion either.
- visarga 2y agoI don't think consciousness is an illusion, but our way of experiencing it is. It appears unified because of consistent semantic space across experiences, and serial action bottleneck. But the brain is massively parallel. I think this illusion of unity in consciousness led to so many people postulating some kind of essence. The way we apprehend ourselves is seriously biased, we have a blind spot.
- n4r9 2y agoThis reminds me of a short scifi story I recently read, "Touring with the Alien" by Carolyn Ives Gilman. I hope it's not too much of a spoiler to say it explores the idea of a visitation of Earth by aliens who are tremendously advanced but unconscious. Personally I can't quite come to terms with such a thing, but it's a neat story. Freely available from Clarke's World: https://clarkesworldmagazine.com/gilman_04_16/ https://clarkesworldmagazine.com/gilman_04_16/
- anon84873628 2y agoI haven't read that yet, but sounds like a similar theme as "Blindsight" and "Echopraxia" by Peter Watts. An excellent hard sci-fi duology by a Ph.D. biologist!
- n4r9 2y agoThanks! I actually came across "Touring with the Alien" in a Goodreads group (Evolution of Sci Fi) which has monthly long and short reads. Watts came up in that month's discussion, with Blindsight mentioned but also "The Island". I hope to check him out some time soon.
- jasfi 2y agoAGI would look like that, given enough time. It would be somewhat plausible for an AGI civilization to go off on their own, becoming completely separate from humanity. They'd have a much better chance at becoming a spacefaring civ.
- hax0ron3 2y ago>Conversely, the main tenet of illusionism is to deny the existence of phenomenally conscious states. For an illusionist there is “nothing it is like” to be in any mental state. Proponents of the theory only accept “quasi-phenomenal” states and properties, which are purely physical, but misrepresented as phenomenal by our introspective mechanisms. >While it is no longer a question of understanding the magic itself, we still have to explain how it happens. The “hard problem” has been replaced by the “illusion problem”. It consists in explaining why it seems to us that we are phenomenally conscious Lol. "why it seems to us that we are phenomenally conscious". Maybe because we are phenomenally conscious? The very subjective experience of pondering whether we are phenomenally conscious, or for that matter the subjective experience of anything else whatsoever, is already proof sufficient that we are phenomenally conscious because it is an example of phenomenal consciousness. Granted, maybe there are some good defenses of illusionism out there, but based on this text it seems to me that illusionism is just a sort of hail mary pass attempt to save reductive physicalism by deploying a bunch of hand-waving and deceptive semantics.
- n4r9 2y agoFor me, it's the other way around. I don't feel like there's anything special about "what it's like" to experience a certain mental state that cannot be explained physically/algorithmically. It feels like the concept of qualia is a last-ditch attempt by humans to make themselves feel special.
- exitb 2y agoNowadays it seems rather easy to have a computer that talks as if it were conscious. Do you think it really does perceive itself the same way we do? I woke up a human today, but someone else woke up an algorithm? If not, what’s missing?
- yldedly 2y agoAccording to the theory, an attention model. Here's artificial consciousness in three steps: 1. Have a robot build perception models of its environment and itself 2. Have the robot allocate computational resources and sensory bandwidth to the models using attention 3. Have the robot control attention using model predictive control Because the attention model is less detailed than its actual attention, by virtue of being a model, it doesn't represent the mechanisms of attention or modeling accurately. Instead, it uses non-physical concepts such as "mental possession" to model itself or other agents paying attention to things, or "qualia" to denote the recursion that occurs when percepts we attend to are summarized by the attention model (which in turn can be attended to, and so on).
- api 2y agoI consider the Fermi paradox nothing but a fun game. There are so many unknowns that we can literally say nothing about it. Nothing. We have no idea. We have a sample size of one and virtually nothing to even calibrate any of the scales for any of the parameters in any model. For all we know abiogenesis (life from non-living matter) is phenomenally rare to the point that there is an average of less than one example per galaxy per billion years. Or it could be common but complex life could be rare. Or, or, or, or... the or's become infinite because we have no information to constrain them. It's even worse than an endless theology argument since at least there you're arguing within a set of theoretical philosophical boundaries. This is literally unbounded. We have only barely started to explore a tiny fraction of the vastness of the universe. It's far too early to make statements like these. I do think exploring it is a fun way to enumerate all the possibilities for what we might or might not find out there, but it can at times get problematic. You have "longtermists" out there who actually cite the Fermi paradox in political, social, or ideological arguments, arguing for real world policies on the basis of an unconstrained untestable hypothesis.
- kelseyfrog 2y agoThe Drake equation works much better when you use probability distributions rather than point estimates.
- shermantanktop 2y agoCan you define “works” in this context?
- kelseyfrog 2y agoProduces probability distributions that aren't clearly extreme like 0 or 1billion.
- shermantanktop 2y agoRight, ok fair. The handling of intermediate distributions when combining factors is straightforward math but I have found it almost impossible to have a coherent conversation about that with many people, especially tech leaders. They want to talk about outcomes so they collapse all the intermediates into if/else decision trees and then get unhappy when the final probability doesn’t match their intuition. And these are smart people… I just think most people generally struggle with contingent probability. Do have links to this type of treatment of Drake?
- jonathan_oberg 2y agoDoesn’t this read like complete bullshit dreamed up by an LLM?
- russfink 2y agoIf you think that, then you’re impugning the entire field of philosophy (and likely psychology, too). CS/EE/Math are not the only fields with “hard” papers in them.
- rishav_sharan 2y agoCan someone ELI5? Not able to process all the heavy terms.
- grantcas 2y ago[dead]
- GMoromisato 2y agoHere's how I would summarize this (interesting) paper (please correct as appropriate). 1. Assume that consciousness is an illusion of the brain (Illusionism). That is, when we see the color red, the brain creates qualia (the feeling of seeing), but it's just an illusion.[a] 2. Why is the brain like that? The Attention Schema Theory (AST) suggests that this helps animals to focus on important inputs. The brain turns certain inputs into qualia (sensations), while ignoring others, to help us focus. Consciousness is kind of a like a blackboard on which certain inputs are placed, which helps higher planning functions to make decisions. 3. Once we have this sense of self, we can infer that other beings also have a sense of self and are able to form social bonds. Moreover, we evolve a morality based on having a sense of self. We believe inflicting pain is morally bad because we don't like feeling pain and can empathize.[b] 4. If Illusionism and AST is true, then it is likely that alien intelligence also evolved in the same way (because of convergent evolution). Therefore, alien intelligence might also have consciousness and might have also developed a moral framework based on consciousness. 5. But what if Artificial General Intelligence is possible? If AGI is possible, then it is likely that alien species quickly transition to a post-biologic state. Even if it takes us another 1,000 years to develop AGI, that's nothing in the lifetime of a species. Any alien intelligence we encounter is likely to be millions of years ahead of us (evolutionarily) and therefore has already developed AGI.[c] 6. Moreover, just as AST is useful in us to efficiently use brain resources, it should be useful in AGI. Thus, AGI might be programmed with (or eventually evolve) consciousness. 7. But such consciousness might be very different from biologically created consciousness and that would lead to misalignment. For example, an AGI might be nihilistic and not think consciousness is special. From their perspective, killing a human would be no different than disassembling a laptop. --------------- [a]: This is in contrast to theories that say that qualia/consciousness is some unique (and unknown) physical process. For example, Roger Penrose thinks qualia is some kind of quantum mechanical effects (I personally think that's bordering on pseudoscience, but what do I know). [b]: Consciousness is intertwined with free will here. You can't have free will without consciousness (cars don't have free will) and if you have consciousness, you have free will (at least as far as humans are concerned). And free will is the basis of all morality. You can't hold someone responsible unless they have free will. And thus, you can't hold someone responsible unless they have consciousness. [c]: Alien civilizations can't be millions of years behind us because then they wouldn't have technology. And they can't be equally advanced because in a universe that is 12 billion years old, having two civilizations the same age would be an awful coincidence.
- omgCPhuture 2y agoIs SETI those guys listening with radio telesopes for life signs and did not get the memo that pr definition every solar system by definition has a astronomically large and ultra power WIDE-BASE RADIO NOISE Generetor in them, you know, like the. Sun? Any radio signals moving in and out of solar systems are essentially scrambled leaving ours and entering say wherever E.T. go home? Strikes me as a little problematic to overpower or filter the by far largest and most powerful radionoise generators: For example our sun us so much bigger and powerful than anything we could begin to compete with, thus making listening with radio for radio that bears hallmarks life of being guaranteeed to fail using that method? Im asking for a friend, me, myself & I.
- singularity2001 2y agoOne question one could ask is whether these huge radio signal generators called Suns are themselves some kind of intelligence. While this was a popular concept in the past it would blow peoples mind today. Fortunately for the average mind there is currently no indication of this being the case so either SETI succeeded in ruling it out or SETI failed in finding the intelligence signal.
- gmuslera 2y agoThis kind of writing reminds me the different churches "knowing" how something that they describe as almighty, omniscient and eternal thinks.
- xpuente 2y agoThe usefulness of AST is not limited to biological systems. A hypothetical conscious electronic system might also need AST to: (1) stabilize internal states more quickly during learning, (2) respond more quickly to input stimuli, (3) use internal predictive flows to 'simulate' inputs in order to learn from a reduced number of sensory-linked events. It may not magically appear. It may, by design, be woven into the learning process.
- shusaku 2y agoGreat share. I was spooked by the abstract but the main text is extremely readable.