6 ms·
Advice for first-time inventors from a patent engineer
- ogou 2y agoIt took 4 years for me to get any communication from the USPTO after I filed. I had a patent lawyer prepare the application and transmit it electronically. There was a confirmation code of receipt and that was it. Nothing for 4 years and then an office action saying no. Ok, fine. One of the reasons offered was that there was a Chinese patent for something similar, owned by Bytedance. I read their patent and it is a huge word salad of a vast array of concepts, with very little application. When it comes to technology, I believe the whole America patent system is dominated by corporations and foreign players. Despite the new marketing of USPTO there is no way an independent inventor has a chance in this system.
- PaulRobinson 2y agoBecause patent specialists are experts at defining the widest possible scope for their idea, when I have reason to read a patent I find it a confusing word mess of noise, that does not have any meaningful interpretation until a case is argued in court, at which point the word salad is brought into the appropriate interpreted focus. I am not convinced an independent inventor is able to ever file a patent that can not be countered from another patent that had no intention to cover the inventor's use case when written, it's just a useful tool to protect the filer in any and all scenarios. Does anyone - except patent specialists who make their living from this - see value in the patent process at all any more? We're a long, long way from the original intent of the process these days, it seems.
- jll29 2y ago“If you disclose your invention publicly and do not file an application within one year, you could be barred from receiving a patent on that exact invention,” I am not a layer not patent attorney, but I have extensive experience as a former asset manager of a IP portfolio of an international stock market traded information company and inventor/co-inventor on multiple US and non-US patents and patent applications. This sentence is poor advice, since the one-year rule exists only in the U.S., whereas other countries have stricter rules. So it is recommended to always keep things secret (meaning you can only tell people under NDA about it) until a patent application is filed. You will normally want to be able to exercise your patent rights (a government-granted, time-limited, territorial monopoly) in multiple jurisdictions, not just the U.S., as your competitors will likely sit not just in the U.S. (if you file only in one country, people can work around your patent by using the method disclosed therein in another, unprotected jurisdiction instead, which is perfectly legal). Another piece of advice, namely to file a provisional application first, is only advisable if you are not quite ready to file the full application, yet you are afraid someone else may file first. In most circumstances it may be smarter to file a full application as the first action; the reason is that no new material matter may be added to the provisional application, and in the course of writing and "fine tuning" the language of the final application, one often wishes to include additional matter. To sum it up, a provisional freezes the scope of the application, while not providing you an earlier "priority date". You need to understand IP well to play this game; most people don't. It's also a game with large capital requirements ($100k/lifetime of a patent, including extension fees, foreign filings and translations) and very long time lines (double decades rather than weeks). But if executed carefully, a single transaction (case of patent litigation or licensing) may bring an IP owner more $$$ than they may earn with their normal operational business.
- Temporary_31337 2y agoUnless you have a business that can easily support these costs AND a plan to make extra money from the exclusivity that patent award gives you then I don’t see how this makes financial sense for any small entrepreneur.
- Beijinger 2y ago“If you disclose your invention publicly and do not file an application within one year, you could be barred from receiving a patent on that exact invention,” Wasn't this rule retired? I vaguely remember something in this regard. "It's also a game with large capital requirements " True. And many BS patents from big corporations are getting granted because their lawyers fight day and night to have it granted. And many solid patents from single inventors get rejected. The patent examiner is just lazy, likely does not even read your applications and rejects it on grounds that make it obvious that he has neither, read nor understood your applications (dont ask :-) ). While this can be fixed, it leaves your skeptical about the whole system.
- phasetransition 2y agoI, too, am not a lawyer, but ended up overseeing the IP portfolio of a publicly traded EU company. Small world... I comment in geneal support of this advice. We have started to submit a presentation that would be used for an examiner interview as our provisional application.
- Intermernet 2y agoThere should be a legally accepted way to publish something, free of cost, that demonstrates a new invention, that prevents other people patenting it, and can allow the person who published it to claim the credit for doing so. I'm not sure what's so difficult about this concept in the age of verifiable chains of communications and transactions.
- light_hue_1 2y agoThis has always existed. You disclose the idea. Things that are public cannot be patented. Put your great idea up on arxiv and it becomes prior work which the patent office can find. Or publish it in some conference. Etc. It gets officially timestamped and you're all done. You don't need any of this useless verifiable chain of communication nonsense. The world figured out how to do this centuries ago in far simpler ways. Whether the patent office finds your prior art or not, that's a whole other question. They may still grant a patent no matter how obviously it overlaps with prior art. But then you can use your prior art when they come to try and shake you down, if it comes down to that.
- bilsbie 2y agoCouldn’t you post it on hacker news or X? That would have a pretty strong timestamp.
- rvnx 2y agoIt’s easy to fake if you are part of YC. You think they would lose 1B+ potential revenue if the only thing they have to do is to change one database record that nobody except them is monitoring ?
- qup 2y agoThey're not the only ones monitoring their own database.
- DowagerDave 2y agoit's pretty hard to unpublish something on the internet though. How many system do you think are consuming HN content? how many consume those? You can't un-ring a bell, so a simple social post is almost always discoverable in the future.
- mikewarot 2y ago>"If you disclose your invention publicly and do not file an application within one year, you could be barred from receiving a patent on that exact invention." Does this mean if I disclose an invention, that nobody can patent it after a year? This is my explicit reason for writing about BitGrid out in the open, since 2004.[1] If it turns out to be useful, that's awesome. If not, it's been a fun mud ball to polish.[2] [1] https://bitgrid.blogspot.com/2004/ https://bitgrid.blogspot.com/2004/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dorodango https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dorodango
- devnull3 2y ago> Does this mean if I disclose an invention, that nobody can patent it after a year? Others can. But during their application who is going to tell that there is a prior art? Patent offices only do basic checks on existing patents and not on the wider internet. Once the others get their patent, you can appeal [1] it. [1] I am not sure its the right word
- jcranmer 2y ago> appeal [1] I am not sure its the right word You can challenge the patent at the USPTO to instigate an in partes review. You can also raise a defense of 'the patent is invalid' if the patent owner tries to sue you.
- Joel_Mckay 2y ago"prior art" is usually meaningless in a first-to-file country like the USA. i.e. if you disclose your IP publicly, there is zero protection from getting scooped by competitors and trolls. If you NDA more than 17 entities, than it becomes public domain in some countries. Patent-pending status is somewhat of a more economical tool, and buys time to entrench a manufacturing product line in a market. A fully complete patent is only useful for litigation and customs enforcement... and can't be revised to cover sleazy IP workarounds. We only won about 4 out of 7 international scope patents I drafted, so YMMV. =3
- jeffreyrogers 2y agoIn theory you can't patent something that has already been described prior to the filing date. In practice I'm sure there's been things that've been patented that someone else independently invented beforehand. It's also not always clear if something is a new invention or not (e.g., some chemical has been known for a while but someone realized it could be used to treat some disease).
- devnull3 2y agoHaving filed multiple patents, it does not leave a good taste in your mouth (esp software patents). You know you are bullshitting but unfortunately it needs to be done because others will do it and deny you to use the invention.
- GJim 2y ago> it does not leave a good taste in your mouth (esp software patents) The very _concept_ of software patents should leave a bad taste in anybody's mouth.
- fatnoah 2y agoFully agree. Over 20 years ago, I did the same job as the Patent Engineer (I had a slightly different title, but same role) at a big law firm. Half of the patents I filed were BS software patents for a name brand tech company, and the other half were for actually novel and cool inventions for things like super-efficient distillation/chilling systems for coffee and satellite antennas for moving vehicles. Getting that job was almost as easy as getting a software job in 2019. I had a masters in EE and a few years of SWE experience. I sent out 5 applications to top local law firms, got 3 interviews, and one offer over the course of a month. Apparently, the bulk of people in that role were post-docs in bio/chem who weren't excited about managing student loan debt while being underpaid lab people. (The EE/CS contingent was 5 out of 30 in the role, and I was the only one with actual SWE experience, so it gave the me and the firm creditability with inventors) My salary matched my SWE salary, I had my own office + secretary, and the firm paid overtime and law school tuition. They also charged $250/hour for my time. I also only lasted about year in that role since it was very isolating and not collaborative. The coolest part of that whole experience came a couple years later when I went to dinner with my wife, her close friend, and the friend's serious boyfriend. In the "what do you do" chit chat, he mentioned working with someone on a new way to brew and chill coffee quickly that they were close to bringing to market. When I asked if it works like [describes invention exactly] his mind was absolutely blown away. As it turns out, I wrote their patent.
- freejazz 2y agoIf your invention is a prior art, then it is a defense to infringement. The asserted patent is invalid.
- hiddencost 2y ago"you'll regret it" is basically the right advice. Unless you're carrying at 10 figure legal budget and a portfolio of thousands of patents.
- floathub 2y agoThe patent system in general and the USPTO in particular is a very strange amalgam. As a holder of multiple patents (both hardware and method/soft), I've found the process to be extremely odd. First you have to phrase whatever your technology involves in a legal vernacular that is weirdly constraining and rarely maps well onto what the thing in question actually does. You always have the sense that you're playing a game of legal-mumbo-jumbo performance art more than actually describing an invention. Second, you then have to interact with patent examiners. Some are great, many not so much. One I encountered was possibly the dumbest person I have ever met. Thick as two short planks with two extra short planks nailed on. Third, the process just seems to go on and on. The examiner will make an objection or point to prior art. These actions may have little basis in logic or common sense, but they do seem to move pieces of paper from one box to another. Meetings occur with the examiner and/or their supervisor where your jaw will drop at how little anyone involved understands the technology being claimed. You can cut through a lot of this with good legal counsel, but that is really just contributing to the gamesmanship of the whole process. And, in the end, a patent is a pretty meaningless thing. A portfolio of defended patents might be an "Intellectual Property" asset (what an awful term). But so many people have to jump through the process just as a defensive act so they have a sliver of reassurance that using the novel thing they came up with will not lead to immediate cease-and-desist injunctions from IP-fortified competitors. What a collective waste of human creativity.
- inetknght 2y ago> You always have the sense that you're playing a game of legal-mumbo-jumbo performance art more than actually describing an invention. My first patent was filed a few weeks ago, with consultations with a patent attorney. This is pretty much the highlight of my takeaway as well. It helps to have a good understanding of the English dictionary and thesaurus to be able to negotiate wording. But yes, it's still mumbo-jumbo. Inventions might be "obvious" to someone else in the trade, but it's hard to say if it's going to be obvious if it isn't described using that trade's mumbo-jumbo instead of Legal mumbo-jumbo.
- freejazz 2y ago> But so many people have to jump through the process just as a defensive act so they have a sliver of reassurance that using the novel thing they came up with will not lead to immediate cease-and-desist injunctions from IP-fortified competitors. Having a patent is not a defense to an allegation of infringement and if that's what your legal counsel told you, then you should seek new counsel.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- matthewsinclair 2y agoAs a holder of multiple patents (some thru employers, and several, now lapsed, that I tried to get personally) the entire system is a joke. As a few people have said here, it seems like it is designed entirely to obfuscate the process, make money for lawyers, and entrench the value of the existing portfolios of large patent holders. In the process of doing some research on patents a while back I came across this article [0] which really resonated with me. [0]: “Against intellectual property” — Brian Martin, https://documents.uow.edu.au/~/bmartin/pubs/95psa.html https://documents.uow.edu.au/~/bmartin/pubs/95psa.html
- foobarian 2y agoPart of the problem is that there are no more easy inventions left. The time when you could get a dozen new inventions just sticking a pair of electrodes into a vacuum chamber in your garage is long over.
- scotty79 2y agoAnd yet lawyers need to earn.
- Manabu-eo 2y agoAt first I thought you were linking to "Against Intellectual Monopoly" by Michele Boldrin and David K. Levine: http://www.dklevine.com/general/intellectual/against.htm http://www.dklevine.com/general/intellectual/against.htm
- matthewsinclair 2y agoI haven’t read that one (queued for tomorrow) but based on the title and ToC it seems to be similar in reasoning to the link I posted.
- tempfile 2y agoThank you for making the distinction (since I should read GP's book) and thanks also for mentioning this brilliant book, so I don't have to.
- singlepaynews 2y agoHi, I work at USPTO, the following statements and opinions are my own and represent me only: 1) While many do indeed file for the broadest patent possible, in my (limited) experience so far this makes an application much easier to reject. The application that I've seen so far that was the most difficult to reject was made difficult by extremely specific claims. 2) The best argument I've ever heard in favor of the USPTO is that it allows small inventors to hedge market competition risk. Imagine you are an AI startup, developing a novel model architecture for a domain-specific application. You file a patent for the method, and once your product begins selling and Microsoft creates a fast-follow product you can sue. Microsoft will have much more to gain from buying your company at that point than giving up the market to some plucky dorks with a Patent, and your IPO is just the cost of doing business for them. 3) To the extent that "it is very difficult to get a man to believe something his paycheck depends on him denying", I am aware of a personal incentive to argue for the utility of the USPTO. Idk what else to say besides offer me a job on your engineering team and I'll quit immediately. (edit: actually I do know what else to say: If you don't care about patents don't apply for one. Fully optional endeavor. If you do care about patents, then I am here to help.)
- generalizations 2y agoI remember learning about the pros and cons of patents vs trade secrets a few years ago- it's a lot less cut and dried than that. With trade secrets, you just have to make a reasonable effort to keep them secret, and then if it gets out you can sue for theft (or some such). As long as there's a secret sauce you can keep out of the public eye it's nearly functionally equivalent. > The application that I've seen so far that was the most difficult to reject was made difficult by extremely specific claims. Tradeoffs: the narrower the patent, the less useful it is, because it's that much easier for your competition to just tweak something inconsequential. > once your product begins selling and Microsoft creates a fast-follow product you can sue Not that easy - you need to be able to afford a patent law fight. Big companies like MS might just take it anyway and risk the lawsuit, because they can afford to drag it out longer than you can stay solvent. On the other hand, if you go the trade secret route, Microsoft can't fast-follow because you didn't publish the whole thing.
- scotty79 2y ago> “If you disclose your invention publicly and do not file an application within one year, you could be barred from receiving a patent on that exact invention,” she says. “Because of the ‘first to file’ system, if someone steals your idea by filing first, this can be hard and very expensive to reverse.” If that doesn't tell you it's an extortion racket on anyone with useful ideas then I don't know what will.
- jeffreyrogers 2y agoThe US is actually permissive relative to other countries. In most countries if you disclose your invention before filing you lose the right to patent it.
- scotty79 2y agoEverybody loses right to patent it. Which is fair. In US someone else can still patent your invention if you didn't. That's where the extortion is to patent it. ANS encoding was invented and published by it's inventory without patent explicitly for everybody to be able to use it. And yet Microsoft just patented a subset of it. It was granted a patent on a thing they didn't invent and was already published for the explicit goal of leaving it patent free.
- jeffreyrogers 2y agoIn theory that patent is not valid since it is based on something that was already published, but I agree that in practice some companies will pay to avoid going to court.
- BS_Alarm 2y agoAFAIK, the US is one of the only, if not the only, country that allows for 1 year.
- Animats 2y agoI used to make money with patents. I've held six of them. But once US patents were weakened, it was no longer profitable. The trouble with a weak patent system is that things which used to be patented are now trade secrets. How Waymo and Tesla do self-driving is a trade secret, for example.
- rostigerpudel 2y agoEuropean Patent Attorney here. AMA
- kragen 2y agoProbably better advice is from expired patent holder Don Lancaster: https://www.tinaja.com/glib/casagpat.pdf https://www.tinaja.com/glib/casagpat.pdf > Now, the patent system may or may not still retain some marginal utility in a Fortune 500 enterprise. But, as a Midnight Engineer or other small scale startup, nearly any involvement whatsoever with the patent system in any way, shape, or form, is virtually guaranteed to cause you a monumental long term loss of time, money, and sanity. I'd guess the main problem is the mythology that has built up around the patent process over all the years. A mythology which no longer applies to the Midnight Engineer or to a small scale startup. For those who don't know, Lancaster was for decades one of the best-selling authors on electrical and electronic engineering, with columns in popular magazines. He was constantly providing consulting services to engineers who were designing products, too. I don't know if he ever had a commercially successful product himself other than his books, but I still think his reasoning is worth weighing.
- jiggawatts 2y agoI think patents could work again if the key acceptance criteria was that based on the patent alone, a team of engineers must be able to reproduce the invention. This would eliminate a whole range of ills with the current system that seems to do little except keep lawyers employed.
- jeffreyrogers 2y agoIIRC the patent court and tax court are the only two that non-lawyers can practice at in the US.