7 ms·
America is wooing foreign tourists for the first time
- cstross 14y agoIt would really help encourage tourism into the USA if the USA didn't levy a freaking tax on entering the USA to subsidize the ailing Florida tourism industry. (Source: http://www.eubusiness.com/news-eu/us-tourism-security.5tl/ http://www.eubusiness.com/news-eu/us-tourism-security.5tl/ ) Which is ailing because the process of entering the USA today, if you're a foreigner (like me) is marginally less friendly than entering the USSR in the mid-1980s. (This is not a knock on the USA, it's a knock on the immigration/border control process. Which sucks. Horribly.)
- nohat 14y agoCharging a fee for entry is definitely not conducive for tourism, but how is it a subsidy to Florida? The article I read says it will be used to advertise, and pay for administrative costs.
- rocky1138 14y agoI don't have a problem charging a menial fee to tourists, so long as it's completely transparent where that money is going. The last thing a country should wish on its image is the tourist money going to military invasions and the like.
- yequalsx 14y agoI think the only way the TSA and ICE become more humane organizations is if people stop visiting the U.S. Please don't come here! There are many other nice places to visit that don't treat visitors with the disdain that visitors here frequently encounter.
- yequalsx 14y agoI'm curious why this is being down voted. It seems obvious to me that if international tourism to the U.S. declined sufficiently then industry would put great pressure on the government to make the process much more inviting. I think there is near universal disgust with the TSA and ICE.
- jakeonthemove 14y agoAt the rate its been dropping, that will happen very soon. In fact, they're already trying to introduce a faster/easier airport travel with "trusted traveler" programs (leave it to the USA to make money out of something that used to be free :-)). Also, I'm surprised France is the most visited country - what do they have besides the Eiffel tower and bad roads :-)?
- zem 14y agothey have a "romantic, quintessentially old/new world in juxtaposition western european destination" mystique that has been built up over decades.
- excuse-me 14y agoThey also manage to have more than one kind of bread, many cheeses which don't come in an aerosol can and food which takes more time to cook than it does to eat And, outside Paris, some very pleasant people.
- zem 14y agotrue, but belgium for instance has all that too, and you don't see it getting that sort of must-see tourist aura
- excuse-me 14y agoThen it obviously needs a tower. Do you have the number for the Belgian tourist office - I have one that French want to sell! Luxembourg is also rather overlooked as a tourist destination, very nice walking countryside and you are never very far from somewhere to eat/drink/sleep.
- jakeonthemove 14y agoFunny that you mention Belgium - I am in Blankenberge right now (on business) - it's a nice little town, but it's nothing special. No offense to the locals, but I can't wait to get out of here - the weather is pretty bad, most residents are old, everyone is slooow (even in the rain :-), shops close at 6pm, banks close at 3pm and Everything's closed all day on Sunday, HSPA 3G here means 1 Mbit on a good day (usually ~500-700 kbit - oh, and you pay $20 for 1 GB), 4 Mbit DSL actually means 1.5 Mbit, and you pay $700 for a teeny-tiny 1 bedroom apartment (then again, it is a resort city). I nicknamed it Lazy Town :-). The only saving grace is the port nearby (~6km in Zeebrugge) - there's a bustling shipping and logistics industry here, and there's plenty of work and opportunities. Overall, for a first-timer in Belgium, I'd recommend going to Brussels or Antwerp - bigger cities, more active, although still very laid back compared to even Paris...
- anigbrowl 14y agoI quite agree about the fee, but also fail to see what it has to do with Florida. The fee exists because Congress has never got around to funding a proper entry-exit database for tourists, with the result that prior to 2007 (IIRC) there's basically no record of whether or not someone left the US after the 90-day period of admission for visa-free entry.
- MiguelHudnandez 14y agoThe ESTA fees don't go to Florida in particular, but in part to Brand USA. I think the rest goes to the TSA to offset the cost of operations. Brand USA gets up to $200,000,000 from ESTA fees based on tourism industry support. All states' tourism situations have been ailing, starting with the reaction to 9/11. The ESTA fees are unpleasant but given that there is now a recipient of those fees with a vested interest in increasing visitation, there may be tangible benefits for future visitors. The $10 fee transforms visitors from a drain of security resources into profit-generating customers, which obviously can lead to a sea change in the way visitors are treated and the processes they are subjected to by the TSA. It will take time for that to occur, though. Disclosure: I work for what could be considered a state-level analogue of Brand USA.
- Variance 14y agoThere's potential truth in what you're saying, but that doesn't mean that a tourism tax is far from ideal. The economics of governments and their agencies are very different from those of companies. Most importantly, while private companies have a market incentive to treat customers better when they pay more, governments don't. This is because governments both have a monopoly and so don't face outside competition, and because they don't face bankruptcy if they don't draw in the $200M in funds that you mentioned. Instead, all that the federal government is saying to the TSA/other ESTA recipients is that "we made a tax which generates $200M, so we expect you to step up your services with the funding". It works only partially, because the only motivation that ESTA recipients (especially the TSA) have to improve is the word of god, and not any meaningful amounts of hard cash profit. The TSA is the worst of all with this, because unlike state marketing authorities, the TSA has no theoretical benefit from increased tourism. The smaller and more local the agencies you are analyzing get, the more like businesses they are, and so the more effective an ESTA would be. So having an ESTA to make the TSA better is essentially just the same as increasing the TSA's funding from tax dollars and telling it to be better. Then you might as well do the latter, so as not to discourage tourists since tourists are much more likely to stop coming to the country than US citizens are to stop paying taxes because the income tax went up 0.01% to fund the $200M. And even increasing taxes isn't ideal, because theoretically, if the TSA experience being better is worth the money, tourism will increase proportionately, and tourism's benefit to the economy will drive up tax revenues automatically without a tax. Most ideal of all would be to find a way to privatize the TSA in a way that's safe and efficient, because then the new TSA corporation(s) would snap to market equilibrium.
- Variance 14y agoI just took a trip out of the US down to Brazil and back a few weeks ago, and dear god, coming back into the country at the airport in Atlanta... The tourists probably had about 20-30 minutes before getting out of the terminal, which is bad enough, but the US citizens were in a Disney World-esque line that was long enough that I missed a connecting flight scheduled an hour and a half after we arrived from Brazil. That was bad enough that I sure won't be flying out of the country for anything less than at least a couple days worth of stuff. I feel bad for anyone coming through who isn't a citizen or can't speak perfect English. The immigration building had these massive screens overhead showing serene farmland scenes and images from across the country, while two or three thousand passengers are stuck in a line desperately waiting to get home or to their hotels at 1 AM. It's all very dystopian.
- tesseract 14y agoYeah, in addition to being frustrated by the wait I always feel so incredibly _embarrassed_ when I'm returning to the US, like I should be apologizing to the people in the visitors line for how horrible and frustrating it is. And that video is definitely over the top. Getting in and out of China (to pick one example out of the places I've visited) as a visitor was way less of a hassle than getting back into the US as a citizen. It's ridiculous.
- pbz 14y agoIt's usually the other way around; meaning foreigners have to wait way more than citizens. And that's just the tip of the iceberg. If you ever had the pleasure of going through the US Embassy for a trip to the US you'd think people who end up still coming here are masochists.
- mirsadm 14y agoIn Melbourne, Australia the wait is over 2 hours and they don't have toilets in the building. Once you pass the many security checkpoints you can't leave until you get your visa. Pretty funny watching everybody run out after they get their visa sorted out.
- userulluipeste 14y ago
- sehugg 14y agoTourism to Florida is down relative to other U.S. destinations (Source: http://tinet.ita.doc.gov/outreachpages/download_data_table/2011_States_and_Cities.pdf http://tinet.ita.doc.gov/outreachpages/download_data_table/2...) so there may be some truth to this. Maybe we can look over the meeting notes (http://www.thebrandusa.com/meeting-records/ http://www.thebrandusa.com/meeting-records/) and find out?
- cletus 14y agoAmerica is currently the center of the tech world. This is largely due to two things: 1. The internet is cheaper here than anywhere else in part because everyone else pays to connect to the US; and 2. The university endowment system combined with some of the greatest research institutions on the planet created the tech VC system that fuelled the growth of Silicon Valley. Manufacturing has already left the US (and most of the developed world). While the barriers are higher for skilled labour, it's not impossible. Many countries have a sufficiently stable political system and sufficient infrastructure to create tech businesses. My point is that the US is outright hostile to those seeking to enter the United States, be they as tourists, residents or temporary workers, and to those who choose to come here and put up with a level of invasiveness that rivals third-world dictatorships and the old Iron Curtain countries. Now some of the post-9/11 measures I don't have a problem with. I see no issue with fingerprinting those entering the United States. On the other hand, as a foreign worker I need to report every foreign bank account I own (separately or jointly), have a financial interest in or signatory authority over whether or not that money was ever earned in or otherwise entered the United States. This includes retirement accounts. Or does it? No one can really say because the rules aren't clear. Failure to comply can result in civil penalties as high as 300% of the balance of that account and criminal penalties including years in jail. When it comes time to renew my visa I have to leave the country to do it. Should I want to leave my job and start a business here I don't believe I have any legal recourse to reside lawfully in the United States so I have to go somewhere else. I'm actually encouraged by stories like this one just because I'm optimistic that the US is finally figuring out that it needs tourists. Maybe someday soon it'll figure out it needs foreign workers and entrepreneurs too. Hopefully before it's too late. It saddens me actually because the fate of the US is the same as that of many companies. Early-stage companies are innovators. Eventually they get so large that they live in constant fear that their success will go away or something will kill the golden goose. Instead of innovating they simply play a game of defense and interference. This is Microsoft of today with its Windows/Office cash cow. The US was formed my immigrants coming to escape the rigid structure and persecution of the Old World. In a mere century the US turned from an agrarian backwater of 2 million (in 1800) to an industrial superpower of 50 million, thanks largely to migrants. The US shut its doors at the outbreak of World War One has been building increasingly larger walls ever since. What disturbs me most is the presumption of (criminal) guilt that seems to pervade state institutions, particularly when it applies to confusing, complex, special-interest bought rules like the IRS code. In no other country I've been have I felt fear that I'd be locked up even when trying to do what I believe is the right thing. This doesn't just apply to foreigners either. The US seems just as hostile to its own citizens too. EDIT: regarding Internet speed, so as to be clear there's a difference between Internet end-user cost (consumers and businesses) and service provider cost. End user cost is indeed expensive, which seems largely due to the regional monopolies that exist in the US, meaning cable companies. That is however irrelevant (for the purpose of my argument). I'm interested in the cost of a Facebook, Google, Ebay or Amazon providing their service in resource terms. Of course there's a latency component to this as well (the US being disproportionately represented in customer terms) but ultimately it has been cheaper and I believe that to still be the case, especially if you get to the scale whereby peering is possible and viable.
- cgs1019 14y agoSo, tourism decreases as a consequence of our making it significantly harder to enter and much less pleasant and welcoming once you do, and our solution is a marketing campaign to convince people that's not really how it is. This seems so fundamentally flawed I don't even know where to start.
- rsanchez1 14y agoFor the first time? Have these people heard of Disney World and Universal Studios?
- NoPiece 14y agoEveryone's skeptic meter should be triggered at the line, "...launched America’s first-ever campaign to attract visitors from overseas." 30 seconds on youtube and you'll find this UK targeted ad than was uploaded 4 years ago. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tkcYTVfXn74 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tkcYTVfXn74 I'm sure there have been hundreds of ad campaigns in hundreds of countries.
- rocky1138 14y agoAs a Canadian citizen, I am close enough to the United States already. It's great that they want to share their landmarks, friendly people, and history. The problem is the gatekeepers AKA the TSA and border police. A quick google search on TSA will give you all the information you need to make an educated choice on where not to spend your holidays. Until this is fixed, I cannot see how the USA can beat places like Taiwan, China, anywhere in Europe (except maybe Germany), Australia, or Iceland for the image of "welcoming tourists." It's purely anecdotal as it's an opinion, of course. Take it or leave it :)