8 ms·
For an interesting side piece: Curiously, however, for a system apparently stultified by the dead hand of government, Australia’s health system far outperf
by defrost 2y ago
For an interesting side piece:
Curiously, however, for a system apparently stultified by the dead hand of government, Australia’s health system far outperforms the free market-based US healthcare system, which spends nearly twice as much per capita as Australia to deliver far worse outcomes — including Americans dying five years younger than us.
The shocking truth: Australia has a world-leading health system — because of governments
Source: https://www.crikey.com.au/2024/10/16/pubic-private-healthcare-life-expectancy/ https://www.crikey.com.au/2024/10/16/pubic-private-healthcar...
Bypass: https://clearthis.page/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.crikey.com.au%2F2024%2F10%2F16%2Fpubic-private-healthcare-life-expectancy%2F https://clearthis.page/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.crikey.com.au%2F...
Overall, we now have the fourth-highest life expectancy in the world.
This is contrary to the narrative that pervades the media about our health system — one in which our “frontline” health workers heroically battle to overcome government neglect and inadequate spending, while the population is beset by various “epidemics” — obesity, alcohol, illicit drugs.
In fact, Australian longevity is so remarkable that in August The Economist published a piece simply titled “Why do Australians live so long?”
Other references:
The Economist: https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2024/08/23/why-do-australians-live-so-long https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2024/08/23/why-do-a...
AU Gov Report: Advances in measuring healthcare productivity https://www.pc.gov.au/research/completed/measuring-healthcare-productivity/measuring-healthcare-productivity.pdf https://www.pc.gov.au/research/completed/measuring-healthcar...
- tightbookkeeper 2y agodemographics in the US are very different than Australia, I suspect those in the bottom 1/3rd of US health drag it down significantly.
- koyote 2y agoI assume you are referring to a larger amount of people living in poverty in the US? Could this also (partially) be explained by the cost of healthcare? Something like a downwards spiral where average people end up poor either due to direct costs of healthcare or neglecting their own healthcare due to cost?
- tightbookkeeper 2y agodemographic differences of all kinds: - greater usage of surgeries and prescriptions, leading to greater exposure to medical malpractice (the 3rd leading cause of death in the US.) - higher birthrate. more pregnancies. - less cultural tolerance of abortion. Greater willingness to take on risky pregnancies - single parent homes (people with less family support) - ethnicities which are more susceptible to certain disease and lifestyle risks - greater exposure to crime in impoverished areas - more life time spent traveling in cars - more restricted access to health insurance (as you said only accessing healthcare in dire emergency) The US is a different world than most countries which tend to be geographically tight and culturally homogenous. It's very difficult to make comparisons, not to mention differences in data collection and reporting ethics.
- biztos 2y ago> medical malpractice (the 3rd leading cause of death in the US.) Not to downplay the malpractice problem, but this doesn’t sound remotely plausible. Do you have some sources to back up this claim? I googled around a bit and it appears to come from some sloppy misuse of statistics in a journal one time, plus internet amplification.
- tightbookkeeper 2y agoThe CDC doesn’t record medical malpractice as a category for cause of death or injury. It’s grouped under “accidents” in their statistics (their official 3rd ranked category). > The CDC’s published mortality statistics, however, count only the “underlying cause of death,” defined as the condition that led a person to seek treatment. Because of this political choice the information comes from 3rd parties digging into the accidents category. https://www.propublica.org/article/study-urges-cdc-to-revise-count-of-deaths-from-medical-error https://www.propublica.org/article/study-urges-cdc-to-revise...
- koyote 2y agoThose examples are mostly good ones, but: > The US is a different world than most countries which tend to be geographically tight and culturally homogenous I am not sure how much you know about Australia, but homogeneity and geographically tight is definitely not how you would describe it.
- atwrk 2y agoDemographics (I assume you mean race?) can't be the reason. West Virgina is IIRC almost exclusively white and has a lower live expectancy than North Korea.
- tightbookkeeper 2y agoIt seems you believe “demographics” is a dog whistle for “which people are white”. West Virginia is extremely poor.
- alwayslikethis 2y ago> the free market-based US healthcare system market, maybe, "free" market? I doubt it. It's not a very free market when there is such a large power differential between the buyer and the seller. You can't exactly shop around for the ambulance or the hospital when you need it, nor can you realistically circumvent the artificially constrained supply [1] of doctors to get cheaper healthcare (unless you live next to the border). When the alternative is a one-sided market like this, government becomes rather more appealing. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Medical_Association#Restrictions_on_physician_supply https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Medical_Association#R...
- WalterBright 2y ago> You can't exactly shop around The vast bulk of health care is by appointment, not a dash in the ambulance.
- globular-toast 2y agoEven so, when was the last time someone needed cancer treatment but said "ooh, that's pricey, nah, I'd rather buy a new car instead". This is my main argument against private healthcare: there's no real choice involved. Without even getting into what a free market is and perfect information etc, the main advantage of a capitalist society is you get to choose what you like. Nobody chooses healthcare (at least, not the super expensive part).
- tastyfreeze 2y agoA large portion of healthcare could be free market. Insurance should be for unlikely events not every single thing deemed "medical". My home and auto insurance don't cover regular costs for maintenance. Why must health insurance cover a checkup with the doctor?
- SoftTalker 2y ago> This is my main argument against private healthcare: there's no real choice involved. Is your argument that there is choice involved in public healthcare? Or simply that it's not even a question?
- N_A_T_E 2y agoIs the US health system free market? The government provides healthcare via Medicare and Medicaid for seniors, the people for whom life expectancy and healthcare quality have the highest correlation.
- defrost 2y agoThe quote is from a Crikey reporter, I (an Australian) wouldn't agree that the US health system is classic free market .. but it appears to have more regulatory capture by vested commercial non government profit orientated interests than by social policy best outcome for the masses civil authorities. ( Describing various systems in various countries as either communist of free market capitalist is pretty simplistic, it's not much as a linear spectrum either ) I'd also argue that the foundation for a high life expectancy doesn't start with good health care for seniors .. unless the metric is "life support via artificial means" .. life expectancy is grounded in healthy living and excerise from an early age well maintained with good health programs.
- mitthrowaway2 2y ago> the people for whom life expectancy and healthcare quality have the highest correlation. What do you mean by this? Fatalities among the young will have a much larger impact on lowering nationwide life expectancy than fatalities among the elderly.
- dahart 2y agoIt’s a mixed bag, but the funding source doesn’t necessarily make it a controlled market, to the degree that Medicare and Medicaid pay non-government providers and allow competition (which again, is mixed). Medicare and Medicaid coverage make up one third of the US population. The other two thirds are on group/employer insurance, private insurance, or no insurance at all. For non-seniors, the medical insurance system certainly sometimes doesn’t feel like a free market from the consumer perspective, but the insurance companies are private for-profit institutions, and the medical providers are too, so it may well fit the definition.
- dyauspitr 2y agoThe issue with most of these is that they have better health outcomes overall but when it comes down to the uncommon cancer your mom has, she will have a much higher chance of survival in the US. The difference is a lot of poor folk without adequate healthcare die of relatively straightforward conditions like diabetes while if you do have healthcare you end up getting the state of the art though it might bankrupt you.
- defrost 2y agoThere's nothing in the Australian health care system that precludes people with uncommon conditions seeking specialist treatments either in Australia or abroad. > she will have a much higher chance of survival in the US. Without a deep dive it looks ballpark the same, to be honest. AU Cancer Survival Rates: The 5-year survival for cancer in 1991–1995 was 55% and by 2016–2020, the rate had increased to 71%. Even with decreasing mortality rates and increasing survival, the number of deaths from cancer has been increasing. 15 Aug 2024 - https://www.aihw.gov.au/reports/cancer/cancer-data-in-australia/contents/overview https://www.aihw.gov.au/reports/cancer/cancer-data-in-austra... US Cancer Survival Rates: Five-year survival rates have also been increasing for an even longer period of time. The overall cancer survival rate was 49 percent in the mid-1970s. It currently sits at 68 percent 2023: https://www.cancercenter.com/community/blog/2023/01/cancer-survival-rates-are-improving https://www.cancercenter.com/community/blog/2023/01/cancer-s...
- dyauspitr 2y agoInteresting, Australia seems to be actually doing better with cancer survival rates. I truly wonder what the downsides are if any.
- Narkov 2y agoWe/Australia has a massive focus on early detection of skin cancer due to our overly sunny weather. It's possibly that we detect more cancer and treat it earlier thus the better outcomes?
- cjbgkagh 2y agoAFAIK Australian healthcare system is mixed public private with a heavy lean on private. The healthcare market is open to market forces as the government works through subsidies. Plus I think many of the hospitals are religiously run institutions which helps protect from private equity influence. The US has massive government regulation and dysfunctional state intervention in healthcare if not directly then vicariously with rules around Medicare. The US government helps make the dysfunction that private equity later exploits. So I’m not sure that it would be correct to use Aus and the US as examples of the either end of the private / public continuum. I would use UK or France as an example of a public system and Singapore as a light touch private, and perhaps India or Turkey as a laissez-faire system. The UK and France systems appear to be degrading and do not appear long term affordable and I think they will soon be adopting Canadian style Maid systems to cut cost. Germany is a weird one because it seems like half the doctors there are homeopaths and the Germans love their insurance but I’m not sure if they get value for it. Personally I’d prefer the Australian or Singaporean style systems but I’d classify those as mostly private.
- defrost 2y agoAustralia absolutely has a hybrid health care industry with layers; health, medical, surgery, pharmacy and mostly outcomes based regulation rather than much assistance to maximise financial profits. The current system grew out of a more fully public system under a many years past Whitlam government, people like the universal health for all aspects and wanted additional private services in the mix. It's evolved from there, with government oversight directed towards keeping things accessable and fair. The US appears to have "massive government regulation and dysfunctional state intervention" as the end result of a lot of fingers in the pie bending regulation toward "middlecare" providers that don't apply splints or save lives, just diddle about with insurance schemes. (Admittedly that's just an impression from afar). > The US government helps make the dysfunction that private equity later exploits. My feeling is the US government is largely an arm of private interests in many matters. Health Care in Australia embraces public policy such as Food Regulation to ban and limit additives, parks and sports grounds to encourage exercise, limiting access to tobacco, and some interesting national level drug acquisition deals to keep pharmacy costs low. These cause a flow on of less per capita input into the medical side; lower heart disease, less smoking related issues, etc.
- rr808 2y agoAlways when I read this I think they are comparing too very different societies where healthcare is just one factor. Americans are so much less healthy than Australians due to lack of exercise, poor diets, stress, no holidays, guns and crime. Its a miracle that if the US health is nearly as good as Australians it shows how great the US healthcare system really is.
- defrost 2y agoPart of the Australian national, state, and local health care system is policy to encourage healthy life styles and to discourage, limit, or ban food additives, tobacco, etc. Back in the 1970s the AU Government was running campaigns such as Life. Be In It: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GNjEge3Awl8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GNjEge3Awl8 (many short segments airing with commercials on TV). Planning requirements typically require open spaces, walking paths, sporting facilities, etc. A "healthcare system" needs to be more than simply "immediate care for the injured, sick, and|or dying".
- analog31 2y agoUnfortunately, obesity rates are rising worldwide, including in Australia.
- Narkov 2y ago> Ozempic has entered the chat.
- atq2119 2y agoThis honestly feels like the kind of thing where 20 years from now we'll be more aware of the side effects and people will shake heads about how stupid "we" were today. If this is going to be an exception, it'd be truly interesting.
- gquere 2y agoThere are already a bunch of studies showing that the ozempic causes massive muscle loss and lessens bone density. And before anyone remarks "just do resistance training", I doubt the people that take the easy solution will do it in conjunction.
- mbostleman 2y agoFree market-based US healthcare system? Which US are we talking about?
- globular-toast 2y ago"Free market" is one of the best examples of a technical term people use with complete confidence despite not knowing what it really means. Furthermore, even if you do know what it means you probably remember it as something you learnt on day 1 of economics class before learning all the reasons they never really exist and what governments try to do about that.
- valval 2y agoI’ve studied economics for years and I’m still of the opinion that the only government intervention to the market should be breaking monopolies and cartels. I’m waiting for a piece of literature that would convince me otherwise, maybe you could provide one?
- globular-toast 2y agoI can't, but I'm curious how you think problems like externalities would sort themselves out. Also what about natural monopolies like utilities and infrastructure that can't really be broken up?
- valval 2y agoI think humans are excellent survivors. I don’t lose sleep over externalities because of that alone. What I mean by that is that once people realise their daily lives are being affected by a negative externality, they start making decisions that alleviate that hardship. I do recognise though that it’s an unsolved problem, and will lead to some form of regulation as our understanding is lacking. I think only harmful monopolies should be broken up by force, since they’re a legitimate market force. I’m conceding some ground on that because I’m not prepared to claim that monopolies aren’t always harmless.
- 2y ago
- WalterBright 2y agoThe US is hardly a free market health care system. For example, Medicare.
- defrost 2y agoIf you wish you could take that up with Bernard Keane who wrote the piece. https://www.crikey.com.au/author/bernard-keane/ https://www.crikey.com.au/author/bernard-keane/ Bernard is well across many aspects of US, UK, and AU political views, government systems, media etc. with his own particular views as we all have. In context he's writing for an Australian audience about a conservative Australian trope that the Australian health system is weighed down with government meddling and would do better with, for example, a "US free market" approach. I think we all appreciate that's an illusion, a myth spun for children.
- grecy 2y agoI think it’s extremely important to see that it is neither a myth nor an illusion spun for children. It is a carefully constructed plan that will ensure rich people get a whole lot richer and poorer people get worse care. It’s not an accident or nice story. It’s class warfare
- dahart 2y agoDepends on what you mean by health care. Medicare is insurance, not care, and while insurance is part of the system, Medicare often pays private healthcare providers for service. Medicare only insures ~14% of the US, less than one sixth and is only available for people 65 and older. For those reasons, your example maybe doesn’t demonstrate what you imply.
- zeroonetwothree 2y agoI expect it has more to do with Americans’ high level of obesity and other poor lifestyle factors.
- axpvms 2y agoAustralians are not exactly a svelte lot either, ranking 10th in the OECD countries for obesity (US is the third), and on par with the UK.
- danielbln 2y agoYeah, Ozzies also drink like fish, at least when I was living there. Good lord, so much boozing.
- apwell23 2y agoless likely to die from drug overdoses. Older age groups are also less likely to die from chronic diseases such as circulatory problems and heart disease. Cancer mortality rates are lower in Australia than they are in all other Anglophone countries, except among American men aged over 65. And Australians are also less likely to die in road accidents than other countries So why are they getting less chronic diseases despite being equally obese.
- Pikamander2 2y agoObesity's definitely a factor, but other developed countries haven't seen the same level of stagnation despite their own skyrocketing obesity rates. For that matter, Americans also smoke less compared to most of Europe. There's likely at least one other major factor, and I would assume that it's some variation of "inability to access high-quality care for financial reasons" given how much of a wealth disparity there is in various healthcare outcomes.
- apwell23 2y agoOlder age groups are also less likely to die from chronic diseases such as circulatory problems and heart disease. Cancer mortality rates are lower in Australia than they are in all other Anglophone countries So you get less cancer because you have 'access high quality healthcare' ? how does that work? wealth disparity there is in various healthcare outcomes. Wealthy have access to good food. have less stress and engage in mental and physical recreation more and ofcourse regular screenings. Why would it depend just on one factor like hospital access?
- ap99 2y agoMaybe the worse outcome related to other factors, e.g. diet or obesity rates. The figure I see thrown around is America has a 40% rate of obesity. Australia looks like it's 32%. European countries look like 20-30%. I think these rates alone could explain life expetancy regardless of health care system.
- apwell23 2y agoyep exactly. 'healthcare' should be called 'disease care' . Most ppl are too far gone to recover from their illness by the time they go to the doctor. All the medicines they prescribe are merely to manage symptoms. I have GERD and reflux. I was given PPI after many many tests. How does taking PPI extend my lifespan. Whatever has gone wrong with my body is still there. How is this not obvious to ppl making this absurd correlation between hospital care and lifespan. Medicine doesn't have shit of new breed of diseases and disorders ppl are dying from. Doctors don't have answers to any of modern illnesses so how does it matter if access to a useless person is govt funded or 'free market'.
- r2_pilot 2y ago> I have GERD and reflux. I was given PPI after many many tests. How does taking PPI extend my lifespan. Whatever has gone wrong with my body is still there. It can potentially extend your life by reducing your probability of developing esophageal cancers, improve your quality of life in the meantime, and there are other complications from untreated GERD I can't recall but would negatively impact your life.
- apwell23 2y agoThey are only approved for short term use because of myriad of side effects ( including things like life threatening colon inflammation, kidney disease ect)
- yodsanklai 2y ago> The shocking truth: Australia has a world-leading health system — because of governments In the US, government is elected by people. You can't blame a gvt for not doing what it hasn't been mandated to do.
- defrost 2y agoHilarious .. next you'll be saying the two party sink-hole the US electoral system gravitated into is representative of the population at large. Are you touring with this material, or is it off the cuff standup?
- SteveSmith16384 2y agoWhen did the people specifically asked for this kind of system?
- marcusverus 2y agoThe people have never specifically asked for anything, because we're not a direct democracy and we don't have federal referenda. What does that matter?
- blitzar 2y agoWe get the government we deserve.
- weberer 2y ago>the free market-based US healthcare system The healthcare system in the US is far, far from a free market. Most people would describe it as a crony capitalist market. There's a lack of transparency, lack of competition, and lobbyists of established players have too much say in the lawmaking process.
- defrost 2y agoSee: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41856242 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41856242
- apwell23 2y ago"less likely to die from drug overdoses. Older age groups are also less likely to die from chronic diseases such as circulatory problems and heart disease. Cancer mortality rates are lower in Australia than they are in all other Anglophone countries, except among American men aged over 65. And Australians are also less likely to die in road accidents than other countries" So what does this have anything to do with healthcare system ( govt or free market) . Looks like you conflated two unrelated things ?
- anomaly_ 2y agoNext to the USA, Australia provides some of the highest earning opportunities for medical specialists thanks to its very well-developed private sector. A doctor might clock AU$300/400k for a 0.5FTE role at a public hospital, and then bring in another AU$500/600k+ from their private practice (and that's a very low figure for a lot of specialities). As a result, Australia can attract and retain extremely high-quality doctors with the public sector essentially riding the back of the earning potential provided by the private sector. Interestingly, I think the reason you don't often see full private specialists is that due to lack of market forces applying to public healthcare, the public system crowds out the private system on complex/innovative care -- so as a specialist you need to retain a public presence to get access to the high-profile work that you use to support your private billings.