11 ms·
The phone ban has had a big impact on school work
- docfort 2y agoI don't dispute the facts in the article, but this question kept popping up in my mind: how do they define reading time? I mean, in a too-pedantic sense, smartphone screen time is roughly divided into reading, viewing (photos/videos), and gaming. Given that they are not allowed to take the phones, it seems unlikely that the school knows a student's primary usage mode. For example, a student could be reading a bunch of fiction on their phone, thereby reducing their time in the school's library. In other words, how holistic is the metric "reading time?"
- CharlieDigital 2y ago> a student could be reading a bunch of fiction on their phone Parent here. They could be, but let's be realistic here: they're likely not or if they are, they are the minority. My kids have dedicated reading time with physical books and, if they want to, they are always free to read more long form text on their devices (not likely -- that's just reality unless you have a dedicated reading-only device).
- jdiff 2y agoI'm a high school teacher. Not for long, but for a few years now. Never have I ever seen a student reading on their phone. I'm not saying it doesn't happen, but it must be a vanishingly small fraction that I have not yet encountered. When my students are on their phones, it's games, or it's (primarily video-based) social media. A smaller but notable fraction is background media consumption, either music or movies. That's not to say I don't have kids who read, though they're much rarer than the music listeners, just that the readers seem to prefer physical books. So at least in my experience, I wouldn't expect that metric to be vulnerable to this particular flavor of distortion.
- docfort 2y agoThanks for the reality check. I was worried about how I could be conflating my own personal view as a parent with the popular narrative of "kids these days and their Instagram/TikTok." Probably says a lot more about me, but I vastly prefer the reading experience of a thick book on a phone than as a physical copy. And I have since I was a teenager (and it was just PDAs and clever TI-89 hackery).
- Ekaros 2y agoI used to read on PDA and then later on Nokia Internet Tablet. But never in school even if I had one where. At those times it was just games(Bejewelled, Space Trader, DopeWars) or graphic calculator software.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> games(Bejewelled, Space Trader, DopeWars) or graphic calculator software Snake!
- philwelch 2y agoMost people don’t have the patience and attention span to read thick books in the first place. That’s something that you have to develop with practice, and kids who have access to TikTok aren’t going to get that practice.
- hooverd 2y agoI read a lot on my phone as a student.
- Der_Einzige 2y agoI know I’m an autist and Wikipedia addictions are not the norm, but how can people not enjoy reading? I got in trouble all the time in school for reading (real books) during class time when the teacher was lecturing about things I already knew. Do kids like this not exist anymore? I thought autism rates were going up! Seriously, no one reads? I thought kids were getting all political and woke, presumably from reading progressive things? I guess it’s all TikTok mind control? I categorically oppose phone bans on the grounds that it harms the “brilliant lazy”, and that these forces are exactly the kind you want to cultivate. (insert the famous bill gates and 4 types of German officers quote about this here) - but if this class of people has evaporated from the school systems than who am I even defending?
- germinalphrase 2y agoI taught at the high school level for a decade. I would occasionally have students review their usage stats and 1) they were regularly a bit shocked by the number of hours they spend on their phones, and 2) the vast majority of that time was games and social media.
- hintymad 2y ago> smartphone screen time is roughly divided into reading, viewing (photos/videos), and gaming My kids are avid readers, but even they won't read on a phone or a pad or a computer. If they got hold of a phone, they'd always choose either games or viewing videos.
- borski 2y agoI hear you, but not all “reading time” is equal. > For example, a student could be reading a bunch of fiction on their phone, thereby reducing their time in the school's library. That would be a great exception, but very much not the norm. Most kids are not reading long-form books or fiction on their phones.
- tshaddox 2y agoAlso, all reading time in the school library won’t be equal. If the school insists on only certain reading time being valid they ought to just force kids to read a specific set of books. (My personal preference would be for fundamentally less coercive education.)
- borski 2y agoSure. But I can pretty much guarantee the likelihood of finding worthwhile reading material in the school library is significantly higher than the likelihood of finding it on TikTok or X.
- renewiltord 2y agoEven if you were watching them, you don’t know that they don’t have an app that plays a game frame at 1 Hz that they sync their minds to while you see the other 59 frames at 60 Hz and think you’re seeing a book. Without root access to the device and blinkers to ensure they aren’t looking at a second device strategically placed out of sight, you can’t conclude anything.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- insane_dreamer 2y ago> a student could be reading a bunch of fiction on their phone It's a nice thought, but I have kids that age and never have I once seen this happen or heard of it happening with any of their friends/classmates; that's not what phones are for according to GenZ/GenA
- Sakos 2y agoMan, I love reading, but I simply can't focus on reading a long book on my phone. There are too many distractions, too many urges that are way too easy to satisfy with all sorts of time wasters. So if I, as somebody who reads a lot of books and has been an avid reader since childhood, can't resist wasting time and focus on reading on my phone, then I can't imagine any significant number of kids would be able to.
- astrobe_ 2y agoAccording to everyone, I think. E-readers exist for that precise reason, although actual books are the best according to me: no battery, more resilient, can be lent. Phones are great as dictionaries (notably foreign language dictionaries).
- fullspectrumdev 2y agoI find most ereaders to be absolute garbage and just read books on my phone.
- TheRealPomax 2y agoDoomscrolling is not reading. And is the one behaviour above literally any other thing that phones force you into. Their form factor and their apps have converged on the perfect device for "making you keep meaninglessly looking at the device" while reinforcing that behaviour.
- aithrowawaycomm 2y agoSpeaking for myself (a grown-up) I do read a lot on my phone, but it's almost all "brain junk food" like Hacker News comments :) instead of something which slowly develops a complex idea like a book.
- BlueTemplar 2y agoYeah, same issue here. Even worse is the plague that are PDFs, for instance for science papers, the reading of which is a miserable experience due to too big fixed pages (lack of reflow).
- ksymph 2y agoPersonally speaking, myself and my friend group used our phones mostly for reading in high school in the mid-2010s. It's the exception but certainly not unheard of. Those interested in writing are likely to do a lot of reading, and there are many amateur writing communities online that are populated mostly by teenagers.
- itishappy 2y agoPhones make for poor reading devices. My girlfriend spends a lot of time reading light novels on her phone, and I don't understand how. The small format, constant scrolling, and the presence of ads on many apps and sites makes the experience look miserable. I don't know how many kids are using the paid versions of their reading apps, let alone reading long-form content at all. There's been a few studies suggesting reading on paper is better for retention than reading on screens, and I've found one suggesting the size of the screen makes a further difference, but it looks like the latter may have some conflicting findings as well.
- j45 2y agoThere’s a bit more than rough categories. Phones and certain services like social are made to capture, retain and redirect your attention. Students come more out of this tie of constructed consumption origin. The default state is often not idle, boredom, it’s consumption. Relative to that.. There’s productive time and non productive time. Passive consumption va active learning or active creating. It’s easy to see what services accessed at a network level per devices. There’s also digital health built into android and iOS that tracks app usage by time. Another option is apps like opal which help manage things.
- tootie 2y agoThis is the principal of a school saying his policy works but he has no data to back it up. Seems like not a story.
- borski 2y agoQualitative observations can often also be useful, even if they can’t be relied upon as proof.
- tootie 2y agoSure but not when there's a direct conflict of interest. I'd also wager he has loads of data on things like test scores and if he says there's nothing conclusive it likely means the data shows no change.
- borski 2y agoI’d wager he has less data than you think, and even less knowledge of how to analyze it. Like most local school programs, I can pretty much guarantee this was a “let’s see how it goes” and the success metrics were qualitative, not test scores. If students were more attentive, more enthusiastic, etc., those would not be numbers that you could report, but would absolutely be positive results.
- al_borland 2y agoIt could also be the students hide them better, because they aren't allowed to have them. When I visited one of our offices in India there was a phone ban. Employees were given a locker for their phone (and other stuff if they wanted), where the phone was to remain while they were in the work area. Being a visitor, I complied, but then quickly found out almost no one else did. They all secretly had their phones out doing whatever when the boss wasn't looking. I stopped locking mine up after a bit as well after seeing this.
- borski 2y agoThat’s possible, but harder to hide for students than employees. Employees are given, generally, a bit more trust than students are. At a lot of schools, students aren’t even allowed to leave for lunch.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoGlad to see phone bans become more popular. Jonathan Haidt had it on his list of suggestions to parents, to avoid the anxiety generation continuing. He had a longer list but the four big ones were: No smartphones before high school No social media before 16 No phones in schools More free, independent play
- pkphilip 2y agoAll very sensible points. I would add no TV at home till 16
- astrobe_ 2y agoYou just get hooked to radio and get a weird fetish for voices ;-)
- talldayo 2y agoI don't get this. I have very little love for programmed television and news channels these days, but I mostly feel that way because I grew up around them. Reality TV sucks, the news is gruesome, Marvel movies are all the same, HBO just airs different flavors of sex and violence. If you're not exposed to this media and the inherently pulpy context it exists under, you're training your children to treat it as exotic and desirable. You owe it to your next-of-kin to show them the news and global politics in the same way too, lest they fetishize extremism in their late age because they weren't exposed to moderate opinions. On the flip side, I lived in a rural area and my parents would frequently take me to play with kids that had no TV or internet access. Words cannot describe how thick these people can be. One of them was a pair of history buff brothers that weren't allowed to read anything their parents didn't vet - they didn't even know what the Civil War was when I mentioned it. There was a family that lived on a farm, where every time I visited their kids would ask me what weed looks like, what porn was and how alcohol tasted. There were the kids that asked me to recite Newgrounds videos verbatim, explain who "Iron Man" is and even ones that (tragically) didn't know the Mormonism their parents loved was a cult. Rejecting social media is a smart thing to teach anyone, but you have to be extremely careful to not use it as an excuse to shelter them. Sometimes I worry that HN creates a "growth hack" mindset for parents that inhibits them from thinking rationally about how a child develops. It's not a new phenomenon but it seems fear overrides our willingness to empathize with the events of our own childhood. It all feels reminiscent of when people played Mozart for their baby because an unreviewed paper correlated it with higher IQ. Missing the forest for the trees, a bit.
- seydor 2y agoAs essential as smoking ban. I won't be surprised to see this expanded to adult situations
- eloisius 2y agoGod, I’d love to see the smartphone/no smartphone sections in restaurants.
- sebzim4500 2y agoWhat would be the point of a no smartphone section in a restaurant? A concert would make sense though IMO.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> What would be the point of a no smartphone section in a restaurant? It elevates the experience. Going back to the class thing [1], cell phone on the table or cell-phone use during dining is a noticeable thing between e.g. Michelin-starred restaurants and diners. (And I’m only counting N > 1 tables.) [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41820633 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41820633
- ruthmarx 2y ago> It elevates the experience. For who? Not for the people who might want to use one, and for the people who get annoyed seeing someone else using one, that's their problem.
- Dylan16807 2y ago> Not for the people who might want to use one A lot of the people that might want to use one would in fact have a better experience if there was zero or minimal phone use at their table.
- 2y ago
- mhh__ 2y agoOn the reading question raised by another comment: I went to school recently enough that we had smartphones but before tiktok. You were allowed them but they'd be confiscated if seen in lessons or corridors. On balance I'd probably try and get rid entirely, but vividly recall my academic/engineering/whatever awakening being from downloading huge quantities of textbooks and the like onto my phone at the age of 14 or 15, so I wouldn't go stray too far away from modern technology in some sense. I could also argue that this made me quite distracted but (say) also meant that it was the best part of a decade until I would see something, conditioned on that I found it interesting, that I hadn't seen before in formal education.
- iambateman 2y agoI think the question “how do we encourage digital exploration without causing phone addiction” is the defining question of our generation.
- dylan604 2y agoPunish companies that make addictive algorithms. Pre-social media, websites were no where near as damaging
- iambateman 2y agoI definitely plan to limit my kid’s exposure to certain algorithms as much as possible.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> the question “how do we encourage digital exploration without causing phone addiction” is the defining question of our generation One component seems to be not providing them with a networked general-purpose computer out of the gate.
- Nasrudith 2y agoThat is how you wind up with new office workers who don't know how folders or a file system works.
- agrippanux 2y agoI swapped my high school son’s iPhone for an Apple Watch w/cellular for school days and his grades and social life improved significantly.
- mh- 2y agoAnd here our schools don't allow smart watches, depriving me of this (wise) choice.
- hammock 2y agoMy school had to ban Tamagotchis back in the day…
- oblio 2y agoCan't you just give them a dumb phone? Also, why do parents these days need so much that their kids have some an instant communication device?
- Mistletoe 2y agoAt the school by me every day is a line that stretches for blocks of parents picking up their kids at 3pm. All of these cars and human time was previously handled by a school bus and one driver.
- oblio 2y agoWhy does this craziness happen?
- lazide 2y agoBecause clearly a school bus is too expensive. /s
- Spooky23 2y agoPeople are paranoid for a variety of reasons about their kids. Also, culturally, parents don’t let kids walk home. When I was a kid in NYC only the kids bussed in from the hood had busses, the rest of us from the local neighborhood walked. State aid only reimburses for trips beyond a certain radius.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoI have a middle school student and have observed this trend personally. Our school is considering a cell phone ban during school hours (can still bring the phone to school, goes in locker, get it on the way out), which I 100% support. We use parental controls on iOS but those are buggy (and Android even worse from what I heard).
- mh- 2y agoThis is how our school works, and I wouldn't have let my kids go to school with a cell phone if they didn't enforce such a policy.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoThere used to be a Silicon Valley parents versus not divide in my personal observation of kids with smart phones/tablets. It’s now generalised to a class division: the children of the rich tend to have tight restrictions at home and, increasingly, at school, around device use. We need statewide rules if we’re to avoid creating a generational gap in cognitive and social competence.
- kelnos 2y agoThat's not surprising. Rich people can afford childcare for all or a large part of the day, and can instruct their nanny to actually engage the child rather than pacifying them with a tablet screen. Parents who can't afford that will resort to anything to occupy their child when they need a moment of peace, and it's hard to blame them, honestly.
- ruthmarx 2y agoIf we want to avoid creating a generational gap in cognitive and social competence we should outlaw private education ad significantly boost state education.
- lubujackson 2y agoAt my kid's public school in SF, there is one girl who lives the projects that was the first to have a cell phone, like 2nd or 3rd grade. And there are definitely well-off parents who are pushing no phone (and no video games, in some cases) now in 4th grade, with some kids having a watch or phone as needed for club sports etc. But the divide is much less rich vs. poor and more about parental involvement (which has some obvious economic relation, but a stable home life seems more relevant). On the othe hand, I know some families at private schools and those kids seem much less regulated phone-wise.
- andrei-akopian 2y agoSome schools ban phones but allow laptops and tablets. It is the phones specifically that are the problem, not social media. (apparently) My phone usage dropped after I got a personal laptop and an eBook reader. So did pretty much every one else's. The phone is just really inconvenient for anything other than doomscrolling. In my opinion, the lack of alternative activities is overlooked. It is a ban and a prayer that the problem will solve itself.
- insane_dreamer 2y ago> t is the phones specifically that are the problem, not social media. disagree; it's the social media that's the problem; the phone just makes it possible to access it at all times remove social media and you won't have kids on their phones all the time (or, if you're very lucky, they might use them for something productive)
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> remove social media and you won't have kids on their phones all the time This is a testable hypothesis. We shouldn’t conclude either way without more evidence. As it stands, enforcing a phone ban has advantages over an app one.
- andrei-akopian 2y agoFYI: Schools have firewalls that block social media, but kids learn to use VPNs.
- BobaFloutist 2y agoFirewalls also do nothing if the kid has a decent data plan.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoSmall sample size but already tested in my household. Block the social media apps and website and phone use is greatly reduced.
- naming_the_user 2y agoIt really can't be underestimated either for children or adults how much we are dependent on ease of access. If you're stuck in a room and the only thing you can do is read a math textbook you are going to do it. If you are stuck in a room and you have a math textbook and a novel you now have a choice. A phone? A phone is everything else. You're putting "the thing we are supposed to be doing" and "everything else" in the same place. I can't even do it as an adult, I need to put my phone on the other side of the room if I want to read something proper.
- grakker 2y agoIt's amazing to me that people argue about this, using weak personal anecdotes or just strange self-righteousness.
- consf 2y agoManaging distraction in an age where everything is at our fingertips is a hard task
- wkat4242 2y agoIt's not only distraction though. The phone is a window to the internet which offers all the knowledge of the world. And in 'my day' I spent a lot of time at the library which was full of thrillers and comics. And spent most of my time learning about computers and electronics. It's not an unprecedented problem and offers new offers new opportunities too.
- dash2 2y agoHas anyone here tried the Haidt recommendation of "no smartphones till high school, no social media till 16" with their children? Is it better than just banning them in school?
- jedberg 2y agoThe problem is if the school doesn't ban it, it's a lot harder for the parent to enforce. The child will either complain constantly about their friends having it, or just do it behind your back. If there is a school ban, then enforcement happens at school too, making it harder to do behind your back, and the bulk of their social circle isn't on social media, avoiding the FOMO issues.
- itishappy 2y agoHaving personally not had a smartphone or laptop through most of college back when Facebook was still cool (smartphone by choice, laptop by crime), I can say that social media on a library computer is a very different beast. You get most of the social benefits (I'd argue all of the important ones, is instant chat really needed?) while avoiding most of the distractions. So I get the complaint, but I feel like even if kids sneak around behind your back (been there too, lol, I rooted my iBook G4 when my parents added a password) the added friction makes a difference. In other words, kids will be kids, but that shouldn't stop us from setting healthy boundaries. Edit: Bit of a tirade, but I'm trying to say I agree with you! Just trying to add interesting context.
- consf 2y ago[dead]
- karaterobot 2y agoMaybe it's a translation issue, but it seems in this article that the effect on school work (i.e. tests, quizzes, reports, homework assignments, etc.) was not studied, as I think the title of the article implies it was. Rather, they studied the phone ban's effect on school culture and bullying. To be clear, I believe a phone ban in schools would have a positive effect on academics, and that that would show up if it were studied. It's just that it doesn't seem like that's what they did in this case. Thus, arguing about whether phones affect attention span, memory, even reading time, is not relevant in the context of this article.
- fleb 2y agoThere are fewer tests, quizzes, reports and homework assignments in Icelandic grade schools than there used to be, and the results are not great: https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/pisa-2022-results-volume-i-and-ii-country-notes_ed6fbcc5-en/iceland_4e941265-en.html https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/pisa-2022-results-volum... https://icelandmonitor.mbl.is/news/news/2023/12/05/concerning_pisa_survey_showing_icelandic_students_l/ https://icelandmonitor.mbl.is/news/news/2023/12/05/concernin... Academic performance is somewhat of a burning fire - I'd guess there is less of a translation issue with the article than a cultural and political issue around the topic.
- EasyMark 2y agoI was hoping some good studies would come out on this topic.
- andrewinardeer 2y agoOne great thing about phone bans is that it brings equilibrium to teachers. A teacher has a bad day and a kid films the teacher crying? It's all over the socials and teacher is mocked. A kid has a bad day and throws a chair through a window while the teacher films it? Teacher is likely sacked for filming kids at school.
- kelnos 2y ago> A kid has a bad day and throws a chair through a window while the teacher films it? Teacher is likely sacked for filming kids at school. Assuming the teacher doesn't post that video, and only uses it as evidence for what the student did, why would they get fired for this?
- kelnos 2y agoIt has always felt absolutely bonkers to me that smartphone bans weren't put into place instantly across US schools as soon as they started becoming common. I grew up in the 80s and 90s. If I'd brought a handheld game console like a Gameboy or something into class, it would have been confiscated immediately. Sure, I get it, that's not the same thing; obviously phones have other uses. But there is absolutely zero reason a kid needs their smartphone during class. All educational materials should be provided by the school. Kids do not need to be and should not be communicating with anyone outside class. If parents/guardians need to get in touch with kids during an emergency, they can do it the way they've done it as long as we've had the telephone: call the main office and have someone walk to the class to bring the kid to the phone. I do expect that smartphones could actually bring something useful to the classroom -- after all, they grant access to more or less all the world's knowledge -- but the downsides of allowing them far far far outweigh any possible upsides.
- Spooky23 2y agoThere’s a lot of reasons where possessing a phone in school is legit. In cities, transit passes are commonly phone bases. Some apartments require smartphones for gate entry. In class, different story of course.
- lurking_swe 2y agowhy can’t a student leave their phone in the locker? or the teacher has a large bin where all students must put their phone into (powered off) before class starts.
- EasyMark 2y agoIt’s not hard to have a little checkin locker by the teacher’s desk as kids come in. Just make sure they turn the sound off before sliding it into it’s temporary home
- Spooky23 2y agoNah, that’s disruptive. You are going to waste 5 minutes at the start and end of every 40 minute class futzing with phones. I think it has to be in the locker. Kids who don’t have lockers yet, no phone.
- countrymile 2y agoA lot of interesting debate on phone bans right now. Including a great discussion on twitter about how some of the research being used to justify bans is using some dodgy stats: https://x.com/MatthewBJane/status/1843795198109000034 https://x.com/MatthewBJane/status/1843795198109000034
- hackable_sand 2y agoit's not the phones
- musicale 2y agoChatGPT can only be used for homework now.
- ein0p 2y agoBoredom is the main driver of productive pursuits and creativity. That’s why the current dependence on phones and FOMO on general worries me. It is far too easy now to unproductively kill time.
- 0dayz 2y agoI think that kids under 18 should only be allowed to get dumb phones (effectively phones with gps/preloaded apps for things like transit)
- createaccount99 2y ago18 is too old, anyone over 12 should have access to the internet 24/7, as a human right.
- 0dayz 2y agoI do not agree, maybe if websites did their job ensuring that kids didn't have free access to websites that are engineered to keep your attention span for as long as possible. And still my idea is only for phones and other portable devices with easy internet access, since that's the hardest for society and parents to regulate the kids screen time and ensuring the kids don't have access to sites engineered to keep them on for as long as possible.
- HomeDeLaPot 2y agoI've been thinking about going back to a dumb phone. Somehow I always find myself using my smartphone in a way that I regret. Wasting time. Staying up too late. Mindlessly snacking while scrolling. Checking for new dopamine hits whenever I get a few moments to spare. If I were an alcoholic, would it be a good idea to walk around with a bottle of liquor in my pocket?
- browningstreet 2y agoI have a 16 year old nibbling. Very popular. They shared their phone social life with me just last week. They have 2200 unread text messages and 700 active Snapchat conversations. Not a great student. At home, never comes out of their room. Up past midnight on their phone. There’s no way allowing them access to their phone during school allows for any schooling to happen. This is what the school system is up against (in certain kinds of privileged high tech communities). They may already be too old for a hard shift, and it’s too enabled by their home life situation, but their school career already feels set.
- GuB-42 2y agoI am a bit surprised that there is no mention of academic performance, which would be the most obvious indication for a successful policy. Instead, what the article basically says is that banning phones results in kids spending less time on the phone, which is an improvement if your idea of an improvement is having kids do things that don't involve spending time on the phone. There is some circular reasoning here. Note that I am not against the idea that phone bans have positive effects on general well being, academic performance, etc... but for me, this article doesn't sell it very well.
- luyu_wu 2y agoThere've been a lot of studies and meta studies on correlation between cellphone usage and academic performance. IIRC the Pearson correlation coefficient for that has always been hilariously low. Something like -0.1 to -0.2. The argument these days is more about "distraction" caused by cellphone usage instead of something quantitative.