6 ms·
How to stop advertisers from tracking your teen across the internet
- amelius 2y agoIf only Congress realized that some of these advertisers and data brokers answer to the CCP ... maybe we could have a tracking-free internet.
- hulitu 2y ago> If only Congress realized that some of these advertisers and data brokers answer to the CCP ... maybe we could have a tracking-free internet. Yes, but Google, Microsoft and Meta answer to Uncle Sam. Why intetfere with their business ? /s
- j-bos 2y agoYou kid but perhaps https://www.vulnu.com/p/government-wiretaps-in-u-s-internet-providers-infiltrated-by-chinese-hackers https://www.vulnu.com/p/government-wiretaps-in-u-s-internet-...
- philwelch 2y ago[flagged]
- curiousgal 2y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Much of Congress answers to the CCP too What nonsense. No it doesn’t. By the same standard of evidence, the CCP answers to American interests.
- hnpolicestate 2y agoCats gotta be out of the bag long by now. Am I to believe Google classroom isn't storing my students information, from as young as 3rd grade, to sell to 3rd parties once they turn 18? Or am I naive to think they aren't already selling it while they are literally children?
- nvarsj 2y agoMost kids just stay logged as as their google classroom email, so that includes search/youtube/etc. Of course Google is tracking all that usage and targeting them for ads.
- hnpolicestate 2y agoBy the time they turn 18, Google will have such a perfect model of who they are. Will sell to the CIA, FBI etc. Complete profiles of how citizens think. Really evil stuff.
- nox101 2y agothis is a lie and you feel ashamed and stop spreading it. Google doesn't sell profles period and doesn't sell data to the fbi/cia The only evil here is you spreading false info
- hnpolicestate 2y agoYou are either being dishonest or are just ignorant. User data is disclosed to advertisers when they auction for ad placement. Many of those advertisers then sell the user data they collect through the auction, whether or not they win the auction, to other parties. It's a virtual certainty the FBI, CIA, NSA etc purchase that information. Your argument is basically Google didn't do anything wrong because they are not the direct point of sale. But they aren't fools. They know what happens to the data they disclose to advertisers. It's repackaged and sold again.
- 2y ago
- canada_dry 2y agoI would hazard to guess that Google classroom (starting at Kindergarten and continuing through post secondary) software is mostly installed via next-next-finish (i.e. whatever the defaults set by Google are). I'd also assume that these defaults are set to very minimal privacy protection for students. Having this digital record entrusted to any company that is not under strong privacy controls should be frightening to parents. School administrators figure the low-cost low-barrier-to-entry is well worth the long term privacy risk to children. * Fortunately my children were out of school when this became common place - so kindly correct me if I'm mistaken.
- Loughla 2y agoGoogle for education has very thorough and strict privacy controls. They have to, most states have pretty strict laws around that anymore.
- hnpolicestate 2y agoYou are correct but it's worse than that. School admins are full blow ignorant to technological privacy risks for children and themselves. Same goes for teachers if I'm being honest. Just assume their level of understanding is equivalent to the general population. They are ambivalent/confused when you try and explain it.
- ykonstant 2y agoThis is one of the situations where I would use a more baity title: "Protect your teen from non-consensual ad tracking". The subject is boring and abstract enough that you need all the trigger words you can muster to garner the interest of the public at large.
- lovethevoid 2y agoThis is the larger problem with discussions on privacy. Anti privacy articles are often very emotionally charged “Apple REFUSES to unlock killers iPhone”, and pro-privacy ones are more neutral like “Why end to end encryption is important”. I understand the attempt to remain neutral sounding, but all that’s doing is making it easier for people to ignore.
- 23B1 2y agoThe best minds of our generation are being used to stalk children in order to sell their data to autocrats and monopolists. Digital Moloch.
- lolinder 2y ago> The best minds of our generation are being used to... This idea is repeated often in threads like this and I'm not at all sure where it comes from. Do the best minds of our generation all go into tech? No. Do the best minds that go into tech all go into software engineering? No. Do the best minds that go into software engineering go to work at Google and Facebook and other advertisers? No. Do the best minds that go to work at Google and Facebook and other advertisers work on advertisements and tracking? No. If it were possible to come up with a rigorous definition of "best minds", I see no particular reason to believe that such a definition would have substantial overlap with "pursues FAANG salaries", much less "works on ad tech".
- stonethrowaway 2y ago> This idea is repeated often in threads like this and I'm not at all sure where it comes from. I think you have a reasonable idea and you’re playing the devils advocate.
- lolinder 2y agoI'm definitely not playing devil's advocate, I genuinely and fervently disagree with the notion that the brightest minds of our generation work on (or even adjacent to) ad tech. The only explanation I've been able to come up with for the idea is that some people assume that the "best minds" of our generation will tend to optimize for salary above all else and therefore would (since they're smart enough to find the high salaries) end up working in a FAANG company as a software engineer. That doesn't seem like a very convincing argument (hence, I'm not sure it's actually the origin), but I haven't yet seen a better explanation.
- stonethrowaway 2y ago