5 ms·
Cloudflare beats patent troll so badly it basically gives up
- btown 2y agoDiscussion on the Cloudflare announcement: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41730415 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41730415
- metadat 2y agoThanks! Macro-expanded: Patent troll Sable pays up, dedicates all its patents to the public https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41730415 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41730415 - Oct 2024 (409 comments) Others?
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoNo. There are no others. It's too recent. Because it's a DUPE.
- metadat 2y agoIt's not actually a dupe, it's a related submission. Thanks for your diligence.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoIt's just a news story reporting on the cloudflare announcement. It brings nothing new to the story. It's a dupe. No need to split the discussion up, of which there is plenty, days ago, over there. No need to make us see the story over and over again on different links. Share the link over there in the discussion if it adds anything. OP is wasting our time, as per.
- normanthreep 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41730415 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41730415
- xbar 2y agoSabre was a charming little Santa Clara network company, decades ago. But some incompetent entrepreneurs and a shabby LA law firm tried to win at a patent trolling. The outcome is hilarious only because I am not paying Cloudflare's lawyers.
- iwontberude 2y agoThanks for the context, not sure why people downvoting you.
- fortran77 2y agoBecause it's "Sable" not "Sabre" (That's why I downvoted.)
- xbar 2y agoI regret my typo, which remains.
- floydnoel 2y agoit's always morally correct to downvote anyone who makes a typo, is that your position?
- quesera 2y agoThis typo is especially confusing because Sabre is a different, well-known, often-discussed, company that holds lots of patents around airline scheduling. Downvoting (and the consequent CSS dimming) is one way to deprioritize a conversation-derailing comment. Even if the derailment was an accident. No personal antipathy is necessarily required or implied.
- ninju 2y agoNo…not all typos are the same. The nature of typo (messing up the name of the patent troll) is what made the reply very important.
- 2y ago
- mmoustafa 2y ago> "In the end, Sable agreed to pay Cloudflare $225,000, grant Cloudflare a royalty-free license to its entire patent portfolio, and to dedicate its patents to the public, ensuring that Sable can never again assert them against another company," Holy cow, that’s incredible. Cloudflare has single-handedly shut down one of the biggest tech patent trolls. I don’t know how they possibly got Sable to agree to those terms, but kudos to Cloudflare counsel.
- CodeWriter23 2y agoSable was on the hook for costs after losing. I imagine this settlement was a fraction of what they owed. If there is truly justice in this world, Sable principals will have to go out of pocket for tax liabilities and costs associated with shutting it down.
- ozim 2y agoSo it was not justice - just predatory capitalism finding out that there is always a bigger fish. Cloudflare wasn’t doing that from goodness of their heart, they were protecting their own profits.
- shawabawa3 2y agoI'm sure it would have been cheaper (in the short term) for cloudflare to have just paid off the troll, like everyone else does It's absolutely a public service for them to have fought them
- SllX 2y agoBeating a patent troll in court is predatory capitalism? I think you’re forgetting Sable was the aggressor (aka the Plaintiff), and they lost their suit in a court of law. Nobody is obligated to roll over and show their bellies if they can win against an unjust lawsuit.
- floydnoel 2y agopatents are granted by the government. hardly seems like a problem with capitalism.
- throwaway48476 2y agoIt likely cost CF millions in legal fees. It's not exactly a win in the fight against patent trolls.
- lolinder 2y agoIt's an expensive win, but how is it not a win? A troll is dead.
- otherme123 2y agoThis is like hitting back a bully in highschool: you will probably lose the fight, and even if you win you'll get good bruises. But in the long term you win, because now everybody knows you will hit back.
- EGreg 2y agoI never understood this “common wisdom” about bullies being actually wimps who won’t touch you after you hit back once. It has never rung true to me. It paints all bullies with a broad brush and tells kids to take their chances physically engaging a larger kid acting like a psychopath. Bullies may either have psychological issues, abuse issues at home with their family, or they may be in a gang. “Standing up to a bully” in junior high or high school may get you jumped by the whole gang, maybe even stabbed. The bully may harbor a grudge and make sure to make an example of you. More broadly, this idea countries have that “this time we’ll retaliate and hit them so hard, they won’t retaliate and hit us back anymore” is what leads to endless escalation in wars. There are better ways to deal with bullies than “standing up to them” as an individual.
- pchristensen 2y agoIt’s not just about you - if a bully starts to believe that others will fight back, and if other bullied see that they can stand up to the bully, and especially if others support those that stand up, it changes the calculus and bullying is less worth it.
- 2y ago
- rmbyrro 2y agoAlthough this is a dupe of a ~1500pt previous discussion, I'd love to see these news on HN front page for several days. It's so delighting to read
- lofaszvanitt 2y agoRemember, this doesn't mean that you, the small guy, must not patent anything, on the contrary.
- spcebar 2y agoI can't help but worry that the people behind Sable will just go and start another shell company and once again engage in this bad behavior.
- zulban 2y agoIndeed. Some people are unlikely to stop unless they're in prison.
- quesera 2y agoYes, that seems likely -- and business-expedient. But this establishes a visible precedent that corporate counsel can use as inspiration for future litigate-vs-capitulate decisions. Cloudflare cannot solve the problem for everyone (that would require new legislation), but they did achieve a big win here. Hopefully it will begin a pattern.
- jalapenos 2y agoOne step short of "and the directors of Sable will be paraded around in public in gimp suits"
- bluelightning2k 2y agoWeird that nobody in comments is mentioning that this is also a PR win. It does a few things: 1. Makes it far less likely they get sued for patents 2. Gives them phenomenal leverage in any other type of lawsuit where they are defending - "if you think we're bluffing that we will take this all the way..." 3. It's a great PR win, winning coverage and widespread respect. I am absolutely certain it was worth the money for this alone