8 ms·
Everything we know about spies is wrong
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/iuMg6 https://archive.ph/iuMg6
- PaulHoule 2y agoReminds me of the joke in Get Smart where they give Max a suicide pill and he asks "How do I get them to take it?" Also the time when the manager of a supermarket (who looked like an FBI agent from a 1970s movie) thought I was shoplifting (I was going the wrong direction and did look scruffy and had a big bag with an open top) and followed me out holding a clipboard that I'm sure he would have whacked me with and said it was an accident if I'd given him any trouble.
- ahazred8ta 2y agoDon Adams and Jonathan Harris were in an earlier 1963 show. They did "Oh, the pain", "Missed it by that much", and "Would you believe?" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I-jtYPHftfY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I-jtYPHftfY When GRU defector Viktor Suvorov was in training, he was told, "This is what a spy looks like:" (shifty man in fedora with his collar turned up) "You are not allowed to look like this."
- nativeit 2y agoThe story of Nora Inayat Khan is an affecting tale of incredible bravery, heroism, and selfless sacrifice. She nearly survived the war, but was captured only days before she was due to be extracted, and died at the hands of one of Germany’s most sadistic torturers. Nora Khan was a “regular” citizen who rose to the moment, committed herself entirely to the allied cause, and nearly single-handedly maintained radio contact between Paris and London during a critical stage of the conflict.
- mangamadaiyan 2y ago> regular citizen Almost, but not quite. She had royal blood on both sides of her father's family: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noor_Inayat_Khan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noor_Inayat_Khan Not that this takes away anything from what you wrote, I just happened to be in one of my pedantic moods :)
- priprimer 2y agoroyal blood is one of them ideas even worse than the notion of race
- mangamadaiyan 2y agoI used "royal blood" to mean that she was in some sense privileged -- nothing more. Bad turn of phrase, I guess.
- belter 2y agoYeah...Declare one person special by birth, and suddenly everyone remotely related claims they're elite too, spreading hierarchy through society...:-) I recognize only one sovereign:...The Burger King
- snapcaster 2y agoLong may he reign
- readthenotes1 2y agoMy heart aches for you. As does, no doubt, your stomach.
- belter 2y agoWe all serve someone...I just prefer mine flame-grilled...
- pwillia7 2y ago
- kalaksi 2y agoThis reminds me... Anyone interested in spy stuff should check out The Bureau (2015). It's an excellent spy series and also a nice change in style compared to the usual Hollywood productions.
- JKCalhoun 2y agoLe bureau des légendes (French title) is an amazing show. Five seasons (the first three probably the superior ones). The first season it's fun to watch and wrestle with whether you would want to be an agent or not. (Eventually I decided I would love to be an agent — but not the high-profile kind — I would want to be the Mémé or Pépé characters from the series — or one of the techies that work in the office).
- joncrocks 2y agoI believe there is a remake of this in production at the moment (working title "The department"). https://theplaylist.net/joe-wright-to-direct-the-department-spy-series-starring-michael-fassbender-20240307/ https://theplaylist.net/joe-wright-to-direct-the-department-...
- dventimihasura 2y ago"What the hell do you think spies are? Moral philosophers measuring everything they do against the word of God or Karl Marx? They're not! They're just a bunch of seedy, squalid bastards like me: little men, drunkards, queers, henpecked husbands, civil servants playing cowboys and Indians to brighten their rotten little lives." https://youtu.be/lNrjAMV0HJk?si=Fbk3fE-Ufm3ACxgv&t=86 https://youtu.be/lNrjAMV0HJk?si=Fbk3fE-Ufm3ACxgv&t=86
- dventimihasura 2y agoHere's just some of what these "librarians, professors, and researchers" were up to: https://www.npr.org/2014/11/05/361427276/how-thousands-of-nazis-were-rewarded-with-life-in-the-u-s https://www.npr.org/2014/11/05/361427276/how-thousands-of-na... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Midnight_Climax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Midnight_Climax
- agys 2y agoThat’s what a spy would say…!
- _yb2s 2y agoCool article. They are saying to use a regular book as a way of numerically referencing your message, but then aren't you limited to some generic phrase from that book? It seems to me, at least in pre-computer times, that a regular book would work fairly well as a one-time pad. Especially something widely available, innocuous, and very long, like a bible. You'd probably want to add something like an offset, and a rule to skip letters (e.g. use every 3rd letter) so there are no real words to provide predictability. Guessing the book, offset, and skip rule would be a massive space- on the order of billions of possibilities. With modern computers of course, this method would be easy to crack.
- WolfeReader 2y agoIf the adversary discovers the book that your spy is using - through any trivial surveillance method - then all communication which that spy has participated in, and will participate in, just got compromised. Part of the appeal of a real one-time pad is that no previous communications can be deciphered again, even by the agents themselves.
- BanazirGalbasi 2y agoThe idea is that there's several layers. If the spy appears like a normal citizen, then they won't be surveilled closely, so the book is less likely to be discovered. Keeping multiple books around means it's less suspicious that they have any given book - you just like to read. Why would the specific book be "discovered" when it's in a stack or shelf of them? You also don't have to send an encoded message in every letter. If you have plenty of plaintext correspondence with a distant friend, and only some of it has any special meaning, then it will be less suspicious in the first place. The whole idea is to blend in and not attract surveillance in the first place. Your counter-argument is based on the premise that blending in has already failed, in which case you're right - the game is up and the spy is compromised. Worse, it's possible to intentionally feed them bad information without them knowing (which happened multiple times in WWII). But this entire article (and the book it discusses) is about preventing that entirely.
- nonrandomstring 2y ago
- yapyap 2y agoThis article is for everyone that pictures James Bond when they hear the word spy
- wongarsu 2y agoWhich may be common but is a bit silly: even in the Bond universe James Bond is an extreme outlier, one of ~5 double-O agents in a much bigger agency. And he regularly interacts with normal spies
- romanhn 2y agoHighly recommend watching The Americans, an incredible show about Soviet spies pretending to be a regular American family. Based somewhat on real people, and very well-researched.
- victorbjorklund 2y agoFun show but hardly anything realistic (other than russia having spies that work the long game pretending to be normal citizens)
- slowmotiony 2y agoI can recommend the french show "Le Bureau des Legends". It's written with the help of various consultants from the intelligence community and tries to be as realistic as possible, with most actual spies in the show being regular university students, office workers, psychologists, or even cafeteria staff. It's a fantastic show, although not very hollywood, so don't expect explosions or shootouts.
- walterbell 2y ago2005-2006 Canadian series Intelligence, at the intersection of organized crime, law enforcement and intelligence is also good, https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0845746/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0845746/. Elsewhere on the Möbius loop lies the madcap 2009-2024 animated series Archer, with a string of award nominations and blink-and-you-will-miss-it references, https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1486217/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1486217/ The 2014-2017 series Turn dramatized New York farmers and shopkeepers who comprised the first US spy ring, including Benedict Arnold storyline, https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2543328/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2543328/
- pseingatl 2y agoIRL intelligence from a potential informant was disregarded because a similar story was told in Le Bureau so the authorities presumed the informant just got the information from the show. He didn't. There were other hostages. Not to mention the captagon warehouses. Or the Syrian intelligence network. But what can you do when their minds are made up and they don't want to listen? All info vetted by retired CIA, btw.
- red_admiral 2y agoThis is pure gold, and still works on the internet to get the specs for PLA tanks: > If she wants to know something specific, but doesn’t want people to notice her asking questions, she should simply make incorrect statements while in the company of experts. Her companions will correct her, especially if they’re men.
- praptak 2y agoI heard this one about Linux in the '90s. "If you need help with doing something in Linux, don't ask for help - you'll get ignored. Just boldly state Linux can't do that and you'll have PhDs running to prove you wrong."
- bonestamp2 2y agoIt works on hacker news and reddit too, for almost any subject.
- qazxcvbnmlp 2y agoThe comments that get the most replies often have something slightly wrong and related to hot button topics for this audience.
- praptak 2y agoIt also works in reverse, when checking someone's story with an untrusted third party (say a suspect's friend). Ask them about the story with some facts wrong. If they don't correct you, the story is probably false and they are just confirming anything.
- neilv 2y agoRelated, around 2000, knowing which hardware device to buy for any/good Linux compatibility could be difficult. And even among supported devices, some had better drivers (currently, or imminently), and some hardware itself was buggier than others. I had access to some kernel developers, but they didn't have time for people's FAQs about current device compatibility. So what I really did do, at least once, was to narrow down the options on my own, and then (lying) mention, in the enthusiastic manner that people did, that I'd just ordered such-and-such device for Linux. As you'd guess, but it was still impressive to see happen for real, suddenly there were a number of experts telling me what I should've bought instead. Question answered. I then admitted my deceit.
- breaker-kind 2y ago> everything you know and think about spies is wrong > The school’s first explosives instructor was Bill Cumper, a boisterous character who walked around with his pockets full of bomb parts and “a detonator behind his ear as if it were a cigarette.” come on. we can acquiesce that people were maybe getting a little crazy with it
- tolerance 2y agoHa-ha. Hee-hee. Is the relationship between academia, the media and intelligence agencies ongoing?
- jasonvorhe 2y agoIs anyone else burned out of these headlines? Doing X for fun and profit Everything we knew about X is wrong I did X for $timespan and Y happened
- ziddoap 2y agoTitle it in any other format and people will say it is clickbait.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 2y agoThough, of course, it's all clickbait because that's the whole point. But there's something enlightening I read in the leaked MrBeast on-boarding PDF (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41549649 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41549649) when it talks about the viewer drop-off at the start of the video there's a mention about not "match[ing] the expectations of the clickbait". (It is easy to find because there's only one instance of "clickbait" in the document.) I wonder about the practical reason this occurs but I suspect the reality for a given individual could range from being an impatient reader to encountering a poorly-written article. I also wonder how the perception would differ (not trying to start a debate, just noting a thought) if the title here included the "Why" from the title there since, at least in this case, the article does a decent job of answering the question: they don't want to appear as spies.
- digging 2y agoBut this title is clickbait. It's a lie. It could have been "How real spies were nothing like movie spies."
- ziddoap 2y agoYes, yes. I've counted about 15 different submissions today alone that have someone complaining about the title being clickbait. Your complaint makes 16. It's always clickbait. If the title was your suggestion, someone else would say it's clickbait because spies are somewhat like the movies.
- next_xibalba 2y agoI'm currently reading "Dark Sun: The Making of the Hydrogen Bomb". The first section of the book focuses on the Russian A-Bomb program in the 1940s and how much of it was accelerated through espionage conducted against the US and UK. I'm struck by how painful a slog spying was. These spies were always effectively working two jobs and much of the nuts and bolts of spying and conveying information to handlers sounds like boring, thankless work. Often, the spies were not paid at all. There are excerpts where handlers bemoan the difficulty and lack of compensation of their spies. All-in-all, it sounds like a crappy job. You really had to be a true believer, I guess. And yet, in the 1940s at least, the Soviets were absolutely looting the Americans. During the lend-lease program between the US and Russia, planes were flown out of Montana to the USSR. US military officers recalled Soviets flying dozens of large briefcases on each flight. Once, a US officer inspected those briefcases and found detailed factory schematics, product and process diagrams and plans, reels and reels of detailed photographs of machinery and parts, and classified documents on the R&D of uranium enrichment. Apparently, in light of this discovery of massive industrial theft, the U.S. took no action.
- Log_out_ 2y agoThe memory of the gilded age was fresh back then, we forgot that those expected to fight were expected to fight for railway and sugarcane barons, poverty and a greatly depressed world. They had no idea of the golden years to come,to temporary moat communism.
- jordemort 2y agoSounds like something a spy would say
- anthomtb 2y agoIf you find yourself in Washington DC, I highly recommend a visit to the International Spy Museum. Its one of the few attractions in DC you need to pay for but worth the ticket price. (Spoiler Alert) At the end, there's mural or placard that says something like: Most exhibits in this museum are here because of failure. The best spies are the ones you never hear of.
- underseacables 2y agoIf you're in DC, rather than pay to go to the spy Museum with the tourists, etc. go up 95 just south of Baltimore, Washington international Airport and go to the NSA museum. It's free. Enigma galore. You could also go south of DC about 30 minutes to Warrenton, where the cold war museum is. It's also free and run bY Francis Gary Powers Jr.
- dgacmu 2y agoWe've made a bit of a family thing of visiting spy museums, and would say: Visit both! (And if you have the opportunity for some reason, the CIA museum is also fantastic, but not open to the public). The Spy Museum has better flashy interactive exhibits for kids, but underneath all of the sound and light has a _very_ impressive collection. The National Cryptologic Museum is, as one might expect, more focused on the cryptography side of things as opposed to the more general spycraft collection in both the Spy Museum and the CIA's museum, and is a better one if you're particularly interested in ciphers and codebreaking. The Spy Museum & CIA museum have more exhibits of hidden microphones, weapons, communication devices, etc. The German Spy Museum (Deutsches Spionage Museum) in Berlin is also quite good and also good for kids. It is, unsurprisingly, particularly deep in Stasi-related materials. They have a fascinating exhibit of a car whose door had been filled with infrared lights for taking covert nighttime photographs, at really mindblowing cost. Also note that the NSA's collection has an online portal: https://5099.sydneyplus.com/final/Portal/Default.aspx?lang=en.US.%20 https://5099.sydneyplus.com/final/Portal/Default.aspx?lang=e.... And the CIA Museum's collection is partly online: https://www.cia.gov/legacy/museum/ https://www.cia.gov/legacy/museum/ (Sorry. I don't know how we became spy museum fans but the kids adore them. :-)
- rramadass 2y agoPeople interested in this stuff should check out; 1) Deception: The Invisible War Between the KGB and the CIA by Edward Jay Epstein - https://archive.org/details/Deception-TheInvisibleWarBetweenTheKGBAndTheCIA https://archive.org/details/Deception-TheInvisibleWarBetween... 2) Brainwashing: The Science of Thought Control by Kathleen Taylor - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brainwashing:_The_Science_of_Thought_Control https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brainwashing:_The_Science_of_T... 3) Yuri Bezmenov's lectures (available on Youtube) on "Subversion Model/Psychological Warfare" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yuri_Bezmenov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yuri_Bezmenov and https://bigthink.com/the-present/yuri-bezmenov/ https://bigthink.com/the-present/yuri-bezmenov/ Caution: If you go down this rabbit-hole it will seriously alter your perception of "Reality" itself and you can end-up endlessly second-guessing/triple-guessing etc. everything you experience and think about.
- mdhb 2y agoJust as a heads up Yuri was called out as largely being full of shit by people like Jack Barsky who was basically the IRL version of the TV the Americans. Also I’m not familiar with that second link but it gives me major red flags at first glance. There is some ok stuff out there on that topic. One of the darker ones that comes to mind came out of the 80s when Hezbollah kidnapped the CIA station chief in Lebanon and then basically used him as a real life experiment of just how badly can you psychologically torture someone and give them the slowest shittiest death possible I think it was a 15 month process in the end and it’s probably one of if not the most horrifying story I’ve ever heard. There’s lots of places to get that story but I believe one of the people who lead that torture also wrote a book about it but I’ve not read it personally.
- rramadass 2y agoThere is a lot of info. on Bezmenov both pro and con and you have to listen to what he says and form a judgement yourself as to whether that is plausible. Everything about him has been muddied (even how exactly he died!) and hence all sources are questionable. The second book on "Brainwashing" is unfortunately named (not to be confused with an older book of the same name by L.Ron Hubbard of Scientology infamy) but the author's credentials are stellar - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kathleen_Taylor_(biologist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kathleen_Taylor_(biologist) It is not a woo-woo book but a scientific one; the last paragraph in the wikipedia page states; Peter Knight believes that Taylor sufficiently "argues that there is no need to invoke the notion of brainwashing as a mysterious and fear-inducing explanation as a last resort" – to Taylor, "brainwashing is less scary than people might think because it is in fact not some magical, secret and ultra-efficient technique of thought control" but a "mundane and ubiquitous" neurological phenomenon that can be understood scientifically. The first book on "Deception" will in a sense set the background since it focuses on deception as fundamental to everything else. This has already been called out in ancient classic texts on statecraft/warfare by Kautilya, Sun Tzu, Machiavelli etc. Example excerpt; They were a metaphor for a world in which he saw deception as a norm rather than an aberration. It was a world in which intelligence services could be provoked, seduced, lured into false trails, blinded, and turned into unwitting agents—through the same failure to discriminate between real and simulated information. The reason it is important for the "common man" to learn about these is because many of these techniques are being used against him under the guise of "harmless business" PR/Advertising/Sales/Marketing/Influence etc. and much much worse eg. Nationalism, Religious Fundamentalism etc. PS: One more book to read (difficult) is "Propaganda: The Formation of Men's Attitudes" by Jacques Ellul - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda:_The_Formation_of_Men%27s_Attitudes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda:_The_Formation_of_M... Excerpts below; "Very frequently propaganda is described as a manipulation for the purpose of changing idea or opinions of making individuals 'believe' some idea or fact, and finally of making them adhere to some doctrine—all matters of the mind. It tries to convince, to bring about a decision, to create a firm adherence to some truth. This is a completely wrong line of thinking: to view propaganda as still being what it was in 1850 is to cling to an obsolete concept of man and of the means to influence him; it is to condemn oneself to understand nothing about propaganda. The aim of modern propaganda is no longer to modify ideas, but to provoke action. It is no longer to change adherence to a doctrine, but to make the individual cling irrationally to a process of action. It is no longer to transform an opinion but to arouse an active and mythical belief." Education permits the dissemination of propaganda in that it enables people to consume information. Information is indistinguishable from propaganda in that information is an essential element of propaganda because for propaganda to succeed it must have reference to political or economic reality. Propaganda grafts itself onto an already existing reality through "informed opinion".
- amenhotep 2y agoCtrl+f Carre - 0 matches? Not particularly strong engagement with the canon. There are spy stories that aren't James Bond!
- photochemsyn 2y agoRichard Rhodes "Dark Sun: The Making of the Hydrogen Bomb" contains detailed coverage of Soviet espionage efforts inside the United States, from the exfiltration of secrets from Los Alamos to a much broader program of industrial manufacturing information gathering (note the Soviets were allies so this latter program didn't really cross any lines). https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/books/99/09/19/specials/rhodes-dark.html https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/books/99/09/19/s... Another interesting one is "The Nazis Next Door" about the US recruitment of ex-Nazis after WWII as spies in the growing Cold War, many with records of war crimes, who were resettled in the USA after their overseas service was completed. https://www.npr.org/2014/11/05/361427276/how-thousands-of-nazis-were-rewarded-with-life-in-the-u-s https://www.npr.org/2014/11/05/361427276/how-thousands-of-na... Incidentally, there's a big difference between a spy and an assassin, and James Bond was not a spy - he was an assassin who was 'licensed to kill'. It's a mistake to conflate these two things, even if they're both managed by the same intelligence agency.
- tolerance 2y agoI appreciate how the comment that takes the subject matter more serious than others (down to the final line) is at the bottom. Thank you for the recommendations.
- marcellus23 2y ago> In the movies, spies are usually ripped hunks who carry lots of gadgets, like James Bond and Jason Bourne. Neither James Bond nor Jason Bourne were really "ripped hunks." Maybe an argument could be made for Daniel Craig, but really most Bonds and Bourne were just kind of handsome, charming men who knew their way around a gun.
- WillAdams 2y agoSean Connery jump-started his career by participating in a Mr. Universe contest.
- marcellus23 2y agoSure, but that was 10 years before he was James Bond. He was not skinny by any means but I wouldn't call him a "ripped hunk". To me that suggests someone like The Rock.
- Rzor 2y agoJason Bourne also didn't carry lots of gadgets. I think Craig was somewhat light on it too.
- t43562 2y agoI like this because films have promoted a bullshit view of various aspects of life with the defense of "its entertainment" but I think a lot of us (including me) have believed bits of it because we have no contrary evidence. On a completely different note, my favorite fictional spy, Bernard Sampson, says something like this (can't find the exact quote) "experienced agents are like nervous old ladies - always worrying about everything." Essentially that "brave" agents are either inexperienced or dead. Sampson is able to do things like shoot but overall he feels its a sign of incompetence if it becomes necessary. If you haven't already, try the "Game, Set, Match" trilogy.
- _def 2y agoThe first sentence is so disappointing. Are we really living in a world where people think stuff is like "in the movies" and where people think that's the primary source for learning?
- AlbertCory 2y ago"Everything WE know" ??? Nobody thinks it's like James Bond. there are tons of books and TV shows about real-life espionage, including by people who went through the CIA's training course.
- Animats 2y agoThere are lots of books by actual agents. If everything you know about spies is wrong, you've been reading the wrong books. There are histories of intelligence. From WWII, Reinhart Gelhen (Nazi side) [1] and William Colby (US side) [2] both wrote good books. The CIA calls their field HUMINT people "case officers."[3] They recruit spies, people who are on the inside of something, but rarely spy themselves. That's how it's really done. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinhard_Gehlen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinhard_Gehlen [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Colby https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Colby [3] https://www.cia.gov/careers/jobs/case-officer/ https://www.cia.gov/careers/jobs/case-officer/
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- _whiteCaps_ 2y agoAn excellent book about a real spy between WWI and II is "Cracking the Nazi Code" by Jason Bell. It's not about encryption, it's about how Canada had someone who understood the German people and how he predicted Hitler's rise to power.
- kjellsbells 2y agoSOE training manual, from the UK national archives, converted to PDF with some introductory text: https://ironwolf008.wordpress.com/espionage/ https://ironwolf008.wordpress.com/espionage/