4 ms·
Pilots Are Dying of Tiredness. Tech Can't Save Them
- snitzr 2y agoThis can't be safe.
- ziddoap 2y agoYeah, people are literally dying.
- cut3 2y agoI turned down a job to design monitoring software for pilots and other operators of heavy machinery because of how orwellian it all was. The software was measuring blink quantity and would penalize drivers for too much blinking so drivers started to wear sunglasses to combat it and management was livid. The human operators were the enemy to this company and it felt horrible even interviewing.
- morkalork 2y agoHow's that work for anyone with allergies? (I'm guessing it doesn't). Getting penalized because it's ragweed season or whatever is bullshit of the highest order.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- account42 2y agoFor safety critical jobs like piloting such "discrimination" mayb be warranted.
- meiraleal 2y agois blinking too much a indicator os sleepiness? if so that would make sense to track (not penalize).
- bpodgursky 2y agoWhen my 3 year old is tired he starts blinking reeeeaaaaallllllyyyyy sllloooooowwwwwlllly. There's clearly signal here if you use it responsibly.
- mdgrech23 2y agoThat is messed up. These dudes have to work so hard to afford scraps they're literally falling asleep at the wheel and gaming the system to get more time behind the wheel so they can get more cash to afford to live in this country. We need to address wage inequality folks.
- anonym29 2y agoWage inequality is not a problem because the gini coefficient does not measure how great or terrible your life is, how financially constrained you are, how much money limits your freedom, etc. Forget about PPP for a moment and just pretend goods cost the same everywhere for the sake of this example. A country where everyone has $0 and makes $1/year has a "perfect" gini coefficient, indicating perfect wealth and income distributions. A country where everyone's a millionaire, but where some people make a million a year and others make a billion a year has a much worse gini coefficient, and yet is still the place you'd rather live in, out of these two examples. The suffering by the people of the former is not mitigated by their high gini coefficient, because their suffering is a result of poverty, not a result of inequality. The celebrations of prosperity by the latter occur in spite of inequality. The takeaway is clear - equality or inequality have a completely non-causal relationship with the quality of life of the people in the region being measured. Further, adviocacy for combatting inequality sounds laudable at face value, but underneath the surface, what does it look like? After all, here in the west we're all the rich oppressors who benefit from economic exploitation of the global south. Accordingly, are we all going to have our assets seized and income garnished to reduce the inequality of the global poor? Remember, the average American public school teacher is in the top decile globally by both income and wealth. The actual problem that you're unhappy about is that average wages have not been keeping up with the rising cost of living over the last 50 years. That's a complex problem with a lot of variables, including quite a few that violate what popular social consesus dictates you are allowed to even think about or question, and is beyond the scope of my response to enumerate. That said, calls to "reduce inequality" aren't it - those are just calls for most of the people on HN to have wages and assets seized involuntarily - at gunpoint and under threat of imprisonment by a SWAT team that will shoot your dog and throw a flashbang grenade in your infant's crib if you resist...
- 2y ago
- hirvi74 2y agoIt isn't just pilots, sadly. Hospitals are chalk-full of surgeons, doctors, and nurses that are all overworked, burned out, and half-awake. While I do not have the statistics, I would imagine sleep deprivation is a frequent cause of a lot of medical mistakes.
- RodgerTheGreat 2y agofyi, the idiom is "chock full".
- arcanemachiner 2y agoFYI, acronyms are spelled with uppercase letters.
- dangrossman 2y agofyi, there is a difference between casual communication style and a mistake or gap in one's knowledge
- joquarky 2y agoFYI, if it's vocalized as letters rather than pronounced as a word, then it's technically not an acronym. It's an initialism.
- arcanemachiner 2y agoThank you, I was hoping someone would take the bait and complete my chain of pedantry.
- hirvi74 2y agoYou are 100% right. What makes this worse is that I Googled it to see if it was hyphenated -- it was. I then noticed that I spelled it wrong, but in that nanosecond of time, I somehow forgot to correct it. I am also sleep deprived too. ;)
- renewiltord 2y ago
- mschuster91 2y ago> Last year, Infosys cofounder Narayana Murthy suggested that Indian youth should work 70 hours a week for the nation's development. Murthy’s advice came up at the Indian Parliament on the first day of its winter session and found support from a list of influential Indian tech leaders, including Bhavish Aggarwal, founder of India’s first AI unicorn, Ola Krutrim; Ayushmaan Kapoor, cofounder of the AI-powered customer platform Xeno; and even veterans like Sajjan Jindal, CEO and MD of JSW Group, and Vinod Khosla of Sun Microsystems. Well... we see the same bullshit being pushed across Europe (particularly Germany and France), justified by us being no longer "competitive" with particularly Asian countries. How about we just go and say "hey, no more imports and trade with these countries until they either reduce their working hours to reasonable limits or there will be levies applied to compensate for the extra productivity gained through exploitation"? Or why do we not go and close our skies to airlines that operate under clearly unsafe regulations? The super rich will not stop undoing a hundred years worth of labor laws history until we all stop them.
- yoyohello13 2y agoAnd we wonder why birth rates are declining...
- morkalork 2y agoAren't South Korea and Japan locked into that death spiral now? Thinking they have to extract more time out of people to make up labor lost to a declining labour force, which makes the labour force decline further, so they squeeze even more...
- mschuster91 2y agoThe old farts in power don't care. They will soon be dead anyway (at least if age-reversal research doesn't make serious progress in the next 10 years), so they want one last giant party - no matter how hard it fucks up those who come after them.
- 2y ago
- owlstuffing 2y ago[flagged]
- qazxcvbnmlp 2y agoKinda seems like a political problem. We don’t have this to the same extent in the US because there a pretty strict rules around crew (pilot & flight attendant) rest. These rules are written in blood and we(as the consumer) pay for it in higher ticket prices. A simpler app that keeps track of the time off the clock allocated to rest would solve the problem but that increases operational costs pretty significantly. Not just reduced hours per pilot but also cancelling/delaying flights when crew run past their time and need to rest instead.
- insane_dreamer 2y ago> there a pretty strict rules around crew (pilot & flight attendant) rest only because pilots and crew are unionized which allowed them to fight for these; if they weren't you can be sure that conditions would be much worse up until the point of a major air disaster that would put pressure on the airlines
- hwillis 2y ago> and we(as the consumer) pay for it in higher ticket prices. With an air transport pilot flying 700 hours and making $220k annually, with 300 flights and 150 people per flight, that's <$5 per seat. The flight crew's wages are a very small part of the cost of a ticket.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoThis is not a tech problem, it's a corporate profits problem. > At 13 hours of flight duty time, India’s FDTL is already demanding, but after the pandemic slowdown, increased route expansion and pilot shortages have forced many to fly beyond the recommended maximum of 60 hours a week, exacerbating crew exhaustion. It's not only unsafe for the pilots, but also for the passengers. > An airline CEO ... claimed the proposed regulations would ... escalate expenses ... By the end of the month ... appeared to have yielded to influence from the airline lobby. But you know, corporate profits are more important, so lets just keep working people to death.
- psunavy03 2y agoOK, a better headline might start out "Indian Pilots Are Dying of Tiredness" for one. For those not familiar, crew rest requirements for US professional pilots are spelled out in Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations, Section 121: - At least 9 consecutive hours of rest during the 24-hour period that precedes a flight assignment of less than 8 hours. - At least 10 consecutive hours of rest during the 24-hour period that precedes a flight assignment of 8-9 hours. - At least 11 consecutive hours of rest during the 24-hour period that precedes a flight assignment of 9 or more hours. - At least 24 consecutive hours of rest in any 7 calendar days. These can be reduced to 8 hours of rest if additional rest is scheduled on the back end. No pilot may fly more than 1,000 hours a calendar year, 100 hours a calendar month, or 30 hours every 7 days. I'm not familiar with the rules in the EU or elsewhere in the world.
- dyauspitr 2y agoWhen you put it that way it seems like a pretty easy job.
- cptcobalt 2y agoI think this counts as flight time, not paperwork & preparation time on the ground.
- yunohn 2y agoYeah that’s my understanding as well for all flight crew - the regulations only define non in-air time. Getting to a hotel to sleep takes a lot of time even after wheels touch ground - gotta taxi, follow SOPs, pass through security/immigration, travel to the hotel, and then actually fall asleep. Also, repeat in reverse to get back to work.
- bluGill 2y agoThe problem is it is almost always a boring tedious job. Most of the exceptions are when they are in the simulator doing training. (they train for worst case things like complete engine failure in weather so bad they wouldn't even take off with good engines - but since there is a possibly this could happen they train for it). However you still want them well rested and paying perfect attention even though the job is easy because every once in a while they hit one of the harder cases in the real world.
- hwillis 2y agoFatal heart attacks at 37 and 40 are crazy. The DGCA's 2024 handbook reports 9,390 pilots and copilots (page 25[1]). Heart attacks at very young ages are more common in India because of rates of smoking and diabetes, but not that common. The large majority of people typically survive MI at that age, and I'm sure those 2 examples are far from exceptional. > IndiGo, India’s largest airline, announced it would be an “early adopter” of a wrist-worn fatigue-monitoring device it was developing with French defense and aerospace company Thales Group. That's toeing the line. If your employer is measuring things like your heart rate variability and blood pressure to figure out how close you personally are to a heart attack, and deciding whether it's worth it to cancel your flight so you can rest- that's abhorrent. It's somehow worse than the employer purchasing your health. It's planned obsolescence for people. How many people would drop dead a year after retiring? Horrifying. The problem is not a lack of pilots or the needs of the country, either. There are foreign pilots and airlines. It's just pilots being driven far too hard by institutions. It won't go away when there are more pilots, it will just become calcified. This is a habit that should be ended through legal means, and fast. [1] https://www.dgca.gov.in/digigov-portal/?page=jsp/dgca/InventoryList/dataReports/aviationDataStatistics/handbookCivilAviation/HANDBOOK%202023-24%20Final%20Draft.pdf&main4252/4205/sericename https://www.dgca.gov.in/digigov-portal/?page=jsp/dgca/Invent...