3 ms·
As IBM pushes for automation, its AI simply not up to the job of replacing staff
- lucioperca 2y agoAI=Actually Indians?
- ldjkfkdsjnv 2y agoAnonymous Indians
- kotaKat 2y agoI always knew the true AI datacenters were the big buildings that said "TATA CONSULTANCY" and "Accenture"...
- xenospn 2y agoHow misinformed do you have to be to think that you can just wake up one day and replace 8000 people with “AI“? What does that even mean? Instead of doing that, you should probably fire and replace the person who suggested that in the first place.
- steveBK123 2y agoLot of CTOs about to lose their jobs if true
- xenospn 2y agoFor good reason
- LiquidSky 2y agoIt’s long been the dream of management to run the company without those pesky employees. I imagine a good bit of the current AI hype bubble is due to that dream.
- nine_zeros 2y agoThe perfect widget will get produced automatically, serving all customer needs. Customers will be supported automatically. Outages will be fixed automatically. All I do is press a button and collect MRR.
- heraldgeezer 2y agoI have had this feeling since I started working... Nobody actually wants employees.
- kibwen 2y agoFor some extremely peculiar and entirely ineffable reason, executives don't seem to be considering the possibility of replacing themselves with AI.
- bee_rider 2y agoCurrently LLM’s have pretty limited context windows and limited ability to come up with brand new ideas, right? But they do write very confidently. So they’ll have to find some people at the company whose main contribution is contextless repetitive pablum, empty phrases expressed with great vigor and confidence. Preferably someone highly paid. Surely nobody like that is working there…
- anticorporate 2y agoI bet you could even use an LLM to analyze the work output of different groups within a company and see whose output most closely matches that of an LLM. Hint: Those people won't have words like "content" "editor" "writer" or "documentation" in their title. They will, though, likely have words like "director" and "vice president" in there somewhere.
- bee_rider 2y agoHaha. In general, I’m trying very hard to not see jobs I don’t understand as easily replaced by LLMs. Everyone thinks somebody else can be, right? But I would be fascinated to see a company with the higher levels replaced by LLMs. Like a union or guild where the members are actually voting on the real decisions, and the LLMs handle summarizing these decisions and building narratives. No idea of it would work. Might still need a human CEO. Would be interesting to see, though.
- rpcope1 2y agoBesides the obvious, you could honestly replace a huge amount of the horrendous documentation (50%+ of it is just carefully camouflaged marketing fluff anyways) for a large number of IBM products with the hallucinations of an LLM and be no worse off.
- anshulbhide 2y agoExpect to see the same story repeating across many large enterprises that dive deep into LLMs without fully understanding exactly what they want out of it.
- datadrivenangel 2y agoIf you can't get good results from outsourcing, why should you expect good results from an LLM?
- lenerdenator 2y agoBecause this time, the C-suite closed their eyes extra hard and tapped their heels one more extra time. Still waking up in western Kansas, though.
- tempodox 2y agoSomehow LLMs unearth peoples' forgotten wishes to believe in magic and miracles again.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoOh they know what they want out of it, but they don't realize that LLMs / AI isn't up to the task at all. At best it's next generation code completion, and code completion hasn't made any jobs obsolete. (or, the time saved with code completion is not outweighed by the increased amount of software projects or the advancement in programming languages and libraries making code generation obsolete) It sounds like IBM's management in this case thinks of AI powered code generators like they (and others) did of COBOL back when, "it's basically english so non-programmers can use it".
- Spoom 2y agoExpect to see the same story being said while actually being used as a cover for replacing expensive workers (e.g. anyone in the US) with cheaper workers. Wall Street is OK with this.
- amelius 2y agoUnrelated question, but was Watson (the version that played Jeopardy) an LLM?
- ilaksh 2y agoYes it was called Watson, but I don't think the technology is related to what they used. So maybe not an LLM at that time. "Watson" just became a brand name for IBM.
- htrp 2y agoNot quite.... Watson predates the transformer architecture by at least a decade Refer to this article https://cbmm.mit.edu/sites/default/files/documents/watson.pdf https://cbmm.mit.edu/sites/default/files/documents/watson.pd...
- amelius 2y agoI think LLM is not synonymous with transformers and are quite a bit older. Afaik, an LLM is just a model (any kind of large model) that predicts the next token based on previous tokens.
- jacknews 2y agoAll they have to do is keep on dumping all their most experienced and talented (expensive) staff, and AI will be up to the task after all.
- cjbgkagh 2y agoIf you keep lowing the average ability of the worker eventually AI will overtake them. Unless your workers are the ones making the AI then I guess possible that the AI would regress faster than the workers.
- falcor84 2y agoYup, if the only task is to let people go, the AI can already perform that.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 2y agoI always think about the directors/vps of these divisions with huge salaries, running business units that are completely useless. They should just fire all those people and hire a few openai engineers
- ilaksh 2y ago"The truth is that Watsonx [IBM’s generative AI offering] isn’t even available to employees to attempt to try and help automate some meaningless task. It's so far behind OpenAI and ChatGPT that it’s not even close."
- datadrivenangel 2y agoWatson is just a brand name for consulting, not any specific tool.
- tokai 2y agoWatsonx is a specific tool.
- notepad0x90 2y agothey're notoriously infamous for firing people when they're over 50.
- ActionHank 2y agoIf it is so widespread, why hasn't there been a class action lawsuit against them? Not refuting, genuinely curious.
- flerchin 2y agoThe first google link for "ibm ageism lawsuit" https://www.cohenmilstein.com/case-study/ibm-age-discrimination-litigation/ https://www.cohenmilstein.com/case-study/ibm-age-discriminat...
- no_wizard 2y agoThey been trying to for some time now[0] My understanding is they are having trouble getting the individual arbitration clauses thrown out to allow it to proceed [0]: https://www.theregister.com/AMP/2024/01/23/ibm_supreme_court/ https://www.theregister.com/AMP/2024/01/23/ibm_supreme_court...
- gryfft 2y agoThis article details some past legal actions taken in different countries about it: https://www.theregister.com/2022/08/16/ibm_dinobabies_case_settled/ https://www.theregister.com/2022/08/16/ibm_dinobabies_case_s... edit: heh, replied concurrently with others pointing the same direction. somebody owes somebody a soft drink.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoBecause they signed away that right: https://features.propublica.org/ibm/ibm-age-discrimination-american-workers/ https://features.propublica.org/ibm/ibm-age-discrimination-a.... That same article mentions a lawsuit about IBM changing its pension scheme, forcing them to revert to the old one and a $300M settlement amount. That said, there have been a number of age discrimination lawsuits, just no major class action it seems: https://www.cohenmilstein.com/case-study/ibm-age-discrimination-litigation/ https://www.cohenmilstein.com/case-study/ibm-age-discriminat..., https://www.theregister.com/2024/06/20/ibm_and_kyndryl_again_sued/ https://www.theregister.com/2024/06/20/ibm_and_kyndryl_again..., https://www.hrdive.com/news/ibm-hr-professionals-suit-age-discrimination-layoffs/694555/ https://www.hrdive.com/news/ibm-hr-professionals-suit-age-di..., https://thenationaltriallawyers.org/article/ibm-hit-with-1-5m-age-discrimination-verdict-despite-sham-investigation/ https://thenationaltriallawyers.org/article/ibm-hit-with-1-5...
- recursivedoubts 2y agoif you want a vision of the future, imagine a chatbot saying "I'm sorry, are any of the following articles useful?" in response to your screams, forever.
- lenerdenator 2y ago> "With AI tools writing that code for us ... why pay for senior-level staff when you can promote a youngster who doesn't really know any better at a much lower price?" he said. "Plus, once you have a seasoned programmer write code that is by law the company's IP and it is fed into an AI library, it basically learns it and the author is no longer needed." This betrays not only a misunderstanding of what LLMs can do, but a basic lack of knowledge of the software development lifecycle. Krishna gets paid $20 million a year to be this big of an idiot. He should lose his job immediately. He hasn't earned it. Remember, your company's management would do anything if it meant they could get a dollar. Never bend over backwards for these troglodytes.
- n_ary 2y agoThis read to me like, why pay a proper experienced person to generate good and reliable results when you can combine to sub-par(no offense to junior engineers, but you don't know all the caveats and sharp edges yet) things where one feeds the other and continue to remain sub-par while mass money is shovelled to the AI forges so they can figure something out and blame the junior(human) and cite the nice little print that their system may generate false/incorrect things, when all the house of cards come crashing down.
- lenerdenator 2y agoThat may very well be the case. Remember, what happens in five years time isn't Krishna's problem. What happens in the next 90 days is Krishna's problem. And if he can drastically reduce payroll while maintaining revenues in the next 90 days, he is judged by the market to be a good CEO.
- FrustratedMonky 2y agoExactly They are also going for the entirely wrong market. Everyone is arguing about replacing programming jobs, "AI can't replace my job". But it is really just fractional. Lets say you have 5 marketing drones writing boring marketing material. AI allows them to do more, you still need humans to use the tools, and to edit, but now you only need 3. AI can't do the 'entire job' but it did enough to eliminate two positions. This is what is already happening. Do you think this stopped with the ESPN case? Companies didn't stop because they got caught, they just got better at it.
- neilv 2y ago> We're told US-based network engineering staff will be reduced to two or three employees per shift during US business hours, representing a 33 percent loss of staff per shift. That's monitoring and maintaining all of IBM’s global datacenters. What's in this sense of "network engineering"? (Is it distinct from some role like "technician" or "operations"?) If you wanted to make IBM's data centers quickly start having downtime, or to be unresponsive to new needs, how many people would you have to hire away?
- heraldgeezer 2y agoSounds like a NetworkOperationsCentre? NOC Operations and Tech sure. But some know linux, some windows some networking. A PC tech wont have a CCNA.
- mglz 2y agoThe "AI will automate it and we can let go of knowledgeable humans" requires a very naive and sinister mindset, which seems widespread among so called leadership roles. If you ask yourself how a rational person could make such a overcommitment to an unproven technology, the answer is: They are not being rational. Why are they in leadership roles? No clue.
- xkqd 2y ago> Why are they in leadership roles? Because they’re useful to the bottom line and are anti-social enough to destroy anyone who threatens it. People and moreover mentality like this should not exist in our society, yet we incentivize for it.
- n_ary 2y agoLeaderships always have golden parachute when things come crashing. Regardless of the long term consequences or outcome, they will always win or move onto next thing before the dues arrive. Also, why can't we replace the leadership with AI? We have more books on management than actual technical knowledge. We can use AI to make similar decisions these leaders make at like what billion times less cost.
- consteval 2y ago> Why are they in leadership roles? No clue Because, IMO, there's a large overlap between being an irrational person and also being likable and smart sounding. Confidence doesn't actually come from being good, it comes from being delusional. In order to truly market yourself you need a healthy disdain for the truth. You spit on reality and create your own. Engineers and other rational-minded people have a big problem - they're too honest. They do feasibly analysis, they look at risks, they talk about weaknesses, pros and cons. But this doesn't strike confidence, quite the opposite - it makes the business folk weary. Why go with you, who estimates 10% chance of failure, when they can go with Mark, who says it's guaranteed to work? Extrapolate that across all decisions and boom, the people at the top are usually the most irrational. It doesn't really matter that it's all a lie because when everyone walks out of that boardroom, they feel comforted.
- klabb3 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rybosworld 2y agoIt seems that an alarming percentage of executives do not have the skillset to steer a ship when interest rates are above 0%.
- DragonStrength 2y agoSometimes it feels like this AI thing is gonna be The Emperor's New Clothes for a whole class of management types. Like, maybe we're automating their jobs actually because AI makes me able to do more, but a lot of that is the admin stuff: I still have to do my own research (which many on the non-tech side don't seem to understand yet) but I can focus more on the tricky parts of my job, which happen to also be the parts I find most rewarding. I'm not sure how they plan to automate that when they're sitting there asking ChatGPT questions like it's an oracle.
- karaterobot 2y ago> "Senior software engineers stopped being developed in the US around 2012," Blake said. "That’s the real story. No country on Earth is producing new coders faster than old ones retire. India and Brazil were the last countries and both stopped growing new devs circa 2023. China stopped growing new devs in 2020." Huh. I hadn't heard this, and it goes against my intuition. They cite a Stackoverflow survey, and some other articles. A bolus of new developers entered the industry around 2000-2010, and are at least senior level now. I assumed the same trend had continued, since development is a pretty safe route to a good salary. What industry are reasonably intelligent people going into these days? The trades are a great option, but I was recently hearing about a scarcity of skilled tradesmen, too. AI was not an existential job threat in 2012, either, so that's not the reason, nor is the present moment's poor job market. What are people doing to make a living now?
- Izkata 2y agoI have a suspicion that may refer to how many people hop jobs for pay raises or otherwise manage to avoid improving their skills. Lots more developers, plenty of years-in-profession seniors, few high-experience seniors. Ever since people started talking about the coding abilities of AI I've been thinking this pattern would just accelerate, with beginners and inexperienced developers leaning on it too much instead of improving their own skills.
- FredPret 2y agoIBM needs help, and cutting costs isn't the answer. Their revenue has been falling for a decade now [0] I don't even know what it is that they sell anymore. I wonder if they do. Also, I found this paragraph interesting: > "Senior software engineers stopped being developed in the US around 2012," Blake said. "That’s the real story. No country on Earth is producing new coders faster than old ones retire. India and Brazil were the last countries and both stopped growing new devs circa 2023. China stopped growing new devs in 2020." The ROI of one good engineer who understands their computer can be absolutely immense. The logical thing to do is to have some good ones and build an organization around them to help them focus 100% on building profitable things. I get the feeling this Krishna fellow sees engineers as a cost to be reduced and thinks the value is added by the rest of the organization, rather than the other way around. [0] https://valustox.com/IBM https://valustox.com/IBM
- pavel_lishin 2y ago> "Watsonx Code Assistant technically knows PHP, but it is very inferior to GitHub Copilot,” Blake told The Register. “Still, it's better than nothing. The CEO keeps imploring developers to use it. No one does, except maybe one or two people." I'm very curious about what PHP is being written over at IBM.
- Null-Set 2y agoA far cry from the 1979 IBM presentation. > A COMPUTER CAN NEVER BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE > THEREFORE A COMPUTER MUST NEVER MAKE A MANAGEMENT DECISION
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoTo me, the most interesting thing in the article was nothing to do with AI. > "Senior software engineers stopped being developed in the US around 2012," Blake said. "That’s the real story. No country on Earth is producing new coders faster than old ones retire. India and Brazil were the last countries and both stopped growing new devs circa 2023. China stopped growing new devs in 2020." This is one article quoting one person at IBM. But if that's true, that's a seismic shift in the landscape from the last, oh, 80 years or so. That ought to make pay and working conditions better - if true.
- rybosworld 2y agoAn engineer is to a software company what a tractor is to a farmer. The tractor does the thing. Getting rid of the tractor because and expecting the same level of productivity is... insane? You can add a bigger engine that makes the tractor better at tractoring (e.g. github copilot), but that doesn't replace the tractor.
- spacemadness 2y agoWhy pay senior devs for code that might actually work when you can hire randos who spend all their time debugging AI hallucination-ridden garbage code.