10 ms·
Octopuses seen hunting together with fish
- riffic 2y agoI'd like to be under the sea in an octopus's garden in the shade.
- sparrish 2y agoSeems like they're reading a lot into why the Octopus is punching those fish that are just hanging around them.
- helpfulContrib 2y ago[dead]
- krunck 2y agoThey're just flexin' for the cameras.
- mannykannot 2y agoI agree, and one thing that makes me skeptical is that for it to be effective, the fish being punched would presumably have to understand that the octopus wants it to act in a certain way - i.e., the hypothesis seems to imply that the fish has a theory of mind with respect to the octopus. Similarly, it seems to imply that the octopus has a theory of mind about the fish - it believes that the fish will understand why the octopus is punching it. I'm not saying that this is impossible, but it is a very big claim. Furthermore, it is not clear from the video that the punching has the outcome implied by this hypothesis. It seems at least as plausible, at least from the video alone, that the octopus is just keeping the fish away from stealing an anticipated meal.
- diego_sandoval 2y agoTheory of mind is not necessary for the fish. I think conditioning should be enough, and conditioning works on pigeons.
- mannykannot 2y agoFair point. On looking at it again, I think the reporter and/or editor have introduced unnecessarily teleological language. The researchers themselves describe the octopus behavior as though it is a matter of herding the fish - presumably, I suppose, to where it feels there are more prey to be found.
- bbqfog 2y agoCould it not be like dogs herding sheep?
- satvikpendem 2y agoOctopuses are much more intelligent than many give them credit for, but sadly I also love takoyaki (but then again, eating horse and whale is also culturally acceptable in Japan, one of the few countries that allow it; I've tried both as well, they're pretty good).
- ravenstine 2y agoHorse meat is really good. Not sure why we still forbid it in the United States considering how we eat plenty of cows and horseback riding is more or less a hobby now.
- edgyquant 2y agoIt’s taboo like eating dog. I don’t even know that’s it illegal
- devilbunny 2y agoNot in all states (it is illegal in some), but there's no mechanism for USDA inspection of the horse, which means you can't sell it. If you slaughtered and ate your own horse, it would probably be legal (and, at personal scale, probably would not be noticed even if it were not). But ask a lawyer.
- seabass-labrax 2y agoI'm intrigued by your statement "horseback riding is more or less a hobby now". Are you implying that a ban on horse meat in the USA was originally intended to ensure an adequate supply of riding horses during the time when they were still widely used? All of the breeds that Wikipedia lists as bred for consumption are related to draught horses rather than riding horses, although for that matter the list doesn't include any American breeds at all.
- mewse-hn 2y agoI think it's a fair assumption that the taboo against eating horse-meat is related to using horses for transport. Historically, armies wouldn't eat their horses unless they were in an extremely dire situation, etc.
- davidashe 2y agoSo? I can punch a fish too. Call me when they’re hyping a product they know is trash - then we’ll know they’re at human intelligence.
- FrustratedMonky 2y agoSo are Octopuses really intelligent if they are in management?
- ActionHank 2y agoand is punching an effective management tool?
- WJW 2y agoFor the octopus it is. Of course, they have many more arms to punch with so this might not translate well to management of humans.
- jejeyyy77 2y agomy boss seems to think so.
- charlieo88 2y ago...and buried in this discussion of octopus management technique, we find the TRUE reason behind the wave of return to office requirements
- jjk166 2y agoEven if they are intelligent, they are spineless opportunistic predators who will squeeze their way into anything. Just like octopuses.
- noelwelsh 2y agoLiterally a sucker punch. It doesn't seem like true cooperation as they don't share in the catch. I also didn't see any measurements of how much they caught versus hunting alone.
- stonemetal12 2y agoIn the NPR article on it, the researcher says it is most likely beneficial for the fish because the octopus can pull prey out of crevices that the fish can't usually reach, so there is more food than either would have alone.
- cryptonector 2y agoThe article doesn't say that the octopus shares the catch though. Maybe the fish don't benefit.
- 10xalphadev 2y ago> I also didn't see any measurements of how much they caught versus hunting alone. How would you propose to measure, Mr. Moasure? Care to share your setup?
- Qem 2y agoThis reminds me of that Triassic Kraken hypothesis: https://gsa.confex.com/gsa/2013AM/webprogram/Handout/Paper232163/TriassicKraken21stCtScan.pdf https://gsa.confex.com/gsa/2013AM/webprogram/Handout/Paper23...
- jpm_sd 2y agoI can't wait for OctoPunch, the turn-based combat video game! You play as the octopus, of course, and build your party from a selection of fishy characters, each with their own personality and special hunting skills.
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoI used to love eating octopus, but since I've learned so much about their intelligence, I have not been able to bring myself to do so, anymore. I have the luxury of choice. There are many, in this world, that do not.
- Intralexical 2y agoI had a bit of tentacle float up in some seafood soup once. Felt like seeing a small severed finger, wrecked my appetite for that meal immediately.
- hagbard_c 2y agoThey only live for 3 years or so, just eat them when they're close to kicking the bucket. This short lifetime combined with their intelligence does raise the question how far an octopus could get if it were able to reach our age. Would they continue learning and adapting, leading to a race of superintelligent molluscs or would they plateau in their first year and just coast along?
- ceejayoz 2y agoAnyone who likes the sound of that should check out Adrian Tchaikovksy's Children of Time trilogy, particularly the second one.
- HelloMcFly 2y agoTypically octopuses produce offspring only near the end of their life, so eating them at any point is destructive for their reproduction and species health.
- neerajk 2y agoaside: me after reading the headline: Shouldn't that be Octopii? But no! "The plural form octopii is doubly incorrect. Firstly, octopus derives from Greek, not Latin; its etymologically-consistent plural form is octopodes. Secondly, even if octopus were a second-declension Latin noun, the plural form would be octopi; in the correct plurals radii and gladii, with which octopii is analogous, the first ‘i’s are part of the words’ stems (radi- and gladi-), and not their case endings — for octopii to be the plural, *octopius would need to be the singular." Thanks wikipedia. TIL!
- fffrantz 2y agoThought exactly the same!
- crazygringo 2y agoI wonder why it is that "octopuses" just kind of sounds wrong? Is it the repeated "s" at the end? But we have no problem saying "buses" or "rebuses". Is it something to do with the plural of "fish" just being "fish"? But we have no problem making whales and dolphins plural with an -s. Is it that "-puses" sounds slightly vulgar, like we're talking about multiple female genitalia? I genuinely don't know. All I know is that "octopuses" just sounds wrong for some reason I can't put my finger on. And that "octopii" somehow "feels" much better, even if everything about it is logically wrong. I'll still say "octopuses", but I know I always want to say "octopii" instead. (And spell it that way too, because "octopi" feels like it would rhyme with "canopy".)
- mseepgood 2y ago"Partners"? "Companions"? More like slave drivers.
- primer42 2y agoI love imagining how the fish are almost an extension of the way the octopuses think. Octopuses seem to have quite a bit of independent cognition in each of their arms, which are wrangled by the central brain. Now they're wrangling independent fish brains instead of octopus arm brains. Incredible
- mellavora 2y ago>Octopuses seem to have quite a bit of independent cognition in each of their arms, which are wrangled by the central brain. Yes, that's inherent in the design. All grey matter (optimized for local intercommunication), no white matter (optimized for sending signals between regions). Each arm has its own ganglion ("CPU") and the central unit struggles to keep up with these and keep them coordinated.
- sharpshadow 2y agoThe fish are able to gather food from the sand which the octopus moves. It happend to me too in the ocean where fish around my feet followed along the spots in the sand I touched. Therefore I was hunting together with fish!?
- bbqfog 2y agoVery cool! > “I think sociality, or at least attention to social information, is way more deep-rooted in the evolutionary tree than we might think,” Maybe, or maybe the neural power required to move all of those limbs is good enough at processing that they developed their own sophisticated behavior.
- mellavora 2y agoWell, given the overwhelming emerging evidence of social attention and behavior in plants, and given that it makes evolutionary sense that "social attention" would provide a fitness advantage in any environment where there are other actors, the only reason to doubt it would be an assumption that "attention to social information" can only happen in creatures with an complex central nervous systems. Which requires rather constrained definitions of "attention", "social", and "information" ok, there is another reason to doubt it. inertia. We've been taught/told that a complex CNS is what makes intelligence, and it is hard to get away from that idea.
- knighthack 2y agoWait... so we have an octopus lording over fishy underlings? Like... a mob boss?
- pvaldes 2y agoToo much Sponge Bob for today little Timmy. Go sleep.
- motohagiography 2y agogiven how the octopus uses camoflauge, operating on their environment by using other fish as a distraction to their prey is logical. punching the still predator fish to keep them moving removes competition and keeps them moving as a part of the noise distraction. longevity research for cephalopods seems like it could be really fruitful.
- setgree 2y agoHow much of a leap is it to say that octopuses have effectively domesticated fish, the way early humans might have turned docile wolves into hunting companions?
- throwup238 2y agoIt depends on your definition of domestication. One could easily argue that ants have domesticated aphids so I don’t think the concept depends on the intelligence of the domesticator so much as the symbiotic relationship between species. However the usual definition of domestication is specific to humans. The aforementioned aphid farming and the octopodes in TFA are technically in mutualistic relationships.
- setgree 2y agoI don't think there is scholarly consensus on whether ant behavior can/should be considered domestication, but, per [0]: > The best-studied insect-associated domestication is that of the attine ants...and the majority cultivate parasol mushrooms in the Leucocoprineae [58]. The ants plant sessile fungal cultivars, manage growth conditions by regulating temperature and moisture and fertilizing the fungal gardens, protect their crop from other herbivores, parasites, and disease, and harvest the cultivated fungi for food [4,58]. This coevolved domestication system has turned ants into obligate fungivores, as experimental removal of the fungal crop results in reduced reproduction and increased mortality among ants [58]. For the fungi, the ants increase their fitness relative to the free-living state by increasing their proportion across generations, providing for geographic dispersal and protecting the fungi against parasites and pathogens [58]. In the higher attine ants, the fungal cultivars are obligate mutualists and cannot grow in a free-living state [58]. It should be noted that fungi may not be the only ant domesticates; some ants tend to hemipteran insects like aphids and treehoppers in a system reminiscent of human animal husbandry [4,10]. I would call this domestication, full stop. [0] https://www.cell.com/trends/ecology-evolution/fulltext/S0169-5347(22)00089-1?dgcid=raven_jbs_etoc_email https://www.cell.com/trends/ecology-evolution/fulltext/S0169...
- Intralexical 2y agoI think domestication implies multigenerational changes in genetics and morphology to make the domesticated species more useful for the domesticating species. It doesn't seem that there's any evidence of that yet. Maybe if they keep at it for a while, and either the fish they hunt with branch off into a separate population or they do it so much that it affects the entire population?
- rsingel 2y agoI'm just slightly disturbed that someone thinks a rich social life is defined by punching your co-workers
- Tool_of_Society 2y agoI feel like my life would of been enriched a few times had that been a viable legal option to pursue :P
- pvaldes 2y agoDisneyfication of octopuses. In that video you'll see, exactly anything that you want to see. Would justify perfectly an: "in the video the octopus is seen trying to avoid being stolen its food by all the other fishes", that is the same behavior that you'll see if you break a crab or an urchin underwater. Many coastal fishes from rocky bottoms will come to steal any food scrap available. They don't cooperate with other fishes on any way. Or maybe they are playing "rock, paper, tentacle", but to me the message more probable here is "this is my food, go away". If you look the video carefully the fishes seem trying to swim near the mouth of the octopus, where the probability of stealing a scrape is higher.
- Tool_of_Society 2y agoIn the one short video you do see what you want to see. Meanwhile the researchers have hundreds of hours into this... Probably shouldn't base your entire opinion of the study on a 17 second video or a fluff article. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41559-024-02525-2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41559-024-02525-2
- pvaldes 2y ago> Probably shouldn't base your entire opinion of the study on a 17 second video or a fluff article. I comment based on what I have, and using my personal experience on the field. Experience based on decades of hard study. I had studied Cephalopods for more than 17 seconds, you can bet for it. If this is common behavior, don't you think that with all the scientists doing research on Cephalopods since Aristotle, and with the millions of hours of people keeping Cephalopods on captivity, somebody would had described it long time ago?. I wonder why suddenly science only finds facts that support the ideologies from the politics that (duh) block, or allow, the money trickle for research. Never had seen so much wonderful hype science as since the last years. So much 'interesting' interpretations on the reality that defy the logical explanation, since the LLM landed. Suddenly cows fly and pigs live underground. How we never realized this wonders before the IA? If you want me to spend hours chasing articles, pruning the lying and counterfeit, and making you a report, no problem. Just pay me for my time. Alternatively, if you want to believe that octopuses are small alien children walking undersea gardens with umbrellas, good for you. It's a free country.
- andrew-dc 2y agoAudio found? https://youtu.be/sAoiwGjBmZs https://youtu.be/sAoiwGjBmZs
- staplung 2y agoThe octopuses I spoke to strenuously deny the fish abuse accusations. "It's true that our innovative management technique - Continuous Tactile Feedback - can look a little rough to the untrained eye, but our Food Collection Engineers are actually very well treated."
- vasco 2y agoYes but I've read the reports in the Annals of Oceanography and the sub-director General of Fishing Affairs said it is happening and the only reason they haven't been able to pursue it is that the dolphins keep vetoing any real measures at every yearly convention. It's a bit of a fishy subject.
- tommiegannert 2y agoThe study: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41559-024-02525-2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41559-024-02525-2 Sampaio et al., Multidimensional social influence drives leadership and composition-dependent success in octopus–fish hunting groups I was curious about the the 3D reconstruction of the scenes. > We manually tracked individuals in the videos using the software Computer Vision Annotation Tool. We annotated three frames per second, which yielded a time resolution of 0.33 s for animal movement. > We then used another software developed to incorporate the previously tracked animals in each camera in the ‘colmap’ habitat models and camera paths, ‘multiviewtracks’ or ‘mvt’ [29] > [29] Francisco, F. A., Nührenberg, P. & Jordan, A. High-resolution, non-invasive animal tracking and reconstruction of local environment in aquatic ecosystems Seems it was specifically developed to track fish. Cool project. Links to https://github.com/matterport/Mask_RCNN https://github.com/matterport/Mask_RCNN and https://github.com/pnuehrenberg/multiviewtracks https://github.com/pnuehrenberg/multiviewtracks.
- UncleOxidant 2y agoIt's too bad there aren't more software projects (and jobs) like this.
- AndrewKemendo 2y agoOctopuses don’t have money, so the people with money aren’t interested in putting more resources into understanding octopuses.
- rkagerer 2y agoBut surely if they can punch fish they can click ads?
- tonetegeatinst 2y agoAwaiting the ad industry giants to see this new source of end users.
- tiffanyh 2y agoOctopuses are practically alien. They can: - shape shift into so many different forms and shapes. - "invisibility", by instantanously changing colors & it's own skin texture, to match surrounds. - can regrow entire body parts if cut off (like arms) - have 9 brains (localized) - and are ridiculous intelligent
- rkagerer 2y agoAnd yet like us they have two eyes. I wonder if we meet aliens from another star-orbiting planet if their light-sensors will look anything like ours.
- Wojtkie 2y agoWell, I'm not sure there'd be much benefit to spending energy on a 3rd eye. You can already achieve stereoscopic vision with just two eyes, why waste the energy on a third? It probably doesn't increase fitness enough to be worth the energy spend.
- john2x 2y agoDifferent sets for different wavelength ranges
- thfuran 2y agoIt might be too hard to parse, but an eye on each arm would give variable baseline and potentially 360° stereoscopic coverage.
- SoftTalker 2y agoYet some creatures have many more than two eyes. Spiders, for example.
- notheyarent 2y agoThose are not eyes though. Animals eyes always come in a pair and whether it’s a human, dog, cat, mouse etc they are Gods gateway to the soul. It’s self evident.
- Intralexical 2y agoSomewhat related, "Octopuses are building small “cities” off the coast of Australia (2017)": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36103801 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36103801 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octopolis_and_Octlantis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octopolis_and_Octlantis
- eddyzh 2y agoIf you want to go straight to the videos here are some links which you get if you click and scroll a couple of steps further. Supplementary Video 6 Typical movement dynamics and web-over temporal characteristics when octopuses are hunting alone. https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41559-024-02525-2/MediaObjects/41559_2024_2525_MOESM9_ESM.mp4 https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs415... Example of a previous fish attack of a structure that triggers a reaction from the octopus and consequent web-over over a food-baited structure https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41559-024-02525-2/MediaObjects/41559_2024_2525_MOESM8_ESM.mp4 https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs415... Examples of octopuses punching fish, thus displacing them https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41559-024-02525-2/MediaObjects/41559_2024_2525_MOESM8_ESM.mp4 https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs415... Example of a multispecific group hunting and typical movements, featuring all species categories analysed in this study except yellow goatfish https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41559-024-02525-2/MediaObjects/41559_2024_2525_MOESM4_ESM.mp4 https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs415...
- e40 2y ago> Video shows octopuses punching their companion fish to keep them on task and contributing to the hunt. What a wonderful combination of words.
- imp0cat 2y agoI can already see the motivation posters in a performace-oriented companies: "Be the octopus in your team!"