6 ms·
Amazon says workers must be in the office. The UK government disagrees
- nottorp 2y ago[quote]There was also a drop in communication that happened in real time - meetings that would have happened in real life weren’t necessarily happening online. Instead, more emails and instant messages were sent.[/quote] Yes, that's a good thing because you have searchable history [1] and can communicate asynchronously without interrupting anyone :) [1] Although that may be bad for CYA purposes.
- khafra 2y agoAfter doing a WFH job for 2 years, and then going back to the office for a different job, what strikes me is how terribly everything is documented here--because when someone walks over and asks someone else how something works, that doesn't get automatically documented like it does in Slack. At my WFH job, I spent a lot of time searching Slack, and reading through documentation which had been distilled from Slack conversations. I learned a lot faster than I have, so far, at this job.
- wildrhythms 2y agoIn general, I find less and less time is given to me and other coworkers to document things compared to a few years ago.
- vundercind 2y agoSimilar circumstances (but longer time wfh) and similar observation. The in-person place is full of these absurd chains of tracking down the person who knows the thing, terrible processes for communication and defining what work needs to be done, et c, in ways that would never survive in a remote company because you can’t work that way when you’re remote. It’s a huge drag on their efficiency, in person or remote, and hurts hiring because they struggle to provide even a handful of of remote days per year in a market where every office worker I know (aside from here) is at least hybrid-leaning-remote (and most office workers I know aren’t in tech, nor is this a tech company). They have no idea that it’s bad, though.
- RandomLensman 2y agoAre these huge differences in efficiency visible in financial numbers?
- nottorp 2y agoHow do you propose to establish that, clone the people at one company, run both clones for a couple years and find out which made more money?
- RandomLensman 2y agoWe kind of have natural experiments: switching to WFH and then switching back (at least for some some), so there should be groups of companies that could be compared.
- vundercind 2y agoFor companies like this one, WFH probably would look bad. It’d both be harder to work that way because they’re already dysfunctional, and it’d make the existing dysfunction more visible (and so probably be blamed for things that would have been going wrong even with everyone in the office).
- pards 2y agoSearchable chat history works when people communicate in public channels. My experience at large financial institutions is that the vast majority of chat is person-to-person. I try to encourage public (or group) chats but I _think_ people, especially juniors or new-joiners, are reluctant to look unknowledgeable.
- pavel_lishin 2y agoMy employer had a great culture of talking things out in public channels, but after the acquisition, nearly everything is in private channels & DMs now. For some things, I've explicitly told people: "can you copy and paste this question in our support channel, so I can answer there?" But for a lot of things, I've just accepted that this is the new normal, and for some of it, I even understand why it is the way it is.
- vundercind 2y agoTeams encourages this awful pattern because their public “teams” don’t just have a normal-ass chat (and you can’t change it to be one), but a weird interface that seems to mainly be for announcements-with-comments. So 1-on-1 and ad hoc small group chats and chats attached to meetings are where everything happens. And god help you if your org also has a short chat retention policy.
- cflewis 2y agoI had a manager who thought putting questions in group chats would make it look like we were not competent and so should be only posted in DMs. Same about asking questions to other team members in bug tickets: don't do it, others will think the team is incompetent. Spoiler alert: He was one of, if not the worst, manager I have ever had because, surprise! he was awful in every other dimension as well.
- stroupwaffle 2y agoThis to me seems not a problem with remote vs. office, but a particular company culture. Meeting notes aren’t difficult to create. The problem with chat-based solutions is people get lazy in articulation. So instead of a cohesive idea it’s spread across a giant thread. And instead of actually creating a proper document, it’s easy to say, “Meh, I’ll do it later it’s in slack.” But then it never gets done, and the info is privy to only those in the conversation. It can be good or bad either way, but there’s no substitute for in-person communication; and there’s no substitute for a thoughtfully constructed document.
- qwytw 2y ago> instead of actually creating a proper document, it’s easy to say, “Meh, I’ll do it later it’s in slack.” Seems like an actual use case for LLMs. Yeah I understand the potential issues but (worst case) confusing documentation with some errors and flawed assumptions yet proper citation and sources (so it can be manually improved and eventually turned into thoughtfully constructed document) seems better than having no docs or entirely outdated ones.
- khafra 2y agoI'd say that, for people just starting a career who need to develop the illegible/intangible skills, in-person mentoring has no replacement. But after that, it's a real tradeoff. You can't just expect people to create and publish meeting notes when they catch a senior in the hallway and get an explanation they need, even if it would help others in their situation (or help themselves, in 6 months when they need to do that again and can't quite remember the steps (Unless their mentor modeled this important skill, I guess?)). https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/reitXJgJXFzKpdKyd/beware-trivial-inconveniences https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/reitXJgJXFzKpdKyd/beware-tri...
- dzhiurgis 2y agoIt's almost like Github needs to come up with chat app that summarises discussions into a wiki...
- nunez 2y agoThis falls apart at places that default to DMs.
- smcleod 2y agoCouldn't agree more, the overhead of context switching in-person is also so painfully expensive.
- drzaiusx11 2y agoThe life hack I've had to resort to for in-office days is wearing large over-ear headphones to signal I'm not available for interrupting. Half the time I don't even have them plugged in. It mostly works, but remote work is still more productive for me.
- benterix 2y agoI can't agree more. I once had a lazy boss that hated putting his ideas in order and expected to act on oral orders that were vague on details. I would always ask at the end of his long stream-of-consciousness speech, "Oh, that's great! I have a big favor to ask you: could you briefly summarize what I have to do in a short email to make sure I haven't missed anything important?" He would look at me with contempt, "Can't you just remember these few simple things?" or would murmur "OK, OK" but never did. So after this kind of conversation I would compose a short email to him, "As agreed during the conversation today, I will do this and that within given period." He hated these emails, I could tell. I'm so glad this shit-show is over.
- kranke155 2y agoIn Person management is the best way to make poor leadership work through constant oversight and changes (the dreaded "over the shoulder" management). Great for bad/mediocre managers, horrible for workers.
- mapt 2y agoIt does seem that you need EITHER a very particular combination of things for "Guess culture" to be more effective than "Ask culture", or you need a system that is so irrevocably corrupted by its faulty incentive structures that it can't function as a bureaucracy without lots of plausible deniability. My boss at this point understands that he's often putting me in a double or triple bind, but is obligated to do so and is never going to get approval for not doing so; My attempts to acquire verbal directives as to priority are met with "figure it out" and a grin. But then he's also extremely forgiving about accountability, doesn't attempt to apply metrics, because he understands that I'm going to be working on it all day anyway. Sometimes the bureaucratic style, enforced from the top down, is "Ask for unreasonable things in order to attain reasonable outcomes". I do not work with life-critical systems, where this sort of thing absolutely would not fly.
- noisy_boy 2y ago> My boss at this point understands that he's often putting me in a double or triple bind, but is obligated to do so and is never going to get approval for not doing so; My attempts to acquire verbal directives as to priority are met with "figure it out" and a grin. But then he's also extremely forgiving about accountability, doesn't attempt to apply metrics, because he understands that I'm going to be working on it all day anyway. Seems like at this point, you two have trust which has been built up based on respect/maturity, evidence of honesty/sincerity and delivery. You two are more or less a well oiled machine.
- arzig 2y agoAsync communications can be exhausting. It’s infuriating to need some bit of information and be stuck with chat because 1. People are terrible at organizing things like slack as far as I can tell. 2. Walking over to someone and having a 15 minute conversation is less disrupting to the day than tossing a mention into the void and then having responses dribble in over the next hour and a half. A work from home full time and don’t want to go back to the office, but the periodic need for unscheduled ad-hoc communication is absolutely the most exhausting part of it.
- dickersnoodle 2y agoLess disrupting the day for who?
- bitlax 2y agoYou just set up a quick video call. I do it all the time.
- nunez 2y agoZoom calls are 10,000% more mentally draining than desk interruptions, for me.
- cassianoleal 2y agoSame here. The commute and being at the office are 100000% more mentally and physically draining than working from my own desk at home though.
- acdha 2y ago> Walking over to someone and having a 15 minute conversation is less disrupting to the day than tossing a mention into the void and then having responses dribble in over the next hour and a half. There’s a balance here, as the 15 minute conversation is often a 45 minute disruption for the target and often the people around them. The other challenge is in my experience the trade off wasn’t “this information cannot be obtained any other way” but more along the lines of “it’s easier to walk over than read the documentation/make any attempt to answer the question on my own”. Asynchronous shifts the downsides to the person asking, so people tend to have strong opinions if they tend to be on one of those sides a lot more than the other.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dzhiurgis 2y ago"History search" is a symptom of lack of system of record Few months or weeks is fine. Everything else is just contributing to noise. Slack started when Snapchat introduced disappearing stories.
- paulsutter 2y agoOf course it’s great to work part time and get paid for full time (“remote work”). But you can see why employers might not love it.
- nxm 2y agoWhat if I told you I put in more hours of actual work from home because it's not spent commuting or recovering from a stressful commute?
- Rotundo 2y agoThe benefit of sleeping a bit longer in the morning on WFH days makes my whole day a lot more productive. Commutes are slowly killing me...
- badhombres 2y agoThe implication is that all remote work is part time effort for full time pay?
- starbugs 2y ago> The implication is that all remote work is part time effort for full time pay? Which wouldn't match my experience. It is exactly the opposite unless you count being present physically somewhere as work.
- Majestic121 2y agoWhat makes you think remote employees work part time ?
- stranded22 2y agoThat’s not what the government is proposing though - they are proposing working from home options and flexibility of working 5 day hours into 4 days (so, 4x10 hrs rather than 5x8). Also though - studies have been conducted and companies shrinking days to 4 whilst keeping 5 days have seen an increase in/same productivity. So, depends on whether the company is after results or presenteeism.
- mfer 2y agoIt looks like the UK gov is covering things like productivity and a loyal workforce. The article doesn’t cover why Amazon is doing it. I suspect their motive isn’t the things the UK gov is suggesting.
- MavisBacon 2y agoCurious what you suspect the motive is in Amazon's case
- mfer 2y agoI don't personally have any special knowledge but... I've read, in numerous places, that Amazon is attempting to use this as a way to alter their finances. To draw people into locations with tax advantages, reduce staff count without paying severance, etc.
- robertlagrant 2y agoI'd be curious to see whether all UK government employees will have the same benefits as the ones being imposed on how Amazon decides to employ its staff.
- difosfor 2y agoIt seems like this is something that warrants a personal approach? Just ask what employees would like to do and why and then work out a schedule that works for both employer and employee. Simply retracting freedom is obviously not going to be a popular measure. And happy employees are better for everyone I'd say?
- Shywim 2y agoThe logical conclusion from statistics is hybrid work. I am full remote because of the distance, bust most of my company is hybrid, and my experience is exactly as described by the results of the Microsoft studies. I go on site 3-5 days per month, and I always connect more (more than 0) with people outside my team and happens, even on work related topics which enable new interesting findings and what not. It helps that the company where I work has a culture that make people want to go to the offices even if they are not required to do so. There are pics days when the office is full because people want to see each others, then they are free to remote work any time it is wanted/needed.
- GiorgioG 2y agoThis is just a way for Amazon to do layoffs without formal layoffs. Let’s face it, the economy is (and has been) slowing down.
- pacifika 2y agoThe employer would you waste the opportunity who to lay off, and depend on a semi random selection of people with the most potential to excel if their personal circumstances improve.
- geertj 2y agoI know this theory is being put forward but it never made sense to me as 1/ severance is at most a few months of salary, and forcing people out this way will also take months, during which time employees will be much less productive, and /2 this approach will skew the population that leaves to those with better options (ie your high performers.)
- rob74 2y agoThis approach will skew the population that leaves to the "troublemakers" who insist on working from home, so if those leave (from the WFO advocates' perspective), all the better...
- lnsru 2y agoI did recently this “back to the office” thing. At the same time layoffs were happening. It was super obvious that not complying with new rules will bring first warning, second warning and layoff without any package. The packages were tailored for greenhorns, as low as possible to be enough for junior engineers to leave quickly. It was obvious again, that the return to the office for older and experienced folks will cause natural attrition and some 5% of expensive people will leave without severance package by quitting like I did. 200 got packages, 300 quit voluntarily. It was one third of workforce in that particular location. I heard it was celebrated as a success in the highest floor. For big organizations these high performers are not important. Good presenters are what matters. Things are achieved by a mass. Sometimes having few departments to do basically the same development. Because somebody on the top of command chain didn’t align properly. Or higher ups just don’t care.
- gadders 2y agoI think it makes a difference if you work in a job you can be sacked from.
- king_magic 2y agoI’ve created hundreds of millions of dollars of value working remotely over the past 10 years of my career. Companies are entirely free to skip out on that if they like. Fine by me :)
- j_m_b 2y agoThis is the first filter on the incoming mass layoffs.
- ppqqrr 2y agoA happy, independent employee is a creative employee, and if your business is such a heavy monopoly that it’s in your interest (if not your primary market strategy) to arrest and interrupt the development of competitive alternatives, keeping your employees in cycles of misery (long commutes, oral culture heavy on tribal knowledge and who-you-know) is no longer a “tradeoff” to be balanced, it’s how you keep competition from cropping up.
- theptip 2y agoSome people prefer working from home; others prefer office full time. I think hybrid orgs are going to be viable in some cases, but it’s harder to reap the benefits of in-person if only some are standing at the whiteboard. In particular if you are a startup and can all fit in one meeting room, the opportunity cost of going remote is huge. For huge companies that need to train lots of new grads, remote can be painful for other reasons. But there are benefits too, and the optimal decision is going to depend on the company culture and work style. I think it’s a terrible idea for government to step in and define universal rights to flexible work; this is a place where labor supply and demand should price in the preferences.
- piltdownman 2y agoThe government already mandates all sorts of conditions around work practices, right to breaks and special provisions. Given the dissolution of the Unions by vested interests like Amazon, combined with their refactoring and min/maxing things like performance metrics and KPIs for use in downsizing and PIP scenarios, the government is probably exactly the appropriate entity to step in.
- nickjj 2y ago> I think hybrid orgs are going to be viable in some cases I think it depends a lot on the company. If your company was remote to begin with and you go hybrid, unless you happen to have team mates who are local to you, it's very possible you'll still never meet them in the office. This place I'm at recently mentioned if you're > 50 miles from an office and within a 3 hour 1-way commute it's expected you go into the office at least once a month. No one from my team is near the office I'd go to, I'd basically be working alone in an open floor style layout while I work remotely with my team mates in the same way I would at home. Except now there's an extra 4 hour round trip commute and $65 cost ($40 train + 2 meals for a 14 hour day) per visit. Over the year that's $780 and 6 extra work days from travel time just to go in once a month.
- ainiriand 2y agoWell, you could not do that legally in Spain, if you give something to the workforces you cannot take it away without agreement on both parties.
- akudha 2y agoThere is no logical reason to park our collective asses in office, for digital work. From employer's perspective, it is just to micro manage people, keep commercial real estate prices high and plain old "I am the boss, so I can make you dance to my tune" thing. I have been working remote for about 7 years now. In my current job, I haven't met anyone in person, nor have I shown my face in any of the meetings. Despite this, I am working well with my team. Of course there is middle management who have nothing better to do than micro manage and schedule calls. So they have now started making noise about people not being on camera. This is a ploy by Amazon to force people to quit. Nothing else. All this talk about "innovate, collaborate, connect..." - these are just empty, meaningless buzz words from middle management who somehow need to justify their paycheck. Even if there are some miniscule advantages of going to office, they are vastly outnumbered by the advantages of working from home. I am just a code monkey, not a dentist or a veterinarian, makes zero sense to spend two hours (or more) a day in commute, clogging traffic and being in a bad mood even before reaching the office.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thrill 2y agoIf the UK government thinks it's knows better than Amazon how to run its business then it can pay their salaries.