6 ms·
Timothy Snyder on How the Collapse of the Soviet Union Took America by Surprise
- anjel 2y agoAdam Curtis' documentary on the fall of the Soviets and 10 year aftermath is the deep dive on this topic. Part 1 of 4. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ke600MgW1F0&t=3s&pp=2AEDkAIB https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ke600MgW1F0&t=3s&pp=2AEDkAIB
- liendolucas 2y agoExcellent. Thanks for sharing this. Just finished part one. I really like the way it was made, just fragments of the daily soviet life.
- mopsi 2y agoExcellent documentary. While it has been criticized for factual errors and omissions, it is by a wide margin the best documentary conveying the feeling of living through that time: the emptiness of not knowing where you are and what you should do to reach any kind of normal, stable, predictible life. Many people in the west nowadays believe that they are living in end times because they are overwhelmed by the many things changing around them. That documentary shows the opposite. The silence that arrives when the music stops. You are hungry, stores are empty, no one knows when and if ever they'll be restocked. Society just grinds to a halt and stops functioning. Completely unimaginable situation for modern people who are used to abundance.
- AStonesThrow 2y agoDennis Quaid is Reagan, in theaters now. https://www.reagan.movie/ https://www.reagan.movie/
- darby_nine 2y agoI highly recommend this movie if only because it's a hilarious combination of excellent production value, terrible acting, and some of the most boring and openly delusional film you'll ever witness.
- AStonesThrow 2y agoThanks! The acting/direction does incorporate sort of a plastic style. Perhaps they meant to really convey that this is all fictionalized history. I agree that it's a transparent hagiography. But American history is replete with hagiographies, and no patriot is repulsed by stories of President Washington and the cherry tree, or Paul Revere's heroicism, Betsy Ross's project, Susan B. Anthony's defense of women and children, or Abe Lincoln's bold proclamations. I mean, today we're not. In the moment, there were certainly plenty of dissenters and grumblers, but bro, history is written by winners, and President Reagan won many elections and established a library. There's nothing delusional about winning! By the way, I read a compilation of letters, I believe the title was, "I Love You, Ronnie" and it became clear that Mrs. Nancy was the driving force in his White House. She cared for him in many ways despite his profound incapacity (perhaps like Dr. Jill Biden today) and First Ladies have been ever more emboldened to use very real influence and femininity to complement the Executive branch. Nancy's role was quite downplayed in the film, but any admirer of Jackie or Michele would need to acknowledge the First Lady's accomplishments.
- feedforward 2y ago[flagged]
- codesnik 2y ago> "arming Ukraine's invasion of Russia's Kursk Oblast" just because you don't like US imperialism, you don't have to suck up to Russian one.
- darby_nine 2y ago[flagged]
- chii 2y ago> where ukraine will end up being fed to the wolves. the wolves came regardless. The west's help is no altruism, but it is also what ukraine would need (and more). > Propping up a defense industry that's feeling the lack of demand; forcing europe to coalesce around the us instead of china; restricting european access to cheap russian gas trying to frame it as some sort of american conspiracy to power grab is either you propogating mis/disinformation/propaganda, or just utterly stupid to the point of an own goal (assuming you're aligned with the west).
- darby_nine 2y ago[flagged]
- wiseowise 2y ago> War was avoidable. The war started in 2014 and Ukraine has been preparing for full scale invasion ever since with or without western help.
- darby_nine 2y ago[flagged]
- wiseowise 2y agoThe dissolution of Soviet Empire and power grab that happened afterwards was definitely a catastrophe for newly formed states and a huge miss for western powers. Those states could’ve been part of western block and now big chunk of them is slowly drifting to China.
- meindnoch 2y agoWhich states are you referring to? Kazakhstan? Turkmenistan?
- inglor_cz 2y agoI have been travelling to the Baltics since 2000, and the development associated with their Western re-orientation is just massive. Nowadays, Riga or Tallinn feel like Nordic metropolises again. Not as rich as Copenhagen yet, but on their way. In the immediately post-Soviet era, they were just ghastly. It is another story in Moldova or Armenia.
- xenospn 2y agoI was just in Vilnius and I completely agree. It’s fantastic and seems like a great place to live.
- hackandthink 2y agoThe baltic story is nuanced: "Between 2004 and 2016, one out of five Lithuanians emigrated, primarily due to insufficient income for residents." (Wikipedia) https://www.statista.com/statistics/1016444/total-population-baltic-states-1950-2020/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1016444/total-population...
- inglor_cz 2y agoThis statistics looks shocking at the first glance, but many Balts are coming back from their Western jobs and building nice houses back home. Some migration is temporary. The idea that you make a lot of money in the West and come back home is fairly widespread in Central and Eastern Europe. IDK how many Poles worked abroad, but at the height of their exodus, there were several magazines just specializing in advertising foreign jobs. It didn't hurt Poland that much, though. Much of their money flew home as remittances and helped build the country.
- hackandthink 2y agoInteresting how two Americans who were present in Moscow provide similar analyses but come to completely different conclusions. "How the Neocons Chose Hegemony Over Peace Beginning in the Early 1990s" https://www.jeffsachs.org/newspaper-articles/bfsmbpe4plx7cc6lgxhf37lx249r22 https://www.jeffsachs.org/newspaper-articles/bfsmbpe4plx7cc6...
- vkou 2y agoExtending an olive branch in the 90s could have cemented a better Russia today. Instead, the country went straight to shit, Make Russia Great Again reactionaries won the vote, and have spent the next two decades carrying out their agenda (Which has managed to pull the country out of the hole it's been in, but as with any fascist movement, require an external enemy). From the perspective of any sane Russian who lived through the cold war, and then the 90s, entering the 00s and expecting the West to act as a partner, as opposed to an adversary would be absolute lunacy. Fool me once, shame on me, and so forth... So the reformists got all the blame, and the hardliners took over. The seeds of war get sown in peacetime. But hey, every one of those seeds had some pretext or other for it...
- RandomLensman 2y agoWhat kind olive branch would you have wanted to see? There was a lot going on at the time.
- vkou 2y agoThe parent poster's link describes the complete disinterest in engaging with it on economic aid. Reformists actually succeeding in their transition from communism might have nipped the problem in the bud. With aid come strings, those strings could have been used to softly steer the internal political clusterfuck in a better direction.
- RandomLensman 2y agoI don't think that is true for all the nations involved and I think there was a poor understand on how and why things would not work out.
- MaxPock 2y agoThe collapse of the Soviet Union started the moment Stalin got rid of Lenin's New Economic Policy. By the time they realized the rot,it was too late and the Soviet Union could not be saved . Had the leaders reintroduced NEP after Stalin's death in the early 50s ,the Soviet Union would still be around with a GDP of 10 or 15 trillion dollars . China is a Soviet Union with NEP
- lukan 2y agoA collapse that goes on for 60 years and includes and survives a massive invasion of the own land with over 20 million dead .. is a different definition of collapse than I would use.
- roenxi 2y ago[flagged]
- andrepd 2y agoCan you give an example of a country that started poor, adopted laissez-faire capitalism, and became a prosperous nation? It seems that the best predictor of whether a country is prosperous in 2024 is whether it was prosperous in 1724. It's also easy to forget that Russia was quasi-medieval almost up to the 20th century.
- RandomLensman 2y agoGermany? Didn't even exist in 1724 and the area was heavily destroyed by the 30 year war the century before. But depends what you mean by "laissez-faire capitalism".
- roenxi 2y ago[flagged]
- ziggyzecat 2y agoSingapore
- ajdha 2y ago"As the Soviet Union came to an end, American anxiety yielded to an odd euphoria. Americans hadn’t expected revolution and disintegration. And yet many were now speaking with confidence about what must follow: a durable capitalist equilibrium would bring with it democracy and freedom." Yeah, yeah. I do not think the neocons would be happy about a democratic Russia with an economy of the size of the U.S. and oil payments settled in rubles. What nonsense.
- inglor_cz 2y agoRussian economy was nowhere near the size of the American one in the real world. I grew up in late stage Communism; the only thing that the dying regimes were reliably producing were impressive, and completely fraudulent, statistics. On paper, we were all economic tigers, but in the street, people queued in front of the shops whenever something rare, such as washing machines, was promised to be delivered. And the Soviet Union was even less developed than Czechoslovakia. Plus, the more developed regions like the Baltics didn't want to stay subjugated to Russia. Russia proper was underdeveloped. No surprise for a country whose access to the sea is limited and distances are absolutely vast. Such places tend to be underdeveloped everywhere - Kazakhstan, inner Congo, inner Brazil, Australian outback, even many places in the flyover US.
- ajdha 2y agoOf course, hence the "what must follow" in the quoted text. These were predictions by the people who publicly always talk about bringing democracy and freedom. What they say in private is a different matter.
- Yeul 2y agoDespite funding the CIA with many billions of dollars every year there are many surprises. This isn't because the CIA is incompetent. No politicians don't want want to hear what the CIA has to say. The US intelligence services isn't run by some tinker tailor spy spy master. It's just another Washington bureaucrat playing politics. They train people who speak the language and absorb the culture and their reports are ignored.
- doe88 2y agoI remember listening that informative piece from The Economist on the end of soviet union https://www.economist.com/podcasts/2021/12/20/what-we-thought-was-a-deal-done-30-years-ago-is-unravelling-a-historical-view-on-russia-ukraine-tensions https://www.economist.com/podcasts/2021/12/20/what-we-though...