6 ms·
Bankrupt Trucker Yellow Loses Ruling over $6.5B in Pension Debts
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://archive.today/pByzu https://archive.today/pByzu
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThis is good news, as it means pensioners will receive their pensions while hedge fund investment goes to zero.
- unmole 2y agoTypically, institutional investors like pension funds are the biggest investors in hedge funds.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- throw0101a 2y ago> Typically, institutional investors like pension funds are the biggest investors in hedge funds. Maybe, but pension funds (should, at least) invest in multiple asset classes and assets to diversify risk. Not only equities and bonds, but if in hedge funds, then multiple hedge funds. Further, hedge funds generally have multiple investments going as well. In both cases if one particular thing goes to zero, not all the money (should) be lost. Whereas with workers it is hard diversify risk away from your employer and your retirement savings if you have a pension. This is why, contrary to popular opinion, shareholders are not actually owners of a company, but 'just' another stakeholder: other stakeholders would include employees, suppliers, bond holders, retirees, etc. Shareholders are often lowest priority, and for taking on that risk of losing more, they get typically get rewarded more (i.e., stock goes up).
- nine_zeros 2y agoShareholders are owners by virtue of having a seat at the board table and controlling the C-Suite. Bond holders and pension employees don't have a seat to control power. This, shareholders are true owners of the company. But laws prevent them taking other stakeholders for a ride.
- throw0101a 2y ago> Shareholders are owners by virtue of having a seat at the board table and controlling the C-Suite. […] This, shareholders are true owners of the company. But laws prevent them taking other stakeholders for a ride. There are laws and legal precedents in multiple countries that state the shareholders are not owners: * https://edwardslaw.ca/blog/shareholders-agreements-in-canada-corporate-law/ https://edwardslaw.ca/blog/shareholders-agreements-in-canada... * https://www.ippr.org/articles/who-owns-a-company https://www.ippr.org/articles/who-owns-a-company * https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-institutional-economics/article/abs/who-are-the-owners-of-the-firm-shareholders-employees-or-no-one/587374B0969C7F1A3566F70D97732399 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-instituti... Further, directors and such have a fiduciary to the corporation and not to the shareholders: > This separation of ownership and control provides the basis for many of the fundamental principles of corporate law. One example is the principle that the directors and officers of a corporation owe a fiduciary duty to the corporation: see Canadian Aero Service Ltd. v. O'Malley, [1974] S.C.R. 592. * https://decisions.scc-csc.ca/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/699/index.do https://decisions.scc-csc.ca/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/699/ind... And that stakeholders must be considered as well: > Under the CBCA, directors have a fiduciary duty to act honestly, in good faith and in the corporation’s best interest. 2 Until a few decades ago, the corporation’s shareholders were often considered its primary beneficiaries. This shareholder-centric form of corporate governance was known as the shareholder primacy model, a model that would, theoretically, obviate managerial self-dealings. 3 > However, at the end of the last century a shift to include non-shareholder interests began to emerge. Many attribute this shift to the hostile takeover wave of the 1980s, which increased shareholder wealth efficiently but left employees scrambling for work and government institutions struggling to respond.4 The shareholder primacy model came under further scrutiny, in both Canada and the US, after the burst of the tech bubble in 2002 and the 2008 financial crisis.5 * https://www.nortonrosefulbright.com/en-ca/knowledge/publications/a979357b/stakeholders-primacy-paradigm-shift-confirmed https://www.nortonrosefulbright.com/en-ca/knowledge/publicat... The primacy of shareholders started to become in vogue in the 1970s, and so (because of recency bias) is what is best known now, but there is a history of other philosophies before that: * https://scholarship.law.cornell.edu/facpub/865/ https://scholarship.law.cornell.edu/facpub/865/ And the primacy of shareholders, being thought of as the most important stakeholder, did not change the legal precedents.
- wfleming 2y agoIt seems appropriate that a company's own pensions should be senior claims over shareholders which might indirectly be responsible for part of other pensions or retirement funds somewhere down the line.
- snapplebobapple 2y agoIndeed. It seems next level insanity that we dont have wage liabilities (capped at some decently high amount per month like 10k a month to avoid c suite abuse) at the absolute front of the line followed immediately by pension liabilities (again with some capping mechanism to avoid c suite abuse) and then followed by everything else in the evemt of a bankruptcy enshrined in bulletproof law. It should just be how it works with no exceptions.
- itsdrewmiller 2y agoIt seems like you are implying that this is bad outcome for pensions - do you truly believe that?
- unmole 2y agoI don't know who invested in this particular fund. But obviously, hedge funds losing money would be bad for institutional investors.
- PlattypusRex 2y agoTrue, we should change bankruptcy law so hedge funds get priority over employees who worked their whole lives for a company. This will benefit all workers with pensions that invest in hedge funds.
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y agoI'm entirely for this change ... ... right after hedge fund "costs" are limited to a microscopic amount. If you're going to treat private financial service organizations as if they are organized for public good (i.e. paying employee pensions), then they need to operate as such, rather than as wealth generators for their officers. And don't come at me with "that keeps the incentives aligned - if the managers/officers make money, the hedge fund is making more money". I don't buy that the only way to get effective investment growth is by making the officers wealthy beyond all belief. Vanguard agrees with me.
- yieldcrv 2y agoDifferent hedge funds
- ars 2y agoThe pensioners would have gotten them anyway, from the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation. The ruling is just about where that money comes from, the money would be paid either way.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThis would’ve enriched shareholders at the detriment of taxpayers, while also causing pensioners to take a cut on their pensions.
- ars 2y agoThe Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation is not paid for by taxpayers, it's paid for by insurance premiums from other companies. Also the "shareholders" are taxpayers, they are in general just ordinary people investing in businesses.
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/RS/95-118/45 https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/RS/95-118/45 > There is a statutory maximum benefit that PBGC can pay. Participants receive the lower of their benefit as calculated under the plan or the statutory maximum benefit. If a participant’s benefit is higher than the statutory maximum benefit, the participant’s benefit is reduced. Participants in single-employer plans that terminate in 2021 and are trusteed by PBGC may receive up to $72,409 per year if they begin taking their pension at the age of 65. The single-employer maximum benefit is adjusted depending on the age at which the participant begins taking the benefit and on the form of the benefit (e.g., the maximum benefit is lower for a joint-and-survivor annuity). The maximum benefit for participants in multiemployer plans that receive financial assistance depends on the number of years of service in the plan. For example, a participant with 30 years of service may receive up to $12,870 per year. Currently, most workers in singleemployer plans taken over by PBGC and multiemployer plans that receive financial assistance from PBGC receive the full pension benefit that they earned. > However, among participants in multiemployer plans that were terminated and likely to need financial assistance in the future, 49% have a benefit below the PBGC maximum guarantee and 51% have a benefit larger than the PBGC maximum guarantee (and therefore, would see a benefit reduction). At the end of FY2020, PBGC had a total deficit of $48.2 billion, which consisted of a $15.5 billion surplus from the single-employer program and a $63.7 billion deficit from the multiemployer program. PBGC’s single-employer program has been on the Government Accountability Office’s (GAO’s) list of high-risk government programs since 2003. PBGC’s multiemployer program was added in 2009. PBGC projects the financial position of the singleemployer program is likely to continue to improve, but the financial position of the multiemployer program is expected to worsen considerably over the next 10 years. The shortfall will eventually be made up from the general fund, funded by taxpayers. But, we are in the weeds unnecessarily. The PBGC should be a last resort, based on the above context.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoI saw a video on YouTube of a Yellow employee of 30 years distraught that he wouldn’t receive pension that he was counting on (see https://youtu.be/kZyHlPMOCvw?t=105s https://youtu.be/kZyHlPMOCvw?t=105s) . It’s heartbreaking. I don’t really understand the pension model or how it is legal to just take it away randomly. Why isn’t the model just to pay employees more and let them save to a 401k that they control? Anyways this outcome sounds like good news. Employees get what they were due.
- rwmj 2y agoIn the UK after a number of scandals of this type, these kinds of "defined benefit" pensions are now backstopped by a government agency (paid for by a levy on all pensions): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pensions_Regulator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pensions_Regulator (edit: actually it's the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pension_Protection_Fund https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pension_Protection_Fund which does the backstop but the two bodies are related) There is a conflict of interest here, but regular employees aren't able to evaluate that.
- ryandrake 2y agoWe don't really know yet if the 401k experiment is going to be successful. People retiring right now are by and large the earliest beta testers of the 401k idea. My parents and their parents had typical Defined Benefit pensions, and they were all able to simply enjoy their retirements without having to lift a finger to understand the stock market and index funds and tax rules and without needing to micromanage some brokerage account. They never had to worry about contribution limits, IRAs vs. 401k, Roth vs. non-Roth, asset allocation, the right investments for pre-tax vs post-tax money, rules about withdrawing contributions vs. earnings, having to guess what year they'll die to pick the right draw-down rate. They just worked, retired, and money magically came in. You have to admire the simplicity.
- toomuchtodo 2y ago> We don't really know yet if the 401k experiment is going to be successful. Unlikely, based on the data. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41488940 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41488940 (citations from a previous comment I wrote)
- legitster 2y agoTo clarify, Yellow has ~$2.1B in assets and ~$2.6B in debts. The Teamsters Union claims Yellow owes the pension fund ~ $6.5 billion (which works out to about $300k for each Teamster who worked at Yellow when it shut down). But the actual numbers here are mostly made up and don't matter. > The funds asked Goldblatt to rule that billions of dollars in federal grant money they received from the US last year should be ignored when that liability is calculated. The wording here is unclear. But the grant money mentioned here is the relief provided by the American Rescue Plan - the federal government dumped nearly a trillion dollars in guarantees that all qualifying pensions are going to pay out at 100%. So what the pensions lawyers are are arguing is that it doesn't matter that the pension is funded or not, they still have a senior claim on the debt. > The Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp., which regulates retirements funds like those set up for Yellow’s union workers, argued that other companies with traditional pension plans would have an incentive to cancel their retirement benefits if Yellow won since shareholders wouldnt be forced to pay a hefty penalty. More specifically, if every company made the same argument, they would all dump their pension funds and now they would all be the government's problem. It would not be a great precedent.
- gotoeleven 2y agoThe moral hazard is already in place: unions will push for more and more generous benefits, even when they know the employer cannot afford it, because they're pretty sure the government will come and bail it out. Why does only the union get to benefit from this largess? Debts held by favored and disfavored political groups have increasingly different values and this difference can only get so large before something has to break.
- nurtbo 2y agoIf the company has to pay out pensions before shareholders in bankruptcy, that would incentivize shareholders and debt holders to push company to reduce or manage pension obligations.
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y ago
- _DeadFred_ 2y ago'Corporations with all their resources can't figure out how to do retirements with the resources available to them, so just dump the responsibility on Bob with a high school diploma working on the line and even less resources and let him figure it out, he has access to 401ks, and if he doesn't, f him he deserves to starve' is the kind capitalist logic that is turning the tide against capitalism in the USA.