6 ms·
Zero chance I ever give my DNA to one of these companies.
by SoftTalker 2y ago
Zero chance I ever give my DNA to one of these companies.
- mhsdef 2y agoDid your relative? I'm not a geneticist so I could be totally off the mark; but, to my understanding, the painful part is that is a big disclosure right there
- dylan604 2y agoyeah, it's like the shadow profiles on social media sites. just because you didn't do it, doesn't mean that someone else doesn't
- HideousKojima 2y agoMy oldest brother did so I'm already screwed
- starfezzy 2y agoCan even one single person here articulate their specific fears of using 23andme, or is it all FUD?
- zetsurin 2y agoMaybe too far fetched? Company sells/loses data, insurance companies use data to deny coverage, or deem claims as pre-existing.
- peanutz454 2y agoCan an insurance company deny claim based on your DNA? They deny claims for pre-existing condition that you hid from the, which would be the wrong thing to do on your part. They cannot deny claim based on pre existing disposition. Practically everyone is predisposed for getting cancer by merely being human, you might even have cancerous cells in your body right now, that you body will destroy in a couple of minutes.
- dekhn 2y agoHealth insurance in the US can't- it's protected by a law called GINA. Life insurance, however, can use DNA information.
- SoftTalker 2y agoReview world history.
- genewitch 2y agoSure. Someone who has their data in 23andme was someplace where something horrible happened. Law enforcement has no leads, so they process the DNA, and find no matches. They subpoena 23andme (or just look at the leaked data, who knows), and that person is now a person of interest. If they don't know they should have a lawyer on their side with them when being questioned, they might talk themselves into prison. Now imagine that person is innocent.
- noirbot 2y agoI know it's not exactly the point, but the answer is you always have a lawyer if you're being questioned by the police, especially if you're not the one who called them. This is in no way specific to any DNA related situation. If any law enforcement shows up and has questions for you, you say nothing until you have a lawyer with you.
- kelnos 2y agoLawyers are expensive. Most people can't afford one for even one encounter with the police, let alone multiple.
- cryptonector 2y agoDoesn't matter. If they're talking to you say you need your lawyer present -- that will end the interrogation, and you might never need a lawyer. But if you don't say that you might end up convicted.
- itishappy 2y agoPleading the 5th is free.
- noirbot 2y agoI'm not saying it's fair or right. As with most things in life, the cost/benefit makes it likely you'll have to take some risks, but people need to understand that literally any interaction with any law enforcement without a lawyer present is a risk of things going horrifically badly. This is especially true if they show up and you do not know why. That is a massive set of alarm bells that should be going off.
- toast0 2y agoIf I've committed a crime and gotten away with it for several decades, I don't need a relative to NARC on me by giving 23 and me and the feds a DNA sample, thank you very much. It's bad enough they took my fingerprints when I worked for a school district.
- atoav 2y agoWrong people come into power, decide that they want some sort of purity based one genetic information, you are not it get genocided.
- Ylpertnodi 2y ago>you are not it [,] get genocided. Wouldn't the singular be 'un-alived', these fucking days?
- atoav 2y agoWell for one, English is not my first language, so take it with a grain of salt. Also: when I use genocide as as a verb, it means there is a concerted effort to kill of a group of humans, that you happen to be a part of. I know we live in an individualist society, but when you are murdered as part of a genocide that has nothing to do with you as an individual, which is a significant part of the horror of the whole thing. You are then murdered because someone thought you belonged to a group that should be wiped of the face of the earth. Whether you really belonged to that group, whether you share the ideology of the group or of those doing the genocide, wheter you are a really nice individual has nothing to do with it. So I chose that word for a reason..
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Can even one single person here articulate their specific fears of using 23andme Sure. I find out my competitor for the top role has a degenerative disease, e.g. Parkinson’s. It’s not relevant for many years. But I use it, subtly, to shape opinion. More pointedly: we are in an era of mass disinformation. The simple fact that somebody used 23andMe makes any lie about it somewhat credible.
- busterarm 2y agoThere's a whole book about said fears. https://www.amazon.com/Change-Agent-Daniel-Suarez/dp/110198466X https://www.amazon.com/Change-Agent-Daniel-Suarez/dp/1101984...
- lurkshark 2y agoThe company seems to be in rough condition. Say they go bankrupt and an ad-tech data broker buys their assets. Now DraftKings can laser focus their ads to folks genetically predisposed to addiction.
- LarsDu88 2y agoThis is both dystopian and hilarious. 23andMe a subsidiary of Pizza Hut... We know exactly what you crave and it ain't anchovies.
- jay-barronville 2y ago> Say they go bankrupt and an ad-tech data broker buys their assets. Now DraftKings can laser focus their ads to folks genetically predisposed to addiction. Excellent example, but yikes!
- kjkjadksj 2y agoYou’d have to work out what variants predispose for that which is no easy task. And once you did that you don’t even really need individual dna data. You might find say a swedish population tends to have the variant and you just target swedes in general.
- stcroixx 2y agoNot having control of how my DNA is used. It can be taken by the state with a warrant, but otherwise I have control over it.
- sophacles 2y agoBesides the obvious examples of gathering a nice database to use for genocidal purposes... (sure lot's of idiots like to say that's overblown or not really a worry, while being alive in a world where there are on-going 'ethnic cleansing' campaigns). There's also things like - the terms of service include the boilerplate "these terms are subject to change at any time", and I don't want those terms to suddenly change to "we will provide your PII to all insurance companies proactively in exchange for a kickback every time they are able to use it to reject a claim". I already get hassled by the law somewhat frequently because my house used to be the residence of a criminal (2 owners ago it was used as a rental and that owner evicted said criminal). I don't want to add getting hassled by a bunch of people who came in below the max IQ requirements over someone I've never met because they're from "that side" of the family.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- myth_drannon 2y agoWhy? It's just a record of a group of letters, not your soul. I upload my dna records everywhere I can. Sure I had some surprises but in general I benefit from those services.
- 23B1 2y agohigh time preference thinking
- Spivak 2y agoOnly gotta last 80 years, it's pretty rational given the constraints. The what-ifs are unlikely to materialize at all, low probability to happen to you, and avoiding them if they do materialize requires that neither you nor any of your relatives submit their dna or have any contact with the justice system ever. DNA is already protected from use by insurance companies so that's a future harm that already got squashed.
- kelnos 2y agoFunny you picked 80 years. It's been roughly 80 years since members of a certain ethnic group were hunted down, corralled, and murdered because of their lineage and genetics. And their murderers mostly only had census data and people willing to snitch on their neighbors to go on. A DNA database? Oof.
- Spivak 2y agoThankfully time only goes forward and since I don't expect a large scale ethnic cleansing among the developed world since our birth rates are already below replacement I think we're fine.
- syndicatedjelly 2y agoThank you for your interest in 23andMe, unfortunately we have decided to not move forward with your application.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- School-Cotton 2y agoWhy not? What practical harm is caused to you by other people knowing your DNA?
- optymizer 2y agoNow or in the future?
- philodeon 2y agoBook recommendation for you: “IBM And The Holocaust” by Edwin Black. If IBM (then known as Hollerith) could do that much damage with German census data on punchcards…
- freedomben 2y ago> Mankind barely noticed when the concept of massively organized information quietly emerged to become a means of social control, a weapon of war, and a roadmap for group destruction. From IBM and the Holocaust by Edwin Black. Imagine the "massively organized information" that will be available to people in power in the future. It doesn't have to be a genocide for it to be useful to them. People in power today are fully on board with "social control" and it's so uncontroversial that they talk about it openly.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- syndicatedjelly 2y agoComments like this are why schools should make liberal arts education mandatory again in the STEM curriculum
- dekhn 2y agoI took an alternate approach: my genome is freely available: https://my.pgp-hms.org/profile/hu80855C https://my.pgp-hms.org/profile/hu80855C When I was sequenced, a bunch of genetic counselors at Illumina analyzed it and said they couldn't find a single gene mutation that was linked to increased risk of disease, which was a surprise to me but is really absence of information rather than information of absence.
- rendaw 2y agoThe problem with publicizing genetic information is that you're defacto publicizing large amounts of the genetic information of your relatives, who may not be in a life situation where publicizing it carries no risk. This is also an objection many have to 23andMe.
- fastball 2y agoFor example?
- ff317 2y agoWhat if they live in a country in which genetic evidence of a disease can deny or significantly increase the cost of health coverage? Even if you're clear of those for now, a new marker may be discovered tomorrow. Apparently (according another commenter) Life Insurance /can/ legally look at this even in the US. What about employers? What if it puts them on the DNA-evidence hook for a "crime" in their jurisdiction which you and they don't think is an ethical law (evidence of homosexual activity in a country that imprisons for it, or worse).
- fastball 2y agoThe crime thing sounds like a huge stretch given it's not actually your DNA. With the insurance example I'm not sure I have a problem with that? The whole pre-existing condition conversation around health insurance is totally out-of-whack. Insurance was not designed for things you know have happened. It was invented to reduce the downside of things that could happen, commensurate with the risk of that thing happening. It's risk management. It makes zero sense to apply that model to something like universal health coverage. If someone is 100x more likely to get cancer, their insurance premiums should be higher. Just like if I'm a ship captain sailing into the bermuda triangle my premiums should be higher than sailing around the mediterranean. If you feel that everyone should have healthcare, utilizing health "insurance" for this is the worst of kludges.