7 ms·
Signatures of gravitational atoms from black hole mergers
- perihelions 2y agoIs the reason these are coherent quantum states that the postulated ultralight axions don't strongly interact with anything except gravity, so they see very little environmental noise to decohere them? Would they also predict there's (much smaller) dark matter halos around ordinary planets and stars, and these also have quantized atom-like states?
- wwarner 2y agoyes, just heard about it on Physics Frontiers. Monsalve & Kaiser are talking about primordial black holes, and are offering a theory that if they were imbalanced in color charge, they could be surrounded by a particle cloud, in a big quantum state. https://pca.st/episode/f0db6ab1-18ff-4201-a6b2-a30b780a266a https://pca.st/episode/f0db6ab1-18ff-4201-a6b2-a30b780a266a
- InDubioProRubio 2y agoStupid question, but between two singularities merging, there is tiny space, with gravitation zeroing out and appearing plank matter being ripped towards one and the other. Can one spot that location in the middle where anti-matter and matter bleed from the nothing on modern telescopes?
- elashri 2y agoRegardless of the gravity canceling out in this region (which is more complicated and probably will not happen). The current LIGO and Virgo wouldn't have enough spatial resolution to pinpoint tiny regions between black holes. To explain what will happen is that gravitational field in region you are describing would have a steep spacetime curvature and a point where it will cancel gravitational forces would be more of a saddle (lagrange point classically) point rather than zero gravity region. Now you also have quantum fluctuations that now with this strong gravitational field you will have virtual particle - anti particle paris pop in and out of vaccum. This is not going to be only in thia region but all around. Also merging process will enhance this phenomenon but deciding where actually this middle point will be difficult. Now it would be impossible at least for our current observational tools to have resolution for the scale we are talking about. Event horizon telescope for example is designed to observe areas around singularities on much larger scales that what you are interested in here. But the interesting part would be If matter and antimatter pairs were produced between merging black holes, they would likely be short-lived. In this intense gravitational environment, any particles created would be rapidly torn apart or accelerated towards one of the black holes. The annihilation of such pairs might emit gamma rays, but this signal would be extraordinarily faint compared to the other high-energy processes occurring during a black hole merge. So the answer is probably No, at least with our current technology.
- pdonis 2y ago> gravitational forces Gravity is not a force in GR. The spacetime curvature in a spacetime with two black holes that merge is not describable in terms of a simple "gravitational field". Spacetime curvature is a fourth rank tensor with twenty independent components. In vacuum ten of those vanish identically, leaving ten independent components.
- oneshtein 2y agoEach black hole has tiny spot with zero gravitation in the centre.
- Vecr 2y agoIn some Newtonian or pseudo-Newtonian models, possibly? Not in GR/General Relativity.
- oneshtein 2y agoWhy we should prefer the GR model, which lacks mapping from the model back to physical reality, over a physical explanation? It's clear that GR is wrong in case of black hole, because mass CAN escape black holes[1], while GR says that nothing can escape black hole after crossing of event horizon, because of [internal implementation of their model] nonsense. [1]: https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2022/10/black-hole-burps-up-shredded-star-years-after-consuming-it/ https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2022/10/black-hole-bu...
- Vecr 2y agoInternal model implementations? You mean the speed of light?
- oneshtein 2y agoOpenGL can predict nice images about black holes. Thus, our Universe is just a frame buffer (array [x,y,z;t]), while gravitation is not a force but a shader. Sorry, our Universe is just a spacetime (array [x,y,z;t]), while gravitation is not a force but a curvature of spacetime.
- Vecr 2y agoYou need some sort of relativity to explain the Michelson–Morley result.
- pdonis 2y ago> between two singularities merging Two black holes merging does not mean two singularities merging. The singularity (singular, not plural) is a moment of time that is to the future of all other moments inside the hole. If two black holes merge, there is just one singularity inside the merged hole. Remember that GR is a model of spacetime, not space. In spacetime, a single black hole looks, heuristically, like a cylinder, and the singularity inside is at the future end of the cylinder. Two black holes merging look, heuristically, like a pair of trousers, and the (one) singularity inside the merged hole is at the future end of the trousers (the "waist").
- Jerrrrrrry 2y agovery good, but I would say (since "light cone" is of such common parlance) that the physical 3d analogous projection would be two slightly overlapping 3d-venn diagram funnels conjoining at an "indefinitely" (asymptotically smaller) small space-time minkowski manifold. naked singularities themselves, however, do not exist.
- pdonis 2y ago> the physical 3d analogous projection would be two slightly overlapping 3d-venn diagram funnels conjoining at an "indefinitely" (asymptotically smaller) small space-time minkowski manifold. I'm not sure what you mean by this, but it doesn't seem to correspond to any actual physical model that I'm aware of.
- Jerrrrrrry 2y agoboth objects have a space cone that is overlapping - since they can observe each other, but also have a small bit they xor can observe, since they are a spatialtime distance apart. regardless, once they are inside the event horizon, their spacetime ends in a "singularity" - that only they experience, since everyone else just saw an ever-slowing couple of observers that never quite reached the event horizon (to the outside observer, who would eventually be either iron or protons, depending if God had decided if they protons should decay or not yet) i was just pointing out cone versus cylinder, since the black holes' effect is polynomial af
- willis936 2y agoWhat you're asking for is a naked singularity. Nothing can produce that, not even another black hole.
- daxfohl 2y agoOne odd thing that never occurred to me until now is that two black holes that pass each other at near light speed, if they intersect by even a nanometer, will be guaranteed to merge. That nanometer has to fall into both singularities due to the properties of black holes, so transitively they have to merge. Kind of weird. I'm guessing it would create a bunch of angular momentum and throw out almost all their masses as gravitational waves. Will be a fun experiment for someone in a few hundred years.
- ordu 2y ago> I'm guessing it would create a bunch of angular momentum and throw out almost all their masses as gravitational waves. Will be a fun experiment for someone in a few hundred years. I'm not a physicist but it sounds to me like a gravitational bomb. I wonder how it will affect its surroundings? Stars being torn apart? I wouldn't like to watch such an experiment in person. Though if someone tried it a couple billions light years away from me, and then sent a video record, I'm all for it. I'd prefer to wait a couple billions years for the record to be downloaded, than to watch an online stream.
- hamzastito 2y ago[flagged]
- api 2y agoMy most recent physics rabbit hole was the black hole hole. They are fascinating. My favorite is the idea of primordial black holes which formed in the instants after the Big Bang. Many models and theories predict them and they could be an excellent dark matter candidate. The universe could be full of black holes in the asteroid mass range the size of hydrogen atoms. There is also a hypothesis that the predicted (by many solar system simulations and models) planet nine far beyond Neptune could be a captured primordial black hole in the 1-5 Earth mass range and about the size of a golf ball to a tennis ball. I really really hope that exists because if it did it would be within probe range. Going and checking out a black hole could allow us to solve physics and develop a complete tested unified theory. Then there’s spooky shit like: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole_electron https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole_electron
- renox 2y ago> The universe could be full of black holes in the asteroid mass range the size of hydrogen atoms. ? Not if there's Hawking radiations.
- api 2y agoIf the Hawking temperature is below the CMB no net evaporation happens. This means there is a mass cutoff and it’s below asteroid mass. Any smaller PBHs would have evaporated by now assuming we are right about Hawking radiation. The math says it should exist but we have AFAIK not proven it. The big black holes will last insanely long amounts of time.
- ithkuil 2y agoI'm confused. Hawking temperature is inversely proportional to the mass. I assume most black holes except the very small ones would thus have a hawking temperature lower than the CMB. Does that mean that effectively no black holes will ever evaporate not even a tiny bit well until the future time when the CMB will be so red shifted that black holes will start to have net radiation?
- profsummergig 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ck2 2y agoApparently I am not watching enough PBS SpaceTime because I still do understand what a "gravitational atom" might be. They are not implying a particle that causes gravity right? Because I thought it is pretty well accepted there isn't a "gravaton" like there are photons. They also don't mean atom-sized black-holes, so I still don't get it. Hoping Matt does an episode on this so I can grasp it. https://www.pbs.org/show/pbs-space-time/ https://www.pbs.org/show/pbs-space-time/
- tectonic 2y agoI think they are more drawing an analogy between the atom one or more black holes with a cloud of particles around them. Black holes are quantum mechanical and so the resulting system could behave much like an atom, including having things that look like energy levels. The universe rhymes.
- pdonis 2y ago> I still do understand what a "gravitational atom" might be. It's a vague gesture in the direction of a speculative theory of quantum gravity. It's not anything we have any actual evidence for.
- pokeymcsnatch 2y ago> I thought it is pretty well accepted there isn't a "gravaton" like there are photons. Different branch of physics that we can't quite mesh with GR yet. A graviton is the quantized "piece" of gravity, like phonon is for sound/mechanical waves, or photons for EM. It exists as much as a photon or any other "messenger particles" exists, in that it's a useful mathematical model. It's not something we have isolated/observed with equipment though.
- andrewflnr 2y agoAs far as I know the existence of the graviton is 100% up in the air, not well accepted either way. But yeah, particles in energy levels gravitationally bound to a black hole in a similar way electrons are electrically bound to a nucleus.
- gradientsrneat 2y ago
- swframe2 2y agoWe were told that nothing can escape a black hole. But when black holes merge, the combined mass is smaller. It is described that the lost mass is converted to gravitational waves. But gravity is the curvature of space caused by mass, it is not described as a form of mass. How do you understand this process of matter escaping a black hole? Is it that the gravitational waves are caused by a "quantum gravity" particle that can't be converted back to any of the other quantum particles?
- cyberax 2y ago> But gravity is the curvature of space caused by mass, it is not described as a form of mass. Gravitational waves carry momentum and energy (and therefore mass), just like electromagnetic waves. Theoretically, you can extract that energy from gravitational waves, by using oscillating masses tuned to the wave's frequency.
- pdonis 2y ago> Gravitational waves carry momentum and energy (and therefore mass), just like electromagnetic waves. No, EM waves do not have mass. They are massless. They carry momentum and energy, yes, but not mass. In GR, the source of gravity is not "mass", it's stress-energy. EM waves carry stress-energy even though they are massless. Gravitational waves do have some aspects that are analogous to EM waves, but there is a key difference: gravitational waves do not have any stress-energy. They are pure spacetime curvature in vacuum. So while there is a sense in which they carry momentum and energy, since properly constructed detectors can extract momentum and energy from them, they do not carry any stress-energy and the momentum and energy they carry cannot be localized the way momentum and energy in EM waves can.
- cyberax 2y ago> No, EM waves do not have mass. They are massless. They carry momentum and energy, yes, but not mass. OK, EM waves can get _transformed_ into mass.