8 ms·
What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing?
- monkpit 2y agoThe submitted title is wild compared to the article.
- westondeboer 2y ago> The Moral Panic Over Ozempic Misses the Point The media has made the drugs about body politics and our obsession with thinness. That’s the wrong story.
- oh_gosh 2y agohttps://archive.is/https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/ozempic-weight-loss-diet-drug-moral-panic.html https://archive.is/https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/o... Appears that the original title was the submitted title. (Note: I'm not sure how Archive.is works with titles.)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- howard941 2y agoThe HN bookmarklet picked up the "What if" title. It's often different from the article title. EDIT: The "What if" title is from the article's HTML markup...
- petesergeant 2y agoThere appear to be a lot of people who derive a significant amount of their self-confidence and self-image from not being fat, and looking down on people who are. They seem to get pretty upset when people who they've been able to dismiss as fat become not fat, and hate that these drugs allow the users of them to take away that moral superiority -- various GLP1 subreddits are full of stories about them. I'd never encountered anyone like that in real life, but they show up over and over again on any discussion of these drugs. It's very strange to me.
- Apocryphon 2y agoIt exists in the same line of argumentation as being against student loan debt forgiveness because one had to pay off one's own loans, except about something that is even more determined by one's birth.
- borroka 2y agoSome alleles give people a tendency to gain weight via a higher appetite, slower metabolism, addiction to substances (in this case food). But no matter your alleles, you still have to pick up your fork and start attacking those triple portions of nachos. Let's not forget that 1-2 generations ago, the percentage of obese people was much lower than today, but the proportions of the above-mentioned alleles are very unlikely to have changed in 30-50 years.
- Apocryphon 2y agoPerhaps food is more ultra-processed now. Micro-plastics. Gut flora disruption. Seed oils. 5G vaccines. Name a fad and there's a [whatever the antonym for panacea is] for why obesity rates are higher.
- goostavos 2y agoIt's feels unfair that a single Halloween Oreo cookie is 70 calories. The caloric density of modern and delicious food is absolutely insane. And so, aside from a rare treat, which mostly leaves me sad (because I only get to eat two), I eat things that aren't ultra-processed 5G seed oil based. And my weight remains controlled despite said 5G vaccines, seed oils, and gut flora disruption. Ozympic seems like a net good if it helps people control their weight. It just always seems preposterous when people blame "ultra-processed food" as the root problem, rather than the over consumption of said food as the problem.
- borroka 2y agoI wrote that someone has to pick up that fork to eat those nachos. However, processed food makes it easier to eat more calories than you need. Ice cream used to be a once-a-week treat. Now, you can buy a pint of a caloric bomb for 2.99 USD. I'm not suggesting a conspiracy, but as someone who exercises frequently and eats similar food when traveling, I can say with conviction that something is going on with the food sold in the US. For example, I often get pimples on my face after eating pork or beef in the US. I never get pimples when I eat pork or beef in Europe or South America. I have more problems not getting fat when I'm in the US and I feel more bloated. The usual explanation, which has merit, is that portions are bigger in the US and people move less than in other countries. However, I eat 95% of my meals at home, cooked by me, and I exercise 1 or 2 times daily.
- throwanem 2y agoParticipate in a Phase IV trial at your peril. But I wonder whether I'd say the same if I hadn't learned to lose and keep off all the weight I needed to, before it came along. (If the downvotes are because I sound like I'm bragging, that's fair but also not my intent. What I mean to say is, I suspect I'd view this class of drug and indication less dispassionately and with more of an appetite for risk, if I weren't so lucky as to have no pressing need for the benefit.)
- ebiester 2y agoYes, but we've had Ozempic since 2017 for type 2 diabetes. That's longer than Vioxx was on the market.
- WillPostForFood 2y agoAnd other GLP-1 receptor agonists since 2005 when Exenatide was approved.
- cyberax 2y agoAnd before that, liraglutide. Ozempic (semaglutide) is basically the same drug with some tweaks to extend its half-life.
- throwanem 2y agoGranted, although I might counter that given so broad an apparent increase in the scope of the indication, 2017-2021 (? I can't immediately find a date for Ozempic specifically) and 2021- might best be taken as at least partially distinct. I think that's an argument less well advanced by me than by someone who could design such a study, though, not least because they'll know far better than I whether the proposition makes any real sense.
- JohnMakin 2y ago> Suboxone is a compound of two drugs that decreases one’s cravings for opioids while blocking their effects. It is safer and less cumbersome than methadone, which requires daily or weekly visits to a clinic, and more effective than any abstinence-based treatment, which requires people to withstand cravings and suppress physical discomfort. This highlights one of the issues I have with articles like this about Ozempic at this current moment - this glosses over something major with these two particular drugs. With methadone, yes, it will keep you off of heroin, but you'll also likely never, ever get off of methadone because the withdrawal is 1) just as horrible and severe as heroin and 2) can last months. To the point where you'd almost be better off just kicking the heroin the "old fashioned" way. suboxone is similar - the drug isn't without side effects either. Of course, that isn't to say these things aren't useful - to have a methadone/suboxone dependency is way preferable to heroin addiction. My only real point is that we should wait to see what long term side effects these drugs have before calling them miracles and glossing over their down sides, because I think the end effect of that is counterproductive to medicine. I'm always immediately skeptical as to what drugs pharmaceutical companies are pushing out, due to the history I've witnessed so far in my lifetime. That all said Ozempic probably would've saved a relative of mine's life. In the end, they'd likely not care about the side effects all that much.
- quickthrowman 2y agoSuboxone is far easier to discontinue than methadone, I took it for 18 months and then discontinued use about 10 years ago. Methadone withdrawals can last for a month (I’d never make it that long) but suboxone physical withdrawals were gone in a few days. Suboxone also has a dosage ceiling (32mg) where methadone does not.
- BearOso 2y ago> I'm always immediately skeptical as to what drugs pharmacies are pushing out Major nitpick here. Pharmacies aren't pushing anything. Pharmaceutical companies are pushing these drugs. Worse yet, independent pharmacies have only been losing money selling GLP-1 agonists. Insurance companies have begun to collude using pricing networks. They claim that the market value that pharmacies get the drugs for is too high, even though they are still patented and brand-name, so the insurance and pharmaceutical companies together are the ones that set the price. Then they refuse to reconcile the cost minus the deductible. Last I knew, it was about -42$ on a month prescription.
- riffraff 2y ago> Ozempic seems to be something of a miracle. It’s a very effective treatment for diabetes as well as high blood pressure, heart failure, and kidney disease. New evidence suggests that it improves depression and reduces suicidality, and it also seems, unexpectedly, to reduce non-food-related addictive behaviors, like gambling. Studies are underway to see if it prevents cancer and Alzheimer’s disease. reminds me of cortisone, which was also hailed (and partially is) a sort of panacea. Turned out not to be a cure for everything, and with some significant downsides, while still being a very valuable drug.
- juoitre 2y agoSee also dicyclomine. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dicycloverine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dicycloverine
- borski 2y agoIt's hard to differentiate because so many of the positive effects of GLP-1 drugs correlate so well with just... weight loss. So in that sense, we will have to see - but if obesity and/or T2D is a trigger for lots of other diseases (and we know it is), then it would appear that fighting it effectively would help fix metabolic syndrome and many of the other diseases that are often comorbid with it.
- renewiltord 2y agoIt's just the same old thing. If someone worked hard to get somewhere, they hate it when someone else gets that for free. Oh, but you didn't really make that art, you used a brush, you used a diffusion model, blah blah. Oh but you didn't really work out. Oh but you didn't really write that Python program in 100 lines, it actually relies on these million lines of stdlib + firmware. If it works, it works. If it doesn't, it doesn't. That's how it is. I have a personal bias to small effect consistent medication over high effect rare medication, but I have at least one friend who has seen great results with Ozempic. So I'm glad to see more people can access this drug. After all, I can't really see. I use glasses or contact lenses.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- coffeebeqn 2y agoWhich is pretty weird because just qualitatively ozempic wont get you into “great shape” - just helps you not be very unhealthily overweight. You still need to do the weights and nutrition for muscles or cardio for great cardiovascular health
- CorruptedArc 2y agoExactly, all of which becomes significantly easier when someone isn't excessively overweight. They still need to put in effort to reach a good place.
- scandox 2y agoWell I'm sympathetic to your point of view, but there I think there are some small chinks in the armour of this argument. To give two examples: 1. I read an article about plastic surgery for show dogs in Brazil: as it pointed out the dogs presented beautifully but their offspring had the original flaws which were undesirable. Might seem absurd but it highlights the possibility of a result being achieved in a way that is inauthentic and has the seeds of future failure within it. 2. There are many things in life in which the result is merely evidence of a journey undertaken which is in itself understood to prove something that is otherwise not visible. For example one might say that someone who did a tremendous amount of exercise has shown focus and determination...the visible result may be them appearing fit. So again maybe the visible result is sometimes just a signifier of the effort it took and that might be considered the important aspect. It really depends on the observer and what they care about. In a sense you and I with our glasses are like Brazilian show dogs - we can see alright but indeed our vision is flawed and when I lose my glasses I can feel pretty helpless.
- slowmovintarget 2y agoWasn't this the drug that also had the occasional effect of stopping people's digestive tract cold so they could no longer eat? Or am I thinking of something else. That's not listed here: https://www.drugs.com/sfx/ozempic-side-effects.html?form=subcutaneous_solution https://www.drugs.com/sfx/ozempic-side-effects.html?form=sub...
- optimalsolver 2y ago[flagged]
- kurisufag 2y agoimagine how the rest of us have been feeling up to this point.
- asdfman123 2y agoTruly the most pressing issue of our day
- falcor84 2y agoYou not liking it wouldn't make it a dystopia. But regardless, I wouldn't be concerned. We humans are interested in the rare and exotic, so I would bet that if being overweight ever becomes unusual, we'll soon see a shift of some people back towards it.
- riehwvfbk 2y agoAnd it will be considered beautiful and high status.
- hypertele-Xii 2y agoImagine taking drugs instead of working out.
- redhed 2y agoIt's more about changing eating habits than working out. Pretty easy to work out and not lose weight (or gain weight if that's your goal).
- linotype 2y agoExactly. It doesn’t matter how much you work out if you’re eating in excess of calorie burn, which is just too easy to do.
- jrockway 2y agoI used to bike 30 miles a day and never lost weight. Cardio is good for pretty much one thing: building cardio. To lose weight, you have to eat less. GLP-1 receptor agonists make your brain think that enough food is actually enough food, rather than "panic, I'm going to die if I don't eat more".
- kevinsync 2y agoSome people take drugs and don't work out. Some people work out and don't take drugs. Some people take drugs TO work out. Some people work out THEN take drugs. Some people work out to AVOID taking drugs. Who cares, everything's a drug anyways. If there was a wetware interface to your brain that you could deploy code into and you wrote a patch for your own obesity, given that we're on HN in the first place, you'd likely think it was cool. Deploying the instructions via organic chemistry? Lame! Dismiss it! The whole thing just reminds me of Mr. Mandelbaum on Seinfeld having "worked out with Charles Atlas in the 50's" -- times change!
- chowells 2y agoWritten like someone who's never lost weight in their life. You don't lose weight by working out, unless you're at like 4+ hours per day. It only takes a couple minutes to eat more calories than a typical workout session burns. What matters is convincing your entire body that you're not in danger of starvation. That it's not a dire emergency that you're expending more calories than you're consuming. That that millions of years of evolved emergency systems no longer are leading you in the direction you desire. And keeping your focus on that for every minute of the 6+ hours per day where your body is screaming that you need more food. GLP-1 agonists very slightly help with that. Ok, they probably help more than slightly if the dosage is tuned carefully, but you do need to worry more about side effects at higher doses as well. Medication is no panacea, but the fact is that we evolved in a very different environment than the one in which we now live. Many people benefit from some help bringing our body's impulses into sync with our new environment.
- akavi 2y ago> We also had initial results from the FLOW trial, suggesting that Ozempic prevents diabetics with kidney disease from needing dialysis. Between this and the 2nd order decrease in renal disease from the reduction in diabetes and high blood pressure, Ozempic would have to end up having some truly awful long term effects to net out negative in utilitarian terms. The US spends 130 G$/yr (0.5% of the _entire_ GDP) on dialysis, and that undercounts just how awful being on dialysis is in subjective terms.
- cyberax 2y agoIt's so awful that kidney disease is basically one of the conditions that triggers Medicare coverage at any age. It's basically one of the very few ways you can get socialized healthcare in the US.
- carlmr 2y agoAlso if applied early enough may prevent diabetes in the first place.
- akira2501 2y ago> 130 G$/yr (0.5% of the _entire_ GDP) on dialysis Why is dialysis a reasonable endpoint for comparison? How do you know that market functions properly and that prices reflect actual costs of providing service? > to net out negative in utilitarian terms. Life long attachments to drugs are universally negative. You only have to ask, "what happens when the supply chain is disrupted?" If you've never been anywhere where alcohol was suddenly hard to get you might not understand how hidden and pernicious these problems can be.
- VyseofArcadia 2y ago> Between this and the 2nd order decrease in renal disease from the reduction in diabetes and high blood pressure, Ozempic would have to end up having some truly awful long term effects to net out negative in utilitarian terms. On a population level, you're absolutely correct. But as an individual, I want to know what I'm getting into for long term effects. I might personally find them objectionable. So I'll wait and see.
- iwsk 2y agoFree lunch good
- fnfjfk 2y agoHow do these drugs affect cardiovascular health compared to exercising? Basically if you run/bike a lot you’ll burn more calories and lose weight if you eat at a deficit. But you’ll also improve your heart health, lower your resting heart rate, etc. Do these drugs help in that way at all or just with losing the weight? It would be amazing if we had a drug that improved people’s heart health.
- riehwvfbk 2y agoThere's also the "a lot" part that's problematic. It's not easy to find time to bike enough that it makes a difference.
- akira2501 2y ago> not easy to find time to bike enough Are children and teens being prescribed this drug? Have you ever lived in the suburbs?
- riehwvfbk 2y ago"Enough" is a lot more than a casual bike ride. I used to have a bike commute that totaled 30 miles. Yes, I was in good shape. But it took 4 times longer than driving and required having a shower at the office.
- akira2501 2y agoSo Ozempic is "maybe a good thing" because it would make it easier for teens and kids to get to the office for the job while maintaining a slim physical appearance? Ok.
- NovemberWhiskey 2y agoYou can’t outrun your fork. These are different parts of the problem. Also: achieving a reasonable weight makes it much easier to get into an exercise program.
- xkcd-sucks 2y ago> What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? Then I will gladly suffer FOMO while other people test this hypothesis over the next decade or so
- jansan 2y agoThere is so much money to be made with these drugs that if there were any negative effects with Ozempic, the money needed to keep them out of the news would look like pocket change in comparison. That's why I try not to be an early adopter for drugs. I am currently doing an old fashioned diet to get my body weight down and reduce my blood pressure (which actually has normalized already).
- Svoka 2y agohelps to read actual article
- 1970-01-01 2y agoI'm just glad something this effective is available. Obesity is a novel epidemic. Being very fat is supposed to be the exception to the rule, and not the default.
- zamalek 2y agoAs far as I understand it, the one major issue is that it can make a temporary problem (overweight) a chronic one. As a counter-example, most people experience depression at least once in their life and most of these take antidepressants on a temporary basis (the exception being those who are genetically/developmentally depressed - i.e. chronic/lifelong). Once the underlying issue has been addressed with therapy or what-have-you, these people can cease use of the drug. This is not the case with Ozempic. If you take it to lose weight then cessation will cause rapid weight gain. You'll be stuck with it for the rest of your life, for something that can [again] usually be permanently solved with other forms of treatment. I think this is morally fine. However, it does mean that these people will suffer even more harm if they are ever find themselves unable to afford/obtain Ozempic. We would effectively be duplicating the current issue that we have with insulin.
- borski 2y ago> This is not the case with Ozempic. If you take it to lose weight then cessation will cause rapid weight gain. You'll be stuck with it for the rest of your life, for something that can [again] usually be permanently solved with other forms of treatment. This is not true. If you stop taking GLP-1 meds, you will revert back to whatever it was you were like prior to taking them, unless you have made significant lifestyle changes. So: you take a GLP-1 med, change nothing, lose a bunch of weight, get off it, and still eat McDonald’s every day? Yeah, you’ll gain it back. But if you exercise regularly (specifically strength training) and adjust your diet, which is what every single doctor worth their salt will tell you you must do, then you can get off of it over time or go to a much lower dose. These drugs are not and should not be prescribed to people who are simply “temporarily overweight.” It is not like magically getting off the GLP-1 meds makes you ravenous; it’s all about whether or not you’ve changed anything while on it.
- calmoo 2y agoBut isn't one of the effects of GLP-1 is that it literally makes you not crave junk food? It doesn't just metabolize food more, or however that works, it also changes your dietary behaviours.
- ghostcluster 2y agoIt's not just weight loss that Ozempic and the other GLP-1 drugs encourage. They also help people stop drinking to excess, and help lower pangs for other harmful drugs like heroin. I believe that these attributes are so promising, that the idea of government subsidized Ozempic just seems like great domestic policy to me. I believe that whichever politician pitches this idea first will get a ton of support from the public and the press.
- themadturk 2y agoI take 3mg of Rybelsus, the pill form of Ozempic, every day for diabetes. This is about half the recommended dosage, but the major side effect for me has been gastric distress...on the full 7mg daily dose I was frequently nauseous, to the point where it rendered me unable to work some days. 3mg is supposedly the dosage you start out with for a month before moving up to 7mg, but 3mg has relieved most of my stomach distress, kept my daily blood sugar numbers down, and probably helped with weight loss (I'm down 15 pounds since February, a steady reduction that started a good 3 or 4 months before starting Rybelsus). The weight loss is a bonus for me; I'm in it for the diabetes benefits. When I was on the full dose, I often felt full. The half dose has the same effect, just not as much. Fortunately my insurance covers most of the cost; at $25 a month, it's over 2.5x higher than any of my other prescriptions, but well within my budget. We'll see how long that lasts, especially since I plan to retire at the end of 2025 and go onto Medicare.
- cyberax 2y agoTry injectable version. Rybelsus works by making your stomach walls permeable to peptides, and as you experienced, it's not the best for comfort.
- themadturk 2y agoThe injectables are substantially more expensive under my insurance, and I really don't like the idea of self-injection. The 3mg Rybelsus tablet are substantially more comfortable to use than the 7mg; minor stomach discomfort and none of the nausea I experienced with the 7mg tablets, yet my A1C is, if not quite as well controlled, definitely in the acceptable range.
- Animats 2y agoThe cost problem will decline over time, as patents run out. The underlying drug is old. The food industry is worried.[1] "One big concern for the industry is the importance of so-called “super consumers”, who drive an outsized share of spend. For instance, consider this recent estimate: 9% of adults drive 34% of candy consumption. Assume that one-third of those adults successfully adopt Ozempic or another GLP-1, and that’s a roughly 10% hit to category sales." The snack industry needs "whales". [1] https://foodinstitute.com/focus/analysis-ozempic-likely-to-impact-snack-manufacturers-bottom-line/ https://foodinstitute.com/focus/analysis-ozempic-likely-to-i...
- borski 2y agoTrue. It would be a good time to short some candy companies. Soda companies will figure it out by releasing lots of diet sodas and energy drinks and so on. See's? Their generation might be dying soon, heh
- Animats 2y ago> Soda companies will figure it out by releasing lots of diet sodas and energy drinks and so on. There seem to be many new products which are just overpriced soda water with some minor fruit flavoring.
- borski 2y agoPrecisely. OTOH, I am glad that more and more are switching to sweeteners like Monkfruit rather than aspartame and the rest. (Yes, I know the jury is out on them being carcinogenic, blah blah, I don't care - I'm just glad that people seem to want to see a greater variety of sweeteners like Monkfruit and Allulose on the market)
- wormius 2y agoI've literally just been buying powder mixes instead of energy drinks (see: mio, crystal light, etc...) and using caffeine pills for the caffeine. I could just do plain water, but then I have that minor desire for flavor. Absolutely not necessary, but helps cut the urge for an expensive can of energy drink. My last purchase was a 4.75 can of Gatorade flavor (not uh, low cal, alas), makes 9 gallons, far cheaper than energy drink. But you can buy low/no cal flavoring too. I think this might be the future (til they jack prices to reach parity with canned/premixed drinks cuz the market says they can).
- l33tbro 2y agoThe article steps around the fact that Ozempic encourages poor nutrition and entrenches body dysmorphia. Working out and eating responsibly not only creates far more longevity, but it mentally empowers you to be the custodian of your own wellness.
- lowbloodsugar 2y agoIn the past I have managed to lose weight with a soul crushing diet and regular exercise. In the last five years, that hasn’t worked and I’m clinically obese again. In my case, working out and eating soul crushing diets, and having that NOT work has had the opposite effect on my mental empowerment, as you can imagine. So I finally broke down to my doctor of 6 years and she said let’s try Ozempic. Doesn’t look like insurance is going to pay for it though…
- l33tbro 2y agoSorry to hear that. Look, I see what you're saying. But a punitive mentality is never going to lead anywhere. At least not for very long. My personal experience has been shifting my goal from "weight loss" to the much more empowering role of being a caretaker. This paradigm shift was the hack that finally got me out of terrible eating cycles, and put me in a much better place. There is definitely a place for Ozempic, particularly as a stop-gap in acute obesity. But I believe it defers personal responsibility for one's nutrition and well-being.
- borski 2y agoIt's nice that that worked for you. Please clarify how "ozempic encourages poor nutrition" (it doesn't), and how it "entrenches body dysmorphia" (it doesn't). Specifically, doctors prescribing GLP-1 meds counsel you on diet and exercise because it is necessary for the GLP-1 meds to be most effective, and "working out and eating responsibly" is not new advice to people who have been obese for a long time. Also, the moral judgment of "just need to work harder" is trash, and untrue. I guarantee you people who have been obese a long time have not spent their entire lives just "being okay with it." They walk into a doctor's office crying, not knowing what to do, at the end of their rope, or they have simply completely given up ever trying again because it has never worked. Sometimes, it is laziness. It would be absurd for me to argue that is never true. But that is a tiny minority, and I would bet money on that. You know what creates far more longevity? Not being obese, and working out and eating responsibly. Sometimes, in order to achieve that, some people need help; and we finally have some help in the form of these GLP-1 medications. I'm not sure why anyone would be against people finally getting healthy.
- thefz 2y ago> What If Ozempic Is Just a Good Thing? Has there ever been a point in human history in which we basically started taking a drug daily for the rest of our lives with no side effect whatsoever?
- borski 2y ago"No side effect whatsoever" is not what anyone is claiming.
- GloriousKoji 2y ago2nd generation antihistamines (Claritin, Zyrtec)?
- goostavos 2y agoNose bleeds :(
- williamstein 2y agoCaffeine? There are side effects, but it's pretty manageable.
- thefz 2y agoYou will be surprised by how many people are sensitive to it and plain avoid coffee/tea.
- vharuck 2y agoDepends on where you draw the line for "drug". Of the top of my head, some population-wide (or nearly so) public health efforts that we consider effective: fluoride in the water, iodized salt, and baby aspirin for older people. There are probably some vitamin supplements that would do a lot of good if most people took them.
- kytazo 2y agoSince when fluoride in water is considered a good thing by any means?
- imwillofficial 2y agoThe problem with Ozempic isn't the drug. It's that we have to take a drug to counter the literal poison that's been fed to us, with full subsidization from our government. We allow poison in food, but not led in our water, radioactive waste in our backyards. Why?
- tstrimple 2y agoFollow the profit.
- tetrisgm 2y agoI've been on semaglutife for a month now. My food cravings haven't disappeared, but their "volume" in my head went from a 10 to a 2. I no longer agonize over thinking about yummy unhealthy foods. I no longer want to treat myself outside of lunch and dinner. I no longer want portions beyond being full. Even if the weight loss aspects didn't work, the upside in clear headedness and not dedicating energy to thinking about food has been worth it.
- johnea 2y agoLike all short term weight loss solutions, when the user stops taking these meds, the weight is regained. Not sure how that is a good thing...
- bloody-crow 2y agoIf you stop doing a thing that has a positive effect on you, the positive effect is gone. Like, if you stop exercising, you lose muscle you've gained by exercising. Does that make exercising a bad thing?
- randomdata 2y agoThe absence of good does not imply bad.
- thrownawaysz 2y agoI'm on liraglutide (Saxenda) for 2 months, can't get semaglutide (Ozempic) in my country without being diagnosed with diabetes Anyway. Food cravings gone, I was eating like 10 times a day before that. At least, but sometimes even more. Now I'm on intermittent fasting/OMAD and has 0 problems. No hunger, no cravings. Feeling significantly better. Lost 30 pounds so far.
- 4b11b4 2y agoIt's not
- hnburnsy 2y agoA study says these drugs could prevent 1.5 million cardiac events over 10 years, add in a reduction in alcoholism and governments should be giving away these drugs to save on healthcare costs... ----- We identified 3999 US adults weighted to an estimated population size of 93.0 million [M] (38% of US adults) who fit STEP 1 eligibility criteria. Applying STEP 1 treatment effects on weight loss resulted in an estimated 69.1% (64.3 M) and 50.5% (47.0 M) showing ≥ 10% and ≥ 15% weight reductions, respectively, translating to a 46.1% (43.0 M) reduction in obesity (BMI ≥ 30 kg/m2) prevalence. Among those without CVD, estimated 10-year CVD risks were 10.15% “before” and 8.34% “after” semaglutide “treatment” reflecting a 1.81% absolute (and 17.8% relative) risk reduction translating to 1.50 million preventable CVD events over 10 years. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37166206 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37166206
- bl4ckm0r3 2y agoThis approach will definitely save someone's life (and probably already is) but there's no golden pill that will, long term, give a healthy, in shape, body to people without effort. Eating disorders are a thing and often have to do with the mind or genetics, but there are so many people just letting go to cravings and having terrible habits when it comes to eating, don't want to do any sacrifice and just let themselves go for so long than it becomes a serious health issues for them. I see plenty of parents feeding the kids like they are going to do foie gras out of them... People eating pastries like it's chewing gum, bagels like it's a snack... some of my American colleagues have never drunk just plain water...only sodas...and a lot of it. I really feel like this is just the trick the food (and healthcare) industry was waiting for to allow those people to eat as much as they want and don't get fat (and possibly get ill later), and the fashion industry to push for a "cheap way" to reach beauty standards (which is why this practice has mostly became popular thanks to famous people using it). Plus there are pretty common side effects (1 out of 10 experiences them) and it fundamentally creates a dependency to a drug, because without changing habits, if a patient stops using the drug, they'll regain the weight in a short time... Most people think they have a condition but in reality it's just them not trying to solve the problem and complaining about it.
- AlgorithmicTime 2y ago[dead]
- reisse 2y ago> This approach will definitely save someone's life (and probably already is) but there's no golden pill that will, long term, give a healthy, in shape, body to people without effort. Why? Is there any rational reason for such pill not to exist? Just because it seems "unfair" to the people who spent more effort to achieve the same? The whole history of scientific progress is about achieving good things with less effort.
- bl4ckm0r3 2y agoit's not unfair, the whole history of scientific progress is to cure unsolvable things with science. this seems pretty solvable to me ;) it's pretty much the same as giving everyone anti anxiety pills cause it's less effort than fixing the root causes.
- idontwantthis 2y agoI don’t understand what body positivity has to do with Ozempic. You should accept the things you cannot or have chosen not to change. If you opt to change them then why should acceptance matter anymore? Once a fat person becomes healthy, there’s still plenty for them to hate or accept about their body. But now they get to do that while also not burdened with health problems.
- milanaa 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]