6 ms·
Academics say flying to meetings harms the climate – but they carry on
- tim333 2y agoWith nearly all climate stuff one person changing won't make much difference which is why we need incentives for everyone to change. Or better tech - on current trends of falling solar cost we may be able to make green fuel from that in a decade or two.
- elashri 2y agoTLDR: Researchers in one big university survey in UK tend to prefer taking air travel (mostly juniors) than taking train or other alternative methods. The article is discussing from European perceptive where there is actually other options. I hope that no would think of similarity with the US because it lack sane alternatives. Driving for i.e two days wouldn't be less harm and wouldn't be possible because you will waste couple of days in traveling and will cost more of the limited money for travel in grants. And I really hope that one day the US will have a good train system.
- Alupis 2y ago> TLDR: Researchers in one big university survey in UK tend to prefer taking air travel (mostly juniors) than taking train or other alternative methods Perhaps they realized one fewer booking doesn't prevent the flight from happening - or change anything except inconvenience themselves? Even if 100% of academics committed to taking the train or heck, walking to conferences, nothing is different other than a lot of wasted time. Time that might be spent much more productively doing something else. The hypocrisy is the only real problem. But, we (both the US and UK) tolerate celebrities and politicians that fly on private jets to events just to scold us about the climate.
- Cheer2171 2y ago> Perhaps they realized one fewer booking doesn't prevent the flight from happening Ah, the good old "collective action by individuals is useless because individual action by individuals is useless" canard.
- Alupis 2y agoI think you missed the part where even if 100% of academics committed to not flying, still not one thing changes. The "do something, anything!" crowd needs reality checks from time to time. Consider yourself checked...
- etrautmann 2y agoThis is useless and lazy nihilism
- timr 2y agoArguing that travel you don't like is unnecessary because it harms the environment? Yes, that is useless and lazy nihilism. OP is arguing that observed preferences are far more reliable indicators of what people actually value than what people say to surveyors/the press/reddit/HN. That's not "nilhilism", it's just a fact. Presumably, academics travel to conferences because they're getting value out of it, and they deem that value worth whatever costs they believe it incurs.
- etrautmann 2y agoI was in and among that set for the last 12 years. Plenty of people travel for fun because someone else is paying. Many conferences are nowhere near a central location and instead are in somewhere exotic because one of the organizers wanted it there. This never sat well with me, but is completely standard and almost never questioned.
- timr 2y agoSure, ok. Let's posit that the value they're getting is that they enjoy travel, and wish to do it. My response is the same.
- matsemann 2y agoThis reminds a bit of the "it's useless to do anything here, China should cut their emissions, not us, we're a mere drop in the ocean!" Which of course means that we can solve climate change by dividing the earth into smaller countries, all too small to have any positive effect by cleaning up their act :)
- ForHackernews 2y agoWe have mechanisms for solving collective action problems. If air travel is bad and we want people to take trains, just tax airplanes and subsidize high speed rail. I don't know how you expect people to pay twice the price and take twice the time to travel somewhere. Prices are information. Tax externalities.
- jltsiren 2y agoDo you vote in elections? You must realize it's a waste of time, at least outside local elections. It's very unlikely that your vote will affect the outcome of any election in your lifetime. And it's even more unlikely that the effect will actually matter. It's good to realize that you are almost certainly a nobody. Your life will probably have no measurable effect on the world. And that's good, because the world would be a terrible place if many people could change it individually. But when a million nobodies make a choice, the world may change. You should act in ways that would be good for the society if everyone did the same. That's a pretty universal idea in moral philosophy. You can find it in most philosophical traditions and most religions. Utilitarianism fails on a large scale, because individual choices have a major effect on the individual but a negligible effect on the society. But if everyone makes choices that are individually good, everyone may come off worse. Civilized societies depend on people occasionally choosing the right thing over the thing that benefits them. To be a human, you need moral agency. It's not enough to be a utilitarian automaton reacting to incentives.
- n8cpdx 2y agoTrain system in the US is almost always slower (except for northeast corridor), and frustratingly not much greener per Amtrak’s own numbers. If I’m going to take days instead of hours, I want better than 34% more efficient. https://www.amtrak.com/travel-green https://www.amtrak.com/travel-green I’m actually posting this with the ulterior motive of having someone respond with better carbon numbers for Amtrak, because I have not been able to find any.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- geysersam 2y agoIt says 34% more energy efficient. But that's not as relevant as carbon emission efficiency. It's certainly more carbon emission efficient than that. The page you linked says up to 73% less carbon emissions, but it's hard to know what that means. I don't believe they actually mean that an Amtrak train emits 27% of the emissions of the worst commerical air travel option in the US, that sounds too high.
- Cheer2171 2y agoFrom London St Pancras International, you're still looking at 8+ hours via train to Zurich, Munich, Berlin, Milan, Barcelona. Americans talk about Europe's rail network like it is a city metro or something. It is 100% unfeasible to do a business trip via train from Rome to Amsterdam, Madrid to Berlin, Vienna to Paris. https://www.chronotrains.com/en/station/2643743-London/8 https://www.chronotrains.com/en/station/2643743-London/8
- etrautmann 2y agoThe travel isn’t always necessary
- etrautmann 2y agoYes, when I was in academic neuroscience as of last year this was 100% true, through truthfully a disappointingly small number even thought about it. It’s seen as necessary for career advancement and that is true. Remote conferences eliminate the most important part of networking
- acidburnNSA 2y agoI keep hoping that additional features in videochat will help regain some of the networking options. For instance, a feature where you queue up for 30-60 second 1:1s with the speaker after a talk would be cool. And then basically chat roulette for the hallway sessions. Would be cool.
- gradstudent 2y agoWe tried various forms of this during the pandemic; systems like gather.town and so on. They were universally awful. I think travel is simply the price of good Science.
- exabrial 2y agoJust wait until you hear about the G20 summit and all of the other idiots lecturing us about it.
- abeppu 2y agoHow important is this, though? Apparently though it's a growing contributor, air travel contributes roughly 2.5% of overall emissions. Even for academics who "need" to attend conferences in person, how many conferences does the average academic fly to per year? I tried one of those online carbon calculators which spat out 1.4 tons CO2 for a round trip west coast to east coast trip (SF / NYC). The average American emissions are at like 10x that, so while it's significant, depending on how many long-haul flights you have per year, it may still matter less than your day-to-day transportation, what you eat, heating your home, etc.
- ImJamal 2y agoRegardless of how much impact it has, it makes them look like hypocrites. If climate change is truly an issue that threatens millions of lives then maybe don't contribute to it unless you absolutely have to.
- viraptor 2y ago> then maybe don't contribute to it unless you absolutely have to. We don't "absolutely have to" do anything. Our comments contributed to climate change, but we did it anyway. Living contributes to climate change, but we don't stop. All of us are choosing some acceptable threshold for our lives.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- geysersam 2y agoDon't you find it interesting that when looking up the overall CO2 emissions of flying you found the number 2.5%, barely relevant, but when you looked up the emissions from a single long haul flight that ended up being ~10% of the average American emissions (already much larger than the global average). How can those two numbers be combined? Most of the worlds population never fly, and that's why it's a relatively small fraction of global emissions. But it's still a very sizeable portion of the emissions of people who do fly, and that makes it relevant. It's the same as saying: is it really important that people in Belgium cause large CO2 emissions? It's such a small country, barely 1 % of global emissions, there's no point to them reducing their emissions. But that's a fallacy (obviously). All emissions can be decomposed into small sets and dismissed as irrelevant. The important question is: how much benefit does these emissions cause compared to alternatives? And, would these emissions fit in the global co2 budget?
- motohagiography 2y agohypocricy is status signalling, complaining affirms it, a lot should fall into place when that clicks.
- FrustratedMonky 2y agoThe old "if you live in society you can't try to improve it without being a hypocrite" argument. "We Should Improve Society Somewhat refers to a panel from a comic by Matt Bors in which a medieval peasant says "We should improve society somewhat" while a modern man, emerging from a well, replies, "Yet you participate in society! Curious! I am very intelligent." " https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/we-should-improve-society-somewhat https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/we-should-improve-society-som...
- Gibbon1 2y agoYes. The whole trope that systematic problems are ordinary individuals personal responsibility to do something about is tiresome.
- naming_the_user 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_economy_in_aircraft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_economy_in_aircraft Modern airliners approach 100mpg per seat. About the same as four people in the average American car (25mpg at four people is 100mpg per seat). Compared to say, your average truck driver (like, 10? 15?), it's absolutely spectacular. A good European train can technically do 400-500mpg per seat, so 4-5x, but load factors tend to be much lower, I believe around 80-85% for planes vs 40-50% for intercity trains. Given that then, in the real world conventional trains are about 2-3x more efficient than planes. High speed trains lose a significant amount of that advantage - can't beat physics (air resistance). At the end of the day, long distance travel is simply expensive however you cut the cookie. There's nothing particularly special about air travel.
- eesmith 2y agoCould you explain how you got 'technically do 400-500mpg per seat' for electric trains powered by renewables or nuclear?
- PaulKeeble 2y agoThis has always been the entire problem with climate change action. We don't accept any reduction in our quality of life whatsoever for the purpose of saving our habitat. Too many of us always expecting someone else to make the change. Those that should be role models undermine their own message and thus many people around the world don't take their science seriously because they don't seem to take it seriously themselves. Since governments are paid extensively by all the CO2 producers who have made it all about personal choice rather than government intervening in industry to fix their direct production of CO2. The outcome of this crisis are now a foregone conclusion, 1.5C is done and onwards to 2C. We are now choosing what type of dystopia we want and the one we are choosing still tracks towards 6C and its a bad choice.
- Vaslo 2y agoThe doomsday cult is at it again I see.
- markgall 2y agoI'm an academic and try pretty hard to take the train. Just got back from a 19-hours-each way Greyhound+train+Greyhound ordeal to give a couple talks. My destination was only two not-that-big states away. They don't make it easy. Last year I had a reimbursement rejected because I took a two-night train option instead of flying -- the finance office considered this a vacation. Any time you do anything other than fly you need to provide comparison data showing that flying would've cost more. But those who fly even when the train is reasonable (for a normal person) face no such requirement.