7 ms·
Irish museum solves mystery of Bronze Age axe heads delivered in porridge box
- 23B1 2y agoI hope this works out for this guy, because these days I have zero faith that W. European governments are run by sane, commonsense people.
- Aeolun 2y agoWhile I sort of agree with you, I also feel like they’re often still better than elsewhere. The basis is so solid that even the insane people are still closer to reasonsble than elsewhere.
- scotty79 2y ago> “crucial to know the exact location where they were found” for “reasons that could range from ritualistic to supernatural” I wonder what they implied there.
- Loughla 2y agoI had the same question. Anyone from Ireland here that might have any idea at all what that's about?
- darby_nine 2y agoIdk about this specific thing, but this is much simpler than it sounds if it operates like other anthropology. Ritualistic means intentional, and supernatural means symbolically meaningful. In other words, this is less of a specific claim and more of an "idk but they were clearly up to something".
- s_dev 2y agoI interpret supernatural to mean religious in this context. I don't think this find will take on an X-Files direction.
- darby_nine 2y ago> I interpret supernatural to mean religious in this context. TBH I have no clue what the word "religious" means outside of abrahamic faiths. Might as well be a meaningless word. Anyway, the supernatural certainly encompasses many aspects of religion without implying anything about aliens.
- Loughla 2y agoThe problem is how it's written, I think. I now understand what you're saying, but the way it's phrased in the article makes it seem like they need to know where it came from for ritualistic and supernatural reasons. Like there are rituals the anthropologists have to perform, not that they might have ritualistic use in the past. It's a weirdly written sentence. Or maybe I've just been awake for too long.
- krisoft 2y agoYou are not wrong. The Guardian made an absolute hash of it. I recommend that you read the original document which says this: “However, to fully understand and appreciate these artifacts, it's crucial to know the exact location where they were found. The context of such discoveries helps archaeologists piece together ancient settlement patterns and cultural practices. For instance, hoards or collections of objects were often deliberately placed in specific locations for reasons that could range from ritualistic to supernatural.” Here is the link: https://www.museum.ie/en-IE/News/Appeal-for-information-about-Bronze-Age-Axeheads-F https://www.museum.ie/en-IE/News/Appeal-for-information-abou...
- throwup238 2y agoJust that the discovery was missing something called context in archaeology. Where they were found geographically, the stratigraphy such as the dirt it was found in and the layers around it, where it was found in relation to the nearest settlement, what kinds of animal bones were found in the same general area, and so on. Archaeologists are meticulous about recording these little details because every any one of them could become important to the investigation. An artifact on its own is (relatively) scientifically useless. Without at least geographic location and a rough idea of the area it was discovered, most analytical methods will have a hard time getting accurate results and any conclusions are suspect.
- scotty79 2y agoWhat would be a supernatural reason then? Is there some context in archeology that is labeled as supernatural that's different from ritualistic context? And what other things lie in the range between those two?
- astrange 2y agoRitualistic is what archaeologists call everything when they can't tell what it's there for, but it was clearly there for a reason. It sounds like it means religious, but it's more general than that.
- AlotOfReading 2y agoThe word ritual is orthogonal to how much is known about the usage. "Ritual" is just a way to describe objects that have some higher purpose, beyond any mundane and utilitarian purposes their basic form might serve. The textbook example is a thurible, the censer on a chain used in churches. They're not used because anyone specifically wants a lot of smoke in the air (a fog machine would do just fine) or because swinging them is fun, but rather because there's a higher ritual purpose being served by those particular objects being used in those particular ways. It's like calling an object rugged or utilitarian. It's not a statement on what you know about the object's specific purpose, but rather an adjective describing something else entirely.
- secondcoming 2y agoFlahavans makes excellent porridge
- ivankelly 2y agoThe oats in clonakilty puddings are all flahavans too
- mandmandam 2y agoFirst off, Flahavans are from Waterford and this find was in Westmeath. Second, if you want the actual best porridge get yourself some Kilbeggan (which are actually from Westmeath, funnily enough).
- VagabundoP 2y agoI’ll fight you on behalf of Flahavans. Meet me. Porridge is serious business.
- mandmandam 2y agoTry Kilbeggan first lad.
- defrost 2y agoBa Mhaith Liom Bruíon le d'Athair
- 082349872349872 2y agoIs cuma liom sa foc faoi aon gharda
- defrost 2y agoCúis snámhphointe mé díreach cosúil le féileacán ( agus is féidir liom rith ar nós na gaoithe )
- A_D_E_P_T 2y ago> It is against the law in Ireland to search for archaeological objects using a metal detector unless written permission has been given. Penalties can be up to three months in prison or a fine of up to €63,486 (£53,435). Written permission from who? He was on his own farmland. You have to write a plea to the government to request permission to use a metal detector on your own land? And, if that's the case, are such requests usually granted? What's the rationale here, and what harms does this permission-first system aim to prevent? > It is understood, however, that Dunne will not face charges. If it's a bad law that they're making a point of not enforcing, why not repeal the law? So many questions.
- DoubleGlazing 2y agoIn the early 80s a couple of lads found the Derrynaflan hoarde. A collection of stunning religious artefacts dating from the 9th century. This resulted in a whole legal mess where they were demanding a payment from the state of what would be arounf €25 million in todays money, after months of legal arguing they got a payout of what would be around €200k today. While this was ongoing there was an explosion in the number of people going out metal detecting for similar items and it's almost certain some items were found and not delcared to the state. So to protect the nations heritage - and we have a lot of it - from being scavenged these strict laws were introduced.
- colmmacc 2y agoThe rationale is that while you may own the land, you don't own the artifacts, and the state has an interest in ensuring that history is recorded and preserved professionally. In effect, archeology is a licensed occupation, but then so is cutting hair in most US states. If the story about metal in machinery is true, then really no offense was committed. Using a metal detector to find what you think is a loose horseshoe is fine. The story might also just be a convenient cover, but no-one will really care. In Ireland, authorities tend to be good natured and mostly only out to get egregious offenders. Maybe the metal detector guy has been looking for coins without permission, and it'll be handled at the level of "ah here would you have a bit of cop on".
- 2y ago
- ahmedfromtunis 2y agoParsing the title I thought it was going to be about an Irish museum that solved the mystery of bronze age collapse. My excitement grew exponentially as the words went by, until it crashed at once. Hopefully though the secrets of that collapse would be unveiled in the coming years.
- wileydragonfly 2y ago“We’d rather it rotted away to dust versus you digging it up.” Good grief.
- blahedo 2y agoThey've survived since the bronze age. They're not rotting away to dust any time soon.
- mcmoor 2y agoWhat I thought when the British claimed they can stole things because they preserved it better. This thing have preserved in this land for centuries, and who's to say that British Museum won't get nuked in the next 100 years?
- iamacyborg 2y agoThat’s not a particularly strong argument considering the state of some of the items in the British Museum.
- fph 2y agoI think the point is "We'd rather you left them where they were after you found them and notified a museum, so that they could be dug out with all due care by professional archeologists".
- pvaldes 2y agoOr as alternative title: "Finder explained all, Irish museum did nothing".
- bell-cot 2y agoTHIS. Yes, I understand why HN wants to discourage "editorial" titles from submitters. OTOH, less-bad web sites often put the actual sober facts in the subtitles - as was done here. Maybe if HN allowed submitters to use those instead, when the title is just click-bait?