5 ms·
Boxed – Things I learned after lying in an MRI machine for 30 hours
- debo_ 2y agoFascinating, and also a potentially new origin story for Magneto in the next X-Men reboot. There was a period of time where I had to get several MRI scans done, and I found them strangely relaxing. I was chastised several times for falling asleep (like the author), but I couldn't help it. I wasn't looking at anything but the ceiling of the machine, though.
- tapland 2y agoHappens to me every time, it’s very relaxing. I get them both-yearly and get a p. good rest. For shorter flights (1-2 hours) I usually fall asleep shortly after takeoff and wake up at landing. The a 320 neo I took recently actually felt too quiet to be relaxing.
- sib 2y agoAgreed - I've had a number of MRIs of the upper spine area and I find it extremely meditative...
- baliex 2y agoThanks for writing about what was at times an unpleasant experience with such care and attention to detail
- debo_ 2y ago> What I need is an app that does nothing but show you truly random pictures, with no curation and no memetic aspirations. If you know of one, please let me know. This must exist, right?
- 1f60c 2y agohttps://archillect.com/archive https://archillect.com/archive? Sadly it seems to have gone quiet.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- joebergeron 2y agoCame to the comments to look for this! I was immediately taken by the idea after reading about the author’s experience.
- Lammy 2y agoCopy and paste this link to avoid HN Referer redirect: https://www.jwz.org/webcollage/ https://www.jwz.org/webcollage/ “WebCollage is a program that creates collages out of random images found on the Web. More images are being added to the collage about once a minute, so this page will reload itself periodically. Clicking on one of the images in the collage will take you to the page on which it was found. It finds the images by feeding random words into various search engines, and pulling images (or sections of images) out of the pages returned. WebCollage also works as a screen saver on MacOS and Unix: it is included with the XScreenSaver package.”
- jaredwiener 2y agoCurious -- why do you want to avoid the HN referer?
- kmoser 2y agoNot too hard to find if you Google "website that shows random images". Examples: https://r.sine.com/index https://r.sine.com/index, https://picsum.photos/ https://picsum.photos/ (refresh to see new image)
- Palomides 2y agosomeone would need to make a little wrapper, but this redirects to a random image in wikimedia http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Special:Random/File http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Special:Random/File
- layer8 2y agoThere’s https://randomgenerate.io/random-picture-generator https://randomgenerate.io/random-picture-generator and similar sites.
- debo_ 2y agoThanks folks! These are all great links. I'd seen that jwz link ages ago and completely forgotten about it.
- Aachen 2y ago> It's also how I realized that wearing special earplugs in noisy places helps me understand what the people around me are saying, mitigating a mild auditory processing disorder that I had never thought much about. TIL this exists. Does anyone know where to read more about these plugs? What do they do? I always feel like I've got a harder time understanding people than everyone else
- rondini 2y agoThere are lots out there, but a popular model you could check out is the Loop Engage. They suppress certain frequencies more than others to help distinguish speech from background noise.
- Aachen 2y agoVery interesting, I see Loop is a Belgian company so it's not some distant shipping (I live a stone's throw from the border) and, for a niche (or so I thought) hearing aid I didn't expect a price tag far below a hundred bucks! Looks like good value if this does what it claims (https://www.loopearplugs.com/products/engage https://www.loopearplugs.com/products/engage)
- robin_reala 2y agoMy partner’s been extremely happy with the Loops she’s bought, with the exception of the “Quiet 2 Plus” models that didn’t work for her.
- Groxx 2y agoConcert-oriented earplugs work fairly well for this, and they're pretty easy to find. They aren't safety-oriented so they don't cut by the ~30db of "normal" plugs, more often around 15db. Generally they (claim to) try to sound more neutral so it's "just" a reduction in volume without much tone bias - personally I can't tell and haven't bothered to check, the small volume cut is all I really care about and any tone bias would be small enough that it's tough to notice anyway. You can of course go much more specialized for many specific goals, but start cheap and simple. $20 or less is easy to find, though you might want to hunt around for comfort purposes (e.g. personally I only find completely soft ones comfortable for long periods, and anything with a long hard stem that pokes out gets bumped and seems like a safety hazard to me).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- fuzzfactor 2y agoThere's always this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bci68qKGrf8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bci68qKGrf8 "I met Jesus in an MRI machine"
- nathancahill 2y ago181 views - 6 years ago.. how did you surface this?
- fuzzfactor 2y agoWell, it wasn't easy. Started early, over 15 years ago, way before 2018. This is an artist whom we broadcast on a live show when I was on the radio. Had no idea if he had anything on Youtube, thought it was worth checking :) For those who didn't watch, TLDW he backslides . . .
- elzbardico 2y agoI just wanted to say that anyone who stays voluntarily inside of a working MRI machine for any extended amount of time should get a presidential model as Hero of Science (if this medal doesn't exist, will please the congress create it just for this guy?). The guy did willingly, for science, what for most people would be an unspeakable nightmare. Thank you, Sir!
- dailykoder 2y agoIn MRIs I fall asleep faster than in most other places. I don't know why, but that's how it is
- sonofhans 2y agoMe too! They have to wake me up sometimes, so I can stay still :D
- dailykoder 2y agoI remember when I had a brain scan, they put my head in some sort of fixture and I tried hard to stay awake. Then I fell asleep, noticed that my head is somehow trapped, woke up scared and twitched a lot. That was a really challenging scan
- ericmcer 2y agoI have only done 15mins at a stretch, but I did foam earplugs with noise cancelling headphones on top and it wasn’t too bad. I just pretended I was in some kind of sci-fi medical healing tube.
- logifail 2y agoI had a "brain MRI with contrast" scan last year, I wasn't offered earplugs. It wasn't that loud, I certainly wasn't in any discomfort. With hindsight I'm not convinced about the informed consent re: the gadolinium infusion, but when you're lying prone in your underwear and the nurse is about to stick a line in your arm you don't feel particularly empowered... [Apologies for the anecdote but] one (with hindsight) comedy moment was that they asked me/reminded me multiple times that no metal was allowed to be present but somehow neither they nor I clocked I was still wearing my wedding band ... So I was lying there in the scanner and suddently I could feel the changes in the magnetic field via the ring on the ring finger of my left hand. A second or two of sheer panic as I wondered if I was about to see my finger get amputated and then I realised it was fine. I should have known better, gold is diamagnetic. [Decades ago] I spent my PhD years running my samples in various high-field NMRs. Nearly lost a set of house keys by taking them too close to a magnet, felt it trying to snatch them from me and managed to step away at the last minute....
- CoastalCoder 2y agoI'm told that back on the day, a guy working at JEOL, on a small-bore research NMI, was wearing a metal-banded wristwatch. And when it started to heat up, he reflexively pulled his arm out of the bore very quickly. That is a bad day at work.
- renewiltord 2y agoWhat actually happened? I imagine he received a burn on his hand?
- CoastalCoder 2y agoIIRC the story (I heard it second hand) he got a very nasty burn around his wrist. He was quickly moving a conductive loop through a very strong magnetic field with a crazy large gradient. (I'm not a physicist, but I assume that's the explanation for the burn.)
- 2y ago
- nelsondev 2y agoSounds similar to experiences inside sensory deprivation chambers. In the SF Bay Area, there’s a company called reboot floatation spa , where you can book time floating in body temperature epsom salts inside a box that blocks noise and light. I also experienced intense visual imagery and extraordinary ability to concentrate on thoughts while my other senses were deprived. And then I got sleepy
- onemoresoop 2y agoI tried an Epsom salt deprivation chamber and while it was nice I did not experience any visual imagery or anything that wowing. I felt very relaxed and I became sleepy as well. I think it was for about an hour, maybe I should have booked a longer session?
- jerlam 2y agoI have also done a sensory deprivation chamber/float tank, but I mostly experienced nausea, from the miniscule amount of water movement. Otherwise it felt like a really bad night of insomnia - lying in bed and feeling trapped.
- pikseladam 2y agoim still shocked that you can stand still for 30 hours. not one session i guess but its still hard
- MPSimmons 2y agoHow do aphantastic people find things they're looking for if they can't think of what they look like?
- rocqua 2y agoThey know it when they see it?
- peterarmstrong 2y agoI can recognize my wife and son perfectly fine, I just can't make pictures of them in my mind. Longer version: https://leanpub.com/aphantasia/read https://leanpub.com/aphantasia/read
- niemandhier 2y agoOld professor of mine used to put himself into his research MRI and perpetually scan his brain, claimed that the fields would help him think faster. Blood is diamagnetic or paramagnetic depending on the oxygenation, and fields stronger than 2T have been shown to have effects on neural activity, so who knows maybe he was right.
- DrillShopper 2y agoI always feel lightheaded around high field MR scanners
- nick3443 2y agoIt's been shown that humans can perceive the earth's magnetic field, which is weak. A 2T field doing "something" to us is plausible.
- ahazred8ta 2y agoWeak, yes, 1/30000th of a Tesla.
- pierrefermat1 2y agoCurious if you could link some relevant papers on this?
- hnisoss 2y agosee the references linked in 10.3389/fnins.2020.00419
- nullc 2y agoThe RF exposure is pretty considerable. I'd bet on RF heating from multi-kw VHF pulses being a more likely cause of any measurable effects.
- hnisoss 2y agoI wonder if he would achieve the same perceived effect being in a very bright room.
- d13 2y agoMRIs are astonishingly musical. I spend a lot of time in them too and the sounds they produce are beautiful.
- geek_at 2y agoIf you enjoy dubstep, you'll have quite a good time in the MRI machine
- DrillShopper 2y agoThere are pulse sequences that make the machine play music - they get used in testing. The first one that I'm aware that was created was Daisy, as an homage to the IBM 704.
- lproven 2y agoI've had several MRIs. I like industrial and EBM. No, it is very much not beautiful. It's like being inside a pneumatic drill. Horrible experience. IME, IMHO, etc.
- d13 2y agoI’m an Indian Classical Music student, and studied tabla for many years. I dislike all electronic music in general. I think I’m hearing something else.
- virtualwhys 2y agoI've had an MRI twice, once for my wrist and another time for my shoulder. The wrist experience was fine, I actually sat down with my hand inside of the extremely loud contraption. The shoulder experience was a different matter entirely. I was in Vietnam during the pandemic, and injured my shoulder during a table tennis training session. At the hospital they do the standard blood pressure/pulse routine, which went fine until the machine started beeping red, at which point the nurse arranged an emergency visit with a cardiologist as my standing heart rate was under 40 BPM. I felt fine but the cardiologist said I had something called bradycardia, and was at risk of a massive coronary if I didn't take medication to speed up my heart rate. I was understandably worried about my heart, but wanted to get my shoulder looked at, so into this long, thin spaceship-like tube I went... and pretty much instantly freaked out :) I pressed the panic button; a tech came in and said, "close your eyes before entering". That made all the difference, MRI went fine after that (well, despite how absurdly loud it is in there). As for my heart, I've probably had this condition my whole life.
- skzv 2y agoLast time I went into an MRI, I realized half way through that I had forgotten to take off my metal necklace. Thankfully it was silver - it was an extreme purity test.
- Yenrabbit 2y ago"Every four seconds or so, you see something new that you would never have guessed from the previous pictures. Each time it's a different cascade of activations in your brain, evoking random memories, creating unexpected connections, and stimulating thoughts that would never have occurred to you...What I need is an app that does nothing but show you truly random pictures, with no curation and no memetic aspirations. If you know of one, please let me know." I made a site quickly, that shows a random series of pictures from Unsplash, since I was curious to try this! https://random-photo-cascade.replit.app/ https://random-photo-cascade.replit.app/ (Built with Replit's new agent feature, which is impressive for this kind of very constrained task)
- Yenrabbit 2y agoAnd very quickly hit a rate limit apparently! Just switched to a different option without the unsplash limits.
- financetechbro 2y agoThis is cool! After watching for a few mins, seems to be heavily weighted towards nature, architecture, and generally artsy pictures. Wonder if there is a way to expand the scope/randomness even further
- theshackleford 2y agoI’ve had a lot of MRIs in the lead up to, and following the discovery of a SCI and something in my lower spine called “tarlov cysts” I don’t know why, but I now find the sounds the machine makes comforting. I’ll often play YouTube videos of MRIs operating for background noise now and my partner thinks it’s super odd. She doesn’t find it pleasing at all, but I find it very pleasing. I find it soothing.
- nick3443 2y agoYou might be a dialup modem
- blueyes 2y agoI would love to know what this research surfaces about aphantasic brains and their opposites.