7 ms·
Starlink U-turns, will block X in Brazil after all
- josefritzishere 2y agoMusk finds obeying the law inconvenient? He's become a neo-monarchist in his old age.
- pyronik19 2y ago[dead]
- maep 2y agoPerhaps it's Gwynne Shotwell's doing. She seems to be one of the few people on this planet who can say "no" to Musk and not get bullied.
- rbanffy 2y agoShe is responsible for the success of a company that's becoming increasingly strategic to US interests. Nobody will mess with her, not even Elon.
- marxisttemp 2y agoWe are on the discussion boards of a startup incubator which had a monarchist as a board member for years. Have you not picked up on all of Silicon Valley going techno-feudalist? Paul Graham probably goes to Urbit rallies when he’s not writing longform essays about rockstar 10X founder culture
- pessimizer 2y agoBeing a monarchist is when you don't censor elected politicians for an unelected dictator.
- synarchefriend 2y agoIncredible that so many tech types are now cheering on the government blocking websites.
- bamboozled 2y ago[flagged]
- YPCrumble 2y agoYou are quite literally saying that you support censorship.
- bamboozled 2y agoI don't know why people get so "twitchy" about this topic, what don't you understand about this situation being unique in history? I didn't say I support this level of censorship. I'm just smart enough and sympathetic enough to see how the platform causes issues for democracy and how this is a hard thing to grapple with for western democratic society. Smart people are using our morality against us and plenty of people fall for it. Everyone I know that seriously uses Twitter, I've basically distanced myself from. It's an insane platform. Twitter is not a "website". I say it again.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Sebb767 2y ago> what don't you understand about this situation being unique in history? Because this exact argument is brought every single time someone supports censorship. Free speech is easy to support when you agree with what is being said, what matters is what happens when you disagree. > I'm just smart enough and sympathetic enough to see how the platform causes issues for democracy and how this is a hard thing to grapple with for western democratic society. Smart people are using our morality against us and plenty of people fall for it. And other smart people tell us that "actually, we do kinda need to subvert our values in this case, trust me". Now, I do see that there are shades of gray, but Twitter is far from a radical platform (we're not talking about KiwiFarms here) and, usually, when you're right, you don't need to win by silencing the other sides arguments.
- nwoli 2y ago[flagged]
- youngtaff 2y agoAll Twitter had to do was appoint a legal representative in Brazil and this trouble wouldn't have happened
- Fidelix 2y agoThey had a legal representative. They were about to be arrested by the tyrant judge, so they fled to Argentina IIRC. Also, the orders are all illegal. God, how HN can be disappointing sometimes when it comes to politics...
- kranke155 2y ago[flagged]
- iagocds 2y agoNobody flew to argentina they were just fired. There are interviews with the last employes reporting that they didn't even got pay after they were fired. It was a suprise decission for them too. What you are saying here is just no sense.
- rbanffy 2y ago> they didn't even got pay after they were fired. Musk is about to learn about Brazilian labor laws. They have teeth, lots of them.
- ricardorivaldo 2y agosome criminals which were condened by a failled coup in 1/8/2022 and where in house arrest , most like the ones which was condened in US for the 1/6/2020 trump coup, so, they are condened criminals
- delecti 2y ago
- mrtksn 2y agoHere it is how it looks like if you try to visit an account of a cult member and political rival of Erdogan from Turkey(the cult used to be ally of Erdogan, then turned against him. Now they publish sometimes credible and other times dubious corruption documents and allegations from exile): https://dropover.cloud/755d93 https://dropover.cloud/755d93 Also, Twitter has legal representation in Turkey and people are routinely detained, imprisoned or made pay fines for their tweets in Turkey. The country also ranked very poorly on any freedom or democracy index, political figures are routinely held in prison. Erdogan government often dismisses orders from the Turkish constitution court, if you think that Musk is into constitution - it doesn’t add up. AFAIK Twitter is also blocked in China and Russia. What is the fuss around Brazil? Why this is not just another day with business as usual?
- soapdog 2y agoTwitter is not complying with Brazilian law, it is simple.
- brigadier132 2y agoIt's not complying with Brazilian law or is it not complying with the orders of a judge overstepping his powers granted by the Brazilian constitution?
- kranke155 2y ago[flagged]
- brigadier132 2y ago[flagged]
- kranke155 2y agoAsking for sources is a way to derail the conversation? Incredible. https://www.bbc.com/portuguese/articles/c0l82k39x28o https://www.bbc.com/portuguese/articles/c0l82k39x28o Here is the BBC Brasil article on the topic. The ban has been upheld by the entire court, not just its more activist judges. A. The law in Brazil says any company needs a legal representative in the country. X does not. B. Under hate speech and misinformation laws some accounts were asked to be removed. They did not. C. Because the company wasn’t replying at all to court requests, they consider that obstruction of justice vs trying to appeal the court D. As far as Starlink they consider it a “de facto economic group under the control of Elon Musk” which is mostly true. Now as far as the Constitution, this is the Supreme court. So saying X has the right to judge the Supreme Court to be in breach of the Constitution, when they themselves are meant to make those decisions, is pretty nutty to me. It's like saying I don't agree with the abortion ban in Texas/Florida so I will continue to do them, since I don't accept Roe V Wave was overturned by Dobbs, so I will just do my own thing, keep doing abortions and f the court. That's a good way to get yourself arrested, which is what happened here. Instead you should look into why do you think this to be the truth?
- wokwokwok 2y agoI mean, who really cares, at the end of the day, but let’s be real. You can only play “fuck you I don’t have a legal entity in your country you can’t touch me” game… …if you dont. Now he’s gone and set a precedent for “how to bully musk into compliance”: 1) find something he owns that is actually making money. 2) blockade it. Feels like that was a stupid game to play, with a predictable outcome, for no really good reason.
- kotaKat 2y agoHe must have forgotten he has 23 ground stations in the country that they'll happily just go take in retaliation.
- drowsspa 2y agoYeah, I don't like a corporation thinking itself to be above a government. Whether the request to ban those accounts was fair is a political game I don't think they should be playing. And Elon is obviously not above banning other accounts... Flawed as it is, Brazil is a democracy. Judges stepping out of their lanes is something up to the representatives to deal with, not a foreign company.
- rbanffy 2y ago> Feels like that was a stupid game to play He's certainly winning some stupid prizes now.
- throwaway48476 2y agoIf platforms care about free expression they would not have a formal presence in authoritarian countries. The best way to protect your users is to operate exclusively within US jurisdiction and let subjugated peoples have accounts. Jurisdictional arbitrage works. So does tor.
- diggan 2y ago> The best way to protect your users is to operate exclusively within US jurisdiction Well, no. If you want to protect your users, don't keep servers/data/legal entities in countries where the government can order you to wiretap your own services and also serve you with a gag order. So no, the US isn't a great place for people who value free expression.
- throwaway48476 2y agoThe US in the 1st amendment has one of the strongest regimes for protecting expression in the world. In this case I'm only considering activity that is intentionally public and published so surveillance isn't considered. Privacy is orthogonal.
- diggan 2y ago> The US in the 1st amendment has one of the strongest regimes for protecting expression in the world Sure, but there are plenty of other countries that has "one of the strongest regimes for protecting expression in the world" also, but also doesn't have gag orders, so I'm fairly sure what country I wouldn't host a service like that in.
- throwaway48476 2y ago>plenty of other countries that has "one of the strongest regimes for protecting expression in the world" Name 3
- diggan 2y ago
- jmyeet 2y agoThis reinforces two lessons: 1. Companies are not your friends. This goes for any company; 2. Companies will always choose profit over everything else, including moral stances. Companies may make moral stances. These are temporary blips. The second is really important because it debunks a lot of propaganda. A common one is "we can't tax companies (or billionaires) because they'll leave". No they won't. There's really no evidence of this. Even if they do, you, as a government, can say "ok, you've lost access to our market". The US wields access to the US financial system quite effectively as a weapon both domestically and with foreign policy. Yet we continue to give mostly ineffective corporate subsidies. Drug prices is another one. It often comes up that US customers pay 10-100x+ for the same drug you can get in Europe or Canada. Lots of excuses are given for this but the reality is that prices are so high because the government has been bought and importing drugs has been made illegal. Even things like Medicare negotiating prices with drug companies is (mostly) illegal. But consider in terms of (2): would companies sell a drug in Canada for $50 when it costs $500 in the US if they were selling it at a loss? No, they wouldn't. So Starlink is still for sale in Brazil because it's profitable and because following the law in Brazil (whether you agree with the law or not) is more profitable than opting out.
- ricardorivaldo 2y agomoney talks, bullshit walks, who is the "free speech" warrior now ?