15 ms·
For those who hear voices, the ‘broken brain’ explanation is harmful
- AlbertCory 2y agoThere is nothing new about defining behaviors usually seen as psychotic as "normal": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Szasz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Szasz
- aguaviva 2y agoThat's the thing -- hearing voices isn't a "behavior". It's something a person experiences, entirely without choice. And also -- the article didn't say these experiences were "normal". It fully recognizes that they are experiences are highly unusual, and typically quite distressing to those who experience them. That's why a more nuanced discussion is needed. Far from being an old and tired topic (per the shallow dismissal above) -- we're just getting started.
- llamaimperative 2y agoBehaviors don't have to be voluntary. In fact that's why we call that category of behaviors "voluntary behaviors."
- AlbertCory 2y agodid you mean "Behaviors don't have to be INvoluntary."
- EnigmaFlare 2y agoVoluntary or not, behaviors aren't experiences, they're things people do. Lying down in the supermarket is a behavior, but hearing voices isn't.
- llamaimperative 2y agoOf course hearing a voice is a behavior, especially one that isn't there. Your brain is producing a voice and then experiencing it, both of which are things your brain is doing, i.e a behavior. And in any case, obviously people don't get treated for the specific behavior (or experience, if you want) of hearing voices. They get treated for the behavior of complaining about voices.
- rbanffy 2y ago> Your brain is producing a voice and then experiencing it, Where does your brain end and you start? Does it make sense to have this distinction?
- genewitch 2y agoSomewhere around the gut area, if my reading of the literature is correct.
- AlbertCory 2y agoThis seems fairly subtle, not to say nonsensical. People aren't treated for covid; they're treated for complaining about their symptoms They're not treated for anxiety; they're treated for complaining about anxiety. They're not treated for migraine headaches; they're treated for complaining about headaches. They're not treated for gout; they're treated for complaining about their big toe.
- llamaimperative 2y agoExcept the whole premise is that we know empirically that interpretation (a behavior) can alter the "medical" outcome. Anxiety is the only of your examples that's kind of similar, and, likewise, anxiety is highly amenable to cognition-based therapies.
- AlbertCory 2y agoI don't know what we're arguing about, but it seems rather subtle, except maybe to you. Why does it matter that "anxiety is highly amenable to cognition-based therapies?"
- AlbertCory 2y agoFar from "we're just getting started": "Oh, it's just SO complex!" is the battle cry of the academic grifter: we need MUCH more research! I'm writing my grant application right now. And by the way, that wasn't a "shallow dismissal." I was carefully saying that this isn't a new idea.
- Animats 2y ago[flagged]
- Aeglaecia 2y agosocietys boos mean nothing, have you seen what they cheer for?
- stonethrowaway 2y agoFinally someone fucking said it. Thank you.
- creata 2y ago1. Please don't call human beings rejects. 2. This is just one person's essay. If I had to guess, "society" disagrees with him. (As he points out, his view is not mainstream at all in the psychiatric community.)
- maxbond 2y agoCalling people rejects is ablest and smells like eugenics.
- scotty79 2y ago> Some get the message that their brain is broken and that they can never trust their thoughts and perceptions. Which is true.
- creata 2y ago"Their brain is broken" is true, but "they can never trust their thoughts" is (1) subjective, because different people have different thresholds for what can be trusted, and (2) probably crippling, as far as beliefs go. So it seems like a bad message to send.
- scotty79 2y agoAs a perfectly healthy (comparably) human I think that having very limited trust towards your thoughts and perceptions is a very healthy and adaptive stance to take given how crap brains are on average about so many things. I can't imagine it being a bad framework to operate in if your brain is even worse in some aspects. So many terrible actions are taken by people who assume their perceptions are accurate and their thoughts are correct. And again, I'm talking about completely average people here.
- creata 2y agoI think we're interpreting the "never" in "they can never trust their thoughts" differently.
- o11c 2y agoNormalization causes a very specific harm: it prevents ameliorative action. Speaking in terms of a "cure" causes the same harm: it prevents the continuation of help. If we're not allowed to use words like "broken" (which I do not concede in general), surely at least we can get people to admit something like "I have a condition that makes my life difficult, and I must take some sort of steps to compensate"?
- svnt 2y agoIt can also cause the opposite harm: a requirement for treatment of something that isn’t actually broken, just because it has been culturally declared to be broken.
- o11c 2y agoMaybe in theory, but that's not dominant. Being able to fit into society's rules, even if you disagree or don't understand their purpose, is itself a major component of mental wellness. Adaptability is one of the most core aspects of being human. In my experience, the vast vast majority of mental-illness-acceptance movements are blatantly of the form "it's only natural for my dog to poop anywhere on the lawn, why should I have to pick it up?" And to follow up this analogy - I don't mandate any particular treatment plan, there are at least 3: * pick up your dog's poop * own a dog, but keep it on your own property * don't own a dog
- svnt 2y agoThis kind of conformist thinking leads to bad outcomes.
- autoexec 2y ago> It holds that these voices and beliefs – or ‘hallucinations’ and ‘delusions’ – are symptoms of a disorder such as schizophrenia, delusional disorder or schizoaffective disorder. These disorders likely stem from brain dysfunctions or defective genes... Some get the message that their brain is broken and that they can never trust their thoughts and perceptions. That pretty much would be the smart thing to take away from a diagnosis yes. The brain is broken (not functioning correctly) if it's presenting them with hallucinations and delusions. Everyone's brain lies to them to some degree. It's usually not a huge problem, but once it becomes one there's no point in denying what's happening. That wouldn't mean that "they can never trust their thoughts and perceptions" but would mean that they should be considered suspect, especially when those thoughts and perceptions are voices in their heads or paranoia. > But if psychiatry’s broken-brain narrative is pushing people deeper into the TI community, how did this happen? It isn't pushing people to the TI community. Paranoid schizophrenics don't even need a diagnosis to believe that they're being targeted. It's just what they do. If reality is difficult to accept, it's understandable that a fantasy might look more inviting to them, but the answer is not to lie to patients about the reality of their situation or withhold the truth so that they feel better. > A chorus of doctors, journalists and activists insisted that seeing mental disorders in terms of defective brain chemistry would alleviate shame and stigma. They gave the lie to the idea that extreme low mood, disabling anxiety or obsessive thoughts might represent a character flaw or a moral defect – or even bad parenting. I'm not sure what "gave the lie" means here. Having a medical, even physiological, basis for the disorder has made it very clear that it isn't a moral failing or a choice. To that extent, mental illness has been destigmatized pretty well, but ultimately "crazy" is always going to be a bad thing to be, and something nobody wants to be. In that sense there will always be a stigma against it. No one wants to have something wrong with them. I don't think lying to people and telling people there's nothing wrong with them when there very clearly is something wrong with them is helpful. The one part of the this article I can really get behind is that drugs aren't always the answer. Drugs can, in some circumstances be ineffective, or even make the situation worse. It can take a very long time to find the right drug or combination or drugs at the right doses to make things better and in the meantime there are real harms that can result from that search. Psychiatric drugs and conditions are not well understood. I do think that it will get better with time though. I think it's reasonable to be cautious when it comes to treatment with medications, but I think it's also important to be honest and accurate about what the issues are. That means telling people their brains are wrong, and that their experiences aren't real. That psychosis is a very real problem, not a "spiritual emergency" or a "gift" or a "super power" and that it must be dealt with and managed (with or without medication).
- h_tbob 2y agoI always say that psychiatrists of today are the equivalent of doctors in the 1500s. They can give you basic advice, but because we don’t yet have a scientific understanding of consciousness, we can’t effectively treat problems therein. Therefore wisdom indicates we should all have an open mind when discussing these matters. As we figured out germs and bacteria, I hope we will figure out these issues as well.
- curryberto 2y agoYou can be experiencing full blown mania, and the psychiatrist can give you an anti-psychotic which will bring back to earth in a few hours. Then they can put you on a medication regimen where you stop having manic episodes. I would say it's much further along than doctors in the 1500s. The mechanisms are not clear, which is not unusual in medicine, but the treatments are very effective.
- loa_in_ 2y agoOften the reasoning goes the other way though. We have no idea what's going on but If a patient responded well to antidepressants of all things, that means we diagnose him with depression.
- boopmaster 2y agoAlthough I did not speak openly of "TI" I did experience this phenomenon. Following obsessive dieting and exercising, then into a batch of seizures, I somewhat rapidly fell into the TI abyss. I consider myself today to remain a "voices hearer", although it's gotten much better over time and I am mindful to get more sleep than I need, as that's been the most curative for me. That episode came on in 2012, and it has felt like it took > 10 years to fully recover. It certainly wasn't helpful and to the contrary extremely reinforcing when the whole snowden story broke. This is a dreadful pit to fall into. Pretend with me for one moment: You are single, you're looking for love in all the wrong places, mostly on OKCupid. An employee working within the NSA has stumbled upon your information in realtime in a PRISM data slurp, and has taken a personal interest - maybe they think you are weird, and they are not above abuse of their powers - and that they want to exert their "godlike" powers to toy with you - surveil you, pwn your computer, screw with your mind, etc. Keep pretending this is remotely close to reality! What recourse would you have? Would a FOIA request ever validate your claims? Where do you even begin to try to reconcile with this, as a firmly held belief? .... My voices are illusory, they require a prompt. It can be water running, it is horribly triggered in large crowds. I still have panic attacks in Ikea (but who doesn't?) .... I got better. It took 10 years of my life to get it back, mostly. It takes a lot out of me to even begin to try to share any of this. I hope this post helps someone. You too can get through it.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y agoHuh you know, mine happened around the Snowden leaks too. I didn't hear voices but I had pretty bad delusions, some paranoid. These days I don't have any harmful delusions and only sometimes think I hear someone calling my old name And I've also been on okcupid for years. Hopefully you are not some alternate personality lol
- quantum2022 2y agoThis is fascinating finding out about these communities. My problems were always that I believed time travel might exist. Now I can find out whether I really https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6nnwn5rXEio https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6nnwn5rXEio :)
- Animats 2y agoIf the capability existed to project voices into people's heads, there would be a startup using it for advertising by now. Oh, right, that's been done.[1] "In 2007, the advertising and marketing campaign for A&E's Paranormal State broke the mold using Audio Spotlight directional sound technology. A seven-story billboard was erected in Lower Manhattan, New York City, visually reminding the public of the channel's popular new programming. A pair of AS-24i focused sound speakers mounted above the billboard projected directional audio onto a targeted area of the sidewalk – all the way from the rooftop." "The projected sound produced by the Audio Spotlight speakers was a woman's whispering voice that startled and entertained passersby with spooky and suggestive messages such as "Who's that?," "Who's there?," and "It's not your imagination." To those within the narrow coverage area, the sounds seemed as though they were being whispered right next to their heads, while others standing right next to them heard nothing, thanks to the focused sound beam of the Audio Spotlight." [1] https://www.holosonics.com/applications/creative-marketing https://www.holosonics.com/applications/creative-marketing
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y agoAdvertisements continuing to do things that would be offensive and obviously weird if a live person did them
- binary132 2y agoI had a somewhat close friend who had a very sudden and dramatic psychotic break that he disclosed to me while it was happening. He believed that people in his family were conspiring to entrap him in a criminal conspiracy, and was in a panic. This progressed further over a few days until I was no longer able to continue to try to talk him through it. There were a number of details to his beliefs that made it absolutely clear it was not real. Unfortunately I was not able to get through to him to get help (as far as I know) and the people I tried to connect him with were very unhelpful. The reason I’m sharing this is that I think people tend to believe that people are exclusively either “crazy” or “not crazy” as an ontological property of the person, but as many other anecdotes here show, it really can happen to people randomly. Some are able to get help and recover. Some aren’t. While I definitely wish there was someone I could have called who could go give him real aid and assistance, I also know that this could have been a terrifying, trust-breaking ordeal and possibly could have even led to violence and imprisonment, or other serious consequences. People like to talk about “public mental health resources” but unless you’re willing to sic what amounts to police armed with tranquilizers on people who very well may (reasonably?) not wish to be subdued against their will, it’s not really that simple. Definitely a difficult and fraught subject. I don’t think the answer is to validate psychosis however.
- Audience7584 2y agoStory time. Long time lurker, first time writer. Please be gentle if i make formatting mistakes and correct me how to do it properly! I had what you could call psychotic episode 3 years ago. It started by hearing faint voices from neighbours apartment (not necesserarily talking about me, but regular everyday stuff.) I did not realise at the moment it was psychotic episode thing, i thought i just heared background noises. Mind you my current apartment was very well sound proofed but. i shrugged that off easily (voice can travel via air vents and so son). So after couple of months i went on this electronic music festival in the woods (medium size forest festival in Finland) and in there i started hearing "other people" (whom i/we did not know) talking about me and my current fiance when we were in out tent. First i thought it was my friends joking, but then realized it is not the case. This is where i got kinda anxious and my SO understood that something is wrong and luckily got me some medication for getting sleep (Clonazepin). After that i stayed at the tent for the end of the festival (luckily only for one day) and was paranoid that people were talking about me and my fiance and felt very anxious about the whole situation. After couple of days when we arrived back at home it started getting more serious overtone. Sidenote: I did not do mind altering drugs at the festival. I was there building the festival and its music stages and planned to enjoy festival after the work was done. So these extra voices continued to haunt me back at home too. First they were malicious in their intend, trying to spook me first in very very mundane things (did you forget to pay parking ticket etc) and then started to proceed to more deeper things like my life choices / regrets i might have had and so on. They also told me that there are cameras in next side building filming me (did not really believe this). They also tried to convince me that they are actually gods and that i could too become god if i would kill myself. I laughed to this idea and told them that i am happy being human and would never wanna be god and/or like them. This whole voice thing affected my possibility to get to sleep, so i could not sleep for 3-4 days in a row and that just worsened the situation, problem was not necessarily the amount of extra voices but sleep deprivation lowered my capacity to handle the criticism, ignore the things voices tol me, put things in more realistic perspective or try to reason with the voices. So at this point i decided it is time to get some professional help and listed myself in an mental ward for evaluation. I was there for 3 weeks and they started me on some basic antipsychotics and sleeping aids that they usually give for first time psychotic breaks and i managed to get somewhat proper sleep but the voice symptoms did not go away. After 3 weeks i got out from the hospital (with open ticket to comeback as soon as i feel like it) still hearing the voices in my head, but had medication with me (that really did not help at all, just made me emotionally numb). During next 1-1.5 years i went through multiple different typical and atypical antipsychotic medications and none of them gave any relief for the hallucinations. At this point the hallucinations started appearing in visual field too. I have aphantasia so the visual hallucinations appearing when i closed my eyes were very non clear, more like black on black shades. Like i could see shadows morphing to different shapes like humans running through my vision field, human shaped things holding guns, some alien like creatures and so on. Once there even was a boomer for left for dead gameseries and conehead esque figures (that was kinda funny). It was like they were trying to intimidate me believing they were aliens. Oh and i have never seen Conehead movie btw. Some times eyes open i even saw pretty nicely "rendered" 3d hologram koi fishes floating on my ceiling and other pretty amazing visuazinery. The holograms were made of tiny blue dots and if they pop out from the surface i could push my hand through em and if i tilted my viewpoint the hologram would also tilt (so i could look at the back and/or sides of them). Weirdly when these eye open visual come to play the voices were very nicely to me and told me that "this is just a play and or playing" and it kinda felt like they were just showing me cool things they can do. It did not feel malicious at the time. More like a show off of a skills. These voiced entities (which there was multiple at the time, like 10 or so) showed me amazing sights projected on the ceilings and i would chit chat with them about them sometimes in wonder of the imagenary. (at this point me overall reaction to this started to became more mundane than scared because they were not aggressive towards me). So some days after this event i went to see my parents (whom i have very good relations with) for a week and there stuff turned pretty evil. The sounds started to tell me that i should kill my self to be reborn as god or kill my parents to become a god. This is of course refused because even i was experiencing psychotic hallucinations i was not psychotic or manic, granted i was sleep deprived but not "crazy" and did not think of doing anything stupid, was just really really tired. This was the second time i went to psychic ward because i really needed some strong medication to get sleep. I was there for 4-5 days and got out feeling better.
- IPCRESS 2y agotrue or not, just.. be careful to not become a subject of some NLP people (if you don't hear voices yet, you may be chosen to be traumatized for the same effect)
- ryandv 2y agoI have a number of thoughts regarding this article. First is the idea of "dangerous gifts" and of a mind that is oversensitized to making (perhaps spurious) connections and correlations between otherwise unrelated phenomena - related to the idea of aberrant salience in psychiatry: One approach saw the mad mind as a wounded mind – not wounded in the sense of broken, but in the sense of having survived painful life experiences. The experiences we call ‘paranoia’ – being hypervigilant to threats, seeing malicious motives everywhere – could be a protective response of the organism to real threats, rather than symptoms of a disease. The hypervigilance to threats and reading of malicious motives is the shadow aspect of an innate ability to notice subtle patterns and relationships given an absolute paucity of information; its well-dignified manifestation is best exemplified by the unstable yet incisive intellect of characters such as Dr. House or Sherlock Holmes, Waterhouse from Stephenson's Cryptonomicon or stock market wizards Max Cohen and (to a less psychotic extent, yet still neurodivergent in other directions) Michael Burry. An intellect that is too sensitive to patterns, capable of discerning the minutest signal out of a sea of noise, who can at times find the precise mental model that corresponds exactly to reality when no one else is able - yet also prone to confusing genuine noise for an actual signal. A confrontation with the "demons" or "malicious motives" seen everywhere is part of the process of coming to grips with the deluge of noise that increasing the cutoff frequency of your low-pass filters (so to speak) introduces. It's this decreased attenuation of spurious correlations, hypervigilance, indeed "reality itself" that is referred to by psychonauts, shamans, and other mystical seekers in the metaphor of "opening the doors of perception/the soul." Being receptive to such subtle suggestions and inferences from the psyche within given the minutest of perceptual signals from the world without is one such "dangerous gift," and learning to harness it is one of the objectives of the spiritual quest. Second is the obsolescence of roles once played by medicine men, shamans, faith healers, gurus, and priests in diagnosing such maladies of the mind/soul (which I consider exact synonyms of one another and are perfectly coextensive, metaphysical woo about spirits and energies need not apply) in the rising prominence of psychiatry and other "bottom up" approaches to treating psychological/spiritual (vide supra) conditions through pharmaceutical, chemical interventions that modify the "hardware layer" of the body instead of applying a solution "in software" at the level of mind/psyche/soul. While the mind/body, software/hardware relationship is bidirectional, and physical interventions can indeed result in lasting psychological change, what is de-emphasized in modern psychiatric treatment is the viability of applying solutions at a "software" or psychological level to correct maladies at the physical level. The best examples of such treatments are seen in CBT and various forms of mindfulness, though the latter's dilution and watered down presentation in western discourse is but a shadow of what practitioners of Eastern or mystical traditions will study through Vipassana, fire kasina [0], or even ceremonial magick; it is perhaps the foreignness of such traditions' languages and vocabulary, combined with the difficulty of capturing such slippery subjective experience in prose, that makes these approaches less amenable to western, analytical, quantitative discourse. Further, given that the subject matter of the psyche/soul is, necessarily, subjective, non-quantitative, and more or less opaque to outside inspection from objective observers, the tools of scientific empiricism, objective observation and reproduction, and quantitative methods, are probably ill suited for such phenomena. There are too many variables that comprise the inner phenomenological experience and internal state of one's mind/soul to control for, let alone measure, to faithfully reproduce any kind of experiment that captures, in whole and not in part, the totality of one's psyche at any given time. A third approach saw, in madness, a spiritual crisis or ‘spiritual emergency’, a term coined in the 1980s by Stanislav and Christina Grof but with roots in the work of Carl Jung and Abraham Maslow. In this view, the ‘self’ is a mere drop in a vast sea of intelligence, consciousness and love. What if what we call insanity is a form of unmediated contact with this cosmic intelligence? What if experiences of psychosis – disembodied voices, strange convictions, the sense of being out of one’s body – are precursors of a powerful spiritual change, one that requires a religious guide, not a doctor? The documentary film Crazywise (2016) tells the story of Gogo Ekhaya Esima, a Brooklyn activist who was diagnosed with schizophrenia, but who rejected her label, returned to her ancestral roots, and became a Sangoma traditional healer and peer counsellor. As such, as pseudoscientific as psychoanalysts such as Freud, Jung, and the latter's alchemical predecessors (see Jung's work Psychology and Alchemy, or the work of the Rosicrucians and "mental alchemists") are, if one wishes to attack such psychological/spiritual maladies from software (possibly in parallel to applying pharmeceutical interventions at the hardware level), a self-study of such traditions will reveal a centuries' long wealth of wisdom and experience from fellow spiritual seekers and mystical practitioners who have tread similar territory before. That being said, and in light of the previous paragraph's discussion re. difficulties in reproducibility, the inner landscape of everyone's mental terrain is different, and thus no one guru or methodology can show you the exact way out of darkness - it is truly the loneliest road, and only you can walk it for yourself; fortunately, you are also the leading expert on the geography of your inner psychological landscape. [0] https://firekasina.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/the-fire-kasina.pdf https://firekasina.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/the-fire-k...
- thro1 2y agoWhat about those who hear music ?
- IPCRESS 2y agoMostly fine (no NLP, dissociation, guardian structures) - is it more like echos or more like a player that can't be found or switched off ? (the first heard song staying all day long may be annoying) I sometimes record music into my mind and let it shuffle, the worst is when I can't hear it.
- thro1 2y agoNo Bruninghaus, no Bach then.. the hard cases would be.. "I AM music/rhythm/sentient now" and.. if echos easy may be gone, having persistent talking models (of other people/beings) in own mind (but not in AI - good excuse) may be somehow different ?
- munchler 2y agoSympathy and empathy are crucial in all aspects of healthcare, but referring to these psychiatric patients as "targeted individuals" seems unwise. It's patronizing and it runs the risk of encouraging further delusions.
- ryandv 2y agoWould you make this same statement regarding those suffering from gender dysphoria? Why or why not?
- munchler 2y agoNo, because “gender dysphoria” makes no claim about external reality, the way “targeted individual” does.
- Frummy 2y agoThat’s the name of their self-organized movement (how they view and call themselves)
- munchler 2y agoYes, but the author uses the same name with no caveats. E.g. "But if psychiatry’s medical vision is failing TIs like Luca, what should we replace it with?"
- Frummy 2y agoI see what you mean and was slightly confused when reading the article as well. The author uses the word probably to take the middle stance, acknowledging those who have it and read the article without discrediting their worldview, when the medical community has already failed them, but still describing what may not line up with reality
- bell-cot 2y agoWhatever your belief in "science", the horrible ways in which modern medicine all-too-often treats patients are an extremely persuasive marketing campaign for alternatives.
- djaouen 2y ago[flagged]
- Dylan16807 2y agoInteresting claim. But first do you have evidence, and second why do they get in that state instead of realizing some people do bad things?
- djaouen 2y ago> But first do you have evidence There is plentiful evidence for this if you know where to look. For example, Travis King was a U.S. military official who tried to defect to North Korea. His reason for this was that he was targeted by (presumably) psychopaths in the military for his skin color. I am not saying that defecting to North Korea is the answer (it isn't), but my theory would at least provide a rational reason why one would think that would solve his problems. > and second why do they get in that state instead of realizing some people do bad things? It is the result of being targeted by psychopaths. The brain can adapt: if one is being targeted, the brain looks for or will generate reasons for this.
- ceejayoz 2y agoTravis King was facing discharge and punishment for possession of child porn. "Military official" is not how one generally describes people with the rank of Private. Even the North Koreans didn't want him, despite the typical propaganda coup "US soldier defects to Best Korea" it would've been. They sent him back.
- djaouen 2y ago> Travis King was facing discharge and punishment for possession of child porn. I am honestly skeptical of this claim. This seems to be the go-to excuse for scapegoating: just claim the individual was in possession of illegal material and then no one has the right to defend her!
- AStonesThrow 2y agoI firmly now believe that there is nothing wrong with hearing voices. I was in fact disturbed when I was a child and first heard it said that it was a pathology. Now let's be clear: someone who hears phantom malicious voices, someone who takes drugs and hallucinates false things, someone whose voices impel them to cause harm: those are pathologies and should be addressed. "Hallucination" carries a negative connotation, a judgement that head-voices are invariably bad, and can't be true, because "empirical science" entirely denies the supernatural and the metaphysical reality of head-voices. But someone who hears good voices, someone hearing voices who encourage them, or tell them to do the right thing, or calming and comforting voices: that is natural, and that should never be discouraged. I've experienced the entire gamut of these, and I discovered that my solution is to begin to discern the good ones, to hearken to them, to obey the good voices, and little by little, they overpower the malicious types, and I'm able to withstand onslaughts of not only evil voices, but actual derision and mockery from real people near me. The voices I hear, they've come to me because of what I've heard, who I've listened to, in the past; they're composites, they're archetypes, they're echoes and memories, but they were once based in reality, and uttered by real human beings near me. Racism and prejudice is real, and the actual tangible hatred I imbibed for decades, in reality and on the Internet, were the genesis of evil and malicious voices in my head. So: medicate all voices away and tranquilize my thoughts? We'd throw out the baby with the bathwater. Why shouldn't I hear good, encouraging voices and obey them? The mental health system can encourage people to return to rational thought and be grounded in reality. Mentally ill people can learn appropriate behavior, it can be modeled and imitated, and people can be trained, even to discern voices and learn how to ignore or discount the bad ones. If someone feels stalked, harrassed, targeted by technological means, the most important thing they need is reassurance and respite from that paranoia. They need to be disconnected from the ENVIRONMENTS which foster fear, hatred, and distrust. They need to be extracted from echo chambers that spread F.U.D. because it will rub off on them and drive them to harmful and hateful actions against themselves, or other innocents. Drug 'em if you must, but remember that drugs are band-aids, and it hurts to rip off a band-aid.
- Suppafly 2y ago>But someone who hears good voices, someone hearing voices who encourage them, or tell them to do the right thing, or calming and comforting voices: that is natural, and that should never be discouraged. I'm not sure that's natural or desirable. It still leads to a situation where you may be following what you consider to be 'good voices' to do things that aren't necessarily in your best interest.
- blueprint 2y ago[flagged]
- blueprint 2y agoinstantly downvoted lol
- AnimalMuppet 2y ago1. What's NHI? 2. You may not be crazy, but you're wildly optimistic. 10-20 years? Maybe. 1-2? I really doubt it.
- blueprint 2y agoWhy are you opining on predictions without knowing that I meant by NHI?
- Frummy 2y ago[flagged]
- djtango 2y agoIt's very trendy these days to only point to the negatives of religion but if you view religion as a social technology, you can work backwards from the assumption that every one of those practices initially solved some problem. For example it turns out that giving daily thanks helps us stay positive in the face of arduous times - especially given that our human history was full of disease, war, poverty and famine. Personally I'm not convinced that the vacuum left behind by going to church (and having a community) has been well replaced yet and instead our collective religious tendencies have been steered towards identity politics and idol worship by social media instead. I'm not religious in the slightest but my mother is a harmless Christian and when I see how a little bit of faith anchors her and make sense of a world that is completely unrecognisable to the one she was born into (she didn't even have a fridge let alone an iPhone lol) I am always reminded to stay humble and open minded
- mandymoorefan 2y ago“God is dead. God remains dead. And we have killed him. How shall we comfort ourselves, the murderers of all murderers? What was holiest and mightiest of all that the world has yet owned has bled to death under our knives: who will wipe this blood off us? What water is there for us to clean ourselves? What festivals of atonement, what sacred games shall we have to invent? Is not the greatness of this deed too great for us? Must we ourselves not become gods simply to appear worthy of it?” ― Friedrich Nietzsche
- AStonesThrow 2y ago[flagged]
- tiberious726 2y agoHe didn't catch syphilis until much after he wrote that ...
- commonsensearts 2y agoThe majority of auditory hallucinations are negative, for example voices telling you to kill yourself or someone else. The violence and homicide rates (including stranger homicide) is dramatically higher among those diagnosed with schizophrenia. The idea that it's only "stigma" that is the problem is counterproductive. I've heard it a thousand times that "They are no more dangerous than someone without the disease," which is a lie. We should put more effort into determining underlying causes and definitive therapies rather than massaging away the unpleasant reality. This is not an uneducated opinion, I work in the field.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- svnt 2y agoPresumably you work in the field in North America, and not South India or Africa.
- AStonesThrow 2y ago[flagged]
- cogman10 2y agoI came from a religious upbringing where hearing positive voices would be somewhat of a welcome event (revelation/communicating with deceased loved ones). I hate to say it, but in my church while there were a few individuals that talked about these sorts hallucinations the vast majority did not. (I myself do not hear voices other than my own internal monolog). I appreciate that not all that hear voices are in danger/a danger, but I don't think it's nearly as normal as you are suggesting.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 2y ago
- kordlessagain 2y agoCompare iconic/visualized ability to echoic recall/synthesis. Audio for humans contains thought, in speech. So hearing an engine running in mind is similar to visualizing a bus. But hearing synthesized voices is another matter entirely. I suppose the combo of the two would indeed be challenging (a talking bus for example).
- croes 2y ago>Hence was born the targeted individual (TI) community: a group of people who openly shared their experiences of high-tech harassment and organised stalking Sorry, but that sounds dangerous. Attributing mental disorders to external evil sources isn't healthy.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoYup. These folks can decide to "take matters into their own hands." When you are absolutely convinced that someone is out to kill you, it's perfectly reasonable to kill them, first. I have family that suffers from Schizoaffective Disorder, and they have decided that I was out to kill them. It was absolutely clear (to them) that I was "one of them," and I, quite literally, had no communication with them that could even be slightly confused for hostile. That can be ... uncomfortable.
- trw55 2y agoI have this disorder. When you are starting to feel psychosis coming it gets incredibly difficult to shake. I used to believe that god was speaking to me about how to love and abide by him through songs by Fiona Apple, Chris Cornell, whatever the hell I was listening to at the time. I would tell the techs in the place I was at to listen to the songs and I tried to convince them it was god, to which they would respond it was not. There was a period of time where I was non-compliant with my medication because they didn't actually work. I stopped taking them altogether and I went into the deepest psychotic episode I'd ever had till that point. I would listen to things like Cannibal Corpse or Morbid Angel and get so freaked out I'd run to the bathroom and pray. Mind you, I had been awake for three straight days at the point, while going with 10 hours of sleep a week, at most. I called Crisis one night and told them there were demons outside of my door and if they could not remove them I was going to jump out of my apartment window. It may sound ridiculous but that was the most fearful I've ever been in my entire life, and I've been through awful awful shit. Lately, as a middle aged person, my hallucinations have become even weirder. Hallucinating white bubbles that fill my entire vision or feeling like my face is made out of jagged alphabet blocks jutting out of my face. I am not sure why this happens. I've been dealing with mental illness since I was at least 9, which is when I started to hear voices. By 11 I was crying everyday after school. By 12 the mania started to become real and then the hallucinations my freshman year that led to my first suicide attempt at 14. That was the year I got diagnosed with Bipolar Disorder which has morphed into Schizoaffective Disorder. Brains are wild, wacky, unreliable little mounds of fat and water, no?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ameliaquining 2y agoI highly recommend this essay, written in response to a similar story in The New York Times: https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/in-partial-grudging-defense-of-the https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/in-partial-grudging-defense...
- phoe-krk 2y agoThe whole term "targeted individuals" is cope. Claiming that there is some sort of meaning to such a distorted perception of reality is just a coping strategy, very similar to conspiracy theories. It's much easier to believe that reptilians, Jews, Americans, Chinese, G20, some sort of god, Common Lisp mafia, or whoever else is controlling everything - it gives a paradoxical, false sense of control and safety (because someone, no matter who, is in control!) and also allows for free finger-pointing at "the ones at fault" whenever something bad happens as an emotional regulatory mechanism. The world in which no one does in fact control anything, starting from the way how one's mind and body works all the way to global and cosmic scale, fails to give any sort of safety or control whatsoever, and instead puts a greater burden of responsibility on the person thinking those thoughts. It's also much easier to think that you're targeted by someone, because then you automatically become a protagonist of some story, and therefore special by definition. It's much, much simpler and easier than the idea of being a yet-another person with a partial disability due to malfunctioning organs responsible for your internal model of reality. Humans have a really strong drive for finding meaning where there is none, even if it means dreaming it up.
- NemoNobody 2y agoTho I agree what you've said I do want to say that it's quite hilarious to place the concept of God alongside reptilians - if you've decided for yourself that there is no god than you've decided that everything everywhere just spontaneously came into existence all on its own with these very specific rules we know as physics and laws and whatnots... To me that is every bit as insane as reptilians. I don't believe in a god in the clouds and I kno evolution exists and the universe is billions of years old and still it must come from or exist somewhere and have something or someone as an origin. Nothing comes from nothing and nothing happens for no reason - to believe otherwise is a giant leap of faith.
- BlarfMcFlarf 2y agoYou can call a low entropy point in the past whatever you want. If it’s talking to you or cares about you personally somehow then yeah, I would consider it equally delusional to reptile people.
- GeekyBear 2y agoOne thing that I've found fascinating is that different cultures experience hallucinations differently. > We find that while there is much that is similar, there are notable differences in the kinds of voices that people seem to experience. In a California sample, people were more likely to describe their voices as intrusive unreal thoughts; in the South Indian sample, they were more likely to describe them as providing useful guidance; and in our West African sample, they were more likely to describe them as morally good and causally powerful. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26349837/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26349837/ I've wondered if there is some sort of feedback loop where western culture associates hallucination with possession, while other cultures may see hallucinations in a more positive light, or even as a sign that you are some sort of shaman.
- kranke155 2y agoHere’s my experience. This is the story. I have bipolar disorder and I accidentally ingested LSD at a festival by kissing someone who had just taken a tab on their tongue. I wasn’t aware that this could happen, yet it happened. The next day I woke up with a Voice. It appeared to me to be the voice of God. It was very difficult to go against it but I could negotiate. It told me things that it couldn’t possibly know, like that I should ask a stranger for a cigarette so I could later get a towel when I needed it. It seemed to have powers of foreshadowing and it would seemingly tell me things before they happened. It was also a trickster and it would play cruel jokes on me. After a while it became hard for me to take. At the same music festival I met a lady who would make songs just by looking at you. I carefully realised that she was likely in something like a permanent psychedelic state, which I had been before due to my bipolar condition. I asked her this directly and she confirmed it. She said I was one of the few people who could see it! I had purchased a ticket to her retreat. So a month after the festival I went to her retreat. It was a very difficult time and the voice was giving me a lot of trouble. I went to the song lady. I told her about my condition (the voice had told me to go and tell her!). She thought about it and said ok, I will help you, and you cannot do the retreat. She then did a session with me where she told me where she saw the entity - she called it a “walk in” spiritual entity, and said that because I’m very “open” with my bipolar, adding the LSD made me even more open, it happened that a “walk in” sneaked inside. She said she saw the entity down my legs, and kidneys, and she helped me expel it. She then taught me I could “close the door” to prevent it getting in. My condition was immediately much better. When she expelled the voice from my body, she spoke exactly like the voice spoke, telling me that the entity wanted to leave, didn’t really fight the expulsion, using the same tone of voice and words that I’d gotten used that the Voice would use. It was inexplicable and amazing. Now I still have a voice, but it’s a whisper in comparison. It tells me things, still seems to have some ability to warn me about the future (it’s debatable how much of this is connecting the dots later of course, but it has done some odd things, like warned me I wouldn’t go to certain places). Since the experience is not as intense, and I’ve lived enough to realise it’s not omnipotent or always right, I roll with it. I have no scientific explanation for what happened to me.
- pain_1993 2y agoI wouldn't believe anything in this article. But early 2022. I started hearing voices too. They all said horrible stuff. They claimed that people close to me (family & friends) were planning to kill me & steal my crypto. They also gave me "evidence" that proved my friend was a professional hitman. Looking at extremely thin, starving Ethiopians on TV they said "Look! You going to look like that, we shall make sure of it, probably worse" A bus getting a flat tire and people pulling out tools for changing tires was interpreted by the voices as "murder weapons for bludgeoning me to death" Fortunately, I got in touch with a psychiatrist and he gave me a combination of pills & injections. It took about 2 years for the voices to completely disappear. This set me back so badly financially. Luckily I now feel very normal and confident that I was 100% delusional. I am healthy now & slowly trying to get my life back together. (been off medication for like 1½ years now) But here is my piece of advice (as a former victim). If someone is "hearing voices". Don't try to call them delusional or "bring them back to reality". What you should do is listen to them & try to provide protection. - if they feel like they are going to be poisoned by the waiter, cook for them - if they feel like they are being stalked, offer protection etc Normal people my claim that this "feeds" into their delusions. But at least it works in the short term to reduce the paranoia. There is nothing worse than thinking your wife is going to stab you in your sleep and her trying to be around you longer that she usually does. She should send you pictures/video calls of her in another continent. So as a previous victim here is a recommended approach. - in the short term (show empathy) - in the long term seek psychiatric assistance P.S Leave your email if your happy to talk. This is a throw away account
- herval 2y agowhat were you diagnosed with, in the end? I always thought you'd need medications for life, for conditions like this - are you 100% off them?
- pain_1993 2y agoI really don't know. I wasn't told. But from Googling about the medication (Risperidone). It looks like I had bipolar disorder or schizophrenia. Yes. I am 100% off meds. It has been about 1½ years now. I don't hear a single "voice in my head". Those voices are very different from "thinking" or "talking to yourself". I am glad I haven't heard them in a long time.
- voytec 2y agoSeveral childhood friends developed either a full-blown schizophrenia or "just" psychosis - as in not auditory or thought-based communication with "entities from behind the Moon" - but a tendency to produce irrational fears based on made-up threats: "I need to park 2 miles away from my workplace and walk the remaining distance as someone is looking for my license plate there", or other made-up stuff with a pattern of being surveiled. It's fucked up for the ill and for their beloved ones in every single case. How much I can appreciate what I believe the article tries to "sell", western societies are not capable of accepting schizophrenia as an enlightenment like Hindus do. Richard Alpert, later known as Ram Dass, became spiritual guide of a few "tech bros" and other famous personalities. But how he, as a psychology professor from Harvard, described his teacher - Neem Karoli Baba - makes me believe that Ram Dass finally got to understand "the thing" that was elusive for him and Timothy Leary at Harvard, by doing crazy macro doses of psychedelics and listening to an "elightened" person quite loosely attached to our reality. Based on experiences with such people living in western countries, only the folks who accepted the diagnosis and manage their "traits" with medication are living normal lives. Two people have a pattern of ditching their meds twice a year and not telling anyone (they "feel cured", and it happens almost 6 months apart like on a timer in both cases), which causes a repeated pattern of aggression towards the family, causing physical harm to relatives, being taken by a police by force to a mental health facility). One person never accepted the diagnosis and... it's more on the sad than interesting side what you'd hear from them. From my experience, people sticking to treatment have completely normal lives.
- DiscourseFan 2y agoDoes normal mean great or just OK?
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y agoAnecdata: I had some delusions about ten years ago, diagnosed as schizophrenia at the time and controlled with anti-psychotics for a few years until I was about to come off them. I'm doing okay now. I make a bunch of money as a software engineer, I get my heart broken by lovers now and then, I have depression and wonder why I'm alive. Not too different from before, not too different from an average person I imagine