7 ms·
Woolly mammoth 'de-extinction' is nearing reality
- bamboozled 2y agoNice just in time for the end of ice by anthropomorphic warming.
- JoeAltmaier 2y agoCurious - the entire objection to this endeavor as mentioned in the OP was, "What's gone is gone" according to some 'expert'. Now, new species are often disruptive in lots of ways. No reason to think an old one, reintroduced, would be less disruptive. But no mention of real issues like that. I think the writer was just fishing for something provocative to say.
- 99_00 2y agoA species that was eliminated by hunter gatherers or sailors with clubs is going to have a hard time getting out control.
- jfengel 2y agoI feel like the main objections would be in terms of animal welfare. You're almost certainly gonna harm a lot of animals in the process. Not just animals born deformed but also dangerous pregnancies. We do that all the time of course. But I'd kinda like to take at least a moment to consider how we minimize suffering before we plunge ahead.
- arp242 2y agoAnd even if you clone a perfect mammoth on your first try, then what? We know elephants are very intelligent, emotional, and social animals. I see no reason to assume mammoths are significantly different. And of course what they're working aren't even mammoths, more like "hairy elephants". Cloning a single hairy elephant and keeping it in captivity would consign it to a miserable life of loneliness. It would be nothing short of cruel. So you managed to clone a herd of hairy elephants, then what do you do with those? The mammoth steppes they once roamed no longer exist. There is no ecosystem to save or improve because that ecosystem is gone. That's what they meant with "what's gone is gone". Can you just re-introduce them to the wild? These are huge animals that need a lot of space. Other animals and people live there. You can't just have a bit of land; you need a huge amount of it. Cloning mammoths is just dumb. None of the logistics really work out and a bunch of mammoths spending miserable lonely lives in zoos is basically the best-case outcome we can hope for and after a few decades of this everyone will all realize it was pointless and mammoths will be extinct once more. All these notions are rekindling a lost ecosystem are nothing more than flights of fancy. For some other animals there is perhaps a slightly better case to be made; I don't know. But for mammoths the case is pretty bad.
- anon84873628 2y agoThe goal of the project is absolutely to release them into the wild. And their historical range is still largely empty of humans. There is enough space for everyone if we are willing to do it.
- pvaldes 2y ago> Cloning a single hairy elephant and keeping it in captivity would consign it to a miserable life of loneliness Easily solvable if you put it with other elephants. Small elephants bond also with humans.
- seszett 2y ago> Easily solvable if you put it with other elephants. Would it be that easy? Imagine a handful of wild humans, having never had any contact with other humans, no education or anything, just put somewhere and left to themselves. How many centuries would they need to even develop an actual language? They might very well be totally unable to cooperate or survive at all, without a preexisting society to guide them. Even if they don't have societies as developed at humans do, I can imagine the same would happen to different degrees with elephants, mammoths, dolphins, crows even.
- Dylan16807 2y ago> Imagine a handful of wild humans, having never had any contact with other humans, no education or anything, just put somewhere and left to themselves. > How many centuries would they need to even develop an actual language? https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/what-is-nicaraguan-sign-language https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/what-is-nicaraguan-sig... https://www.nature.com/articles/34646 https://www.nature.com/articles/34646 I'd say less than 0.1 centuries.
- pvaldes 2y agoNeo-mammooths obviously will learn the language of their modern elephant mothers without any effort.
- katbyte 2y agoWell the thing about a large mammal like an elephant is population control is easy and the effects generally more understood Unlike a zebra muscle which one it’s in your local lake goooooood luck ever removing them and now your lake may die a toxic blue green algae death
- sidewndr46 2y agoYou would think that, but we can't even agree to eradicate the hippopotamus from the Americas. Why? Animals rights groups think it is apparently an issue to just exterminate them. These are literal invasive species brought in by a drug lord. If it turned out that mammoths were actually a problem, we'd never agree to actually control the population.
- hparadiz 2y agoProbably one of the few actual wins of human activity.
- anon84873628 2y agoWhy?
- gweinberg 2y agoThere's no reason we should be able to agree. Some people like them and want them protected, other people hate them and want them gone. If it were really clear that they were harmful, shooting them all would be super easy, I could probably do it myself. Why would the fact that the guy who introduced them is a drug lord matter? Hippos can't inherit original sin.
- blackbrokkoli 2y agoYour comment made me laugh, but to actually answer: It matters from a Chesterton's Fence perspective: We know that the hippos were not brought for any good reason, inevitability, etc.
- 2y ago
- kenjackson 2y agoIt’s more than that. They also say: “Both Asian and African elephants, which Colossal plans to use as surrogates to grow mammoth calves, are endangered, and every elephant gestating a "mammoth" calf can't grow babies of its own. "That's going to reduce population size," Lynch said.“ We risk putting existing endangered species at more risk to try to bring back these past species.
- xhevahir 2y agoWell, it's not as if the surrogacy would continue indefinitely, putting a continuous strain on elephant reproduction. They would need surrogates only long enough to establish a breeding mammoth population, and there's even the possibility that, should elephants get even nearer extinction, future mammoths could return the favor, so to speak, by performing as surrogates themselves. If, as I've been told, grasslands are a better carbon sink than taiga, and mammoths are capable of converting the latter into the former, I'm hopeful for efforts like this.
- hparadiz 2y agoThe range of the Mammoth currently includes massive chunks of Alaska, Canada, and Russia where few people live. They might thrive in that environment much more so than the Asian and African elephants we have alive today. Maybe would even give them more breeding partners in the long term.
- anon84873628 2y ago>We risk putting existing endangered species at more risk to try to bring back these past species. Well, if the currently endangered species go extinct, we'll have the technology to bring them back too ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- tim333 2y agoThe elephant population is about 500,000. Using one or two as surrogates isn't going to change things much in itself. It's humans multiplying and taking their land which is more the issue.
- 2y ago
- Kye 2y agoThis doesn't seem any different from the reintroduction of horses to the Americas. Humans get along with similarly massive pachyderms now. This isn't like bringing a brachiosaurus back where there's no realistic way for them to live in the current biosphere. The risk to elephants in using them for this is a real concern though.
- lolinder 2y ago> Humans get along with similarly massive pachyderms now. Some humans do on a single continent which has a human population density half that of Eurasia, and even that not particularly smoothly: https://wwf.panda.org/discover/knowledge_hub/endangered_species/elephants/human_elephant_conflict/ https://wwf.panda.org/discover/knowledge_hub/endangered_spec...
- anon84873628 2y agoIt seems the de-extinction efforts help reinforce the rewilding and land conservation efforts. If an area has been populated by these reintroduced species it may be more resistant (politically if not physically) to human development.
- pizza234 2y agoFurther into the article, there's a section dedicated to the main objections ("Unintended consequences"). > For one, de-extinct animals may be sickly, given that the pool of available DNA for each species is relatively small. > It's also worth considering who would be liable if large-scale mammoth reintroductions went wrong. > Reintroductions can lead to clashes between humans and wildlife. > The makeup of the reintroduced population matters too > There's also no guarantee that animals will stay where we release them I have the impression that while each single point may be unlikely, there are (too) many unknowns in the project. In addition to the biological objections, there are the ideological ones, primarily: > Instead of using that money to bring back three extinct species whose ecological impact is unknown, the funds could be put toward saving roughly 100 species that are currently facing an uncertain future I agree that this is ultimately purely driven by profit: > "If they're successful — and I have no doubt that they will be — they're going to make a ton of money," he said.
- anon84873628 2y agoYes, an underlying motivation of the project is simply to fund more biotech research. Which, if it comes to fruition as imagined in sci-fi novels, could radically upend ecosystems and societies alike, in far more dramatic ways than discussed here.
- JoeAltmaier 2y agoThat cow is already out of the barn. There's precious little ecosystem left on this tired old iron ball that hasn't been radically upended. Funny how any effort to arrest the runaway catastrophe that's been caused is met with resistance that calls it 'further damage'. Like we aren't already facing tremendous risks by leaving it unchecked.
- patall 2y agoIn addition to that, societies and ecosystems could also upend differently if we do not develop this technology. As every technology, you can use it for good and you can use it for bad. But simple banning (or 'moratoria') do rarely stop a novel field from developing, and just end up pushing it in the less open grey zone of top secret research projects.
- namlem 2y ago[flagged]
- Eridrus 2y agoThere's a real (small c) conservative bias where we should keep things as they are rather than changing them for all sorts of reasons. People who want to actually change the world are a bit of a rarity.
- 99_00 2y agoI hope this is for real and they make progress to their goal.
- loufe 2y agoI think it's a world of difference bringing back a species for which we have actual DNA, instead of creating a "wooly-mammoth-like" creature via guesswork. I'm not opposed to the effort, if privately funded, just weird to consider the pointlessness of it in my eyes.
- nemo44x 2y agoPersonally I’m curious how they taste. A Mammoth burger could be succulent for all we know.
- afavour 2y agoDoubt we’re much closer to that. When was the last time you had an Elephant burger? Definitely the closest alternative that isn’t really accessible today for a bunch of good reasons.
- throwaway48540 2y agoWhat are the good reasons? I assume we're talking about a situation where we could create the elephants "on demand", like with these mammoths.
- Ekaros 2y agoI'm wondering as well, there should be sufficient supply of those dying old age or accidents to have at least some going around. The long gestation cycle and comparatively long time to maturity reasonably make them inefficient, but still some supply would be expected.
- adolph 2y agoWell for one, a rate limiting factor is gestation period which is proportionally long for elephants. You’d probably be better off farming Homo sapiens or maybe reviving some other species of homo. Put them in gestational pods to harvest their metabolic heat energy. Maybe run mental simulations of various things via neural link. https://www.bbcearth.com/news/elephant-gestation-period-longer-than-any-living-mammal https://www.bbcearth.com/news/elephant-gestation-period-long...
- nickdothutton 2y agoHow many times have I heard this in the last 40-something years? Just get on with it.
- Arch485 2y agoCool, but why would we want to do this? Is there any practical value? There are species that are important to our current ecosystem that are going extinct, why are we bringing back mammoths instead of fixing that?
- vikramkr 2y agoWe are trying to fix that - there are eight billion people on this planet and we as a species are capable of doing more than one thing at a time.
- Arch485 2y agoThe article says that trying to bring back mammoths is endangering other elephant species, so in this case it is mutually exclusive
- pvaldes 2y agoThis claim does not stand a minimum logical analysis. More animals in captivity means that you are increasing the habitat of this species. You can fit more animals from this species in the planet than before.
- pvaldes 2y agoThe economical value just as domestic animal for frozen areas is invaluable. But, the males would be most probably very complicated to manage. Also would help to fix those ecosystems in some way.
- bankcust08385 2y agoRich Russians have a hammer, and this is a nail.
- xutopia 2y agoIt's a bit crazy to think that we're bringing back a wooly mammoth just in time for record temperatures. Science is amazing... would be amazing if political forces would do something about climate change.
- doodaddy 2y agoI am unconvinced that we know enough about life’s engineering to do something like this safely. I am doubly unconvinced that private industry will take the risks seriously. This sort of project is steeped in classic misguided pie in the sky human thinking - let’s live on the moon or terraform mars instead of fixing our mess on this planet! Let’s resurrect an extinct species instead of saving the ones we’re about to make extinct! And then the idea that if the population gets out of control, well, we could just cull them. What, because we didn’t do a good enough job the first time?
- huitzitziltzin 2y agoWhat’s “safety” here? I don’t intend the question to be trolling. What’s the risk of bringing back a wooly mammoth? Sure it could die of a weird disease bc we didn’t have the full genetic code. And yeah I’m equally unconvinced from the article that we actually can do this, but it’s unclear to me what the risks are if we can and do? Scenario: Bring back one to one hundred wooly mammoths and… X worst case scenario happens. What’s X in your view for the wooly mammoth? I can’t think of any that seem actually bad but maybe my creativity is lacking?
- troad 2y ago> What’s the risk of bringing back a wooly mammoth? I imagine a big one is the needless and possibly intense pain and suffering for the surrogate mother elephant, and her experimentally-GMO'd calf. Elephants are highly social and by all accounts quite empathetic animals. Also the opportunity cost - elephant populations are highly endangered and every pregnancy cycle used up for this research is one less actual living elephant.
- doodaddy 2y agoAs a few others have pointed out, animal welfare is one. As you point out, disease is annother. And another is the instabilities that can arise by introducing a new species to an ecosystem. Do we really have an understanding of where the mammoth fit into the food chain? How it fit into its environment? I’d expect the answer is a resounding “no” because we don’t even fully understand this dynamic for plants and animals that live today.
- Animats 2y agoAt least they're re-creating something big. Jurassic Park notwithstanding, large animals are far less of a threat to humans than something small that could become an invasive species. Humans have tens of millions of RPG rounds in stock.
- creatonez 2y ago> Humans have tens of millions of RPG rounds in stock. What is this, Horizon Zero Dawn? Will we have to steal parts from the mammoth's cauldron facilities for our survival, while the mammoths continue to get stronger and stronger in an unstoppable paperclip optimizing loop?
- hashhar 2y agoBy paperclip optimizing loop did you by any chance mean https://www.decisionproblem.com/paperclips/index2.html https://www.decisionproblem.com/paperclips/index2.html?
- creatonez 2y agoThe game I mentioned has several paperclip optimizing scenarios unfolding at the same time, including one where terraforming robots (some of which are designed like mammoths & serve a similar environmental purpose) keep getting stronger and stronger to protect themselves from robot hunters while the AI's central command system has gone missing. It takes place in a completely "reset" world, so from the perspective of humans the robots have always been part of the natural environment. Not the most realistic AI story, but very fun.
- Dylan16807 2y agoThe same idea that is referencing.
- bink 2y agoAnd yet Australia "lost" the Emu war.
- sushid 2y agoZeno's mammoth is what I'll call it until I see one breathing in front of me.
- hnbear 2y agoIs it a mammoth or an elephant that looks like a mammoth: "To produce the calves, Colossal scientists will first identify the genes encoding the woolly mammoth's most emblematic physical traits, such as shaggy hair, curved tusks, fat deposits and a dome-shaped cranium. They will then insert these genes into the genome of closely related, and therefore genetically similar, Asian elephants (Elephas maximus)." They're not actually taking a full mammoth set of DNA and inserting that into an elephant egg to grow into a mammoth, which they'd done with earlier animals referenced in the article. Also - how do they know the mother can actually handle it? Seems pretty cruel to make the mother carry an edited child that she might not be capable of handling.
- PoppGolfer 2y ago[flagged]
- steve_adams_86 2y agoif it’s actually an elephant that looks like a mammoth, shouldn’t it develop in the womb much like an elephant would? I imagine they would perform a c-section to extract the baby in order to save both mother and calf if it was growing too large.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- karaterobot 2y ago> The question isn't so much whether we can resurrect lost species but if we should. I see what you did there, and I approve.
- _zagj 2y ago> It's also worth considering who would be liable if large-scale mammoth reintroductions went wrong. "The ecosystem has been adapting to the absence of mammoths since mammoths started going extinct," Lynch said. "What if there's an unintended consequence and something bad happens?" > Other experts echoed these concerns. "To get some impact, you need to have a lot of animals," Sophie Monsarrat, an ecologist and the rewilding manager at Rewilding Europe, told Live Science. The target species are all ones that humans (and exceedingly primitive humans, in the case of the mammoth) hunted to extinction, and inadvertently, at that. If there are unintended consequences, why couldn't we just hunt them to extinction again? The species listed in the article are all large, and all mammalian and non-flying avian (Dodo). It's not like they can hide or get away from us easily.
- timoth3y 2y agoThey are not operating from the full DNA, but "enough DNA to piece together functional genomes." However, even if we had pristine copies of mammoth DNA we could not re-create a mammoth. Complex organisms like mammoths (or humans) are not fully defined by DNA. They are an ecosystem of bacteria and smaller organisms. We don't know the number for mammoths, but about 40% of the cells in the human body are not human. They don't have our DNA. Without them, however, we could not even process food. We get those organisms, not from DNA, but from other humans and the environment around us. These scientists may be able to create something, and hopefully something that will not suffer horribly, but de-extinction is not nearing realty.
- canadianfella 2y ago[dead]
- cma 2y ago40% of the cells but much less of the mass: bacterial cells are much smaller.
- timoth3y 2y agoThe point is not how much they weigh, but that we can't survive without them. It's not just the digestive tract. Our eyes, out lungs, even our skin rely on a huge diversity of specialized and symbiotic organisms to function correctly. This ecosystem evolved in parallel with our DNA, and it's been lost for the mammoth. Yes, it seems we have the technology to create something with this DNA, but it won't be a mammoth as the organism existed in the past. It may not be viable, and it may suffer horribly.
- cma 2y agoPart of the point though was for some reason the number of them. If we didn't need the large amount in the digestive system but still needed it for lungs and eyes, looking at the number and saying it's only 1% wouldn't have any real implication for whether the offspring would be viable if it would have messed up lungs and not be. Aside from that though, it may be important, but there are also lots of cross-species animals (ligers, mules, etc.) that don't get the full bacterial dose from the father of which half of their genetics come from and that doesn't seem to be a main cause of any of their problems that I've heard of.
- dham 2y agoFirst of all, no one even lives in the places Mammoths would live. Second of all, they can't be any more destructive than the Argentine fire ants that I deal with every year. You can't get rid of them; you only need to slow them down with bait. They're literally everywhere and spreading.
- heroiccocoa 2y agoDelusional technohopium to cope with the fact that we are only increasing the rate at which we are annihilating biodiversity globally. Just today the government of Namibia announced they are going to cull wild animals amid drought (https://www.dw.com/en/namibia-to-cull-wild-animals-amid-drought/a-70097693 https://www.dw.com/en/namibia-to-cull-wild-animals-amid-drou...). This is e/acc delusion akin to entropy pipe dream that is atmospheric carbon dioxide removal.
- ederhex 2y agoBringing back a large species that went extinct by our hands into a climate it isn't built for is a new kind of cruelty we can add to our list.
- pvaldes 2y agoCruelcruelcrueltycruel. Please stop flashing the cruelty card here. Is ridiculous Being alive is better than not being alive, right?. Even if you experience pain or feel bored. Every animal experiences pain somewhere. Is fine. Is a part of having evolved pain receptors. Those receptors are here for our well-being and safety. There is nothing special about pain. Is part of our biology. We have methods to alleviate the pain at birth, why just assume that veterinarians will not use the tools that they have? because vets-bad-duh? All this pseudo-religious movements that say that all pain must be eliminated at any cost seem totally unhinged. They made promises that can't be fulfilled and they know it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- xg15 2y agoI know the entertainment industry is obsessed with reviving old franchises, but this is going a step too far!