8 ms·
48% of NYC riders do not pay the bus fare
- Lammy 2y agoJump the turnstile / Never pay the toll Doo-wah diddy and bust in with the pre-roll https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=itStM-gwUyU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=itStM-gwUyU
- pclmulqdq 2y agoWhy would you if you can get away with not paying? When I was a NYC resident, I looked at people who evaded fares with disgust for raising the price for all of us, but it's really just a consequence of failing to enforce the law. I should have been looking with disgust at the NYPD guys who walked around the platform like tough guys but constantly failed to hand out tickets to fare evaders.
- readthenotes1 2y agoBoth can be true...
- vladvasiliu 2y agoBecause it’s the right thing to do. You can’t have a cop behind each person to enforce all the laws. People should “self police” and realize that we’re living in a society where we must actually adhere to the values we say we have instead of just paying lip service. This is why we can’t have nice things.
- jart 2y agoI didn't know petty thievery was among our values, Vlad.
- pclmulqdq 2y agoSelf-policing by social shame doesn't work when there is a large population of shameless people. That population happens to also include pretty much all of the thugs in the NYPD.
- SllX 2y agoSelf-policing is nice but it is nicely complemented by actual police work. Cities should be aggressively policing fare evaders and maybe that means putting actual police in front and inside the fare areas to catch fare evaders, exclude people with hygienic issues and take harassment reports/arrest sexual harassers.
- parpfish 2y agoMaybe we need to stop thinking about public transport as a revenue generating/ self funding organization and just think about it as a critical piece of making a city work. Nobody worries about whether the fire department is “breaking even”, you just pay for it through taxes because it’s essential
- readthenotes1 2y agoWhere I live, the fare ticket's affordance is the ability to kick homeless off public transportation as it is the most comfortable place they have during hot summer days. I wish they would also kick off people who eat on the train and leave their mess behind, but they never confront nuisance-makers.
- pests 2y agoDid you know the homeless can also buy a ticket, even without a home?
- readthenotes1 2y agoOf course. But they have to have the money, and based on the number that flee ahead of the ticket checker, it's not a way many want to spend what they have.
- VWWHFSfQ 2y ago> just think about it as a critical piece of making a city work That's what the NYC MTA is... and they're $42 billion in debt. And they need to "borrow" another $23 billion from taxpayers to fund themselves for 2025-2030. [0] https://www.osc.ny.gov/files/reports/osdc/pdf/report-3-2025.pdf https://www.osc.ny.gov/files/reports/osdc/pdf/report-3-2025....
- mikem170 2y agoDid that have anything to do with the cancellation of congestion pricing? I heard that was supposed to generate $16 billion through 2030 for the MTA.
- dumbo-octopus 2y agoPublic transit fares are generally malformed. I personally never pay the LA Metro fare. Why? Because I pay the Metrolink fare, which by their own admission covers same-day Metro transit. But police will actively seek me out as a person who looks like they have money and give me a hard time for not “tapping”, all while folks who very clearly have no money waltz on into the metro, stopping only to smoke crack on the elevator up. There’s a general problem in this country of what to do with law breakers who do not have money. It seems like the answer is to make them work and garnish their wages, but for whatever reason we are against that.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y agoThere are no jobs that want jobless people. There's few that even want 18 year olds
- dumbo-octopus 2y agoPlenty of work for prison laborers.
- Retric 2y agoSure at 20-50 cents an hour, but that’s not really relevant here.
- dumbo-octopus 2y ago“Keep society functioning”? I’m not asking for them to man the electric grid, but there’s still a ton of work that is too inconsequential for any minimum wage job to be worth it, yet would still be a net benefit to society for somebody to do it. Things like picking trash up off the side of the highway.
- dumbo-octopus 2y agoAh, a ninja-edit. Cool. But tell me: why isn’t that relevant here?
- booleandilemma 2y agoI'm not too familiar with the buses but I use the subway and see people evading the fare daily. I pay but then I feel like a sucker.
- stevenwoo 2y agoI’m only familiar with the buses near me - I don’t think the bus driver would let me on board if I didn’t pay - how do these riders get away without paying? The driver will wait for people to get exact change and not move, though I have seen a driver let someone on who claimed they lost their card. I can see how people do this on a train or subway (until you get spot checked for fare) but I have to walk by the meter/card reader where I am for buses. The article is behind a paywall so I only got the first two paragraphs.
- dataflow 2y ago> I’m only familiar with the buses near me - I don’t think the bus driver would let me on board if I didn’t pay - how do these riders get away without paying? There's a history of bus drivers being attacked pretty badly for ticking off the wrong traveler. So they don't enforce this for the sake of their safety; they're supposed to just make a record of it and move on. https://gothamist.com/news/why-the-mtas-bus-drivers-dont-enforce-the-fare https://gothamist.com/news/why-the-mtas-bus-drivers-dont-enf...
- senkora 2y agoMany NYC buses let you enter at the middle or back of the bus, so it is easy to simply not tap when you get on. You don’t go past the bus driver.
- liveoneggs 2y agoSelect Bus Service uses those paper tickets or OMNY app reader, both of which are self-service and available in the middle door of the bus, far away from the eyes of the driver.
- dotnet00 2y agoThey usually just don't insist that strongly because they'd rather not get into a confrontation, as not moving might also anger people other than just the one you're holding for (as an argument I once saw happen on a bus went after a driver insisted, "the money isn't coming out of your paycheck so why do you care?"). Previously the consideration used to be nice because it was possible to end up in a situation where your metrocard was too low on balance, too far away from a machine to add more money to it, and you didn't have change. But nowadays most busses have tap-to-pay, so there shouldn't be many excuses.
- lsb 2y agoAll New Yorkers pay 80% of the cost to run the bus before they even think about boarding. (“Farebox recovery ratio”) This is an excuse to fund more cops. Transit should be free, like sidewalks and parks.
- VWWHFSfQ 2y ago> Transit should be free, like sidewalks and parks. Sidewalks and parks cost $0 for people to walk on, or let their dog shit in. Maybe $15/hour for the guys in blue jumpsuits to clean it up once a week? NYC has the largest subway system in the world _by_far_ (and also one of the oldest). It's extremely expensive to operate. Don't compare it to walking around on sidewalks or in parks.
- snypher 2y agoNYC parks budget is like $600m, it must cost something to maintain?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 2y agoSidewalks, as with trains, require construction and maintenance. An extra walker a day on a sidewalk costs the same marginal $0 or so an extra rider on the trains does. Both are expensive to run on large scale.
- VWWHFSfQ 2y agoThe difference is that when a sidewalk or park is ruined and un-walkable then it's cheap and easy to just put up some orange cones. So the cost of failure is basically zero. Not the case with the 4 train, or the L, or the 2-3. Those trains can't fail. So it's very expensive to make sure they don't. Nobody cares if Madison Square Park is blocked off for a day. (Maybe except the vagrants). But the city will literally grind to a halt if the green or red lines aren't running.
- 2y ago
- orange_joe 2y agoThe simple truth is that urban progressives no longer believe that the poor owe anything to society in general. The idea of enforcing the law against such a presumably disadvantaged group is anathema. Until there is a cultural shift where you can discuss the idea of mutually upholding the commons more and more city services will devolve into taxes on honesty.
- drawkward 2y agoIs society equitable to the poor?
- orange_joe 2y agoIn the case of the NY subway, it would cost a poor person receiving subsidized fare about $2.20/day to do their part, or about 9 minutes of work at minimum wage. It is not a crime to ask a person to participate in their own survival.
- scotty79 2y agoSome groups like restaurant employees don't get minimum wage. Also almost 40% of people have no job.
- orange_joe 2y agoThat's not true in NYC, food service workers have a minimum wage of $15. other groups you're thinking of also have minimum wages (i.e. door dash drivers) the labor force participation percentage is a slight of hand. You're including children (who receive free metro cards), retirees (including social security beneficiaries, pensions), and people who might just be rich. 40% has nothing to do with people's ability to make or have money.
- snakeyjake 2y ago$60/month is not a lot to you. $60/month is not a lot to me. $60/month can be an infinite amount of money if you are poor, which I have been.
- megablast 2y agoIt should be free. Most roads are free.
- srj 2y agoRoads are funded by gas taxes, or with income/property taxes.
- scotty79 2y agoWhat's wrong with funding buses the same way?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- marssaxman 2y agoI totally agree, in principle! But I also remember what Seattle buses were like when we still had the ride-free zone: people would just ride the bus back and forth across the zone all night, to have somewhere to sleep. To a point, making buses free makes them more accessible as transportation; but then, literal free-riders make them less accessible as transportation. I don't know what the solution is.
- 8bitsrule 2y agoIn King County, buses lost -a lot- of riders when COVID appeared. And that ridership hasn't rebounded yet. At non-peak times, it's maybe 1/3. (And that's at 15 minute intervals ... a -lot less- frequent that New Yorkers expect [Youtube] ). So yeah, a high tolerance for freeriders should prevail below 1/2 loads. Also there a lot of new drivers these days ... there's more than enough for them to learn and watch ... policing should be low priority. Kids (IIRC) are free-riding anyway.
- micromacrofoot 2y agoit shouldn't have a fare! taxes are the fare! the amount of time, effort, and money spent on fare collection is absurd! taxes are more efficient
- ipnon 2y agoFare evaders are often critics of the high price, not realizing that the price could apparently be cut in half if all riders simply cooperated to pay the fare.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 2y agoAs if that’s what would happen with the extra revenue.
- m_ke 2y agoI wonder what percentage of that is people getting on a bus to get to a train, where they actually pay the toll. I used to have to take a bus to a train and it was normal to have people get in through the exit doors in the back because the front of the bus was too packed to get through (people not moving to the back because they're old or want to be close to the exit to get off). Almost everyone got off on the last stop that was next to a train stop where they would go down and pay to get on the subway. I also used to take another bus down metropolitan ave in Queens, which usually only had 5-10 people on it at a time but would be stuck in heavy traffic due to all of the people driving down the avenue from Queens to Brooklyn, and it made me wonder how much time everyone would save if we made the bus free to incentivize more of the drivers to take the bus instead.
- known 2y ago[dead]
- poidos 2y agoDoesn’t NYC spend significantly more on police to crack down on fare evasion than they do on skipped fares?
- dotcoma 2y agoI imagine that 90% of those who get on a bus without paying have a smartphone in their hands. Is there really no way to charge for bus rides via smartphones, and track those who are on buses but don’t pay?
- dotnet00 2y agoMost if not all NYC busses have tap to pay now, so yes, they could tap and pay. Tracking phones that aren't paying might cause issues though.
- dotcoma 2y agoEven without tapping, I mean. You’re within a few feet of one of those sensors for more than a minute? Thanks for your purchase (if you have credit, or a card tied to the system). And if you don’t, it’s one line on your record, just like you were speeding or peeing on the streets. I’m not against treating buses as something we pay with taxes. But as long as we are required to buy a bus ticket, I think we should track those who don’t.
- rayiner 2y agoYou can’t have nice things if you don’t have nice people. In Germany busses often use an honor system: https://www.german-way.com/travel-and-tourism/public-transport-in-germany/ https://www.german-way.com/travel-and-tourism/public-transpo.... Half of riders evading bus fare is third-world country levels of dysfunction. How does a developed country get to that point? And is it even possible to get things back on track? I imagine you could institute harsh punishments for fare evaders, but if you need to do that, you’ve already lost. You can’t beat orderliness into people.
- pcwalton 2y agoI was curious about your claim, having spent time abroad in Germany and never having seen an honor system. In fact, what your link describes is not an honor system but a proof-of-payment system. Proof-of-payment systems are common in the US too, for example on Caltrain in the Bay Area (which reportedly has very low fare evasion rates).
- telotortium 2y agoProof-of-payment works on Caltrain because they have conductors who will walk up and down the aisles to examine your ticket/scan your Clipper card for payment. On busses, which don't have conductors, it really is an honor system.
- pcwalton 2y agoIn Germany they have Kontrollieren who come through the buses and check all the passengers. The frequency varies from line to line, but you generally won't be allowed to get away with not paying for long. I have no doubt that if they weren't there, fare evasion would be high even in Germany (and this isn't a recent thing--my experience is from 2003).
- telotortium 2y agoI wonder how the frequency is now. A lot can change in 20 years. I’m also surprised that Kontrollieren can fit on the busses - during peak hours, busy bus routes generally are standing room only. On the other end of the spectrum, Istanbul has turnstiles at bus stops, just like a subway.
- tamaharbor 2y agoFunny no one in the comments has mentioned law and order.
- Arnt 2y agoStrange. 48% is a lot, and the difference indicates that there may be design problems. By design problems I mean... For a while my bank's ATM gave me only large-denomination notes and the bus company's machine didn't accept those. So I'd stand there, money in hand and unable to pay. Later, when I had my first child, a few of the tube station entrances only had ticket-stamping machines at the stairs, not at the path I had to use with my baby pram. Do NY buses have that sort of problem? https://archive.is/e7agL https://archive.is/e7agL btw