15 ms·
Intel Layoffs: Is Future U.S. Chip Independence in Trouble
- mepian 2y agoCan the US government nationalize Intel in the worst-case scenario?
- bitmasher9 2y agoCan they? Maybe. Will they? No. Besides, how would it actually help.
- michaelt 2y agoSome people think countries should keep a certain amount of certain industries around, regardless of whether they can be run profitably, just in case a big war breaks out and you need those things and can't source them from abroad. A government might keep things like shipyards in business, even if they can't compete in the global market, just in case we ever need a rush order of new warships. And keep steel mills in business to supply the shipyards, and so on. Because modern weapon systems need modern integrated circuits, if there was the political desire the state could keep Intel on life support forever.
- lizknope 2y agoThe US government would be even worse than Intel at running their business. The more likely scenario is that the US govt declares Intel "too big to fail" and they give them a bunch of money. They are already doing that through the CHIPS Act.
- catproc 2y agoMy favorite part of this is how not only do we kick the can down the road, but the executives also get even more money. I assume that's their favorite part, too.
- mdasen 2y agoSort-of. You can't just take without just compensation so it'd probably cost the government $200B (you can't buy a whole company just at its market cap). But when what? OK, you've nationalized Intel. All the same people are working at Intel. You've bought Intel, but you haven't really changed anything. GovernmentIntel faces all the same problems that Intel faced like high US wages and having been behind on EUV lithography. The biggest problem with Intel is that it ignored EUV for a decade hoping to save money. If the US nationalized Intel in 2012 and the government said "you're going to invest in EUV," then Intel would be in a different place today. Nationalizing Intel in 2024 wouldn't really do much. They've already changed course and should have High NA EUV chips out years before TSMC. Of course, the US could have also just said "we'll offer billions if you invest in EUV fabs in the US" back in 2012. I guess the question is: what does nationalizing Intel give you? It gives you control, but you also basically already have control if you're willing to give them money - and nationalizing companies typically costs more than incentives.
- jmclnx 2y agoSadly it has been from the beginning. Companies in the US only care about profits, not about what is good for the Country they are in. And in reality that is how capitalism works. Pouring money into these companies will do nothing. What is needed is laws with real punishment for the Company and maybe the CEOs. IIRC, there was a time were all defense contractors had to be 100% sourced in the US, not now. So I would say a law like this: "70% of all products you sell and all the components must be 100% built in the US. If not, you are fine of 30% of your pretax worldwide revenue, including international subsidiaries". If you leave the US, you will be nationalized.
- Workaccount2 2y agoAdvanced economies simply don't work like this. You cannot have an entire generation raised with the mantra "You must go to college. Take loans. Go to college" and then expect to have a strong blue collar work force. I went to college to sit at a desk at home and get a salary, not commute to a job site and make an hourly. And even without the mantra, who the hell wants to be the skilled technician working 60 hours a week in a clean lab to push out top quality silicon, when they can be the skilled SWE fiddling with a login page for twice the pay, from their home office, for 30 hours a week? If you break it down, it becomes more and more of an irreconcilable problem.
- rahkiin 2y agoWhy, in your example, is the technician working 60 hours or being paid hourly? Why cannot a technician work 40 hours on a salary?
- fragmede 2y agobecause different people like to do different things? twice the pay is a benefit, sure, but then you have to sit in front of screen all day long staring at it. Some people wanna work with their hands, and really don't want to sit in front of a screen, no matter how much you pay them. some people even forgo a livable amount of pay, and choose the starving artist route. not everyone optimizes for pay, nor do they have the ability or aptitude or even desire to become a software engineer.
- Animats 2y agoThe US doesn't make much consumer electronics. How can it remain in ICs? Someday, Foxconn will figure out that it doesn't need Apple any more.
- xadhominemx 2y agoYou think Foxconn is going to get into the commodity android smartphone business? Compete with Xiaomi for single digit market share at zero margin?
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoPick your economy-ending force in China: - Xi's cult of personality and curtailing of capitalism - A Taiwan invasion attempt that brings massive blockades and boycotts - Demographic collapse from decades of poor fecundity - Financial house of cards / property crisis Zeihan used to be a cuckoo clock of saying this stuff every year, but recently most of the poo-pooers have gone quiet and even started saying things that quietly agree with him, so I think China doomism is entering mainstream policy planning. China is undeniably being far more militaristic and aggressive in recent years, and this combined with the COVID shock has led to a large rethink in policy and a questioning of outsource manufacturing reaching the point of sharp security concerns. Globalization being "over" is debatable, but the notion that the world is in a post-war "new history" is dead with the Ukraine war and China's increasing aggression.
- Animats 2y agoThe underlying big effect is that countries that are industrializing can grow economically at about 10% per year by copying the advanced countries. When they catch up, growth drops to about where their new peers are, because the fast catch-up phase is done. Happened to all the "Asian tigers" - Japan, Taiwan, Korea, Singapore. Now it's happening to China. Normal part of progress. Good summary in "How Asia Works", by Studwell. Everybody has a property overbuilding crisis. "Build it and they will come" seems to be a universal for developers. What matters is how they come back from it. Japan took about three decades. The US took about three years.
- kamaal 2y ago
- darby_nine 2y agoApple seems to be just as much a player as Intel.
- verdverm 2y agoApple designs chips, but does not print them as Intel does (both)
- mepian 2y agoApple's shareholders would riot if the company started building its own semiconductor fabs.
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoMoore's SECOND law is the big kicker here. The cost of a current top end fab is astronomical for experienced semiconductor companies. There is no "skunkworks" to get a top end fab going. The real prayer is that Moore's FIRST law / node shrinks run fundamentally out of steam in producing efficiency or speed results, and that gives the entire industry time to optimize and drop fab equipment costs for near-top-end fab performance. This may actually start to happen in the next 5-10 years.
- thijson 2y agoI think Jensen Huang stated that Moore's law is dead a few times. I've seen projections of cost per transistor for the leading node being more expensive than the trailing node. The only reason to pursue it would be that the market can bear the additional cost because power or some other attribute is better.
- bitmasher9 2y agoThere’s a big difference between designing chips and manufacturing chips. The concern here is Intel is the last US HQ CPU fab that matters, and its relevance is waning.
- darby_nine 2y ago
- AnotherGoodName 2y agoThe thing that will surprise a lot of people is how low Intel pay is in the USA. Just look up Hardware Engineer Intel on Payscale or other wage comparison site. Other companies are paying 50% more for the equivalent level. Eg. "Intel Bay Area Hardware Engineer salary" level 5 vs entry level "Google/Meta/Nvidia/AMD/Apple hardware engineer salary". On a direct, with no PPP or similar conversion comparison they do pay more for Bay Area talent than TSMC does for talent in Taiwan but Taiwan has significantly lower costs of living so you really wouldn't be better off even as talent in Taiwan migrating for an Intel job. There's no way Intel is getting the best talent nor has it been for a long time. They do not compete in the slightest and they haven't in a long time. They do not even come close. Oh and they are doing layoffs of the cheapest hardware engineering workforce in the USA right now. Lets see how this pans out for them.
- jp42 2y ago100% agree on pay. Also Intel is ossified, there is less and less team where you are held accountable. Empire building is rampant. One of the fundamental thing missing is vision and how each team is relate to that vision.
- BobbyJo 2y agoA friend left his SWE position at Intel(He was part of the Altera acquisition) about 4 years ago. His weeks consisted of answering one email on Monday and working out the rest of the work week because his lead did pretty much nothing, and their manager not only did nothing, but made shit up regularly. It was pretty wild honestly.
- protastus 2y agoOne problem with paying people significantly below market is that some of your people will be disgruntled and will optimize for working as little as possible without getting fired. Soon enough there are entire groups whose culture aligns with cutting corners and pretending to work.
- snapcaster 2y ago
- Chiba-City 2y agoOur legacy "computer industry" was a lend/lease styled business model industry. Our legacy "computer companies" were financing companies. Not "computing" companies. That lends/lease financing business model justified the sales forces operating on commissions. All that is over now. Everything has changed now. Computer automation (CPU, RAM, Storage, I/O) is now priced in the mere 100's of dollars. That signifies "stuff" you can buy at Best Buy or even 7/11. Stuff you can "buy" signifies "stuff" that cannot be sold on commission. There is no more role for financing (lend/lease). There are no roles for sales forces operating on commissions. I love bits and bytes. So what? Follow the money.
- polalavik 2y agoWhat? We are talking about a major IC designer/manufacturer not gateway desktop computers from 1999. Theres still tons of money to be made in chips - the whole world runs on them. but the cost is in the multi-multi-billion dollar r&d to build a fab that actually makes functional chips. And then having the work force that can produce successful yield after successful yield 24/7 that keeps the economics of the whole thing on par with Taiwan and other major supply chain countries in the indo-pacific where wages are lower.
- bitmasher9 2y agoWhat matters the most is the product. Intel has had a serious of serious problems on that front over the last decade. From product delays, to Speculative Execution security concerns, to oxidation/voltage issues. Meanwhile their competition has been absolutely killing it, to the point where their X86 moat is collapsing. Their major software partner, Microsoft, is spending $$$ to open the option to work with other vendors. The fact that Apple successfully walked away is a major advantage for MacOS over Windows. All the tax incentives, all of the trade deals, all of the weight of the federal government won’t matter as long as Intel continues to produce inferior products. Now they have 15% fewer minds to work with. In twenty years it won’t matter if Intel is still operating fabs or not, the chips will be so far behind all the serious workloads will be on other silicon.
- ptdorf 2y ago> What matters the most is the product. This ^^ I went from a Intel MacBook Pro that can boil eggs to a M2 silent, efficient killer machine.
- KK7NIL 2y ago> Atkinson says that while the CHIPS Act is a start, the United States is likely to need additional funding, support, or incentives if the goal is to see competitive leading-edge semiconductor fabs owned by U.S. corporations. “We’ve hit a double in the first inning, and that’s pretty good,” he says. “But the problem is everybody in Washington thinks we’re done.” This is the problem. Asia has seen semiconductor manufacturing as a strategic investment and so setup long term benefits, subsidies and education programs. They also have leadership that stays in power long enough to see these plans through. Meanwhile the US has been enjoying the easy gains of SW companies juiced up on low interest rates (which leads to inflation, which favors industries that require very little capex). Finally people are realizing that we still need HW companies but all we get is a one off band-aid solution, just enough for the industry to survive until the next election. It really is like the old joke that Asia is playing go while the US is playing chess (strategic vs tactical thinking).
- riku_iki 2y ago> if the goal is to see competitive leading-edge semiconductor fabs owned by U.S. corporations. I think another efficient goal would be to invite politically friendly asian companies to build fabs in US. Not clear if US companies can catch up at this point.
- KK7NIL 2y ago> Not clear if US companies can catch up at this point. I'm biased as I'm working on 18A at Intel but I'm very optimistic for this node. We could leapfrog TSMC (this is all public information). And in the last few years Intel speedran 4 nodes to catch up, which was quite the feat. > I think another efficient goal would be to invite politically friendly asian companies to build fabs in US. This was part of the CHIPS act too (which I think shows how scattered the US semiconductor policy is), TSMC and Samsung got money to do exactly that.
- osnium123 2y agoDo you feel like Intel is a compelling employer for you and does it pay well/create a positive environment for you?
- BlarfMcFlarf 2y agoCompanies that want bailouts, if they are of national interest, should get those in exchange for partial ownership. When private ownership fails, national funds should come with national controls.
- snapcaster 2y agoAgreed, I'm willing to concede the point that any great power needs a chip industry but I hate my money getting put into the incinerator that is modern Intel with no strings attached
- philwelch 2y agoThis is how the GM bailout was structured, though the government ended up selling their stake in GM after it was rebuilt. Based on the performance of the companies that the US government does own, this seems like a really bad idea in general. Amtrak has been a money pit for special interests for decades and the USPS is only profitable because they have a legally protected monopoly they constantly abuse to shove spam into the same mailbox where I occasionally receive bills and jury summons (to the point where my USPS service is easily at least 90% spam).
- mdasen 2y agoIt's also how the bank bailouts were structured. They weren't free money. They were loans plus government ownership (which the government typically sold off for a nice profit). The loans were typically 5% which would rise to 9% after the first five years. People talk about the bailouts like they were free money and say things like "the government should bail out ordinary people." The reality is that they weren't favorable terms - but reasonable enough that the banks wouldn't fight taking the money. The government wanted to stabilize the banking system (and automakers) and it wasn't totally clear who would need money. For example, how much money do you need over the next month? Well, that depends on factors you don't know about. Maybe you have a medical emergency or some other unexpected thing happen. So the government wanted the banks to accept the money rather than say "nah, we think we can weather the storm" and then fail creating more chaos. If the government had said "we'll give you $10 and own half your company," no bank would have accepted that. Instead, it was typically structured as preferred shares (essentially a loan) offering 5% interest for the first 5 years and 9% after that plus warrants for ownership of the companies equivalent to 15% of the money invested. When the financial system stabilized, the banks typically repaid the loans and bought the warrants from the government. For example, with Citibank, the government gave them $45B and made a $12B profit 2 years later - a 27% increase over 2 years. That's pretty good. With General Motors, the government gave them $13.4B in exchange for $2.1B in preferred shares and 61% ownership of the company. People act like they got free money, but that simply wasn't the case. The government got a reasonable deal on that money, especially given that they were trying to force the banks to accept it. Some believed that they could go without the help and that the "bailout" terms weren't in their best interest. They didn't want to make a deal while their value was low since the government would be getting a lot for their buck. But the government's terms were reasonable enough that some cajoling got them to accept it. I mean, Citigroup went from $900B in July 2007 to $400B in July 2008 to $50B in January 2009 (and around $85B when the government sold its ownership in 2010). Citi did need the bailout and the US government ended up with 36% ownership. Citi clearly wouldn't have sold 100% of the company to the government for $5B in 2008 or 2009. At that point, you might as well roll the dice and take your chances. The government gave Citi $45B and got $22.2B back as cash from Citi and 36% of the company (basically, 36% of Citi for $22.8B). Note: when you buy large chunks of companies, you don't get the market price. As you buy more shares, you get to investors unwilling to sell at that price and the price goes up. Maybe 1% of shareholders might be willing to sell at $50B, but then some will believe they should hold rather than sell. So the government didn't get a bad deal.
- shortrounddev2 2y agoIsn't AMD an American company edit: I guess they don't manufacture their own chips though
- rahkiin 2y agoAmd does not have a fab. Intel does have a fab.
- mepian 2y agoWhat’s interesting is that AMD used to have a fab… then it was spun off… then it gave up on keeping up with TSMC's latest nodes. Possibly for the same reasons Intel is struggling right now.
- onepointsixC 2y agoThere’s only a handful of leading edge customers. If you can’t peal off TSMC customers you’re toast.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- lizknope 2y agoAMD spun their fabs off as Global Foundries in 2009 Then in 2014 IBM "sold" their fab division to GF but IBM actually paid GF $1.5 billion to take them.
- shortrounddev2 2y agoIf Intel somehow needed to sell its hardware, could the US block any sales to non-US based companies?
- KK7NIL 2y agoAt least some of the equipment (EUV machines being the big example but even things like high bandwidth oscilloscopes and many other tools we never hear about) are already export restricted (export is still possible but requires approval). Whether the executive could place a blanket "no export" on all of it without a legal battle is a very different question. Edit: this is only for whether or not the equipment can leave US soil. Whether it can be sold to a foreign company but stay in the US is a different question (the answer is yes if I had to guess)
- bee_rider 2y agoI don’t have any mind for policy. Law just seems like very confusing hyper-spaghetti code. But, I really hope the CHIPS act is well-targeted. We don’t need Intel, the chip designers, anymore. I mean, their chips are fine basically, or maybe they aren’t so great, whatever, they can still sell them, I don’t care. But we absolutely and desperately need a chip foundry company and if IFS can be that, they deserve a chance (and are probably the best bet we’ve got, unless somebody can convince TSMC to send us some folks, but that seems pretty unlikely).
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoIntel has 10 wafer fabs worldwide. Yes, not all of them are at maximally modern nodes... But here's an idea. Let's spin off Intel's fabs not into one company, but two. Get a little anti-trust and market competition to go with the CHIPS investment. Intel won't like it, but make the CHIPS funding dependent on it. Yes I know, no way that gets out of congress intact.
- bee_rider 2y agoIt would be a fascinating experiment if we could try it safely somehow. Break up Amazon, Intel, Microsoft, Apple, and Amazon and watch their various parts try and figure out how to make money. A world in which I can buy a Graviton chip fabbed in the US by IFS, and then consider installing Windows on it (nah, but it would be nice to have the option) would be really neat.
- osnium123 2y agoI don’t think the economics can support running two different development teams in the US. The latest EUV tools cost $400M for example.
- onepointsixC 2y agoWho will be their customers? Intel’s woes are all because their fabs fell behind, if they were fabless they would just go to TSMC. Global foundries could keep up and had to give up on leading edge. Without Intel as their own customers Intel fabs will die.
- catproc 2y agoHave we tried more stock buybacks and layoffs? Will that help?
- disqard 2y agoWhile snarky, I think your comment is incisive. It might be a little bit "on the nose", kinda like "speaking ill of the dead" too soon. Intel is not yet interred... Interesting to see how Intel's hubris has painted it into a corner. Will the US govt. consider it "too big to fail" and infuse it with more cash as needed? Time will tell. P.S. If the govt. does provide cash, what will prevent some future CEO from short-term juicing the stock using that cash, collecting a big paycheck (and running away before the stuff hits the rotary object?)