4 ms·
I dunno, Dragon's return capacity is 3000kg which is about $240m... I think if there was a giant sack of pure gold bars up there it would be economically viable
by IshKebab 2y ago
I dunno, Dragon's return capacity is 3000kg which is about $240m... I think if there was a giant sack of pure gold bars up there it would be economically viable. The problem is there isn't. No way are you going to be able to refine it in space either.
- kibwen 2y agoIndeed, I'm referring to the cost of the whole operation, including all the bits where you need to develop and deploy a fully-autonomous robotic mining operation a zillion miles from anywhere.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoIt might not be so hard to do because space is such a good insulator. You could get two chunks spinning on a tether and use a solar pumped laser to heat them. It would be a sort of melting-point chromoatograph where you'd get different materials melting out at different times. Cooling the collected material would be expensive, but you'd end up with most of the gold all together in one stratum of the result.
- lightedman 2y ago"It would be a sort of melting-point chromoatograph where you'd get different materials melting out at different times." In geology, we do something incredibly similar called the Bowens Reaction Series. Take a bunch of stuff, melt it and cool it, watch what precipitates and crystallizes from the melt in order to determine the overall composition.
- kadoban 2y ago> Cooling the collected material would be expensive Can't you just throw it in the shade and wait? Space is an excellent insulator, but radiation cooling still happens. Just let it sit there for a few weeks/months and you're all set, right?
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoI think you're right. I've been thinking in terms of vehicles with habitats, where the conductive heating would eventually be a problem. But this is just a few buckets on a cable, the whole assembly can stay at molten-metal temperatures for weeks without hurting anything.
- theptip 2y agoWhy would you return the materials in Dragon? You can build a simple glider from space-side materials. The return trip is way easier than getting out of the gravity well. You don’t even need crew.
- Teever 2y agoBonus points if you design the glider in such a way that it is covered in some sort of ablative material that helps mitigate climate change after it burns off keeping the mined material from doing so to maximize material return.
- theptip 2y agoThis is an interesting idea. I initially assumed you’d just structure your payload (eg titanium) to ablate during reentry. But maybe you can do something better with carbonaceous asteroids, or simply with regolith, to produce a cheap ablative shield. I suppose the problem would be with the changes to aerodynamic profile during reentry - but perhaps regolith tiles could be manufactured to ablate in a consistent-enough pattern?
- Ekaros 2y agoReturn trip is double the complexity as first you need to get there. And then you need to slowdown to get back here as into orbit. Getting off the Earth is somewhat solved. But getting there and back at scale is not really done.
- IshKebab 2y agoYou can't glide back to the surface. Kind of feels like you should be able to but it doesn't work out like that. If it did then that's how all spacecraft would descend. Scott Manley did a good video about it. https://youtu.be/5kl2mm96Jkk?si=Uf9ntP6R39SJrVBm https://youtu.be/5kl2mm96Jkk?si=Uf9ntP6R39SJrVBm Skip to 3:45 for your exact "well meaning suggestion from people who aren't rocket scientists".
- theptip 2y ago
- fnordpiglet 2y agoSmelting using focused solar radiation against a spinning carbon crucible would be cheap, mechanically simple, and effective. I’m not sure why you think you can’t refine in space.
- bartonfink 2y agoBecause right now it's not even research, let alone economical. This isn't Stellaris, this is real life.
- fnordpiglet 2y agoI see, so when pursuing future technologies we should stick with what we know? We typically research what’s achievable in the near future, however the mechanics for purifying heavy metals with centrifugal forces isn’t new fwiw. It’s how we made atomic bombs.
- bartonfink 2y ago[flagged]
- fnordpiglet 2y agoYes. 80 year old technology trying to do something much more complex than separating two very distinct elements. I’d remind you you’re commenting on an article about asteroid mining, which is sci-fi that’s becoming more attainable. What I don’t really get is the nasty hostility.
- bartonfink 2y agoTone policing is a weak retort. If you'd rather we just sing Kumbayah and talk about science fiction then yeah! We could even staff these centrifuges with autonomous bipedal androids a la Lt. Commander Data. Those are becoming attainable in much the same way as your mechanically simple, cost effective, never been built zero g metal gas centrifuges. Learn something with that big brain of yours.