5 ms·
Profits are fine, excessive profits at the cost of people who need housing are not. There is no silver bullet, but increasing supply along with strong regulatio
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
Profits are fine, excessive profits at the cost of people who need housing are not. There is no silver bullet, but increasing supply along with strong regulation to protect renters is welcome vs them being cattle to be squeezed by for profit entities. Human rights are a thing, there is no right to profit.
> The six largest publicly traded apartment companies in the U.S. — all of which are linked to an alleged rental price-fixing scandal — experienced profit increases during the first three months of the year, according to an analysis from left-leaning watchdog group Accountable US exclusively shared with The Hill.
> In the analysis, the companies earned a combined $300 million in profit during the first quarter of the year, in part, due to rent increases.
Lots of profit to squeeze out with regulation, based on the evidence. The Vienna model is a proven model if for profit enterprises walk away from housing.
https://thehill.com/business/housing/4718252-large-apartment-companies-rental-fixing-scheme-profits-analysis/ https://thehill.com/business/housing/4718252-large-apartment...
https://accountable.us/report-top-corporate-landlords-see-profits-soar-amid-rent-hikes-and-fees/ https://accountable.us/report-top-corporate-landlords-see-pr...
- itake 2y agostrong regulation increases costs (see all the permits and surveys required in SF). What are "excessive profits"? 10%? 15%? 25%? > experienced profit increases during the first three months of the year Does this even mean anything? This could mean their vacancy rate decreased and thus their business is more profitable. I don't see the issue with companies reducing vacancies and providing more housing to more people.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoI cannot say, but experts can, and suggest to legislators and regulators implementation details. To operate a business in a jurisdiction is a privilege, not an entitlement.
- itake 2y agoI'd love to see the data on this. Usually when you increase construction costs, via additional regulation, you're going to increase the price of rent/sale. What expert thinks increasing costs will lower prices?
- toomuchtodo 2y agoIt's the other way around. Regulation around pricing forces housing providers to provide housing within a constrained cost model (land + materials + labor + cost of capital + permitting/AHJ requirements [regulation]). If they cannot meet the market (or choose not to, for whatever reason), public housing is an option, with muni bonds issued to finance construction. This removes the profit component, which a for profit enterprise needs, but public housing does not.
- itake 2y agowhere does the public housing come from? WA and CA can't seem to figure out how to build public housing. In WA, the best I've seen is the gov buying hotels and having the hotel sit empty for years [0]. If regulations make it impossible to build housing and public housing has the same regulations, who is paying that bill? The existing residents via sales and property taxes? you can google construction costs in sf. how does regulations reduce any of those numbers? [0] - https://www.kiro7.com/news/local/king-county-taxpayers-paying-roughly-330k-month-empty-hotel-renton/ZKZ7IE4QANDW3M2XUFJB55YBYU/ https://www.kiro7.com/news/local/king-county-taxpayers-payin...
- Manuel_D 2y agoWashington has at least done a better job than San Francisco. Seattle has built over twice (IIRC three) times as many homes per-capita than SF over the last decade, despite lower population. The fact that rent control is banned statewide has a big role to play there.
- robertlagrant 2y agoIt's not "despite" lower population. The thing that drives the costs up isn't evil landlords or the dreaded "profit motive". It's just demand massively outstripping supply, and high wages.
- tossandthrow 2y agoThe natural interest rate plus a bit. If you can earn 25% percent in profits in the current environment then it is a clear indication of an inefficient market - a market that needs to be regulated in order to create efficiency (like in this case as with many other cases: remove monopolistic behavior). While it is problematic if you can't derive profits from productive activities it is also problematic when entities derive unsustainable profits - also for the party deriving the profits. If there is not a bit middle class to consume products, then there will not be be a market to supply products to.
- schrectacular 2y agoTargeting profit rarely helps. The big players can afford the financial engineers to make the profits negligible from an accounting perspective. Likely funneled into growth. The small players cannot, so you put them in a situation where selling to a big player is rational. And the oligopoly grows.
- tossandthrow 2y agoThe current economic environment definitely over indexes on very abstract metrics to steer, which is problematic. I am also not proposing any formal system. I am saying that it is quite easy to spot profits that are too high. I am also saying that the governments role is to ensure efficient markets. In this case it is suing RealPage. It could also be making it easier to make housing in a specific area to counter under supply. it is all regulation.
- Manuel_D 2y agoThe phrase "protect renters" is often used as a dogwhistle for price controls. For example, rent control and affordable housing mandates that require a certain % of units to be rented at below market rates. Can you elaborate on what exactly you're referring to here?
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThis would be an unproductive use of time. It is very clear you are pro "no regulation" around housing (based on your thread comments, "just build more"), so a heated argument with the potential for the subthread to be detached by dang does none of us any good. I'm not here to change your belief system, and to attempt to do so would provide no meaningful impact to macro outcomes.
- Manuel_D 2y agoAll I'm asking you to do is list the specific laws or regulation you're referring to here when you write about the need to "protect renters". I don't know if we agree or disagree, because you haven't actually stated what your beliefs are. I definitely support regulations around housing: housind needs to be safe (fire exits, sprinklers, etc.). Landlords can't engage in deceptive practices, like putting up ads for one unit and giving the tenant a different one. Units should be promptly repaired. Landlords shouldn't discriminate on the basis of protected class. I could go on.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoDynamic price control of rents to prevent them from accelerating beyond what wages can support (existing tenants win vs potential new market entrants, them the breaks when supply is catching up to demand or cannot meet demand), tenant rights with strong local regulatory oversight, government incentives to encourage a diverse ecosystem of suppliers bringing new supply onto the market based on forecasted market demand (cost of capital, regulatory streamlining support, construction labor pipeline, etc), upzoning whenever possible to encourage density as much as reasonable. Supplier diversity is needed to prevent use of market power to restrict new supply coming online to hold rents higher than they otherwise would be (strong evidence homebuilders are doing this current state, restricting supply to juice profitability). The rest should be self explanatory. As you said, there is no silver bullet; it is various policy measures working in concert to attempt to arrive at a desired outcome. I am not anti profits, I am anti "gouge the human for basic needs for profits." TLDR Some profits? Okay. Too much profit? Not okay. People living in constant fear of not having a home? Not okay. Build, build, build. (am a landlord myself, do not raise rents unless actual costs go up, reduce rents when needed by tenants, keep my profits reasonable [~%6-%10], usually no more than $100/month/door)
- ZoomerCretin 2y ago[flagged]
- toomuchtodo 2y agoI support price regulation when called for. Your hyperbole is...not congruent with reality, considering the incredible agriculture subsidies provided and automobile tariffs. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/08/economists-kamala-harris-price-gouging/679547/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/08/economists... https://www.ncsl.org/financial-services/price-gouging-state-statutes https://www.ncsl.org/financial-services/price-gouging-state-... https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2024/08/15/fact-sheet-biden-harris-administration-announces-new-lower-prices-for-first-ten-drugs-selected-for-medicare-price-negotiation-to-lower-costs-for-millions-of-americans/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases... From a paid Matt Stoller BIG (https://thebignewsletter.com/ https://thebignewsletter.com/) piece on monopoly pricing: > Something real is going on. In individual markets, CEOs have been bragging publicly that they are restraining production to increase prices. Profit margins in the food industry jumped during Covid and haven’t come back down. Or take rent. There’s a company called RealPage that works with the biggest corporate landlords to hold apartments empty so they can increase prices, which jumped up 11% in 2022. There’s some evidence of conspiracy around pricing in virtually every industry. Turkey, poultry, and pork. Frozen french fries. PVC pipe. Anesthesiology. Oil. Ammunition. Pharmaceuticals. K-Pop. Credit bureaus and FICO, Verisign, industrial gasses, architectural software, locks, entertainment data. Homebuilders. Garden chemicals. Defense and aerospace. Ticketing. Estate Sales. Gaming. Drug wholesaling. Work ID information. Seeds and chemicals. Laws to crack down on this behavior has popular support, so I won't spend additional time defending the idea in this forum, as it is unnecessary. https://blueprint2024.com/polling/inflation-poll-06-25/ https://blueprint2024.com/polling/inflation-poll-06-25/ https://blueprint2024.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Screenshot-2024-06-24-at-1.02.41-PM-884x1024.png https://blueprint2024.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Screens... > The most popular policies are calling on all states to suspend taxes on groceries (68% selected), cracking down on overcharging by hospitals (66%), starting a congressional committee to hold hearings on and investigate price gouging and overcharging by corporations (63%), requiring public utilities to cut rates for electricity (63%), reducing the deficit by cutting spending (62%), and prosecuting price gougers (61%).
- SmartJerry 2y agoExcessive profits are actually the catalyst for competition. THe cycle of capitalism and free markets looks like this: earn excess profits -> people build more supply -> prices come down and excess profits dry up -> people stop building -> earn excess profits. When you fix the 'prices come down and excess profits dry up' all you get is people stop building.
- medvezhenok 2y agoThat works in a well functioning, liquid market. If there are barriers to entry for new competitors (like regulatory hurdles, or zoning), this free-market theory falls flat on its face.
- nilsbunger 2y agoThe free market theory still works with the barriers, it’s just that the “excess profits” have to get even higher before someone steps in to build.