8 ms·
Peloton to charge $95 activation fee for used bikes
- ziofill 2y agoshameless
- CoastalCoder 2y agoIt's a for-profit corporation, I'm not sure shame is useful concept when reasoning about its behavior. It also reminds me of the fable about the frog and the scorpion.
- philipov 2y agoI wasn't familiar with the fable so I looked it up. It seems entirely appropriate that it emerged in Russia in the early 20th century. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Scorpion_and_the_Frog https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Scorpion_and_the_Frog
- rchaud 2y agoIn that case, maybe we need a new word to describe businesses that are entirely VC-subsidized , then IPO with their books deep in the red and then start enacting anti-consumer policies because they're "for-profit".
- api 2y agoIf it's cloud connected, it's going to do this.
- throwaway48476 2y agoUnfree software that you do not have source for serves its owners not you.
- gjsman-1000 2y agoThere are plenty of other ways a company could extract this fee. For example, no spare parts, or ability to subscribe, or customer service, if you don’t pay. The software is only an implementation detail that even free software couldn’t stop.
- cyberpunk 2y ago... Isn't capitalism great? I remember a thread on here a while back where some folks were sharing their peloton-alike setups and sadly I've lost the bookmark for it. Isn't it possible to hook a road bike up to some kind of 'bike treadmill' or such and go on virtual rides (maybe with an iPad or a tv or something infront of it?). With the kinds of money Peloton are charging, it did seem like a much better deal, and you get a road bike included...
- nsxwolf 2y agoA Peloton is just an old-fashioned stationary bike with a SaaS. You can still buy plain old stationary bikes (aka "Spinning Bikes"), no need to rig up a real bike.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 2y agoI believe it is even possible to use a different stationary bike hardware and connect it to the Peloton subscription if you enjoy the service.
- CivBase 2y ago> Isn't capitalism great? Does "capitalism" now just mean that businesses can do whatever they want? Consumer rights are awful in the United States, but that isn't because our economy is capitalistic. It's because our government is inept.
- manuelmoreale 2y agoI think by “capitalism” they mean this pervasive attitude of trying to extract money to customer in every way possible.
- tgv 2y agoAs long as the government allows it, greed will make corporations try to grab more and more, especially since the finance/MBA types have taken over. It's not strange to call that capitalism, since it is in its very nature.
- tommica 2y agoWow, did not see any reason in the article to justify it, except making more money... Quite brazen to scalp like that
- bagels 2y agoOr... lose less money. It's not like they're reaping any profit. They're trying to prevent the company from failing.
- bdcravens 2y agoPeloton is both a product manufacturer and a service provider; setup fees are common with many service providers. For example, if you bring a phone you bought elsewhere to your carrier, they'll charge a fee to activate it for their network.
- daemonologist 2y agoI've never been charged a fee to activate a device on a new carrier, probably because they'd much rather have the money from my monthly subscription - in fact I've seen offers from carriers to buy out your current contract if you switch to them.
- Almondsetat 2y agoIf you want to reply to this comment you are going to have to pay me a fee.
- jlund-molfese 2y agoI don't think it's that common with companies that are both manufacturers and service providers. That'd be like Apple charging you $75 if you wanted to use iCloud+. It makes used products less valuable, which ultimately hurts your brand image in the long-term, even if you might be able to boost services revenue for the next quarter or two.
- drdaeman 2y ago
- RIMR 2y ago>The Bike and Tread maker said the secondary market is an “important source” of new members. So why are you creating a $95 barrier-to-entry for those new paying members? Are you really so strapped for cash that you want to drive potential customers to your competitors, or entirely away from your online subscription? If people are selling their Pelotons, and the buyer is buying a subscription, Peloton should be grateful, not punishing their customers with arbitrary onboarding fees.
- tiahura 2y agoProbably because the numbers show so few people reup that getting $95 upfront is Peloton’s optimal strategy.
- mannykannot 2y agoPeloton has just started an economics experiment which will give further insight into how valuable its services are regarded by the marketplace.
- dylan604 2y agoWhat kind of golden parachute is attached to that lead balloon?
- dr-detroit 2y ago[dead]
- mjhay 2y agoI guess there's more social aspects with Peloton that people are into, but it's also easy to hook up a road bike to a fluid trainer and call it a day. Cheaper to get started (even including buying the bike), and no subscription.
- hathym 2y agoif only they can put a tax on the air we breath
- dylan604 2y agonah, they'll start with each email you send. only, they'll call it postage to avoid getting tagged with raising taxes
- flightster 2y agoI would happily pay one cent per email if it meant everyone else had to as well...including advertisers Think of how much better the signal-to-noise ratio of email would become.
- deno 2y agoIf that 1¢ gets you straight to Inbox then the signal-to-noise would take a very bad nosedive. If not, then it will change nothing anyway. Phone calls cost money and there are still plenty of SPAM calls.
- ApolloFortyNine 2y agoThey are losing money still so desparate moves like this I guess make sense, but adding friction to the new subscriber workflow just seems wild. There's a reason why just about every subscription out there offers free trials/discounted first months. It's to get you in the door. It's not even as if the bike is disabled when bought used, you can just use it like any other spin bike happily. This ONLY effects people who are trying to sign up for a subscription.
- afavour 2y ago> It's not even as if the bike is disabled when bought used, you can just use it like any other spin bike happily. While that’s true, a Peloton attracts a premium price above regular spin bikes. So if you had no intention of using the software you’d just buy a cheaper bike. If you do intend to use it you now have to add $95 to whatever price you’re paying.
- DaveExeter 2y ago...or, the seller has to subtract $95 from the asking price. This makes every used Peloton worth $95 less.
- lesuorac 2y agoDo they command a premium when used? I have one that I got for free, YMMV.
- laweijfmvo 2y agoYep. They seem to be going for very low cost around here...
- notarobot123 2y ago> YMMV I thought they were stationary.
- dessimus 2y ago
- farceSpherule 2y agoThey have a sh*t, subscription based business model. It did well during COVID and is floundering.
- matwood 2y agoThey have/had a pretty good business model and then completely mismanaged COVID. Now they're saddled with tons of debt from thinking the COVID trajectory was forever, and it's crushing them. https://www.cnbc.com/2024/07/02/peloton-staves-off-liquidity-crunch-in-global-refinance.html https://www.cnbc.com/2024/07/02/peloton-staves-off-liquidity...
- xnx 2y agoThe difference between Juicero and Peloton is a difference of degree, not kind.
- geodel 2y agoYeah, they both are extracting juice from vegetables by rpms.
- dr_kiszonka 2y agoThe FTC's Lina Khan said mistreatment of customers signals that a company has monopoly power. Maybe Peloton is heading that way?
- shagie 2y agoWeight gain is a sign of pregnancy. I've gained weight... A̶m̶ I̶ P̶r̶e̶g̶n̶a̶n̶t̶?̶ Am I pregnant? It's highly doubtful - I've got the wrong plumbing. There can be lots of reasons that a company mistreats their customers. I would be very hesitant to say that every instance of mistreatment of customers is an indication of monopoly status... and while they are (were?) the most popular ... https://www.traqline.com/newsroom/blog/us-fitness-equipment-market-brand-retailer-market-share-online-sales-trends-other-market-insights-infographic/ https://www.traqline.com/newsroom/blog/us-fitness-equipment-... > As of September 2023, the most popular Fitness Equipment manufacturer continued to be Peloton, in both unit (11%) and dollar (25%) share. > However, as seen with outlet share, Peloton saw decreases in brand share. In dollars sold, Peloton saw the largest decrease in share across all Fitness Equipment brands, with a loss of 4 points YOY; in dollar share, Peloton lost 1 point. That does not look like a monopoly. Rather this looks more like desperation from a company on its way down trying to milk any revenue out of its customer base.
- anticorporate 2y agoTo be clear, it's a signal of monopoly. Not every signal is meant to be used in isolation. Weight gain in association with other changes is still a signal for pregnancy, just as mistreatment of customers in association with other characteristics of monopolization is a signal of monopoly status.
- shagie 2y agoI take issue with people making suggestions that some company is a monopoly each time a company is found to be mistreating its customers. If one wants to claim that some company of a monopoly - they should back it up with more than one signal... such as a dominant position in the market, no substitutes for the products, or lack of concern about other companies entering the market (such as NordicTrack).
- smittywerben 2y agoAlright, go out to the back near the dumpster. Ask for Tony. Tell him you need a Peloton. If he asks "Which model?", say "Preactivated". You didn't hear this from me.
- RobinL 2y agoThe effect of this should be to reduce the price of used peletons by around $95 - i.e. effectively seller pays. I imagine that's the thinking behind this (ie it only affects the customer who's leaving the service), but it probably leaves a bad taste in the mouth of the buyer anyway, which doesn't feel like great business
- awkward 2y agoOnly if the information clears the market. If sellers don't get exposed to this, they don't know to lower the price, if buyers aren't exposed they'll think they got ripped off and resell or become predisposed to churn.
- lelandfe 2y agoProbably a worthwhile addendum that they had a "restructuring" in May, laying off 15% of their staff, ~400 people, and their CEO stepped down. They've yet to find a replacement CEO, still running under interim leadership.
- eej71 2y agoPerhaps when the current Sonos CEO is freed up, which might be quite soon, he can take on this one.
- xeromal 2y agoThe starbucks CEO just freed up.
- apercu 2y agoYup, let's recycle CEO's because they worked at a place that people have heard of before. It'll bump the stock price for next quarter. lol. (You're not wrong)
- playingalong 2y agoYeah, let's recycle. But let them pay a re-initialization fee.
- HeyLaughingBoy 2y agoAny CEO worth his salt will renegotiate that to let the shareholders pay the fee.
- KennyBlanken 2y agoNo he didn't...he just negotiated another huge increase in pay and weekly use of a corporate jet for a 1000 mile commute back and forth from SoCal to Seattle. Funny thing is, he just left Chipolte - where he got them to move their HQ from Denver to where he lives in SoCal.
- tristor 2y agoSetting aside the larger issues with Peloton's business, this particular move is something that comes due to poor product management. Having strong product sense is exactly about knowing what psychological effects product changes will have on your customers and target prospects. This type of change stinks of spreadsheet product management where rather than applying product sense, they just took the current rate of sign-ups with equipment where the serial number had been previously registered and then figured out a price they could charge that would juice their numbers on the assumption that the rate of sign-ups would stay the same, without acknowledging that doing so will have a detractive effect on the rate of sign-ups. This is the type of things companies do when they look at their business only by the numbers without any understanding of their product or their customers. Unfortunately this is happening more and more across all industries as financial engineering takes precedence over product development.
- flightster 2y agoBought a Peloton used on FB marketplace. I only use the "just ride" functionality and train with a separate heart rate monitor. Looks like I can't connect it to the internet or else they'll even take that away. Might need to just rip out the wifi chip.
- tombert 2y agoI have the Bowflex equivalent to the Peloton, and they charge $120/year for the classes. I did it for one year, and realized I almost never actually did the classes, just the free built-in training sessions. I didn't renew the next year for that reason.
- ein0p 2y agoBeatings will continue until people find the very idea of subscriptions repulsive.
- karmakaze 2y agoIs the Peloton service any good (still)? Are competitors that far off? Seems like they're leaving room to be overtaken
- lvl155 2y agoPeloton had a golden opportunity to change consumer behavior during the pandemic. They should’ve just given away their bikes.
- boplicity 2y agoThey didn't have enough bikes. That's why they got in trouble: they made huge investments in bike manufacturing, which turned out to be far more than the demand they ended up with.
- maxglute 2y agoI'm still hoping for a gamified exercise bike where you can weave through traffic and the hardware physically tilts. When is biking sim going to approach racing / flying sim.
- HeyLaughingBoy 2y agoI used to be in the industry and I think there's at least one Wahoo bike that does this. And it's controllable remotely. [edit] I might be thinking of the variable resistance: that's controlled over wireless.
- maxglute 2y agoYeah that's the brand I was thinking, they had one where bikes tilt up/down to simulate hills. I'm hoping for one that also tilts side to side. Their software/game also looks kind of meh. But I don't really need exercise bike to "simulate" biking, throw it in MS flight simmulator and do multi axis ET bicycle flights, or at least some sort of twisted metal.
- fullshark 2y agoCrap like this is why the subscription model has so much appeal to the finance world, just endless consumer surplus you can try to siphon off of to create more cash flow.
- jerlam 2y agoPeloton is just bringing all the things people both love and hate about going to the gym to your home. This is just a copy of the gym's initiation fee. Next up: fixed-term contracts, impossible-to-cancel membership fees, and variable pricing via salesmen.
- m4tthumphrey 2y agoDoes variable pricing happen outside of B2B?
- drivingmenuts 2y agoI'm holding out for rubbing shoulders with the really fit people who silently remind me that their body is a temple and mine is a dumpster.
- daft_pink 2y agoThey really need to make an eliptical. They own Precor. Shouldn’t be hard. Just sayin'
- somethoughts 2y agoJust out of curiosity, is it easy to jailbreak a Peloton bike? Or are there any interesting open source stationary bike platforms?
- m4tthumphrey 2y agoYou can use the bike as is - ie without a sub. The sub is for the classes.
- MrMetlHed 2y agoBut isn't the screen totally useless without a sub? I don't know enough about Peloton, but I thought you couldn't really do much with it other than ride the thing without subscribing. I guess a jailbreak for the screen (is it Android?) could be pretty useful if you want to put an entirely different UI on the thing and use it with alternatives.
- pugets 2y agoIf I did a push-up for every product that has “revolutionized” the fitness world in the last several decades, you would see my body and probably assume that I had used those products. If you have a floor, a wall, and autonomy over what enters into your mouth, then you already have everything you need to gain muscle and lose fat. Nobody needs a $1400 bike with a $40 monthly subscription to maintain a calorie deficit. It’s absurd. Peloton preys on their customers’ fear of sunk-cost by selling common exercise equipment at exorbitant prices. They want you to fear that if you don’t use the equipment, then you’re wasting your money.
- elzbardico 2y ago> autonomy over what enters into your mouth This is incredibly underrated. Basically I lost weigth by focusing on this first. then exercising became easier. YMMV, but one thing that helped me control food intake was meditation, for a lot of us, over-eating is a response to anxiety.
- pugets 2y agoThat’s also how I lost most of my weight. Sure, you could spend 25-45 minutes on the treadmill… or you could just not eat 5 Oreo cookies, and you would achieve the same result (from a caloric perspective). My best tip for not eating junk food: Don’t buy it. It’s so much easier to eat chicken and rice when you don’t have a bag of Doritos on standby.
- neuralRiot 2y agoI think the most important role of excercise on the weigh loss journey is the sense of accomplishment and effort. Whenever you’re tempted to eat some junk you’ll remember the body pains, the sweat you dropped and think: is it really worth to eat that?
- nojvek 2y ago> for a lot of us, over-eating is a response to anxiety 100%. We use food as entertainment. To get a dopamine hit from fats and carbs. For most of human history, food was scarce. We evolved to get huge dopamine hits from food. Our brain sees starving as a danger. It's only post WWII that food became abundant. Now those signals work against us.
- mikeocool 2y agoPeloton's interesting -- for the audience they target they have a pretty good product (if you're setting up your road bike on your stationary trainer and signing into Zwift, you're not their audience), they have a committed and paying user base, and their instructors turned into legit celebrities. But the market decided they were going to be the next Apple, and they had a CEO stoking those flames (and killing a few kids along the way). Turns out that 2020 was not a great year to be forecasting who was going to be the next Apple (who would have guessed), and now they're paying the price. If the market had accepted that Peloton was actually just a good fitness company they probably would have had the opportunity to be a decent company, just not the next Apple. Maybe not every company should try to pursue infinite growth.
- drivingmenuts 2y agoThey could still become the next Apple, but they have to enter a period where everyone just assumes they'll go bankrupt (because they are teetering on that edge), then hire back an old CEO who nurtures some good ideas (and does a better job of minimizing the faults and selling the strengths than Melon Husk) and magically turns them into a company whose profits are measured alongside major economies.
- MattSteelblade 2y agoI am curious about the legality of this. This directly diminishes the value of Peloton bikes for sellers. Imagine if the fee was so high that it was greater than the value of the bike; the used market would obviously be affected. If there was no subscription, but a purchased license, I would understand that argument, but a fee on top of a monthly subscription? My question is, preferably to a contract lawyer, would Peloton owners have a case to make that Peloton has diminished the value of their property by $95? Is that even a thing? If there was a competitive marketplace, for example, an alternate service for you to hook your bike up to, it would be an argument against this; but as far as I am aware, a Peloton bike can only be used with Peloton's services.
- coin 2y agoWhy do posters edit the title? Title and article clearly refers to equipment, not just bikes.
- tombert 2y agoMan, I didn't realize how desperate they must have been. I interviewed with them once in 2020, didn't get an offer, and I was a bit disappointed. It sounds like I dodged a bullet with them; if nothing else I'd probably be fired for calling their leadership fucking morons.
- KilgoreBass 2y agoIs this even legal? I feel like regulators might want to get involved
- KilgoreBass 2y agoI wonder if regulators are going to have something to say about this
- mensetmanusman 2y agoGood. How else will the executives get paid?
- nunez 2y ago1. Part of the $44/mo Peloton subscription is subsidized by the $2500 bikes. Given that they fucked up by scaling production to a vastly overestimated demand forecast AND that increasing the subscription price for all members will lead to future problems also, it makes total sense for Peloton to reclaim some of the value this way. 2. As others noted here, Peloton bikes sell for well under MSRP in the secondary market. A $1000 used Bike+ (or Bike with the swivel attachment) and a $95 one time activation fee is much cheaper than spending $2500 new before taxes and delivery fees. 3. I did road cycling for a long time. I still do, but much less frequently than I did in the past. Raced for a little. (I was terrible, but also not very committed.) Peloton is amazing. The instructors are top-notch. Way better than your local cycle instructor, on average. The programming is vast and really well done. There's something for everyone. The community is quite social, if you're into that (I am not). The bike itself is really well made as well. Nothing cheap about it. I'm especially fond of the auto-resistance feature because it gives me a good ballpark as to how hard I should be working to get the most out of whatever class I'm taking. (The resistance on the bike is extremely well calibrated and calibrates on boot, I believe. This is a huge problem at cycling studios, since you're usually using beat-up bikes that haven't been calibrated in a while.) You can absolutely get some other spin bike, strap a tablet onto it and use Peloton that way, but I think you'd be missing out on a lot. You could also fix your road bike to a trainer and use something like Zwift, Strava or Wahoo but that's an entirely different thing.
- 39896880 2y agoThough not included in the current FTC definition of junk fees, it should be