18 ms·
A road safety plan that will lead to cars communicating with each other
- tocs3 2y agoI like the modern world and its safety features. Things (cars, planes, food, etc.) are generally safer but I just do not really trust any of the people that would be writing these rules. I fear the regulatory capture aspect of it and what it might mean to me trying to get to the grocery store. I only drive a three or four times a week (most of that is short duration rural driving). It is not that I think some one will take my car from me so much as the industry may just work to make everything not new obsolete. A new $30K car (or even $8$15K used) is a steep price for an individual to pay to meet regulations.
- CuriousCosmic 2y agoIt's worth noting that this is 100% about providing more information to vehicles rather than requiring vehicles to use the feature. Think of it in the same category as driver assistance technologies (like radar cruise control, forward collision warning, lane assist, rear cross warnings, rear cameras, or blind spot warnings/cameras). It'll almost certainly never be mandatory to be road legal but it'll probably be a standard feature on most new vehicles.
- ItsBob 2y ago> It's worth noting that this is 100% about providing more information to vehicles rather than requiring vehicles to use the feature. I'm calling it here and now: this absolutely will become mandatory in the nearish future. 100%. Same as in Europe with the speed regulator thingy in the cars... advisory at first now mandatory in many places.
- madrox 2y ago* For some definition of near and mandatory Even when they started mandating airbags in new vehicles, it took something like seven years to go into effect so car manufacturers had time to plan. And then they didn’t make cars that didn’t have airbags illegal. Even the most universally embraced ideas take time to roll out.
- ItsBob 2y agoI agree: it won't happen overnight. It will happen within a handful of years though. Too much potential for control to let it pass...
- pixxel 2y agoAirbags aren’t a useful tool for data/control.
- micahdeath 2y agoWe have to get the `internet` or some other network rolled out first.
- whartung 2y agoRear cameras are required now, or will be in a few years. Dunno if this is a California thing or national, but just like the third brake light, this is already happening. California is also working on legislation to require cars to be aware of where they are so they can notify the driver if they’re speeding.
- ryandrake 2y ago> It'll almost certainly never be mandatory to be road legal but it'll probably be a standard feature on most new vehicles. I think many of us said the same thing about backup cameras, but since 2018 you can't buy a car in the USA without one. So you have to get a screen in your car whether you want it or not.
- spencerflem 2y agoI think they meant legal to drive, not just required for new cars
- trte9343r4 2y agoWe already have safety rules, but those are ignored! If you cycle into grocery store, you may get chased and attacked by dangerous dogs. Many people gave up cycling and jogging for that! And in grocery store more dogs and excrements! There are rules against all of that, yet it is widely ignored. Lidars will get vandalized pretty fast, because they will impede flow of traffic. Or thugs will use it to stop passing vehicles to make kidnapping easy!
- ClumsyPilot 2y ago> thugs will use it to stop passing vehicles to make kidnapping easy! We already have this thing, it’s called a red light. Is there a name for this, when people come up with a plausible sounding scenario for crime driven disaster, but it does not actually have basis in real world? The ‘razor blades in candy’ scares parents every Halloween but is completely made up and has never been reported. Peter Thiel had a similar moment on Joe Rogan podcast where he explained his elaborate social theory based on how chimps behave, but got the basics of chimp behaviour totally wrong TL DR: tech people suck at predicting human behaviour
- spacebanana7 2y agoPeople do get kidnapped at traffic lights. Here's an incident of it happening in Florida a few months ago. The ability to arbitrarily stop vehicles would be very useful for this kind of crime because it could be done in less crowded areas. And criminals could more readily select for expensive vehicles, young women or whatever else they're wanting. [1] https://www.crimeonline.com/2024/04/12/video-florida-woman-appears-to-be-carjacked-kidnapped-at-traffic-light https://www.crimeonline.com/2024/04/12/video-florida-woman-a... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=usuo0jOcHJA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=usuo0jOcHJA
- ClumsyPilot 2y agoBut the comparison we are making is different - do people create a fake traffic light, because that is really easy; and I have never heard of it happening. Ofcourse there are places where vehicles have to stop naturally, you can’t avoid that.
- panick21_ 2y ago[flagged]
- CuriousCosmic 2y agoAre you familiar with V2X? The concept is actually specifically to help pedestrians and bicyclists. It's essentially just a LTE or WLAN link (which most modern cars already have and that costs less than 100usd) that would allow intersection cameras, etc to report useful information back to vehicles. i.e. the city can have infrastructure watch for pedestrians on crossings (or even just know the crossings are active or the light is red) and report it to vehicles approaching. This makes assisted driving tech safer for everyone involved. It also generally just adds a lot of opportunities for QOL improvements. An example is parking. The city infra can tell the vehicle (or your phone) where the closest open parking space is relative to your destination and handle scheduling spaces so that you get the space the first time around. And importantly the cities that have been pioneering this tech have been pushing it while also pushing separated bike lanes, improved transit, more distinct street vs road distinctions, etc. This tech is something that has been in development since the 90s and it's now reaching maturity to the point where modern cars could adopt it today, older semi-modern cars could be trivially upgraded, and it can see widespread use in 10-20 years. Also it's not the first line of defense for pedestrians but rather one of many that can be rolled out now while also pushing other material benefits.
- panick21_ 2y agoThere is a gigantic difference between 'this technology has some useful applications' and 'this is fundamental to improving road safety'. And there is even a more gigantic difference between cost and useful how useful it is. Again, we know how to make gigantic gains in road safety. Its not difficult, its proven technology, its cheap, it can literally be done quickly. The only question is will of politicans. That's it. First of all, its already incredibly absurldy expensive how the US currently does traffic. There are far, far to many traffic lights and traffic lights are expensive. Far to many lanes and far to wide, incredibly expensive. That again makes traffic signaling more expensive. Now in addition to traffic lights you need cameras everywhere, often covering 8 lane stroads, and then you need comptuers to process all that data. And do so correctly under difficult conditions. Installations of these system will be hugely expensive. You can already compare your avg traffic intersection between the Netherlands and the US. The US often only has 1 sensor while the Dutch have many more. US intersections still operate based on completely outdated signaling orders for the most part (not to mention completly unsave and unfriendly for anything but cars). So when in the US most towns can't even configure their basic signaling orders in an efficent way, but you want them to do complex video image analysis and messaging? How does that make sense? Again, we know how to make things cheaper and much, much safer. And it doesn't need fancy technology. We don't need people with PhD in data science to implement this. If you want to make an argument that some of this has some uses, sure, whatever. I honestly don't think anything you mentioned is really all that complelling but I guess its possible. > The city infra can tell the vehicle (or your phone) where the closest open parking space is This is great, if your goal as a city is maximum utilisation of parking space, but that shouldn't be the goal in the first place. If cities actually listen to experts on how to actually manage parking correctly, finding a parking spot wouldn't be hard in the first place. > And importantly the cities that have been pioneering this tech have been pushing it while also pushing separated bike lanes, improved transit, more distinct street vs road distinctions, etc. That just means that the lobbies pushing this stuff have successfully done their job despite far more important things. No city in the US has even begun to fully implement modern traffic practices. Playing around with this V2X thing and investing money into it is foolish. In the actual countries where they take safety seriously, you know where they actually successfully have reduced traffic accidents and death. In those countries you hear very little about V2X and the almost universal thing you hear from all the actually successful experts is that road infrastructure needs to be changed according to the newer standards. Most nations did gignatic damage to themselves in last 50 years and all of it needs to be undone. I'm sure those governments have V2X somewhere, but its simply not what most actual traffic engineers in those countries talk about. This V2X stuff is something car companies and lobbiest are primarly pushing. Its mostly popular with tech people. Most actually existing organisation for traffic safity are pushing what we know actually works. > It's essentially just a LTE or WLAN link Most vehicles can barley even software updates at all. And most old cars simply wont be updated with everything need to fully support this stuff. And even then most people on motorcycles and bikes don't have a great way of receiving that information. And there tons of old cars who want have it, so you can not realy on this for the next decades anyway. > This tech is something that has been in development since the 90s And designing streets without killing unbelievable amounts of people has been in development much longer and yet still traffic accidents are going up in the US not down. So maybe focus on that instead of fancy tech from the 90s. > Also it's not the first line of defense for pedestrians but rather one of many that can be rolled out now while also pushing other material benefits. The problem is that once this tech is there drives will relay on it. The idea that in order to be safe to cross, a whole complex change of senors, network tech and so on has to work is crazy. And talking about defense in depth is all fine and good, but if the actual first 4 lines of defense don't work, you are never gone stop anything. Literally every $ spent on this by the government or cities is 1$ less for infrastructure that is proven to save lives. I think people really don't understand the amount of destruction these issues are causing. The insane amount of people (and children) killed is one thing. But beyond that the cost of the current transportation patterns are actually insane. The amount of cost in terms of police, firefighters, the cost for delays and infrastructure damage. Not to mention the hilarious amount of cars that smash into people houses. The overhead of insurance. People times dealing with all that stuff. How much of this can V2X fix? Almost nothing is the answer. Its actually comical how bad it is. And even worse that this is done by doing road infrastructure the most expensive possible way. So its both expensive and does a bad job, its actually crazy. But sure lets invest in V2X when most towns can't even maintain the road in proper state or paint cross walks correctly. Great plan.
- handsclean 2y agoSoon: “Your honor, it may be true that my client’s driving speed in combination with the thick fog prevented him from reacting to obstacles, and that his car then struck and violently killed this man while he used the crosswalk. However, it was not the fog or my client’s speed that caused standard crash avoidance safety mechanisms to fail, but the crash-ee’s negligent decision to go outside without a phone with a functioning and active location beacon.”
- CuriousCosmic 2y agoThe crosswalk pedestrian detection is using LIDAR fwiw. Provided the vehicle was equipped with V2X and the crosswalk had pedestrian detection it'd go something like this: 1. The crosswalk announces itself to the vehicle via a P2P 3G, LTE, or 5G connection. 2. The vehicle notifies the driver or the adaptive cruise control (if enabled) slows down while approaching the crosswalk. 3. The post with the crosswalk button on it has a LIDAR sensor that looks down the length of the crosswalk (and presumably another one facing from the opposite direction) and a relatively low power DSP digests the LIDAR input looking for approximately not-car shaped forms on the crosswalk. 4. The crosswalk announces a pedestrian on the crosswalk to the vehicles if a pedestrian presses the button on the crosswalk post or if a pedestrian form is detected on the crosswalk. 5. The vehicle alerts the driver or the adaptive cruise control comes to a complete stop, prompting the driver to resume when the route is clear (or when it no longer reports pedestrians using the crosswalk. 6. When the crosswalk timer is complete and no pedestrian forms are visible on LIDAR, the crosswalk announces an empty crosswalk to the vehicles. So the "they didn't have their phone on them" defense wouldn't even begin to come into consideration.
- 1659447091 2y ago"Your Honor, the towns bored teens or some other joker tampered with the senors/devices and my client/'s car never got the message."
- CuriousCosmic 2y agoYou are still at fault for hitting a pedestrian who isn't even using a crosswalk but is just walking across the road so that argument still doesn't work. At best if they can prove that was the case, it opens the city up to liability for failing to maintain infrastructure or allow the infrastructure to gracefully degrade/fail. Also a similar system to this already exists outside the US (ex: Pedestrian Crossing or Kerb detectors [1] at Puffin crossings in the UK) to extend the crosswalk time if pedestrians are still using the crosswalk. 1. https://www.agd-systems.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/326_-Datasheet_ISS4.pdf https://www.agd-systems.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/326_-...
- david-gpu 2y agoI wish that the safety of the people outside of motor vehicles received at least as many resources (funding, research, legal) as the safety of motorists -- who are cause of these risks in the first place. Motorists already have strong incentives to make their vehicles safer for themselves, but they have very little incentive to make things safer for people outside of their vehicle. For that reason we need better regulations and infrastructure that account for those externalities.
- tocs3 2y agoAnd everything is so partisan. It does not seem to matter what is up for discussion. If party A is for it then party B is against (or vise versa). I like the notion that cars could have extra safety features but as is noted in other posts there are low hanging, lower cost, existing solutions that are not being implemented. By all means lets look into some of the tech solutions. But politicians (policy makers and pundits) are not the ones to listen to.
- cogman10 2y agoThe solution is one that is unpopular to a good number of consumers, it's to make cars smaller, lighter, and slower. While I'm sure it's happened, death via golfcart is a pretty rare occurrence. Death via a Dodge ram, on the other hand, happens all the time. [1] Giant trucks are super popular and super deadly. I was nearly killed by one myself (driver ran a red light while I was in the cross walk). While I wouldn't outright ban them, I definitely would be up to something like requiring a CDL before you can buy one. [1] https://www.autoblog.com/article/most-deadly-cars-other-drivers-crashes/?guccounter=1 https://www.autoblog.com/article/most-deadly-cars-other-driv...
- beardyw 2y agoBut you can still drive a Cyber Truck.
- panick21_ 2y agoI'm not pro Cybertruck. But people collectively losing their mind over it is ridiclous. Other trucks are more common and more unsafe. I have heard 100x more people making Cybertruck jokes but almost never about actually improving safety in any signifcant way. Farming browny points by with low-hanging anti-Musk stuff seems to be more important then anything else for most people. There is a whole cottage industry of anti-Cybertruck stuff all over the internet, if all those people put their energy into actually explain how to actually improve safty, we would be much better off.
- Terr_ 2y ago> I have heard 100x more people making Cybertruck jokes but almost never about actually improving safety in any signifcant way. That's a weird kind of blame shifting. 1. Many things that ought to change have already been laid out well in advance. Things like defined limits on how "sharp" the outsides can be or having a crumple-zone front instead of a pedestrian meat-tenderizer. This is especially true in jurisdiction where those recommendations are requirements, and the vehicle cannot be legally sold. 2. Many critiques have obvious solutions like "don't do the dumb thing" or "do it the normal way." 3. Improving safety is normally the job of the car manufacturing company, why would Tesla be any different? 4. If your want very detailed engineering fixes from the internet, tell Tesla to open-source their manufacturing process and pay people for time.
- Kon-Peki 2y agoMore info, from the source: https://ops.fhwa.dot.gov/program_areas/ops-cavet.htm https://ops.fhwa.dot.gov/program_areas/ops-cavet.htm There is a link to an ongoing test in the downtown area of Tampa, FL. They’ve installed lidar near crosswalks; when a pedestrian is in a crosswalk it broadcasts a “pedestrian in crosswalk” signal that nearby compatible cars hear (they’ve installed receivers in 1000 cars).
- panick21_ 2y agoHow to waste the maximal amount of money for minimal benefit. Lidar at ever intersection. The idiocy is incrdible.
- Kon-Peki 2y agoI'm totally in support for reserving RF spectrum for this and can imagine many scenarios where low-cost, low-power RF transmissions would improve road safety (I've just braked really hard; I've just crashed; I'm an emergency vehicle stopped in the road; etc). But yeah, lidar at every intersection is just plain bonkers.
- kfarr 2y agoSells a lot of v2x chips tho
- bdavbdav 2y ago1000 cars doesn’t sound like many as an accident reduction survey, unless it’s just to prove the tech itself works.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rightbyte 2y agoI really don't want connected cars. It introduces way too much remote attack surface where there was zero before.
- dylan604 2y agodo the cars need to be connected to communicate with each other though? I think you're beating on a dead horse of an unrelated subject
- Arainach 2y agoCould you elaborate? Communication is itself a connection. The complaint isn't that the cars are connected to the internet, it's that they're connected and communicating with each other. In an oversimplified system where Car A broadcasts "I'm braking" allowing Car B to slow down and avoid a collision, the attack vector is a simulated "I'm braking" message that causes car B to slow down/stop even though Car A is not braking (or may not even exist).
- dylan604 2y agoMaybe I missed the meaning, but with all of the other threads about connected cars, it's all about connected to the internet. Broadcasting current mode of operation doesn't really seem connected in the same way to me. Sure, it might be a way to "attack" another car by sending the same signal, but that's totally different from someone accessing the car remotely for other purposes. If you fake a hard braking signal, to my car, then my car will respond by slowing down and then transmitting that as well to other cars.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- onemoresoop 2y agoThey need to communicate somehow. That is a large a attack surface and bad actors could inflict a whole lot of damage. I'd say we take it slowly before we jump headfirst into this.
- new299 2y agoThe number of negative comments here seems odd to me. If you actually want practical and safe self driving cars widely deployed it seems obvious that instrumenting roads and making them a better platform for self-driving vehicles is an important part of this process. To me this work seems like a part of the process of evolving roads from a Ad-Hoc and poorly documented system involving a lot of human guess work into a more robust and reliable platform for self-driving and human driven cars.
- adrianN 2y agoWe don’t even instrument all the train tracks, a small portion of the network relies on the conductors. I think it’s unlikely that the people commenting today will live to see a sizable portion of the road network instrumented for self driving.
- drtgh 2y agoAs the article and the linked PDF quickly mention, cybersecurity is a concern, a really big problem difficult to solve. A cracked traffic or car signal, a spoofed radio signal, or more simply a malfunctioning sensor from both, is something to watch out for. Then, at what point could the data received be trusted without a real trusted source like a visual of what is really happening? Collapsing a city or causing an accident could be as simple as tricking vehicles into thinking they have another vehicle in front of them by receiving false data with the codes of legitimate vehicles or traffic signals for example. IMHO vehicles should not react to data from third parties/external, but to a own -and mandatory redundant- sensoring data within the vehicle. But even nowadays there are problems with this as owners of cars with automatic proximity braking systems could explain. There is also another problem, when the vehicle is connected to a network to receive an OTA or to modify any type of engineering parameter, it already has its own vector of attack, homologous to when one use the remote key to open and start the car, and the signal is captured and cracked by a third party; We didn't saw manufacturers solving this across all this years. The article concludes like if the problem were political, a sabotage, but without explaining why the cybersecurity is a real problem. I'm European, so I'm not sure what lobbies are involved there, for sure they exist, but if we ignore it and look at it from a technical point of view, IMHO the cybersecurity problem should be solved -which I'm not sure can be solved- before moving the money.
- bankcust08385 2y agoSelf-driving cars able to communicate intent and negotiate could be extremely efficient by reducing collisions and traffic. From a standstill, all vehicles waiting could accelerate simultaneously rather than create pressure waves due to human reaction times. With fully-autonomous coordination, might also be possible to do away with traffic lights and other control elements to negotiate scheduling of vehicles moving across each other so they cross intersections using precisely-allocated time slots without stopping.
- UltimateEdge 2y agoIt seems this comment is paraphrasing the following video by CGP Grey: https://youtu.be/iHzzSao6ypE https://youtu.be/iHzzSao6ypE
- psini 2y agoSounds like reinventing trains, but honestly why not with all the existing road infrastructure
- BoringTimesGang 2y agoThe 'tech bros reinventing trains' refrain fails to take into account that the same people would love 1/100th of the coverage of the global road network for rail.
- xen0 2y agoThis is a terrible world for pedestrians, bicycles, or anything other than an autonomous vehicle.
- patapong 2y agoNot necessarily? This depends on how the system is set up. For example, cars could share the positions of pedestrians and bikes with each other to ensure that even cars with no direct line of sight are aware of them, making the roads safer for everyone. Likewise, if traffic lights are integrated into the system, the waiting times could be much shorter as cars can dynamically slow down to allow pedestrians to cross, wihtout being contrained by fixed time blocks of green/red.
- nxobject 2y agoThe article doesn't make it clear to me when the DOT talks about "V2X being deployed", what the full scope of that is – does it refer to just the physical technologies, or the lowest layers of the OSI model? Or does "V2X deployment" here mean more application-level stuff, i.e. a series of minimum requirements about what information classes of devices will broadcast to other classes of devices, with what limitations? Without that clarification, I think the first thing readers of HN will think, justifiably, is "is all of my car's information being broadcast all the time to everything", for plenty of reasons – dragnet surveillance, disruptive attacks ranging from Flipper pranks to state actors, etc.? It's not clear whether that's true or expected of this V2X initiative. After some quick digging, it looks like so far, it looks like only very domain-specific features have been "implemented with V2X", and will be for the forseeable future (see p7+ in [1]) – oversize vehicle complaince, pedestrian in crosswalk, blind spot warnings. How that's implemented will probably need a lot more digging. [1] https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/68128 https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/68128
- Havoc 2y agoMakes sense to me. Even if it’s just a “hint” that could massively alter outcomes. eg braking a second earlier could be the difference between crash and no crash
- jonplackett 2y agoIs it just me or does this seem like it could be abused? Like, could you just stand on a bridge on a freeway and send ‘I’m max braking’ signals to all the cars and then they all react to that and stop? Bearing in mind the incredibly poor tech of most cars - like the keyless entry that you can just boost the signal while the keys are in a house and open the car - I don’t have much faith in car companies to do a good job. I don’t mind my car reacting to real events actually happening before I know about them, but reacting to signals scares me a bit. Is there some clever way that they’ll avoid this?
- Havoc 2y agoYes definitely worth some careful consideration. The current situation of 2 tons hunks of stupid metal flying around with only slow reacting humans to maintain safety isn’t optimal either though. There has got to be some sort of happy medium here
- h_tbob 2y agoAs an American there are few times when I think the government did something awesome. But I’m amazed they are thinking of this. This so awesome. Plus the FAA will need to do this as we get more electric personal aircraft
- xnx 2y agoLike other networks, dumb pipes (roads) and smart endpoints (self-driving cars) will serve us best in transportation. Vehicle to vehicle communication makes almost no difference to the remaining hard problems Waymo is working on. E.g. Vehicle to vehicle doesn't help a Waymo car identify and properly handle downed power lines during a snowstorm.
- eth0up 2y agoMy morning $0.02: I have thought for many years that we need to make driving a part of both middle and highschool. Not merely the principles of motor vehicle operation, but the humanities aspect too. For example, psychology, basic physics and sociology would be integral to the curriculum. It is important to view transportation as closely as possible for what it is. As conscientious driver, I do my best to be courteous and safe, for both selfish and altruistic reasons. I try to apply my understanding of traffic dynamics every time frustration is detected. It is impossible for me to drive without observing stupidity, inefficiencies and systemic flaws. Realizing that I am part of it and not an exception, I try to view others (drivers, bystanders, pedestrians, cyclists etc) with equal or greater importance to myself. I do not tailgate, unless it is a collective circumstance, eg slow high-density traffic. I heed speed limits, general laws, and remain cognizant of signs. I expect unexpected behavior and try to not react beyond necessary correction. And I piss off a lot of drivers. Traveling the speed limit in the right lane in low density traffic, I will be tailgated or worse. Yet, while mostly driving well within legal parameters, I make good time and often end up ahead of erratic impatient drivers. I believe that most collisions can be avoided through rational driving practices. But many are never exposed to the concept. A mere pulse is sufficient to receive a driver's license. Traffic enforcement also seems to be more revenue than safety driven and lacks consistency, eg ephemeral speed traps. An essay or book could be easily written on this subject. As such an integral, ubiquitous part of society, it is amazing that such minimal attention is placed upon it. The fact that so many lives are at stake seems enough to make a religion of it. We really should do much more, without sloughing responsibility onto technology and the lottery of enforcement. For me it is one of the most outrageously glaring contradictions of expressed values there is, with carnage universally and quietly accepted as collateral damage.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y agoThis would work if we had the ability to deny licenses to people, which would require us to have a real alternative to driving in more cities :( > And I piss off a lot of drivers. Traveling the speed limit in the right lane in low density traffic, I will be tailgated or worse. Yet, while mostly driving well within legal parameters, I make good time and often end up ahead of erratic impatient drivers. The impatient drivers overtake me but curiously I've never gotten a single ticket nor been in a collision. (I was forced off the road exactly one time)
- neonate 2y agohttps://www.its.dot.gov/research_areas/emerging_tech/pdf/Accelerate_V2X_Deployment_final.pdf https://www.its.dot.gov/research_areas/emerging_tech/pdf/Acc...
- Joker_vD 2y agoHow about Google and Apple teaming up, taking all the data they receive from Google Maps/Apple Maps telemetry, including the destination waypoints, using it to calculate globally optimal routing for every car on the road, and then making the cars execute it? Like, sure, this may sound like a central planning caricature but we do actually have enough computing power to pull it off in this case! It will be glorious! And pedestrians can be easily taken into account since they all carry small GPS/radio-trackers on them anyhow.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThe main issue I see is one of privacy and government control. Kill switches, speed governors, cars communicating with other cars … soon we’re on the doorstep of the same ability the CCP has to restrict transit.
- slackfan 2y agoWe are not on the doorstep, we are very much already there. And we do. Quiet Skies exists, and all intercity Amtrack trains fall under TSA as well.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y agoI don't mind governors, you can set all US cars around 80 MPH without putting any cars on the Internet. The risk to privacy isn't a government nefariously shutting down my car, it's a bunch of corporations trading my personal information, and I'm already losing the war
- Joel_Mckay 2y agoThe other problems with capturing peoples freedom of movement, is the liability it creates in insurance and or legal accountability. It will lead to countless edge-cases that usurp normal judgement by rational drivers. Example: "The school bus stopped on the railway crossing, because some drunk in a Tesla passed out in the turning lane." What a silly policy from naive nerd hubris. =3
- Mistletoe 2y agoHonestly a neat idea, making cars not run into each other seems like an almost trivial idea to implement if they can talk to each other.
- hnburnsy 2y ago>The timeline for the DoT's plan extends to 2036, by which time it hopes to have fully deployed V2X across the National Highway System, for the top 75 metro areas to have the tech enabled at 85 percent of signalized intersections and to have 20 vehicle models that are V2X capable. In the shorter term, the agency aims to have V2X tech installed across 20 percent of the National Highway System and 25 percent of signalized intersections in major metro areas by 2028. So the same government department that took around 10 just years to get adaptative headlights approved thinks this will happen in 11 years. Yeah, not going to happen this century.
- xyst 2y agoAmericans will do anything but build alternative transportation options to cars, build more efficient cities to allow for biking/walking to be more viable (car independence), or replacing useless parking garages, parking lots with scalable housing and living. Automated vehicle transportation is a bust. Now Americans think installing a backdoor into a vehicle is going to solve the problem. Smh. All of this while a majority of the country is suffering from intense heatwaves, increased intensity of storms due to climate change.
- nightshift1 2y agoAbout time. I like to drive and wish to keep my liberty on the road as much as anyone else but I think it would be easy to send basic just-in-time telemetry to the other neighboring cars to improve cruise control, emergency braking and heavy traffic situations. The car in front of you could easily send its exact speed, throttle/brake position. If it is following gps, it could broadcast the next turn on its route to help you predict its intentions (turn signals are often lacklusters or too complicated for some drivers) In traffic, it could help stiffen the elastic by reducing the reaction time either by either telling the driver to get ready or accelerating for them. The possibilities are infinite once you have a minimum of telemetry.
- loloquwowndueo 2y agoHot take, but if a turn signal is too complicated for someone, said person should NOT be driving a 2-ton land torpedo.
- mjevans 2y agoMight be a perception bias, but I DO notice that many, at least not infrequently, drivers near me either do not use their turn signals, or activate them _way_ too late. It's like they were never told "the turn signal is to communicate your intent, in advance" Like at least 0.5 - 1 blocks in advance (depending on speed) on normal surface streets. The whole goal is to give the driver behind you at least 5 seconds to react to that intent.
- darby_nine 2y agoI'm far more worried about pedestrians with these larger cars than most vehicle/vehicle interactions. I'd much rather move away from cars than lean into them.
- userbinator 2y agoThe drive down the path of authoritarian dystopia continues... as everyone is so focused on "safety" that they lose sight of what it means to live.
- bfrog 2y agoI see nothing about the humans outside of the metal clown cars. Meanwhile e-bikes are growing, and pedestrians and other road user die needlessly to oversized vehicles driven by anyone with a pulse due to lax licensing rules. Fix licensing, make vehicles safe for those walking/biking not just those in other clown cars.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoWear retro reflectors and high visibility at night: No amount of driver training can change the fact we have the oldest average driving age in history, and with that comes poor eyesight.
- renewiltord 2y agoNo amount of reflectors will help you when the guy who kills you only notices you as a bump he felt after looking up from the phone. Just put concrete down on the bike lane divider.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoIt’s about turning the risk knob, everything help.
- bfrog 2y agoYou could wear something brighter than the sun blasting train horn sounds in a 360 and still get nailed by some clown mobile. It’ll be deemed an accident, person will get at most a ticket. As the addage goes, wanna murder someone? Use a car, it’s an accident don’t you know?
- mensetmanusman 2y agoThat’s always true, even for motorcyclists.
- cratermoon 2y agoI agree. DOT needs to be more than the Department of Cars and Highways.
- PaulHoule 2y agoIf it doesn't involve the cellular network authentication won't work. The killer app will be something I can put in my house that makes anyone driving by thinks a demolition derby is going on so they'll slow down. If it does involve the cellular network it will face opposition because people don't want to buy another plan and coverage will never really be satisfactory, even if the cell phone industry is able to force every driver to buy a plan for their car.
- boredpeter 2y ago[dead]
- Animats 2y agoOh, that's back? I thought that died with the "V2V" scheme, which was used as a justification for 5G cellular. The document [1] comes across as a solution looking for a problem. Like much of IoT. Waymo cars do not have, or need, a vehicle to vehicle communication system. They talk to their HQ, but that's not part of the main control loops. Most of the problems Waymos have to avoid don't communicate much, if at all. Traffic cones, pedestrians, bicyclists, and people in wheelchairs have to be sensed directly. Once you have the sensing to do that, large vehicles should not be a problem. (Yes, Tesla has had trouble sensing fire trucks, semis, etc., but that's a Tesla problem) It doesn't seem to be necessary that traffic lights and signs broadcast their status to vehicles. It's not something Waymo has asked for. So what is this "V2X" thing supposed to be for? Surveillance, probably. [1] https://www.its.dot.gov/research_areas/emerging_tech/pdf/Accelerate_V2X_Deployment_final.pdf https://www.its.dot.gov/research_areas/emerging_tech/pdf/Acc...
- canadianfella 2y ago[dead]
- ghssds 2y ago> V2X enables vehicles to stay in touch with each other as well as pedestrians, cyclists, other road users and roadside infrastructure. I understand this as traffic cones, pedestrians, bicyclists, and people in wheelchairs being V2X-enabled too, somehow.
- falcor84 2y agoOh, that sounds dystopian - "Ma'am, I'm sorry to inform you that your husband was fatally hit by a car as he attempted to cross the street without his government-mandated V2X tracker; as you are aware, by doing so he triggered the suicide exclusion clause in his insurance policy and forfeited his eligibility"
- TomK32 2y agoAll just because he once signed up for a Disney+ trial.
- marcus_holmes 2y agoI rode a scooter in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, for about six months. It was fascinating because the road traffic controls are largely ignored, in favour of communicating via body language with the vast numbers of other scooters around you, pretty much treating the odd car as a stationary obstacle. There's also a strong feeling of "we're all in this together and we co-operate to keep things moving and get where we need to go". Crossing the road there is a matter of slowly and clearly walking into oncoming traffic, trusting that they will stop or go around you [0]. It kinda works the same on a scooter - you slowly and clearly do the utterly illegal thing that you want to do, and everyone will stop for you or go around you. Riding the wrong way up one-way streets, or on the wrong side of the road, is common and perfectly safe as long as you take it slow and keep your eyes open. I think this concept of clear communication works better than the conventional system of road traffic controls. IIRC there have been tests done in the UK where removing road traffic controls led to people slowing down and communicating their intentions more, with greater flowthrough and reduced collisions. Automating this will be interesting. Yes it'll probably work, and accidents will be reduced. But it moves us further into making the act of driving illegal. If we are all safer when the robots drive, then it's reasonable for humans to be disallowed from driving. But is the world a better place if we don't drive our own cars any more? [0] I have had to explain this to very confused German tourists a few times. "The light is green for me to walk, why are they not stopping?" cries a worldview being shattered.
- zarzavat 2y agoThe reason it works in asia is because people drive slower - by necessity. You can’t barrel down one of those chaotic streets at 30mph, you’ll kill someone. You need to slow down to deal with all the chaos. We can have the same advantages in the west while still keeping the rules-based system, by making roads narrower.
- marcus_holmes 2y agothat whole "slow is smooth, smooth is quick" thing - yes the traffic is slower, but we were generally moving the whole time. Driving in Australia is a constant stop-go procession of road traffic controls. I don't know if it actually was faster, but it sure felt like it.
- femto 2y agoIf you want to know where this is heading, keep an eye on the fortunes of Cohda Wireless. https://www.cohdawireless.com/ https://www.cohdawireless.com/ Cohda was started in 2004 by three very smart Information Theorists (Grant, Alexander, Rasmussen), who basically solved the problem of how to get a WiFi/OFDM signal to/from a vehicle moving at speed through a built up city. The company name is Ad Hoc, as in Ad Hoc network, spelled backwards. Cohda's original version was effectively a preprocessor between the WiFi and the antenna, that tamed the multipath channel. Back then they had some impressive coverage maps of the Adelaide CBD, whereby plain WiFi struggled to get coverage in a 100m radius, whilst the Codah system had seamless coverage out to about 1km. They were (and still are?) the leaders in this space.
- danw1979 2y agoYC summer ‘28 entry: V2X-connected kids shoes, that constantly broadcast the position and heading of your child to nearby traffic.
- andrepd 2y agoAnything but addressing the underlying issue of car-centric city design!
- truculent 2y agoIf we want a system that produces safe and effective motor transportation with increasing automation, we should probably look at air travel, which is both remarkably safe and uses a large degree of automation. How would the air travel regulators evaluate this proposal? How does this compare to similar methods in air travel?
- batch12 2y agoMaybe these cars could get their own lanes, or better yet, tracks...
- furyg3 2y agoIt's kind of crazy to me that we focus on things like this, which would only work for the most modern of new cars, but don't focus on other, simple things. In many European countries all cars need to undergo a yearly road worthiness check. So not just the emissions checks, but also the lights, tires, brakes, seatbelts, shocks, steering, and other basic things. It seems like such a system (even every 2 or 5 years) would result in major reductions in accidents and injuries and be applicable across all cars.
- snapcaster 2y agoSome states in the US (comparable to countries in europe) do do this (my state included)
- Wissenschafter 2y agoYes, let's just focus on small stuff we already do instead of the big elephant in the room of automated cars with less human error... Sometimes I can't even on this website with supposedly some of the smartest folks.
- oneplane 2y ago> Yes, let's just focus on small stuff we already do No, you don't > automated cars with less human error. The comment you replied to already noted that this has no effect on existing cars, of which many magnitudes more exist than automated cars (those do not exist on the road, not to the degree that is proposed). > Sometimes I can't even on this website with supposedly some of the smartest folks. Oh, the irony.
- Wissenschafter 2y ago>Oh, the irony. Yes, quite funny. The claim is absurd. Cars communicating with each other is feasible even for older vehicles.
- idiotsecant 2y ago
- yabones 2y agoThis won't work. None of the "safety technology" we've added in the last decade has worked. Not that the individual subsystems don't work effectively on their own, but that the entire vehicle is becoming a less safe place. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in_U.S._by_year#/media/File:United_States_Motor_Vehicle_Deaths_per_Year.webp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in... There's two main contributing factors, weight and distraction. Weight is easy to tell by looking around. More people than ever are driving around in huge SUVs and pickup trucks. But the bigger issue is distracted driving. The majority of other drivers I see are on their phones while moving. Almost everybody is checking their phones at intersections. And those that aren't have another distraction, the big tablets built into their cars, the use of which is required to change trivial settings. Adding more tech won't solve this. Only removing and limiting its use will roll back this trend.
- davidmurdoch 2y ago> None of the "safety technology" we've added in the last decade has worked Forward Collision-Avoidance systems really great.
- jiveturkey 2y agoi disable mine. 100% false positives. agree though, great for the masses.
- davidmurdoch 2y agoYou might be an aggressive driver. haha
- Sohcahtoa82 2y agoEh, phantom braking is definitely a problem. It's gotten better, for sure, but I've definitely had times where there was nothing within 1/4 mile in front of me on the highway and suddenly it slammed the brakes. When I first got my Tesla in 2019, there was one specific overpass that I would go under during my commute that seemed to have a ~20% chance of triggering automatic emergency braking. I got into the habit of preparing to stomp the throttle which would override AEB. Luckily, a software update came out a few months in that seemed to fix that specific case. Now, I've done 1,300 mile road trips that didn't have a single phantom braking incident.
- HPsquared 2y agoDriver monitoring is the next big win, but people will not like it. More likely to be rolled out somewhere pragmatic / illiberal like China.
- rangestransform 2y agoI will not buy anything that tries to impede me from doing what I want with it
- dddddaviddddd 2y agoIf this reduces vehicle-vehicle collisions, that will be an improvement. However, much more needs to be done to prevent pedestrian-vehicle and cyclist-vehicle collisions, and installing transceivers in pedestrians is not a realistic option.
- Clent 2y agoPedestrians don't need a transceiver installed, they have a smartphone and that should be enough.
- Brett_Riverboat 2y agoJust what my car needs, a government mandated attack vector. As if the crap that car companies are already forcing on people isnt enough.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bastawhiz 2y agoYou know what we don't need in our cars? More alerts. Unless my car is going to have a Terminator-style HUD to put a red box around something that I need to care about, there's only so many dings and beeps I can understand while I'm trying to drive. If I have to read an alert that a pedestrian is in a crosswalk up ahead, it's immediately getting turned off. My car already tries to tell me when it thinks I'm about to hit someone or someone is about to hit me. By the time I've looked at the screen to know, I'd have already hit them. How many of these warnings will eventually cause alarm overload? That's not to say I'm opposed to safety tech. I think it's a great idea. But there's no way to safely and effectively convey all that information to me while I'm already driving. If this gets rolled out as planned, I can't see how cars won't be constantly dinging and beeping and cause notification blindness, negating the whole effort.
- caseysoftware 2y agoThis will be gold for advertisers, insurers, and law enforcement agencies. And poison for anyone who values or needs privacy in any way.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoI spent two years building a module for use with intersection signal controller firmware (makes light turn red, green, yellow). The goal was to make better use of all of this extra data that we had. Sensors have improved, and all of this V2I stuff should really complete the picture. I poured my soul into that project. I really thought a lot about extensibility and ways to make it easy to accommodate new data sources. Here we had a chance to not shoot ourselves in the foot like we did last time these algorithms were visited, back in the 80's. And then we discovered a memory leak in some vendor's V2I component which was supposed to slurp vehicle position data from DSRC and feed it to my controller. We couldn't get it to run stably in the cabinet, so the whole thing just kind of... stopped. Then they put me on some pointless project, so I quit. This was 2017. Last year, I ran across somebody on youtube demoing my project. I got in touch, just to say hi, and he asked me for tech support--he didn't know how to configure it. I said: > There's a readme on the SD card, plus an SDK that should get you started writing modules for various detector types. He said: > What SD card? I see what looks like a memory chip, but it's soldered onto the board. They had told me I was building a research platform, and then when it finally ends up in the hands of a researcher, it turns out they've changed the hardware to make it useless for research. I was so angry. They never wanted to change anything, they just wanted some intellectual property that they could use as a bargaining chip in some way that had no impact on the intersection whatsoever. This "V2X" business appears to be the updated branding, and it's a good idea at its core, but from what I know about the people implementing it, I'm not going to get very excited about how it'll turn out.
- DCH3416 2y agoIs this why I have to wait at intersections with no incoming traffic for 2 minutes only to have a platoon of cars show up so that they can all stop and I can go
- maxwell 2y agoCross like a New Yorker.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y ago
- throw7 2y agoThere's little to no info on what v2x actually is and does. I suppose it's in research, but when the linked pdfs say it's proven to work... excuse me while I press x to doubt. The real problem is the disregard for pedestrian and bike safety and I don't see anything in "v2x" that helps the situation. In fact, I just see things getting more expensive and a big honking security nightmare.
- bedobi 2y agoThis is dumb and will not work and we have known it will not work for decades. Road safety and traffic are solved problems. Look to Tokyo, Amsterdam, Copenhagen. TLDR: provide viable alternatives to driving to move non-essential vehicles and trips off the roads, physically segregate modes, calm traffic and speeds in urban spaces etc etc. This is cheap and easy to do and doesn't require new technology lol. It's actually hilarious how much resources, time and energy otherwise smart engineers are willing to spend on solving the wrong problem. Optimizing intersections algorithms is a great example. Intersections are best optimized by not having intersections. If there has to be an intersection, make it a roundabout to randomize the flow vs the US style start-stop-start-stop grid of intersections which is GUARANTEED to gridlock BY DESIGN. Let alone that the no 1 thing is to do all the things mentioned above to take non-essential vehicles off the road in the first place.
- copperx 2y agoOne of my predictions of the future is that once it is shown that self driving isn't five nines reliable, countries will start installing electronic signals on roads to make self-driving reliable. And self driving will only be legal on those roads.
- Eumenes 2y agoCome and take my analog vehicle, feds, I dare you.
- selimthegrim 2y agoWell can they get cars to dim their headlights and not mess with others' collision detection?
- therealcamino 2y agoYeah, there are lots of interesting applications of getting other vehicles or traffic signals to favor you by sending wrong data! There are a bunch of references to "Security Credentials Management System providers" in the DOT document. So it sounds like there will be some attempt to reject self-serving incorrect data, and even a mechanism to report and exclude "misbehaving" devices. But there are lots of gray areas and value judgements in what's allowed to be sent. The message types are interesting to read (second link below). I thought at first that the Red Light Violation Warning was a message where your own vehicle sends out "Hey, we're blowing this red light, everybody watch out!" But I think that one is intended to be sent by the traffic signal system. But still, if you aren't in control of what your vehicle sends, what's to stop it from broadcasting data you don't want it to send, like "Hey, we're exceeding the speed limit by 17 mph"? Another value judgement that seems like it would be made at some regulatory level. Even if the messages are completely anonymous as claimed, you probably (at a personal level) don't receivers to clue in traffic police to show up further along your route, or have insurance companies try to match those with private roadside license plate reader data. At a societal level I'm sure some people would favor that, and others wouldn't. https://www.its.dot.gov/resources/scms.htm https://www.its.dot.gov/resources/scms.htm https://www.its.dot.gov/research_areas/cybersecurity/scms/SCMS-PoC-Supported-V2X-Applications_27427021.html https://www.its.dot.gov/research_areas/cybersecurity/scms/SC...
- foxyv 2y agoI wish there was some beacon or something I could wear while walking that would let cars see me and not hit me or at least slow down. There are just way too many drivers with their heads down looking at their phones. I see a ton of them just blowing through stop signs at full speed every day. It would be nice if their cars would be on the look out since the drivers seem unable to.