7 ms·
Making 'food out of thin air'
- lainga 2y agoIsn't most food in industrialised countries made partly out of thin air (via the Haber-Bosch process)?
- goda90 2y agoIf you're counting that then you might as well count photosynthesis as making from thin air as well.
- _Microft 2y agoThis seems misleading? In that case you could as well argue that our food was made from pure energy (photons from the sun) which might make it sound like we had Star Trek replicators - which we obviously do not have.
- knodi123 2y ago> which we obviously do not have Yeah, but a lot of us wish we did. So maybe branding plant-based diets that way could be a compelling sales tactic with the nerd demographic.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- actionfromafar 2y agoI wonder if the low knowledge of this is because only Finnish investors are allowed?
- gs17 2y agoMostly it's because it's pretty early on, only running the factory for a few months, and not at Generally Recognized As Safe status in most places. They recently launched products in Singapore through a partnership with a Japanese company: https://solarfoods.com/new-solein-powered-products-launched-in-singapore/ https://solarfoods.com/new-solein-powered-products-launched-...
- A_D_E_P_T 2y ago"Homogenized bacterial carcasses" (the article's words, not mine,) are going to be an extremely tough sell as a consumer food product. It's not the sort of thing that humans have evolved to eat in bulk quantities, and unless the stuff is extremely well characterized, I'd be wary of small-molecule toxins and inflammatory agents, like lipopolysaccharides. The article also notes that: > Today, almost half the world’s habitable land is used for agriculture. Of that, an astounding 80% is dedicated to livestock grazing and animal feed If this invention can produce protein at a low enough cost -- which seems doubtful -- it might be interesting as a form of protein for animal feed. The trouble is that protein sources for animal feed are typically extremely cheap. For instance, "peanut cake" is a byproduct of peanut oil manufacture. It's what's left over after the oil is extracted, and it's ~35% protein, full of vitamins, and almost as cheap as dirt. I don't see how something made in a vat can compete with that. I suppose the "homogenized bacterial carcasses" could also be purified and broken down into their constituent amino acids, which would be useful if somewhat more niche.
- krunck 2y ago'"Homogenized bacterial carcasses" (the article's words, not mine,) are going to be an extremely tough sell as a consumer food product.' These seem to sell fine: compressed curdled cow leakage that was left on a shelf to grow mold for up to a few years - cheese wheat slurry foamed by bacterial activity then baked - bread
- A_D_E_P_T 2y agoThe two of those are about as old as human civilization, and can be made with stone age tech. Besides, the primaries are milk and wheat -- and you can make bread and cheese wholly without yeast and mold. (Tortillas, ricotta, etc.) I don't think that humans have ever consumed bulk bacteria as a food source.
- ben_w 2y ago> The two of those are about as old as human civilization, and can be made with stone age tech. Mainly demonstrating you can literally sell rotten milk so long as you label it "traditional". > I don't think that humans have ever consumed bulk bacteria as a food source. We never communicated across the globe by swiping our fingers across small sheets of transparent fused sand with glowing lights behind them, until one day we did. We never survived having our heart removed and a different one put in its place, until one day we did. We never saw the far side of the moon, until one day we did. But, as it happens, we have already done this with algae: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spirulina_(dietary_supplement) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spirulina_(dietary_supplement) Not all changes are progress, but all progress involves change.
- gs17 2y agoThe wiki page on them is kind of funny to me: > It's been stated that the land efficiency for Solar Foods methods is about 20,000 times greater than for conventional farming.[8] Michael Le Page for the New Scientist took a more sceptical view, noting that the x20,000 improvement only applies to the factories themselves. If land use for Solar panels is taken into account, then land efficiency only improves by about x10.
- digging 2y agoThe myth of the 20000x farmer, debunked. Merely a 10x farmer.
- actionfromafar 2y agoWhat if it's a large nuclear power plant?
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoNot. Economical. Also, the false assumption is that the solar panels would be consuming usable arable land, although of course the deconstruction of the criticism that reduces from 20,000 times to 10 times isn't listed. There's plenty of desert out there. There's also plenty of roofs and parking lots
- DennisP 2y agoThere probably aren't enough roofs and parking lots to run civilization plus produce enough calories to feed us. Deserts are nice but then you're talking about a lot of long-distance transmission, which gets expensive; most likely if we end up with a lot of fallow farmland closer to consumers, we'll use that. Still a great trade going from 40% to 4%. But if we do manage some kind of really cheap nuclear, that'd be even better.
- DennisP 2y agoWell if we can only recover 36% of the planet's land area, I guess that's not worth it then.
- saad_123 2y ago[dead]
- guidoism 2y agoAren’t plants literally making food out of thin air? They take a series of photons and pull the carbon out of the “thin air” to make food.
- obloid 2y agoBy the title I was expecting to read about some process to synthesize carbohydrates by capturing CO2 and water out of the air. Which I guess is basically what plants do.
- actionfromafar 2y agoBut it basically is about that?
- partomniscient 2y ago>"This means 40% of the planet’s total habitable land is dedicated to animal products, despite the fact that meat, dairy and farmed fish combined provide just 17% of humanity’s calories." It's complicated. Not all calories are equal, this obviates the fact that those calories may be the main sources of specific proteins, vitamins and minerals etc. that are essential to human health and not easily obtained elsewhere. I get what they're trying to promote but its not a completely valid standpoint to take, and I say this as a vegan. Plus its not something easy to transition from for the majority of people because so many complex systems are involved that are resistant to change for a variety of reasons. Including profit motive and general resistance to change. (e.g. Just think about the amount of time it took the wine industry to move away from using cork even though it was proven new bottle sealing methods were superior.) I still applaud the general idea, and they mention vitamin's, advantages of fermentation etc. later - but this paragraph really irked me.
- worik 2y ago> It's complicated. Not all calories are equal Yes And land is not fungible Where I live, amongst sheep farms, there is not much land suitable for cropping
- mcmoor 2y agoYeah ranching used to be done on land not suitable for farming. This way it's just using unusable resource. But the modern practice is using something consumable by human so the economic is different?
- YeGoblynQueenne 2y agoIn the same vein, humans don't eat calories, like we don't eat vitamins, minerals, protein, etc: we eat food. Even today when there is more popular knowledge (though to be fair, mainly confusion) about the nutrient content of food, most people will gravitate to what they are used to eating culturally, and what tastes good. Which, incidentally, is how we end up eating a lot of stuff that's really not good for us at all.
- ch4s3 2y agoThis is pretty interesting. It looks like solein has about 1.5x the protein content of whey protein and a much lower cost. It seems like they could compete in the supplement or meal replacement markets pretty easily.
- Mistletoe 2y agoWe already went through this with synthetic meat. It’s really hard to beat the efficiency and self replication of plants and animals. Keeping everything sterile and exchanging gases and nutrients is not an easy task in a lab. https://www.ucdavis.edu/food/news/lab-grown-meat-carbon-footprint-worse-beef https://www.ucdavis.edu/food/news/lab-grown-meat-carbon-foot... I have experience growing up human cells, fungi, and bacteria in bioreactors and it doesn’t scale like a chicken house or field of corn. Maybe the Finnish bacteria is better than meat but I have my doubts it gets to where it needs to be.
- ycombinatrix 2y agofool's errand - everyone knows food is one of the 5 principal exceptions to Gamp's law of elemental transfiguration
- raptorraver 2y agoWe already produce food out of thin air using plants. It’s called photosynthesis. If you don’t want to eat those plants yourself you can feed them to ruminants and they’ll turn them to meat and fertilizer for you to grow more food out of thin air. It’s more nutritious and tastes much better than these weird inventions.
- DennisP 2y agoThe problem is land area. > Today, almost half the world’s habitable land is used for agriculture. Of that, an astounding 80% is dedicated to livestock grazing and animal feed. > We need more forests...they are home to many billions of plants, animals, bacteria and fungi whose complex metabolic interactions make up the biosphere with its crucial role in stabilizing the climate. The article also mentions that photosynthesis is "surprisingly inefficient," which is why there's room to drastically reduce the area we need to feed our livestock.
- tuatoru 2y agoBannning biofuels would go a long way to reducing agriculture's use of land. Trying to improve the efficiency of photosynthesis is one of those "what could possibly go wrong?" ideas.
- DennisP 2y agoSure but the idea at the link is more like fermenting our food in vats. (Or at least our livestock's food.)
- ranger_danger 2y agowhat about hydroponics? that doesn't need vast amounts of horizontal land
- jollyllama 2y agoAnd then there's the fact that killing all those countless bacteria just for food is pretty cruel. Not vegan!
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- worik 2y agoThis a solution without a problem There is no food shortage in the world. Famine is an economic and political problem, not a food shortage This is worse than just a unneeded conceit, as it pushes further the meme that food is made not grown Highly processed food is being recognised now as a major cause of obesity related illnesses, we need less of it not more of it
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoCheck out this guy. He's got the entire environmental equation figured out. He knows exactly what all the land dedicated to human production would equate to in terms of biodiversity, environmental resilience, topsoil loss, carbon capture, all of it figured out! Wish I had such confidence
- kragen 2y agoa quibble with the title: all food is made out of thin air. what plants get from soil is basically just phosphorus, potassium, iron, chromium, boron, and sulfur, which are essential but only present in trace quantities in the resulting food, totaling less than 1%. the carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, and nitrogen that make up the vast bulk of plants all come from the air more or less directly a quibble with this quote from the article > Only a fraction of agricultural land (16%) is used to grow the crops that we eat directly, as i understand it, part of their denominator is pastureland which is not really suitable for plowing. but it is surely true that by increasing that fraction by a factor of ¼ to 20% we could satisfy everyone's caloric needs with an entirely vegan diet eating bacteria and other microorganisms is nothing new; yogurt, kefir, and natto are mostly bacteria, and of course microbial carcasses play key roles in not only the beer, bread, and kombucha mentioned in the article, but such foods as also wine, bread, most cheeses, kimchi, sauerkraut, pickles, soy sauce, many sausages, and tofu of strong odor unfortunately, i have to agree with adept's comment that processing the homogenized bacterial carcasses through slaughtered livestock may be a way to reduce potential human health risks (as well as unfounded health concerns). we're currently experiencing a global obesity pandemic, causing a significant fraction of global mortality, which seems to be due to ultra-processed food. we're likely to see growing support for the bioreactionary position attributed to desantis in the article: > Florida is fighting back against the global elite’s plan to force the world to eat meat grown in a petri dish or bugs to achieve their authoritarian goals.
- gmuslera 2y agoIn the Pohl's Heechee saga there were CHON food machines that essentially were food synthesized from those main 4 elements and traces of others. But not all the other elements come from thin air, some come from soil, and your nutrition may be lacking something essential, even if they doesn't contributes a lot on total weight.
- kragen 2y agoyeah, that's basically what these companies are building. i guess i left calcium, magnesium, chlorine, selenium, and sodium out of my list of essential trace elements; any others?
- kkfx 2y agoAllow me to translate: from space exploration and submarines ops to climate changes issues we desperately try to create food in artificial environments we can create a bit in all climates, nearly everywhere and possibly in simple buildings, we have substantially failed so far, but enthusiasts articles keep piling up in the hope research keep up and evolve... Aside a small interests to cut out all small and medium scale food productions, because industry of this kind demand a certain scale and if that's the future of food that's means few giants can subjugate a wide mass of people for mere strategic role in the society: being the sole who can feed people. Essentially so far both nightmares and dreams, in practice we can do something but only for very few in survival mode consuming an immense amount of resources.