3 ms·
The current SCOTUS would disagree strongly as they are using ridiculous loopholes from the bench
by dylan604 2y ago
The current SCOTUS would disagree strongly as they are using ridiculous loopholes from the bench
- refulgentis 2y ago[flagged]
- tsimionescu 2y agoTrue, SCOTUS hasn't been using ridiculous loopholes in a few decisions recently. What legal professionals are saying is that they have simply ignored the explicit text and spirit of several laws or the constitution in a few recent decisions, particularly their presidential immunity case.
- pfannkuchen 2y agoI remember thinking as like a 10 year old that it was weird that presidents are immune from prosecution. So it’s definitely not a new thing. Is there something very nuanced about the Supreme Court ruling that I am missing? As with many political issues, online discussion about the topic is mostly screeching, and it’s hard to tell what’s really going on.
- raverbashing 2y agoIt's the other way Discussions about software are (and in most cases) what works best here. But anything else the quality of discussion goes down a lot The funny exception is that sometimes you see a very insightful and relevant comment about a niche subject in a tangential discussion
- Dylan16807 2y agoAre you gonna say what's wrong or just make a big deal out of being disappointed? Or, if you really just mean flippant with no other implications, then software discussion here gets equally flippant all the time.
- refulgentis 2y ago[flagged]
- dataflow 2y agoThe "equivalent" you mention is more like the opposite rather than the equivalent. It's making a sweeping generalization about millions of software engineers using 1 counterexample pertaining to one specific company, completely ignoring the impact the millions of other people have had through that practice. Extrapolating from a highly-non-random team of (say) ~100 engineers to a population of 4+ million is just a baseless thing to do. SCOTUS is the exact opposite of this. It has a whopping 9 members, all of whom directly influence every single decision -- which is published publicly. There is no other member of the population to extrapolate to (vs. the millions in the SWE case); you just have to extrapolate temporally... for which you have plenty of history to base things on. Making sweeping generalizations about how the majority of them operate is as close to the exact opposite of baseless as it could possibly be. Maybe you're right regardless and the parent is "not even wrong" nonetheless; I'm not opining on that conclusion one way or the other. I'm just saying your attempt at an analogy arguing for that is very much not making a case for it.
- refulgentis 2y agoNothing from me will be good enough for you on this topic, I'm afraid. I'm sorry I can't meet your expectations, I recognize that it is on me, not you. n.b. for reader so it's clear I'm being earnest in my exit, not passive-aggressive: Yesterday, we disagreed on whether "parallel construction happens" obviously shows that it is meaningless the 5th circuit said geofencing warrants violate principle of presumed privacy. This was important because given parallel construction happens, I cannot say that it is unlikely that the tech companies, judges, DA, and cops will collude to continue serving geofencing warrants, responding to them, and using them for evidence, hide it from the court and defendant, and use parallel construction to nail them.
- bryan_w 2y ago
- dylan604 2y agoWhile it might not be loopholes per se, but to disagree that current bench has grabbed the wheel and jerked hard is undeniable and you loose credibility yourself. I'm sorry you think semi-emotional pissed off commenting from someone that is very much IANAL, but it doesn't mean the actual subject isn't wrong. Just looking at it from an ethics viewpoint, they've made a mockery of everything they're supposed to stand for. But of course you'll just try to claim your comments are so much more well thought out and we can all try a little harder to be you.
- refulgentis 2y agoYou are appealing to emotion and reciting a political argument to make a professional ethics claim. I think SCOTUS isnt going great too. Doesn't have anything to do with how likely it is a motion like this survives or the legal principle being discussed.
- moomin 2y agoHonestly the current court is more of a Ritchie “trusting trust” scenario.
- bee_rider 2y agoIf a bunch of lawyers wanted to complain about the general usability of software and how it impacts their lives, or complained about the fact that the engineers seem to be maliciously breaking previous conventions, that’d make sense. Sure, they don’t know much about file systems, but they would rightly be annoyed if we suddenly decided to break precedent and take the floppy-disk icon to mean “I’ve backed up the file to a floppy disk so it is ok to delete the local copy and close the program.”
- dataflow 2y ago> This is the 2nd HN legal discussion I'm facepalming at in 24 hours. I can't help wondering if the flippant way HN generally discusses law would hold if there was a legal site that tried opining on software engineering. It seems to me an irrational approach that doesn't hold for other subjects[1], and is just unconsidered. Hey there. I very much am not fond of citing the site guidelines normally; I understand people get worked up about stuff they feel is completely off-base. But given that I was one of the participants in the previous discussion that apparently made you similarly facepalm yesterday, and that I was similarly left clueless as to what flaws you saw in the actual merits of the arguments you were expressing your disdain at, I would suggest taking at least this one guideline to heart: "Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community." If you feel people are misinformed on some topic, please try to enlighten them with thoughtful explanations, instead of just expressing scorn and facepalming. It's not that people can't handle the scorn; it's just that it's unhelpful and unconstructive -- it certainly won't help anyone who is Wrong On The Internet become more correct.
- refulgentis 2y agoFacepalming isn't sneering -- in that loose of a definition, the above post itself is sneering. You are misrepresenting the thread: you made a reply demanding I enumerate any legal professionals who had their careers ruined due to parallel reconstruction, in response to me answering someone's question about why the 5th circuit decision yesterday mattered in practice. You also didn't attempt to follow-up at all, you weren't doing earnest inquiry, there wasn't a crowd of people. Just you, bringing up an unrelated topic to police me answering someone's question, via agreeing with them that it can still happen mechanically, but it won't in practice, because police / warrant judge / tech company / DA chain is diffuse enough that they can't effectively collude to hide from the trial judge they used a geofencing warrant. You've replied here a few times, as I note in my reply to one of the others: Nothing from me will be good enough for you on this topic, I'm afraid. I'm sorry I can't meet your expectations, I recognize that it is on me, not you. You read my posts as dishonest personal attacks, and its due to my cocksure verbiage coupled to my inability to definitively rule out the possibilities you raise.
- eadmund 2y ago‘Loophole’ is another way of saying, ‘the law as written.’ The job of judges is to apply the law as written, not the law as they wish it would be. I think that in general the U.S. Supreme Court’s recent decisions have been misinterpreted in the media, and far less ridiculous than, say, Wickard v. Fillburn or Reynolds v. Simms.
- dylan604 2y ago> The job of judges is to apply the law as written well, thank goodness we've never had an activist court so that the phrase activist court had never been used before. What a wonderful world it must be that you think we live, unfortunately for me, that's not the world we live in. The very fact that each and everyone of those judges manipulate the Senate swearing that precedence is important and their impartiality prevents them from prejuding any hypothetical case being posed in their questioning are just words.
- know-how 2y ago[flagged]
- jimt1234 2y agoThe job of judges is to apply the law as dictated by their billionaire, gift-giving "friends". Made a few changes to reflect the current state of SCOTUS. :)