5 ms·
Wow. That was really excessive. I can't imagine why Joel felt the question merited that kind of response. My feelings mirror one of the other comments in the
by timr 18y ago
Wow. That was really excessive. I can't imagine why Joel felt the question merited that kind of response.
My feelings mirror one of the other comments in the thread: most software jobs suck. Not everyone can work at Google or Fog Creek, and outside of the protected bubbles of the major tech centers, software work tends to be a tedious grind. (Even in the protected bubbles, I know a lot of dissatisfied techies -- free soda remains charming for only so long when you're working insane hours in a cube, on death-march projects, taking all of your creative orders from the MBA with the corner office.)
The sad thing is, I think that Joel and the guy posing the question are both partly correct: the software industry does pay really well for new grads, and yet it does discriminate against older techies. Programming is a questionable long-term career choice. Instead of insulting the guy for asking a question, why not have a discussion about the problems he perceives? Software may be better than ditch digging, but that doesn't mean that programmers should be eternally complacent and unquestioning minions of code.
- nir 18y ago> that doesn't mean that programmers should be eternally complacent and unquestioning minions of code Yes, but it would do many of us good to consider the options from time to time. It's not just digging ditches - you rarely get anything like the compensation and freedom that many software gigs offer even in fields like architecture or medicine, where you need years of training and education just to get to the starting line. It's definitely not all roses, but as someone who got into software relatively late in life (28) I'm still surprised at times how easy we have it. (I suppose it's like growing up in a Western country - life don't seem that great to you, until you compare it with how most of the world lives)
- ntoshev 18y agoThere is something strange about the notion that programmer's ability declines with age. I am a bit over 30 now and I've only become better, as long as I'm motivated (it was easier to stay motivated when I was younger). It seems to me that as long as you don't stop learning, you will only get better, and the experience of people like Steve Yegge seems to confirm it. I don't understand the whining about the workplaces either. At the end of the day, what makes Google a great place to work: the free soda and perks or the options to work on interesting things? If you choose the former, probably you are not really wired to enjoy programming as much as some of us are.
- paddy_m 18y agoI agree. I'm getting better by leaps and bounds every month ( I have been programming full time for about 3 years). I'm excited by how much I will know in 10 years. It is weird that you don't see a lot of really good programmers in their 40's and 50's I could see how, if I continue growing like I am now, most programming jobs I know of would be an easy coast. Why don't people do that. This is going to come off as pompous, but I wonder if its just that you don't see a lot of nerdy hackers continuing into their 40's. I can think of a bunch of programmers from DC who were in their 40's and 50's , they were mostly government workers and enterprise type programmers, I doubt those types continue pushing and exploring.
- arghnoname 18y agoKeep in mind that with most things the rate of improvement is much faster in the beginning and slows down as a greater level of mastery is acquired. I've been doing this for about 4 years. I'd program at work, and then I'd come home and read books on programming, architecture, etc. When I didn't feel like that, I'd be learning a new language. When I didn't feel like doing that, I'd be writing some software to do this or that. I want to continue to get better as much as ever, but now most of what I see, I've already seen. New things to learn come by less frequently than they did before. It's not that people in their 40's and 50's give up and just coast, it's that it's a case of diminishing returns. Once you know a decent amount of languages, you see the commonalities and the point of it begins to fade, and how many books can you read on OOP or functional programming? Good coding style? Project management? When you're at the phase when every sentence in the book is a worthwhile lesson it's easy to learn fast. When lessons come through slow experience, like lessons from maintaining a project for 15 years, things go more slowly.
- gaius 18y agoI doubt those types continue pushing and exploring Ageism is rampant in the IT industry. Can you blame people for migrating to "safe" jobs when they have families to support? I've often thought, if I ever start a company, I'm going to exclusively hire 50-somethings (I'm in my 30s now).
- deleted 18y ago
- sabat 18y agoSuck? Maybe they suck, but working as a programmer is better than not working. Believe me, I'm being laid off at a mortage company (that was once a thriving internet startup -- don't ask), and watching these loan people deal with the fact that they may not work for years is harsh. Tedious grind? You can create your own opportunities, but in software you're more likely to find a job in rough times than most other industries. Don't spit that fortune in the eye.
- potatolicious 18y agoNot to mention software is one of the rare industries where, if you're not happy taking orders from the MBA PHB, you can leave and start your own thing. No other industry requires less capital to start your own business. The amount you can accomplish with spare time and your personal laptop is insane compared to the kind of capital other industries demand for their startups.
- ahoyhere 18y agoNo other industry? Anything where the business owner can create intangible products himself/herself (e.g. writing, design, wedding planning, whatever) has just as low starting capital required.
- timr 18y agoThe argument "X is better than being unemployed" can be made for many values of X. It isn't spitting on fortune to suggest that some values of X are more desirable than others, and should be pursued strategically over the course of a career.
- sabat 18y agoIn bad times, X is always better than being unemployed.
- azanar 18y agoWas it really necessary to treat this as a binary choice? This comment and the one above it seem latent with severe blowhard sentiment, where one declares that x sucks, and the other declares things other than x that suck more. It takes some of the wind out of the argument they are trying to make, which maybe are worth exploring further. Is there age discrimination in programming? Probably, although I've had at least one manager assert to me, with some plausible evidence, that reverse age discrimination also exists. But, unfortunately, that conversation gets drowned out in cynicism and hyperbole, and oneupsmanship by additional cynicism. It is tiring, because all it succeeds in doing is creating additional angst and frustration. In the people who believe what is being said, they now believe they are now facing down a life consisting of death marches and idiocy, with the other option being indefinite unemployment. It creates a self-fulfilling prophecy, where they will engender that kind of attitude in the places they work and live; with some regularity, what they expect a place to be like is what it will become. For the people who try to fight against that sentiment but find their thoughts, however reasonable, drowned out in the sea of people who claim that they lack sufficient context simply because they lack the requisite cynicism, they'll eventually give up and either succumb to the prophecy or just leave the community to its own misery. To this I ask, do we really need more cynicism, and is it really deserved? Are we certain this hasn't gone past discussing things reasonably, into the realm where people attempt to out-gloom one another in hopes that it justifies them tolerating their own plight? When do we stop admitting the inevitability of this and start taking action to change that, or at least investigating deeper what action can be taken? How are we so certain that all of these crappy programming jobs that we look at with disdain aren't the product of the cynicism of people, perhaps like us, who currently work in them and make them and the rest of the culture that way? It is, to me, increasingly hard to tell where things honestly suck, and where people make them suck for the sake of producing drama and fulfilling their own expectations of misery. I agree with Joel; this is the textbook definition (if there were a textbook) of a mutual self-confirmation club, and I worry that it exists even here on HN.
- mechanical_fish 18y agoI can't imagine why Joel felt the question merited that kind of response. This isn't exactly the first time the question has been asked over there. Once you've read it for the 100,000th time I'm sure your patience tends to wear thin. Meanwhile, though it's conventional wisdom that "programming is a questionable long-term career choice": compared to what? Banking? http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/businesstechnology/2008556531_webwamu24.html http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/businesstechnology/200... A nice construction job? http://paper-money.blogspot.com/2008/12/new-residential-construction-report.html http://paper-money.blogspot.com/2008/12/new-residential-cons... Middle management at Circuit City? http://money.cnn.com/2008/11/10/news/companies/circuit_city/index.htm?postversion=2008111008 http://money.cnn.com/2008/11/10/news/companies/circuit_city/...
- aswanson 18y agoI think he meant it along the lines of how many successful (however you define that) 50 year old programmers do you run into? Most people who start out their careers doing code eventually migrate into management or something more lucrative by that point.
- potatolicious 18y agoThat's true for all industries. That 50 year-old banker is not the guy who's running around on the trading floor all day - he's probably a manager of some sort as well. Similarly, if you go into other engineering fields (electrical, mechanical, civil, etc) nearly all the 50 year-olds are managers also.
- gaius 18y agoBut how does that scale? What's the ratio of managers to workers? For every 10 20-something new CS graduates, there's maybe 1 50-something manager. What happened to the other 9? This isn't a new problem, after all the Army needs only 1 Colonel for every 12-16 Lieutenants... The option to stay on as a junior officer until retirement doesn't exist, it's "up or out".
- 18y ago
- anthonyrubin 18y agoHave you ever had a job outside of software development? Most office workers are in the same boat that we are. A great deal of the population is worse off. As a software developer you have ample opportunity to better yourself and improve your situation.
- tjmc 18y agoIn some ways your comparison proves his point. As a developer with a degree and over 15 years of varied and international experience, I'd rather be regarded as a professional than just another office worker. Most of my friends are in professions where their experience is both respected and rewarded with steadily improving pay and conditions. Taking just 3 examples - how many skilled civil engineers, optometrists and hydrogeologists have to deal with new graduates or having their work outsourced to India? The low barriers to entry in IT are both a blessing and a curse. It's great in your 20s, but by your 30s the gap with most other technical professions that require similar levels of intelligence and skill becomes obvious. That decade of experience doesn't count for as much as a lot of it is now outdated and irrelevant. For those of us who love the technical, creative side of developing and don't desire moving "up" into management, I can understand the sentiment.
- pmorici 18y agoThe thing that ticked me off about the guys post was that he was basically looking for a job where he could just go punch the clock until retirement.
- spolsky 18y agoIt's a DAILY question on the Joel on Software discussion forum; there's a group of people there that have turned it into a mutual self-confirmation club where they all try to make each other depressed about how bad their jobs are.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- timr 18y agoFair enough. That's context that we don't get when your comments are cross-posted here. That said, I still feel bad for the guy who posted the original comment: he wanted some advice on what to do next, and got called a little girl.
- axod 18y ago"Just looking for something that will have the best chance of keeping steady employment until retirement (in my early 30s now)" That's a pretty lame depressing question to ask though. IMHO he should try and find some ounce of passion in himself, and find something he enjoys, or ideally loves.
- nihilocrat 18y agoThe insistence for people to be so blithely money-oriented enrages me more than any sort of weaknesses on his part. He didn't even qualify it with "with interesting work". It bothers me just how many people like this I've met, but I'm hoping it's just a misunderstanding; I integrate my work life with my personal life, I feel it's just the way I understand my being, whereas I'm betting these people shut down when they punch the clock and go on to enjoy interesting and fulfilling hobbies at home. My brother quit being a body piercer not because of the job itself, but because he felt that interacting with people solely for the purpose of a material transaction was banal and ingenuine. He still does piercings, for money, but only if he already knows the person. If you include work that indirectly achieves this goal (working behind the scenes for a company that impersonally sells goods or services to anyone) you have cut out almost every job imaginable in a modern industrial economy. Imagine living your life like that.
- gaius 18y agoNot everyone can work at Google or Fog Creek, and outside of the protected bubbles of the major tech centers, software work tends to be a tedious grind. My experience is that it doesn't matter where you work; 90% of programming isn't on the "cool" parts, the parts that other people see. It's on the bread and butter, the nuts and bolts. Working on a trading system at a bank probably isn't so different from working on AdSense at Google, or on a telco switch at Ericcson or WoW at Blizzard.
- yef 18y agoJoel is right. Software is a great industry and programmers, as a fundamental part of that industry, enjoy great benefits as a result. Professional, clean, safe work environment, good salaries, benefits, smart peers, growth opportunities. But it's everyone responsibility, including programmers, to take ownership of their career. They need to work on their craft, grow in their roles, learn other parts of the business, and take responsibilities that are aligned with their long-term goals. My gut feeling is that the people who feel stuck in "sucky jobs" are treating their jobs as just that -- jobs, rather than opportunities to grow, learn, and eventually be better than their boss is. The latter requires significantly more time, of course, far beyond the average 9-5'ers habits.