10 ms·
1970 Clean Air Act was intended to cover carbon dioxide
- jmclnx 2y agoI remember as a young kid, all the commercials with the tag line "CO2, the clean gas". Or something like that, I can only assume the Oil Industry had a big hand in removing CO2 from the act.
- Jtsummers 2y agoSure you're not mixing that up with natural gas? Usually advertised as clean compared to other fuels (coal, especially for power plants, but also sometimes to gas and diesel for vehicles). Though often the comparison part was left out or left very understated implying that it was somehow non-harmful or non-environmentally impacting.
- jandrese 2y agoI couldn't find anything on Google under the tagline "CH4, the clean gas", and all of the marketing I could find called it natrual gas instead. It was marketed as a "clean" solution, laughable as that may be. I guess it's a little less bullshit than all of the "clean coal" marketing.
- Jtsummers 2y agoThey wouldn't have advertised it as "CH4", that's not how people know it. It'd be methane or natural gas, more likely natural gas. Though the examples I'm coming up with are more recent than I was thinking (last decade) so unless GP is very young wouldn't have been around in their childhood. Continuing my search, but I have recollections of a 2000s push for natural gas that was heavily predicated on its "cleanness". Lots of city and school buses, for instance, were switching to CNG from diesel in that time period (and in comparison, CNG is almost certainly cleaner than diesel). EDIT: Ok, found some things. Google Image search for (no quotes) "clean natural gas" and set the range to 2000-2010. You'll find a variety of images both for and against this claim. Including things like "This Bus Is Running On Clean Natural Gas" (2009) [0] or "Clean. Affordable. Abundant. American. Natural gas is the answer. Tell Congress to put it to work." (apparently from 2010) [1] [0] https://images.app.goo.gl/yfrQn8fYrB7zLqqh9 https://images.app.goo.gl/yfrQn8fYrB7zLqqh9 [1] https://images.app.goo.gl/4Aj7ybMt3wVWq49BA https://images.app.goo.gl/4Aj7ybMt3wVWq49BA Here's [2] an example from the 1980s calling it cleaner, source for me was [3]. [2] https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ympy04dETxXWfqkCn0zm9NmE1z19x4PI/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ympy04dETxXWfqkCn0zm9NmE1z1... [3] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/nov/18/the-forgotten-oil-ads-that-told-us-climate-change-was-nothing https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/nov/18/the-forg...
- seiferteric 2y agoAlso methane has a higher proportion of hydrogen than other fuels and so releases less CO2 and more water when burned.
- jandrese 2y agoThe problem with that theory is that it is hard to mistake "natural gas" for "CO2". CO2 to CH4 is exactly the sort of thing that people would mix up.
- Jtsummers 2y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41184982 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41184982 - from the original commenter in reply to my question. They apparently did make that mistake.
- xboxnolifes 2y agoThe problem with this theory is underestimating just how fallible human memory is.
- jmclnx 2y agoYes, that is it, Natural Gas. Been a long time. But it was around the time of this bill, so it makes one wonder.
- josh-sematic 2y agoI wonder whether this changes anything in practical terms. Can the EPA start enforcing the CO2 regulations again and take it back to the Supreme Court with this as part of the defense? Or is there another pathway to get a new judgement from the courts by taking this evidence into consideration?
- jandrese 2y agoWith Chevron deference dead they won't be able to enforce anything about CO2 without it getting tied up in the courts and probably killed in one of the circuit courts.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- spencerflem 2y agoYoud need a new court first lol I don't think the current one is very open to suggestion
- hughesjj 2y agoEnd of the day we can always ignore the Supreme Court rulings. Thermonuclear option. Marburey vs Madison was the courts interpreting the constitution to say that judicial review exists. Judicial review itself is a precedent that we've all been following in good faith. I'd honestly love a historic review of judicial review and see if we think it's been a net positive or negative. For every civilian rights win there's also a dredd Scott, not sure how it's balanced on the whole. I've always thought it was a good thing and I like it in theory but... Now that I'm older I'm thinking about it's application in practice more critically
- hash872 2y agoI have a pretty low opinion of judicial review, but I'm not clear that reviewing actions by administrative agencies actually qualifies as JR. Review is when the courts strike down actual laws passed by Congress. In this case it's an administrative action by an agency
- 2y ago
- giantg2 2y agoAm I missing something? I didn't see the study linked in the article. You would think that any competent lawyer would have had this research performed as part of the prior case. Makes me wonder what they actually found.
- Jtsummers 2y agoYes, you missed the last paragraph: > The study, soon to be published in Ecology Law Quarterly, concludes that Congress “understood far more about the potential threat of anthropogenic climate change than either the [Supreme] Court or most commentators have recognized.” This is an announcement and summary of key points of the study, it is not able to link to it because it's not been published yet.
- giantg2 2y agoThey do sometimes share pre-publication drafts. Seems premature to put out an article with almost nothing in it. The information in the article lacks any sort of detail or even a logic basis for tying the points together. Plenty of policians make claims on a topic related to a bill that go farther than the actual bill that passes. So while one person has an interpretation the other members of congress can have different interpretations when passing the bill. That's why the preamble and the bill's contents are so important. Perhaps even the notes from the debate. But just a statement outside of those contexts? Bit of a stretch without seeing the research.
- colpabar 2y ago> The study, soon to be published in Ecology Law Quarterly, concludes that Congress “understood far more about the potential threat of anthropogenic climate change than either the [Supreme] Court or most commentators have recognized.” Looks like it hasn't been published yet.
- andrewla 2y agoThis endless jockeying to try to get the courts to allow the executive branch to have more power is ridiculous and dangerous. If Congress wants the EPA to regulate CO2 they should just pass that as a law. The reticence to act on this is bananas. Congress has all the power here -- they can give the EPA discretion or specify a mandate for how they handle CO2.
- jvanderbot 2y agoThey did pass it as law, called the 1970 clean air act.
- seizethecheese 2y agoThis is clearly under dispute and not a fact that can be stated so cleanly . The article itself makes it clear that the Supreme Court ruled in 2022 that this is not the case.h
- mbStavola 2y agoSeemed to be the case for 50+ years.
- spencerflem 2y ago[flagged]
- RangerScience 2y agoCheck out the book “Legal Systems Very Different From Our Own” for the millennia-old tradition that is “finding a way to interpret a holy text according to your politics”
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- burkaman 2y agoIt is understandably confusing, because the Supreme Court also ruled that it is the case in 2007: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massachusetts_v._EPA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massachusetts_v._EPA. > greenhouse gases fit well within the CAA's capacious definition of air pollutant - United States Supreme Court
- akira2501 2y agoWe can argue about what they intended, but here is what they wrote: "The term “new source” means any stationary source, the construction or modification of which is commenced after the publication of regulations (or, if earlier, proposed regulations) prescribing a standard of performance under this section which will be applicable to such source." and "The term “existing source” means any stationary source other than a new source." Finally.. congress didn't hand EPA an unlimited authority to make decisions about sources. It handed them a process they must follow when it comes to ruling on "new sources." With a law this complex, I'm not sure you can bring the intentions of a single sponsor into the consideration: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/7411 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/7411
- spencerflem 2y ago[flagged]
- Jtsummers 2y agoFlag it if you think it's off-topic, nothing is stopping you from doing that unless your karma is still too low (yours isn't). It'll get off the front page quick with just a few flags, though this one is also likely to trigger the flame war detector and get pushed down the rankings soon.
- spencerflem 2y agoAlready did, just makes me sad :( I love tech and software and fiddling with things and the beauty and elegance of code and the joy of discovering how things work, and the creativity ppl can have. And then there's posts like this and its like 'wow, these people suck, what am I doing' Shame too, cuz the article itself is fine
- andrewmg 2y agoAh, forgotten records, including the musings of poet Allen Ginsburg, provide a secret decoder ring to interpreting the Clean Air Act. This is not, of course, how one interprets statutes. For what it's worth, the linked press release's description of the Supreme Court's decision is wrong; the court did not, in fact, hold that "Congress had not empowered the EPA to regulate greenhouse gases," but that it could not regulate in the manner that it did. And, so far as the statute at issue is concerned, the evidence is overwhelming that it was never intended to empower EPA to restructure the nation's electricity system. I wrote a fair bit about this at the time, and was apparently persuasive.[1] [1] https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/20/20-1530/204857/20211213141438218_20-1530%2020-1778%20Westmoreland%20Merits.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/20/20-1530/204857/202...
- doctorpangloss 2y agoI don’t think this is the “bitter medicine” or “hard truths” you think it is. Separately, while it’s very interesting that you played a role in writing this, and I believe that you’re correct in general about the errors in the linked articles: despite the fact that you are highly experienced, there are still idiots who win court cases, even Supreme Court cases, on crap arguments, sometimes. However, idiots never become surgeons. In my personal experience, I don’t know any idiots who also write sophisticated software. So this idea that there is some kind of objective, apolitical correct interpretation of a statue - that the practice of law at the highest levels in trials in front of the Supreme Court has this major objective element to it as surgery and math does - is kind of bupkis, you are as much practicing something imaginary, subjective, political, and poetical as the musings of Alan Ginsburg as the professors do. So what is your opinion: do you really think Supreme Court decisions are apolitical? How would you tell the difference between a politically motivated decision that uses your arguments as a “parallel construction” to support that political decision, and a sincere belief that your way of reading the statue is objective and apolitical? Because that is what people are pissed off about.
- MisterBastahrd 2y agoI think it's fairly obvious that the court system is more metaphysics than physics. Even when the laws are clear, we still have politically motivated jurists who will put their own denominational spin on the application of said laws.
- devlsadvocate 2y ago[flagged]
- NotYourLawyer 2y agoThis is such a stretch. If it has really been intended, it would have been explicit. The fact that the drafters were aware of the issue and didn’t make it explicit actually cuts the other way.
- yaletoo 2y ago[flagged]