6 ms·
The Story of Samsung's failed deal with iFixit, as told by iFixit's CEO
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoRelated from 2 months ago: We're ending our Samsung collaboration https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40456107 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40456107
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoRelated iFixit blog post from 3 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27885176 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27885176
- wordofx 2y ago> Wiens sips a Diet Coke and settles in as I start explaining the framework of our conversation. He interrupts me politely to get a big caveat out of the way related to confidentiality terms iFixit still has with Samsung. I really struggle to read these types of interviews. If I wanted to read the novel I would buy the book… but if I’m reading an article I don’t want the fluff…
- magicalhippo 2y agoSame, really annoys me. Guess writer has a word-count target to meet and adding such fluff is an easy way to get there. Guess one could train an LLM to de-fluff articles?
- CoastalCoder 2y agoSame for me. I'm sure that commercial writers these days face all kinds of pressure regarding their writing styles. But usually I just want pyramid-style writing for the news.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- wccrawford 2y agoIt's invading everything, too. Ninja warrior used to be a show about amazing athletes conquering the courses, with a quirky backstory thrown in sometimes. Now, almost everyone has a lengthy backstory that is told at least once per season, and it's a significant amount of the runtime of the show. It's gotten to the point that even athletes that have basically no backstory still end up with a lengthy segment on themselves. For fairness, I guess?
- TRiG_Ireland 2y agoWhich is why World Ninja League (an actual sport) is better than American Ninja Warrior (a TV show with a sporting element). See also World Chase Tag vs Ultimate Tag, which has basically the same distinction.
- wccrawford 2y agoI had never heard of it. Thanks!
- mynameisvlad 2y agoOr maybe, just maybe, it’s because viewers tested more positively to the backstories and the connection helps them choose someone to root for and therefore be more invested in the show. The showrunners didn’t do it for shits and giggles, they did it because it makes them more money. If you want just the sport bits, you can always watch Sasuke, the original, which I believe has less backstory interstitials.
- wccrawford 2y agoI imagine it's the same thing that caused the comment here about not liking it. I don't care if it "tested well", I don't like it. And yes, I watch Sasuke when I get a chance. Also, Australian Ninja Warrior. The British one isn't as good, IMO, but we watch that, too.
- joncrocks 2y agoOr it could be cheaper to make. i.e. It's cheaper per unit-airtime to have a small crew interviewing people for backstory (+ editing) than recording people doing the course. They can pad-out the expensive bit (holding the events) with filler/b-roll.
- igornadj 2y agoGenerally I agree, but this is one single paragraph of colour followed by the rest being straight reporting below, and adds important context.
- pdar4123 2y agoFolks agreeing with this take should take a hard look at their attention spans and ability to focus and comprehend - it’s honestly really shocking to see how many people can’t handle sitting still and reading for 10 minutes (or fewer!) straight! I should say I’ve struggled with this too, I have to be super mindful otherwise I’ll flip and skim and find myself distracted. But it is interesting there’s an embracing of this by many - “I always ask ChatGPT to summarize xyz.”
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> Folks agreeing with this take should take a hard look at their attention spans and ability to focus and comprehend It's not a complaint about the text being long. It's a complaint about the text being content-free.
- loveangus 2y agoFor news content I agree, but for deep-dives on people and their character I quite like the background and scene setting that authors do.
- michaelt 2y ago> “I don’t know why Samsung insists on charging so much for service parts,” Wiens says, visibly frustrated. “The prices that we see are out of line with what we know components actually cost to manufacture.” Wiens starts to elaborate but stops himself. He clarifies that he would love to discuss this more, but his contract with Samsung prevents him from doing so. I mean, it's pretty easy to guess: They want to run the spare parts division at a profit, they know they've got no competition (except used parts off recycled phones) and like some car makers, they know that means they can charge through the nose. Wikipedia tells me [1] Samsung released 17 distinct model numbers in 2023, and 30 in 2022. Presumably a lot of those have custom, nonstandard screens with rounded corners and curved edges and camera notches and folding and fingerprint readers and whatnot. So presumably the minimum order quantity is huge - they can't just hold a few spare screens and make more on demand, they probably have to buy (and pay for) several years of spares upfront. And of course every phone will have multiple parts, different subassemblies (do you want to order the screen with or without the fingerprint reader?) and maybe different colour schemes as well. And any spare parts you make and don't sell are wasted. So it's very easy for a spare parts division to be very inefficient, if it's not well managed. If they're determined to run the division at a profit - that inefficiency gets passed right along to the end user. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samsung_Galaxy#Release_history https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samsung_Galaxy#Release_history
- altdataseller 2y agoIts also easy for me to see as a 3rd party. Perhaps ifixit should manage the whole manufacturing and logistical aspect of maintaining all those spare parts themselves? Too unprofitable? Too much hassle? Oh..
- michaelt 2y agoifixit might be able to do a better job, yes. It's their core business rather than an afterthought, after all. But part of the problem can only be solved by Samsung. They're the ones releasing 30 phone models in a single year - and the ones making design decisions like having six different screens available for the same phone because the coloured bezel is glued to the screen. And of course if Samsung buys screens for $50 and sells them to ifixit for $100, holding 1000 in stock requires half the capital outlay if Samsung does it.
- daghamm 2y agoI really liked the plans Samsung employees had to give old phones a new life. I have a box of mostly working phones from different companies and I often wish there was an easy way to use them for different automation tasks around the house. Anyway, I'm not surprised it didn't work. Engineers see possibilities while lawyers only think about how something goes very wrong and the company ends up in court.
- NoboruWataya 2y agoIn other words, lawyers also see possibilities, albeit maybe not the same possibilities as the engineers. (That's assuming that this was shut down by Samsung legal. I didn't see that in the article, though I skimmed a bit so maybe I missed it.)
- JohnFen 2y ago> while lawyers only think about how something goes very wrong and the company ends up in court. To be fair to the lawyers -- that's primarily what companies hire them to do.
- DowagerDave 2y agoMaybe a lot of executives and lawyers start from this perspective, but if so it's a bad position. Lawyers are supposed to be educated risk mitigators, working to maximize value not just minimize risk. I see so much CYA that they adopt a "better safe than sorry" attitude that doesn't accurately blend likelihood and impact, to the detriment of the company. They also rely on thin case law and current events which is basically just anecdotal evidence; they rarely look at data or have the skills to interpret it. You're better off hiring an actuary to run your GRC team.
- JohnFen 2y ago> Lawyers are supposed to be educated risk mitigators, working to maximize value not just minimize risk. Not so sure I agree with this. Lawyers are supposed to provide an analysis of the legal risks of things the company wants to do. It's the job of management to take that information and weigh it against the other business factors to determine if the risk is worth taking or not. If a company is too risk-averse, legally speaking, that's a fault of management, not the lawyers. That said, good lawyers won't just give a binary "recommend/don't recommend" answer. They'll also provide various options for other ways of doing something that have different risk profiles.
- ilaksh 2y agoThere are many companies that just do whatever they can get away with and because of their market position, this is a lot. Maybe someday there will be a movement to boycott these abusive companies or something. Check out https://futo.org https://futo.org
- RobotToaster 2y agofuto, the company that keeps trying to hijack open source with their proprietary licence?
- 3np 2y agoThese? https://gitlab.futo.org/keyboard/latinime/-/blob/master/LICENSE.md https://gitlab.futo.org/keyboard/latinime/-/blob/master/LICE... https://gitlab.futo.org/videostreaming/grayjay/-/blob/master/LICENSE.md https://gitlab.futo.org/videostreaming/grayjay/-/blob/master... Yeah, that's.. Unfortunate. I hope they don't attempt to relicense immich (AGPL), at least..
- CivBase 2y agoDidn't they start saying "source first" instead of "open source"? What's wrong with that? Nothing about their current licenses stand out as unreasonable to me. Even though their licenses aren't technically "open source" - i.e. not an OSI approved license - their license is clearly in the same spirit and I would absolutely refer to it as "open source" in casual discussion. They did the wrong thing at first, but their intent was obviously not malicious and they corrected it. Why let that undermine the rest of the good things they're doing?
- brookst 2y agoWhy would people boycott a company with a strong market position that is operating within the bounds of what it can get away with? This reads like suggesting people should boycott their favorite restaurants because reasons.
- ilaksh 2y agoBecause what they get away with is abusive and shows no regard for consumers. Your comment reads like you ignored all of the context of my comment. It's like if your favorite restaurant served really good burgers for $1000, but if the pickles and lettuce fell out and you tried to put them back in, the waiter would come over and slap the burger out of your hand and make you spend another $1000 to get a whole new burger.
- GeekyBear 2y agoIn my opinion, if you are going position yourself as a neutral arbiter of device repairability, it does not pass the smell test to enter into for-profit business relationships with the companies manufacturing the devices you rate. Providing consumers with information on where to find reputable companies selling repair parts would be a much more palatable alternative to selling them yourself. > “I don’t know why Samsung insists on charging so much for service parts,” Wiens says, visibly frustrated. “The prices that we see are out of line with what we know components actually cost to manufacture.” Wiens starts to elaborate but stops himself. He clarifies that he would love to discuss this more, but his contract with Samsung prevents him from doing so. In this case, the for-profit business relationship with Samsung also stands in the way of advocating for consumers.
- diffeomorphism 2y agoI would argue the opposite. They are not aiming to be a neutral arbiter but an active advocate for better repairability. For that they should have for-profit business relationships with basically all companies manufacturing such devices. In particular, that would allow them to pressure or drop any one misbehaving company. > Providing consumers with information on where to find reputable companies selling repair parts would be a much more palatable alternative to selling them yourself. That does not really make sense. They are a repair company and the only company selling specialized parts is, of course, the manufacturer. > also stands in the way of advocating for consumers. That is much too bleak. They made a deal happen in the first place, which is large progress even if it did not quite work out, and compromises are a fact of life.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- brookst 2y agoAgreed that for-profit relationships are inappropriate, and I also think iFixit’s business selling repair tools and parts is inappropriate. The whole thing comes across as self-promotion for their tools/parts business. Add in their dabbling in lobbying for regulations to force manufacturers to make devices that you can buy ifixit (and other) kits for… and it starts to feel as disingenuous as Epic’s “pro-consumer” interest in outlawing the razors/blades business model that game consoles use.
- capitainenemo 2y agoAt least the samsung phone I bought scores pretty well on repairability in this review https://m.gsmarena.com/samsung_galaxy_xcover6_pro_scores_high_repairability_rating_in_disassembly_video-news-55945.php https://m.gsmarena.com/samsung_galaxy_xcover6_pro_scores_hig... Although I'd love to know what iFixit thinks, esp since I'm hoping to hang on to it for a few more years at least. Was hoping to find a general database of phones, but it looks like they don't do a ton of reviews. Only 21 smartphones listed here, including both apple and android. https://www.ifixit.com/repairability/smartphone-repairability-scores https://www.ifixit.com/repairability/smartphone-repairabilit... Of which only 3 were samsung.
- bdcravens 2y agoClick the View Legacy Scores link. They have several older Samsungs (probably 20-25), dating back to the Samsung S 4G in 2011. https://www.ifixit.com/repairability/legacy-smartphone-scores https://www.ifixit.com/repairability/legacy-smartphone-score...
- capitainenemo 2y agoWell, this phone was released late 2022 so I'd be surprised to find it in a legacy list already. And indeed there was nothing in the legacy list more recent than 2020. I bought it the instant it was released so I've gotten 2 years out of it so far with just a few scratches from constantly forgetting and putting it with my keys in my pocket. I have a 2nd battery for quick swapping, but that also helps with battery longevity. I protected the USB port with one of those magnetic connectors so hopefully that will last a while too.
- bdcravens 2y agoIn the case of that specific phone, it seems to be a bit more niche (not that I obsess over the phone industry, but this is the first time I've heard of it, and as a frequent phone shopper, I'm not sure that I've seen it offered by any of the US carriers, but again, my perspective is limited). It does seem that given the amount of effort they put into a teardown, they limit their teardowns (which is way more comprehensive than a typical "review") to some sort of mass market threshhold.
- adamc 2y agoHideous, unreadable number of ads on the desktop.
- ffhhj 2y agoHaving owned a Z Flip that cracked I can tell you that managers at Samsung use iPhones or any other brand, because they never noticed that all the modal windows are centered in the screen directly on the fold making it difficult to see and click it when you sit the phone at 90deg.
- noboostforyou 2y agoAnecdotal only but I've had to buy very obscure Samsung replacement parts twice in recent years and definitely noticed how expensive it was. One was a proprietary cable for a tv and another was a specific-length ignition wire for a stove top pilot light. Both times I was able to find a no-name brand replacement part on amazon but reviews were mixed and there was no guarantee of fitment. And it wasn't that much of a discount compared to Samsung's direct parts store which was quite pricey. I paid over $60 for that pilot light wire.
- FireBeyond 2y agoI have a Samsung fridge that has an integrated water pitcher setup (keeps it full inside the door). It's actually pretty cool. Nice pitcher too. However, I made the mistake of putting it in the dishwasher on a Sanitize cycle (normal cycle is meant to/should be okay). The heat deformed the pitcher (just plastic). I did some various heating myself to make the top sit right again, but it just never did, and it being very slightly off-kilter was enough to not trip the fill mechanism. So I went to buy a new one. Holy hell. One hundred and twenty dollars. For this: https://www.amazon.com/Samsung-DA97-17395A-Refrigerator-Reservoir-Manufacturer/dp/B07FNBVX5X/ https://www.amazon.com/Samsung-DA97-17395A-Refrigerator-Rese... And this is not someone on Amazon gouging. Indeed Samsung themselves want $140. https://samsungpartsusa.com/products/da97-17395a https://samsungpartsusa.com/products/da97-17395a for a plastic water pitcher. > I paid over $60 for that pilot light wire. Not Samsung, but I had a double oven whose circuit board died. The manufacturer wanted more than the cost of the oven for a new circuit board (was an older oven). That one thankfully ended up being a fairly common and simple fix (some capacitors and some other things - there was someone on eBay selling repair service - "$59, send me your board, and I'll send it back in three days repaired").
- gknoy 2y agoMy LG refrigerator had similarly priced replacement parts for the removable shelves in the doors, several of which cracked. It was bonkers. Is this partly because the demand for these specific parts is relatively low?
- oneepic 2y agoOfftopic: on mobile I get a really awful ad that puts borders on the whole screen, and cuts off the article's words on the far left and right. I'd say I will never go to this site again, but then again, I may as well never read news on mobile again, right? (As this ad might just pop up on another site anyway) Still, it's a shameful practice.
- fuzzfactor 2y agoI thought Samsung was a financially successful company, like the biggest in Korea. What's wrong that they can't afford to make a generous deal with a much smaller player that likes to keep broken phones from being a show-stopper? Not just a good deal but a generous deal, what happened to the kind of business acumen that made things like this affordable for successful businessmen? Are billion-dollar outfits not as capable as they were in the past when they were only multi-million-dollar orgs? Why would that be?
- sianyancey307 2y ago[dead]
- susanhea 2y agoGet in touch with hackremotespy@gmail.com for all your hack related such as; Cloning, Tracking, Spying, Retrieving of deleted text messages, Upgrading of results, Hack social media accounts, Erase criminal record. His service is safe and secure. Get in touch with him via his email hackremotespy@gmail.com